[ IMAGES: Images ON turn off | ACCOUNT: User Status is LOCKED why? ]

Trade rumor frank nitkinia possibly to the piston, Piston scout Malik Rose was in the building scouting frank. Per Marc Berman
Author Thread
houston20
Posts: 20484
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 9/18/2019
Member: #8797

10/17/2019  10:28 AM

Fizdale stated Frank Ntiliikina will play “significant minutes” tonight. Pistons scout and ex-Knick Malik Rose in house. Detroit has been mentioned as liking Ntilikina. And wrote last year they inquired about Dotson.
Ntilikina’s contract option for his fourth year has an Oct. 31 deadline. Smith’s option faces a similar deadline, but it would seem difficult for Knicks brass to pass on executing it, considering he was the key piece of the Kristaps Porzingis trade.

Was Ntilkina also being showcased? There have been suggestions in Detroit the Pistons may have some interest. Pistons executive Malik Rose, a former Knick, was at the Garden for the game. The Post reported last season the Pistons asked about Damyean Dotson, who did not play Wednesday.

https://nypost.com/2019/10/16/dennis-smith-jr-frank-ntilikina-fail-knicks-point-guard-test/?utm_source=twitter_sitebuttons&utm_medium=site%20buttons&utm_campaign=site%20buttons

AUTOADVERT
Vmart
Posts: 31800
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 5/23/2002
Member: #247
USA
10/17/2019  10:56 AM
You never know with the Knicks. They simply don’t appreciate what they have.
houston20
Posts: 20484
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 9/18/2019
Member: #8797

10/17/2019  11:03 AM
Vmart wrote:You never know with the Knicks. They simply don’t appreciate what they have.

I think perry doesn't trust frank long term and is looking trade frank for anything he can get. We also got to remember this frank option hasn't been picked up and perry said the knicks will make that decision by october 31 meaning either looking to trade him or not pick up frank option.

fishmike
Posts: 53828
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 7/19/2002
Member: #298
USA
10/17/2019  11:13 AM
houston20 wrote:
Vmart wrote:You never know with the Knicks. They simply don’t appreciate what they have.

I think perry doesn't trust frank long term and is looking trade frank for anything he can get. We also got to remember this frank option hasn't been picked up and perry said the knicks will make that decision by october 31 meaning either looking to trade him or not pick up frank option.


what does that mean "doesnt trust Frank long term" ???

3 PGs is not a glut, he's 21 and may be able to play other positions. Not picking up his deal would be stupid but again its the Knicks.

DS looked like a robot without oil last night. Dude couldnt move. We have Elf, who's OK but essentially a cast-off on a one year deal. We have DSjr who cant stay on the court but I think most here like his talent level. Who's next? Kadeem Allen?

I like Frank but he has not played well. He's shown flashes, but nothing consistent. That being said he was drafted at 19 and everyone knew it was gonna be a few years. Well its a few years and we are seeing stuff. How much and consistent we'll see

"winning is more fun... then fun is fun" -Thibs
knicks1248
Posts: 42059
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 2/3/2004
Member: #582
10/17/2019  11:19 AM
Vmart wrote:You never know with the Knicks. They simply don’t appreciate what they have.

Trading frank or dotson would be a sacrifice for what the team is really lacking in, which is perimeter scoring.

If we can get kennard, a sniper who shoots 40% from downtown, then you can play him with barret or payton.

When frank made stops, we couldn't score, didn't push the pace, and turned the ball over twice in the clutch..so just like offensive player can score a bunch of empty stats, franks defensive was kind of wasted because we couldn't capitalize on the other end.

ES
houston20
Posts: 20484
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 9/18/2019
Member: #8797

10/17/2019  11:19 AM    LAST EDITED: 10/17/2019  11:22 AM
fishmike wrote:
houston20 wrote:
Vmart wrote:You never know with the Knicks. They simply don’t appreciate what they have.

I think perry doesn't trust frank long term and is looking trade frank for anything he can get. We also got to remember this frank option hasn't been picked up and perry said the knicks will make that decision by october 31 meaning either looking to trade him or not pick up frank option.


what does that mean "doesnt trust Frank long term" ???

3 PGs is not a glut, he's 21 and may be able to play other positions. Not picking up his deal would be stupid but again its the Knicks.

DS looked like a robot without oil last night. Dude couldnt move. We have Elf, who's OK but essentially a cast-off on a one year deal. We have DSjr who cant stay on the court but I think most here like his talent level. Who's next? Kadeem Allen?

I like Frank but he has not played well. He's shown flashes, but nothing consistent. That being said he was drafted at 19 and everyone knew it was gonna be a few years. Well its a few years and we are seeing stuff. How much and consistent we'll see


What i mean is frank isn't perry guy and he doesn't want him for the future. Perry is more interested in dsj and payton then frank because the problem with frank is this frank offensive isn't good but defense is great. We got to give dsj more time he was rusty last night and perry more invested developing dsj then frank. Also frank hasn't got a start at the point guard position this preseason dsj and payton have gotten starts that has to tell you something how perry and fisdale view frank.
fishmike
Posts: 53828
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 7/19/2002
Member: #298
USA
10/17/2019  12:03 PM
houston20 wrote:
fishmike wrote:
houston20 wrote:
Vmart wrote:You never know with the Knicks. They simply don’t appreciate what they have.

I think perry doesn't trust frank long term and is looking trade frank for anything he can get. We also got to remember this frank option hasn't been picked up and perry said the knicks will make that decision by october 31 meaning either looking to trade him or not pick up frank option.


what does that mean "doesnt trust Frank long term" ???

3 PGs is not a glut, he's 21 and may be able to play other positions. Not picking up his deal would be stupid but again its the Knicks.

DS looked like a robot without oil last night. Dude couldnt move. We have Elf, who's OK but essentially a cast-off on a one year deal. We have DSjr who cant stay on the court but I think most here like his talent level. Who's next? Kadeem Allen?

I like Frank but he has not played well. He's shown flashes, but nothing consistent. That being said he was drafted at 19 and everyone knew it was gonna be a few years. Well its a few years and we are seeing stuff. How much and consistent we'll see


What i mean is frank isn't perry guy and he doesn't want him for the future. Perry is more interested in dsj and payton then frank because the problem with frank is this frank offensive isn't good but defense is great. We got to give dsj more time he was rusty last night and perry more invested developing dsj then frank. Also frank hasn't got a start at the point guard position this preseason dsj and payton have gotten starts that has to tell you something how perry and fisdale view frank.
people say this stuff but it doesnt make sense to me. Perry is in the FO. He's got to evaluate talent, not play favorites.

Mario was a "Perry guy" also. He gone. I mean PG is the spot up for grabs. Perry cant afford to play favorites. His job is to give Fizdale options. Fizdale's job is to get 2/3 of these guys playing good BB.

"winning is more fun... then fun is fun" -Thibs
houston20
Posts: 20484
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 9/18/2019
Member: #8797

10/17/2019  12:27 PM
fishmike wrote:
houston20 wrote:
fishmike wrote:
houston20 wrote:
Vmart wrote:You never know with the Knicks. They simply don’t appreciate what they have.

I think perry doesn't trust frank long term and is looking trade frank for anything he can get. We also got to remember this frank option hasn't been picked up and perry said the knicks will make that decision by october 31 meaning either looking to trade him or not pick up frank option.


what does that mean "doesnt trust Frank long term" ???

3 PGs is not a glut, he's 21 and may be able to play other positions. Not picking up his deal would be stupid but again its the Knicks.

DS looked like a robot without oil last night. Dude couldnt move. We have Elf, who's OK but essentially a cast-off on a one year deal. We have DSjr who cant stay on the court but I think most here like his talent level. Who's next? Kadeem Allen?

I like Frank but he has not played well. He's shown flashes, but nothing consistent. That being said he was drafted at 19 and everyone knew it was gonna be a few years. Well its a few years and we are seeing stuff. How much and consistent we'll see


What i mean is frank isn't perry guy and he doesn't want him for the future. Perry is more interested in dsj and payton then frank because the problem with frank is this frank offensive isn't good but defense is great. We got to give dsj more time he was rusty last night and perry more invested developing dsj then frank. Also frank hasn't got a start at the point guard position this preseason dsj and payton have gotten starts that has to tell you something how perry and fisdale view frank.
people say this stuff but it doesnt make sense to me. Perry is in the FO. He's got to evaluate talent, not play favorites.

Mario was a "Perry guy" also. He gone. I mean PG is the spot up for grabs. Perry cant afford to play favorites. His job is to give Fizdale options. Fizdale's job is to get 2/3 of these guys playing good BB.

I think perry has lot of control on the decision making and i also think fizdale agrees with perry on a lot situations. They asked fizdale about frank option the other day and fizdale said that's for scott perry to decide not for fizdale decide. Also look at this way fizdale wanted to draft knox, robinson, rj barret, ignas and sign the free agents that fizdale wanted like trier and payton. Fizdale wants to run a team with lot veteran player and some young guys and fizdale is not interested in developing certain players that are going to take lot of time like frank.

BigDaddyG
Posts: 39879
Alba Posts: 9
Joined: 1/22/2010
Member: #3049

10/17/2019  2:01 PM
knicks1248 wrote:
Vmart wrote:You never know with the Knicks. They simply don’t appreciate what they have.

Trading frank or dotson would be a sacrifice for what the team is really lacking in, which is perimeter scoring.

If we can get kennard, a sniper who shoots 40% from downtown, then you can play him with barret or payton.

When frank made stops, we couldn't score, didn't push the pace, and turned the ball over twice in the clutch..so just like offensive player can score a bunch of empty stats, franks defensive was kind of wasted because we couldn't capitalize on the other end.

I'd rather keep Dot over kennard. Kennard was unplayable last year due to his poor D. Has that improved. If we trade Frank, I'd rather get picks back.

Always... always remember: Less is less. More is more. More is better and twice as much is good too. Not enough is bad, and too much is never enough except when it's just about right. - The Tick
martin
Posts: 76221
Alba Posts: 108
Joined: 7/24/2001
Member: #2
USA
10/17/2019  2:05 PM
BigDaddyG wrote:
knicks1248 wrote:
Vmart wrote:You never know with the Knicks. They simply don’t appreciate what they have.

Trading frank or dotson would be a sacrifice for what the team is really lacking in, which is perimeter scoring.

If we can get kennard, a sniper who shoots 40% from downtown, then you can play him with barret or payton.

When frank made stops, we couldn't score, didn't push the pace, and turned the ball over twice in the clutch..so just like offensive player can score a bunch of empty stats, franks defensive was kind of wasted because we couldn't capitalize on the other end.

I'd rather keep Dot over kennard. Kennard was unplayable last year due to his poor D. Has that improved. If we trade Frank, I'd rather get picks back.

unfortunately Detroit's cubbard is fairly dry if it's a direct 1-to-1 trade:

INCOMING:

2021 second round draft pick from L.A. Lakers
L.A. Lakers' 2021 2nd round pick to Detroit [Detroit-L.A. Lakers, 2/6/2019]

2023 second round draft pick from Portland
Portland's 2023 2nd round pick to Detroit (via Cleveland) [Cleveland-Portland, 2/4/2019; Cleveland-Detroit, 6/26/2019]


OUTGOING:

2020 second round draft pick to Sacramento
Detroit's 2020 2nd round pick to Sacramento (via Phoenix) [Detroit-Phoenix, 7/9/2015; Phoenix-Sacramento, 6/23/2016]

2021 second round draft pick to L.A. Clippers
Detroit's 2021 2nd round pick to L.A. Clippers (via Philadelphia) [Detroit-Philadelphia, 6/21/2018; L.A. Clippers-Philadelphia, 2/6/2019]

2022 second round draft pick to Memphis, Chicago or Washington
Washington will receive the most favorable of Chicago's 2022 2nd round pick, Detroit's 2022 2nd round pick and the L.A. Lakers' 2022 2nd round pick; Chicago will receive the less favorable of (i) the more favorable of its pick and the Detroit pick and (ii) the L.A. Lakers pick; Memphis will receive the less favorable of the Detroit pick and the Chicago pick (via Chicago's right to swap for Detroit; via Washington's right to swap L.A. Lakers for Chicago or Detroit) [Chicago-Detroit, 2/8/2018; Detroit-Memphis, 2/8/2018; L.A. Lakers-New Orleans-Washington, 7/6/2019; Chicago-Washington, 7/7/2019]

2023 second round draft pick to L.A. Clippers
Detroit's 2023 2nd round pick to L.A. Clippers (via Philadelphia) [Detroit-Philadelphia, 6/21/2018; L.A. Clippers-Philadelphia, 2/6/2019]

Official sponsor of the PURE KNICKS LOVE Program
houston20
Posts: 20484
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 9/18/2019
Member: #8797

10/17/2019  2:17 PM
looks like frank isn't playing tomorrow according to chris iseman

Chris Iseman

@ChrisIseman
Doesn’t sound like Frank Ntilikina will play tomorrow. Fizdale said they want to see Elfrid Payton and Dennis Smith Jr.
https://twitter.com/ChrisIseman/status/1184892881254932480

jrodmc
Posts: 32927
Alba Posts: 50
Joined: 11/24/2004
Member: #805
USA
10/17/2019  3:41 PM
It's somehow funny (not funny) that DSJr looked almost the same rusty against Trae Young as Frank did not being rusty. I sure hope DSJr's D is going to improve, because he's obviously not going anywhere soon.

I hope they keep Frank. Volume on this board will go down the tubes if Frank isn't around to talk about.

jrodmc
Posts: 32927
Alba Posts: 50
Joined: 11/24/2004
Member: #805
USA
10/17/2019  3:49 PM
fishmike wrote:
houston20 wrote:
fishmike wrote:
houston20 wrote:
Vmart wrote:You never know with the Knicks. They simply don’t appreciate what they have.

I think perry doesn't trust frank long term and is looking trade frank for anything he can get. We also got to remember this frank option hasn't been picked up and perry said the knicks will make that decision by october 31 meaning either looking to trade him or not pick up frank option.


what does that mean "doesnt trust Frank long term" ???

3 PGs is not a glut, he's 21 and may be able to play other positions. Not picking up his deal would be stupid but again its the Knicks.

DS looked like a robot without oil last night. Dude couldnt move. We have Elf, who's OK but essentially a cast-off on a one year deal. We have DSjr who cant stay on the court but I think most here like his talent level. Who's next? Kadeem Allen?

I like Frank but he has not played well. He's shown flashes, but nothing consistent. That being said he was drafted at 19 and everyone knew it was gonna be a few years. Well its a few years and we are seeing stuff. How much and consistent we'll see


What i mean is frank isn't perry guy and he doesn't want him for the future. Perry is more interested in dsj and payton then frank because the problem with frank is this frank offensive isn't good but defense is great. We got to give dsj more time he was rusty last night and perry more invested developing dsj then frank. Also frank hasn't got a start at the point guard position this preseason dsj and payton have gotten starts that has to tell you something how perry and fisdale view frank.
people say this stuff but it doesnt make sense to me. Perry is in the FO. He's got to evaluate talent, not play favorites.

Mario was a "Perry guy" also. He gone. I mean PG is the spot up for grabs. Perry cant afford to play favorites. His job is to give Fizdale options. Fizdale's job is to get 2/3 of these guys playing good BB.

Where are the previous regime's picks, other than Frank? Mario? You're basing an argument on Mario? Perry can afford to do anything that puts his mark on the walls and hope the **** sticks. Frank ain't his ****, so if all things are equal, who do you really think is going? Elf and even Trier have a better shot at staying higher on the depth chart at PG. Watched Frank stand around twice, off his man and watch Old Man River drain threes last night. 19 year old long ass arms and all. That's not a good look.

Although it would have been a great shopping point if Frank could have shown at least something against Trae last night. Now that's out the window. 2 weeks left. Clock's ticking.

Vmart
Posts: 31800
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 5/23/2002
Member: #247
USA
10/17/2019  4:44 PM
All you have to do is see that KP is gone and he was by far the best thing this organization had since Ewing. Don’t think Perry isn’t agenda driven. He isn’t looking at talent all he is thinking is he isn’t my pick.
Nalod
Posts: 71157
Alba Posts: 155
Joined: 12/24/2003
Member: #508
USA
10/17/2019  6:27 PM
houston20 wrote:
Vmart wrote:You never know with the Knicks. They simply don’t appreciate what they have.

I think perry doesn't trust frank long term and is looking trade frank for anything he can get. We also got to remember this frank option hasn't been picked up and perry said the knicks will make that decision by october 31 meaning either looking to trade him or not pick up frank option.

Or they might extend him, or they might not, or still keep him and then pay him less or more at the end of the season. Fact is you nobody knows what’s in Perry’s head.

I would lean toward knicks trading two players for one if it made sense.
Not a question of who is right or wrong, its about our players stepping up! Dennis looked really bad.

Sangfroid
Posts: 24681
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 7/7/2009
Member: #2784

10/17/2019  8:58 PM
Nalod wrote:
houston20 wrote:
Vmart wrote:You never know with the Knicks. They simply don’t appreciate what they have.

I think perry doesn't trust frank long term and is looking trade frank for anything he can get. We also got to remember this frank option hasn't been picked up and perry said the knicks will make that decision by october 31 meaning either looking to trade him or not pick up frank option.

Or they might extend him, or they might not, or still keep him and then pay him less or more at the end of the season. Fact is you nobody knows what’s in Perry’s head.

I would lean toward knicks trading two players for one if it made sense.
Not a question of who is right or wrong, its about our players stepping up! Dennis looked really bad.

If the get rid of Frank, they had better get someone in the backcourt that plays D. That person hasn't shown up yet...

"We are playing a game. We are playing at not playing a game..."
GoNyGoNyGo
Posts: 23559
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 5/29/2003
Member: #411
USA
10/18/2019  7:59 AM    LAST EDITED: 10/18/2019  12:07 PM
knicks1248 wrote:
Vmart wrote:You never know with the Knicks. They simply don’t appreciate what they have.

Trading frank or dotson would be a sacrifice for what the team is really lacking in, which is perimeter scoring.

If we can get kennard, a sniper who shoots 40% from downtown, then you can play him with barret or payton.

When frank made stops, we couldn't score, didn't push the pace, and turned the ball over twice in the clutch..so just like offensive player can score a bunch of empty stats, franks defensive was kind of wasted because we couldn't capitalize on the other end.


This is right..

But also, Frank runs the offense well. The problem is the offense is get the ball to X and let X go 1v1 ISO. There are no easy baskets in the offense. No sets they run with player movement.

I would also like to see offense/defense subbing. However, Smith and Payton are NO BETTER than Frank on the offensive side. DSjr should be but wasn't last game.

Vmart
Posts: 31800
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 5/23/2002
Member: #247
USA
10/18/2019  8:50 AM
Sangfroid wrote:
Nalod wrote:
houston20 wrote:
Vmart wrote:You never know with the Knicks. They simply don’t appreciate what they have.

I think perry doesn't trust frank long term and is looking trade frank for anything he can get. We also got to remember this frank option hasn't been picked up and perry said the knicks will make that decision by october 31 meaning either looking to trade him or not pick up frank option.

Or they might extend him, or they might not, or still keep him and then pay him less or more at the end of the season. Fact is you nobody knows what’s in Perry’s head.

I would lean toward knicks trading two players for one if it made sense.
Not a question of who is right or wrong, its about our players stepping up! Dennis looked really bad.

If the get rid of Frank, they had better get someone in the backcourt that plays D. That person hasn't shown up yet...

I don’t think they are sacrificial. Frank plays a solid defense and that alone makes him more valuable. See what I don’t understand about the Knicks is their need to constantly meddle with positions. I would be very excited going into the season with Frank and Smith. How unnecessary was Payten. This team is it’s own worst enemy they can’t get out of their own f’ing way.

Trading KP I hate KP for his diva BS and his brother I would not have traded him for this BS of a package that we got in return. How do you trade him first off why? He is under contract. I don’t understand how the Knicks are trying to move Frank this guy is a winning player. If the Pistons are there to see and cover him over anything else the Knicks have that’s a sign this guy has something other teams want which makes him a good player to have. Our front office doesn’t see it. How is this organization going to develop anyone when they give up on everyone and think grass is always green elsewhere.

HofstraBBall
Posts: 27987
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 11/21/2015
Member: #6192

10/18/2019  9:08 AM
Vmart wrote:You never know with the Knicks. They simply don’t appreciate what they have.

Nor do fans.

Was never a fan of Frank as a lotto pick. However, never a fan of giving up on draft picks. So many times teams sacrifice so much to get those picks. And most fans forget about the players traded or the ****ty seasons endured to get those picks. Frank is what I thought he would be. A good role player that can be physically bigger than others at his position. I do feel he has shown improvement with his shot and aggressiveness to the basket. I also know that it takes more than a couple of years for young players to improve. Specially when it comes to improving ones confidence. Which seems to be the thing Frank is missing most. Given he did not play a full year last year this may be the year that he can work on that. If he does, think he has the mechanics to take the next step. Its also about risk and reward for me. What do we have to risk if we keep him. If its about getting a 2nd rounder for him, that's not much in terms of reward. He is also a player than can play multiple positions so if its concern that he will take PG learning minutes from DSJR, think that can be managed.

Did not like the way DSJR played against the Hawks but before the knee jerk reactions kick in, lets keep in mind that it has been said he has dominated the pre season scrimmages and btw has also averaged much better numbers than Frank in most categories his first two years. Also, think he has the most potential of the three to be at an All Star level. All be it with a lot of things to work on.

My biggest thing from a team development side, in terms of which players should stay or go is up to WHAT type of system the Knicks are wanting to develop?? It should always be the first step in accumulating personnel. If your looking for the tough defense, half court set type offensive system than Frank is the best fit. Along with most of the guys the Knicks picked up as FA's. If your looking for the modern speed ball, three point shooting basketball system, then most of these guys don't make sense. It just seems like a professional organization would know the steps to take to build a team. And for me, it all starts with the system and identity they wish to develop. That was my biggest issue with Phil. Why get a guy that is running a system from the 90's and one that most players in the NBA were not accustomed to. Did not seem like the system for a rebuilding franchise who is looking to the future. And we all know how that worked out?

'Knicks focus should be on players that have grown up playing soccer or cricket' - Triplethreat 8/28/2020
newyorknewyork
Posts: 30118
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 1/16/2004
Member: #541
10/18/2019  9:18 AM
GoNyGoNyGo wrote:
knicks1248 wrote:
Vmart wrote:You never know with the Knicks. They simply don’t appreciate what they have.

Trading frank or dotson would be a sacrifice for what the team is really lacking in, which is perimeter scoring.

If we can get kennard, a sniper who shoots 40% from downtown, then you can play him with barret or payton.

When frank made stops, we couldn't score, didn't push the pace, and turned the ball over twice in the clutch..so just like offensive player can score a bunch of empty stats, franks defensive was kind of wasted because we couldn't capitalize on the other end.


This is right..

But also, Frank runs the offense well. The problem is the offense is get the ball to X and let X go 1v1 ISO. There are no easy baskets in the offense. No sets they run with player movement.

I would also like to see offense/defense subbing. However, Smith and Payton are NO BETTER than Frank on the offensive side. DSjr should be but wasn't last game.

No it isn’t “right”. Young was pretty much taking over the game. There is no shot at winning without the defense Frank played on him down the stretch. Zero. To claim his defense was empty wow. That offensive rebound and assist to Portis was pretty damn clutch as well.

In hindsight, Trier could have came in for Morris with Barrett sliding over to the 3. Trier is more capable of getting deeper into the paint if we were gonna go iso the way we did.

Bembry exposed the lack of speed and athleticism we have at the forward positions though. He was able to get all the lose balls. They were able to just throw the ball up in passes to him and he was able to just get it while our guys looked like they were stuck in mud. We don’t have overall speed for spacing and iso offensively.

Randle has talent and is our big money FA signing. Fiz needs to find the way to flow the offense through him, but avoid getting caught up in iso. PNR with him and Barrett or Frank or something and have him doing passing or scoring reads off that.

https://vote.nba.com/en Vote for your Knicks.
Trade rumor frank nitkinia possibly to the piston, Piston scout Malik Rose was in the building scouting frank. Per Marc Berman

©2001-2025 ultimateknicks.comm All rights reserved. About Us.
This site is not affiliated with the NY Knicks or the National Basketball Association in any way.
You may visit the official NY Knicks web site by clicking here.

All times (GMT-05:00) Eastern Time.

Terms of Use and Privacy Policy