The 60 million dollar question: Was Phil worth it?
Let’s look real quick at the timeline, MSG does a McKinsey study’s and determines Dolan must back off and he hires Mills and fires Grunwald. Grun was not the problem, but not part of the solution. Mills is president and GM at the moment. This is October. Within weeks the Dolan seduction of Phil is in play and by March he is named president and mills GM.
I not going to argue Phils mistakes. He tried to “legislate by proxy” the Triangle and with the benefit of hindsight either he needed to coach to coach the team or hire the right surrogate to implement it. I think his first choice in Kerr was a good one. Luke Walton was not ready to take our reigns and in any event we did not have the talent. Old news.
So what did 60 mil buy Dolan? A tear down, even if clumsy at times was something not seen in MSG. PHil tried to rebuild and compete but at least he did not mortgage the future and remember we were short two no. 1 picks in his brief tenure! Clumsy was the hire of Fisher but he got it right with Hornacek.
Phil was wrong to give Melo his NTC but at the time it was reasonable. Melo in decline but a box office draw he was also correct to attempt to move him even if it was not a nice thing to do. Melo would not leave unless forced out and shamed into it. Phil looked bad doing it.
Phil handled the KP exit as a coach that was disrespected and wanted him gone. I get this level of thinking and his response. Which is exactly the reason why Phils firing was well timed and justified. Not the action of fielding trades was his undoing, but thinking like a coach.
In the end Mills moves back up and a good level headed GM in place and we needed not a Culture shake up but it just further evolved. Mills is in his natural place and has a good up and coming GM. Be nice to say this how it should have been all along but Phil, warts and all got us here and perhaps his celebrity was used also as a lightening rod to absorb what needed to be done. Melo had to move on. Horny became a good coach as well as Rambis! This team is playing up to its potential. It’s not a super talented team but exceeding its on paper projections.
And, we have rookies!!!!! Evolution of the culture still in progress. I like this team!!