nychamp
Posts: 20555
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 3/8/2009
Member: #2556
|
fishmike wrote:franco12 wrote:nychamp wrote:fishmike wrote:TPercy, nychamp, CrushAlot, BigDaddyG, Panos, Caseloads, TripleThreat, jskinny35, mlby1215, Paris907, Allanfan20, Cartman718, Uptown, nykshaknbake.. you guys all picked the Knicks to win considerably fewer wins than they did the year before. What’s your thought process? In a word, defense. I believe the Knick defense will be atrocious this year. As I see it many of their key players are either defensive zeroes (Kanter, Hardaway-judging from preseason, McDermott, Kuz) or severely flawed. Only solid defenders appear to be Frank, Baker, LT. KP has an impact, but also is flawed as a man defender. I also haven't seen any indication that the coaching staff has a successful plan or is capable of getting the team to play competent team defense. They don't prevent easy layups. They don't guard the 3-pt line. Looking at the preseason and the body of work from last year. I hope to be proven wrong. I'm not convinced KP will take the steps he needs to this year to be the number one on a non-awful NBA team. While I love what he can do, I worry that he can be exploited and attacked more effectively without Melo on the team. I also worry about his apparent tendency to try to play a SF's game in his 7'3" body. Not sure that it is the right approach. He is at a strength disadvantage, even against smaller guys, and like it or not (he doesn't seem to), he needs to play a certain % of the game close to the hoop to maximize his advantage. I could see him putting up same-ish numbers as last year. Finally, I worry about KP and injuries. I could easily see him missing significant time. Again, I hope to be completely wrong. Fish - I would also add they lost every one of their preseason games, and they looked awful doing it. New faces, change in focus - I think it's a step back to take 3 steps forward. sure... could be, but nychamp didnt really answer my question which is why the Knicks would be worse that last year (or why he thinks so). Why would defense or injuries be worse than last year?I guess my point is 25 wins is feasible. It could happen. My question is why do you think the Knicks will be worse than last year? If you're looking for someone to quantify it with advanced stats, I'm not that guy. Apologies if that's the type of back and forth you're trying to promote in this thread. In an attempt to more directly answer your question of why this year worse than last year I guess I would say two things. First, even though Rose and Melo were not winners overall last year, and hindered the team in many obvious ways, they did produce in spurts and would alter the game dynamics. Opponents were put on the defensive and had to react, game plan against, make adjustments because of the potential for takeover moments, offensive outbursts, the real possibility of a dominant offensive performance, especially by Melo. He had a bad year and wound up not coming through much in the clutch, but this ever present potential for it did always affect how teams approached the Knicks. This year, there is nobody to command that type of attention and I believe teams will be less on their heels against the Knicks, play more at ease against us. Nobody on the Knicks will be as hard to shut down this year. Additionally, there is even less familiarity with each other than last year, and the lead guys are younger and still pretty green. To me that equals missed opportunities, questionable decision-making and losses. All of this even acknowledging that last year's D was epicly bad. But this year, everyone knows the Knicks have almost no proven defenders and no one to truly worry about defending. Second, 24 and 31 wins are different, but not hugely so IMO. So I guess the idea of variance is a part of it for me. Sort of what Bonn said above, we weren't strictly a 31-win team last year, that was destined for 31 wins exactly. They could have won 27 or 35 perhaps if they played that same season again and again many times. They were at a particular level, basically a sucky team, capable of getting a lucky bounce or call here or there, but ultimately finishing with a number of wins that was in line with the level of team they were. Bad. So I am anticipating equally bad defense, maybe a bit worse, and less effective offense overall resulting a handful more losses. Again, I'd love to eat these words and see a real growth year for KP, have Frank be a two-way star right away, and witness a metamorphosis with Beasley and McD. I'm just not expecting it to happen.
|