[ IMAGES: Images ON turn off | ACCOUNT: User Status is LOCKED why? ]

training camp questions
Author Thread
fishmike
Posts: 53899
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 7/19/2002
Member: #298
USA
9/19/2017  3:52 PM
starting with:

What changes does the coach make? No more Phil and triangle.. Is Jeff on his own? Has Mills and/or Perry given him direction?

What does the PG rotation look like? Frank, Baker, Sessions and Jack.
Do any of the invited guards makes the team? Jaramaz? XRM? Randle?

What's Lee's role?

Is Melo a Knick? Or is he waiting for a trade? Is he looking to move the ball or working on getting his shots off?

Who starts at center? Where does Noah fit in? Is KOQ trade bait?

Kuz, Lance, Beasley... who wins those minutes?

"winning is more fun... then fun is fun" -Thibs
AUTOADVERT
Knixkik
Posts: 35517
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 7/24/2001
Member: #11
USA
9/19/2017  4:52 PM
I see Jeff really speeding things up. We probably see a lineup of Porzingis, Melo, Lee, Hardaway, and Ntilikina more often then not. Willy serves as 6th man playing 24-26 mpg. Beasley, Thomas, Baker, and either Sessions or Jack round out the rotation. O'Quinn probably is the odd man out (unless we go big.) Noah will be a match-up dependent rotation player when he returns. Kuz probably doesn't play much, as Beasley brings a similar skill-set and is probably a better player.
CrushAlot
Posts: 59764
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 7/25/2003
Member: #452
USA
9/19/2017  5:14 PM
Interesting stuff in the papers today. Jack said at voluntary workouts Jeff hasn't mentioned the triangle. Also, in one of the Beasley articles it said that guys are working out in Melo's gym but he is working out in a gym seperate from teammates.
I'm tired,I'm tired, I'm so tired right now......Kristaps Porzingis 1/3/18
BigDaddyG
Posts: 40052
Alba Posts: 9
Joined: 1/22/2010
Member: #3049

9/19/2017  5:24 PM
Knixkik wrote:I see Jeff really speeding things up. We probably see a lineup of Porzingis, Melo, Lee, Hardaway, and Ntilikina more often then not. Willy serves as 6th man playing 24-26 mpg. Beasley, Thomas, Baker, and either Sessions or Jack round out the rotation. O'Quinn probably is the odd man out (unless we go big.) Noah will be a match-up dependent rotation player when he returns. Kuz probably doesn't play much, as Beasley brings a similar skill-set and is probably a better player.

I'd count Jack and Noah out at this point. If they show something, it's all good. But they need to prove that they're healthy. Beasley and Kuz bring the same thing (scoring) but they do it differently. Kuz might be our best three point shooter coming in, so he's going to get minutes. Beasley is perfect as a small ball four. It will depend on the matchup, with Thomas defending the the tougher opponent at either forward spot. I'm hopeful that Thomas can stay healthy. I don't think we can count O'quinn out because of his defense, especially against physical bigs. Frank might be the odd man out coming in, but I think he'll get his minutes as the season goes on. Best case scenario is Sessions and Jack get traded or waived to go to a contender around the trade deadline.
Always... always remember: Less is less. More is more. More is better and twice as much is good too. Not enough is bad, and too much is never enough except when it's just about right. - The Tick
jrodmc
Posts: 32927
Alba Posts: 50
Joined: 11/24/2004
Member: #805
USA
9/20/2017  6:52 AM
Well, one easy answer is Noah (and his 25 abs) fits nicely in a chair for the start of the season... with a contract that might as well be another NTC...

If we still have Melo at the start of the season, i think the rotation is going to be:
Lance, Kuz, Beasely.

Jarret Jack is bench-end fodder; what happened to Ramon Sessions? He get put on IR already? Our evolution at the backcourt has certainly got reality show written all over it...
Pablo and Jose becomes DRose and Brandon-55-points-at-MSG which now is Frank Nitti and the 9 million dollar Baker?

From what can be gleaned from Tarrytown, the Phil era is now officially over, Triangle-wise, anyway.
More questions:

Does KP not show up come Monday? (cue the dramatic background muzak)

I wonder who (and if anyone) from the NBDL is going to get a camp invite?

Lee versus THJr?

knicks1248
Posts: 42059
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 2/3/2004
Member: #582
9/20/2017  8:31 AM
CrushAlot wrote:Interesting stuff in the papers today. Jack said at voluntary workouts Jeff hasn't mentioned the triangle. Also, in one of the Beasley articles it said that guys are working out in Melo's gym but he is working out in a gym seperate from teammates.

Can you imagine the media circus if he was in Tarry Town. Mills/perry is schedule to meet with the media Friday, and i think it's extremely important to shut the drama down for the sake of the rest of the team.

That Melo drama is set to be the biggest distraction in training camp.

ES
TheGame
Posts: 26639
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 7/15/2006
Member: #1154
USA
9/20/2017  10:20 AM
If Jack is healthy, he will be our best pg and should get 10-15 minutes a game. The interesting camp question will be who will start at pg. I want Frank to win that competition. He probably will not be the best pg at the start of the season but you might as well throw him out there. The kid has a year of professional experience, so it is not like he is coming from college. I can see the argument for starting him out slow, but in my mind, he can handle it. The coaches will hopefully make the best decision.

The next issue is whether the team treats Melo as if he is going to stay. Melo likely starts no matter what but it will be interesting how many minutes he gets.

Trust the Process
Gudris
Posts: 21011
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 12/12/2015
Member: #6213

9/20/2017  10:38 AM
TheGame wrote:If Jack is healthy, he will be our best pg and should get 10-15 minutes a game. The interesting camp question will be who will start at pg. I want Frank to win that competition. He probably will not be the best pg at the start of the season but you might as well throw him out there. The kid has a year of professional experience, so it is not like he is coming from college. I can see the argument for starting him out slow, but in my mind, he can handle it. The coaches will hopefully make the best decision.

The next issue is whether the team treats Melo as if he is going to stay. Melo likely starts no matter what but it will be interesting how many minutes he gets.

i dont think he can handle it , i saw his interviews, he looks pretty nervous, i am not sure if he can handle NYC pressure that easy

Paris907
Posts: 21146
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 7/4/2015
Member: #6099
USA
9/20/2017  1:28 PM
I think Kuz has a solid 3 but don’t be surprised if by seasons end it’s Dotson. KP/Lee/Kuz/Dotson/ all shoot the three and well.
fishmike
Posts: 53899
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 7/19/2002
Member: #298
USA
9/20/2017  1:49 PM
Paris907 wrote:I think Kuz has a solid 3 but don’t be surprised if by seasons end it’s Dotson. KP/Lee/Kuz/Dotson/ all shoot the three and well.
I think Dotson is a sleeper pick and I think he's the surprise player. I think he's a solid 3&D guy for years to come with some other nice skills as well. He got a wake up call at the right time in his life and hopefully the Knicks fully benefit. Fingers crossed.
"winning is more fun... then fun is fun" -Thibs
HofstraBBall
Posts: 28047
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 11/21/2015
Member: #6192

9/20/2017  1:51 PM
fishmike wrote:starting with:

What changes does the coach make? No more Phil and triangle.. Is Jeff on his own? Has Mills and/or Perry given him direction?

What does the PG rotation look like? Frank, Baker, Sessions and Jack.
Do any of the invited guards makes the team? Jaramaz? XRM? Randle?

What's Lee's role?

Is Melo a Knick? Or is he waiting for a trade? Is he looking to move the ball or working on getting his shots off?

Who starts at center? Where does Noah fit in? Is KOQ trade bait?

Kuz, Lance, Beasley... who wins those minutes?

Melo's side is expecting a trade before Friday.

Jack or Sessions will be the stating PG with Frank getting most of the second unit minutes.
Think Lee and Baker get most of minutes at 2 and Dotson spot minutes.

Prediction for starting lineup

Noah
KP
THJR
Lee
Jack

2nd. Unit
Willy
Anderson
Beasley
Baker
Frank

Unless they bench Noah and put KP at 5 and Anderson at 4 in starting lineup.

Think JH will also mix in small ball with may KP at 5, Beasley/LT at 4, Timmy at 3, 2 PG's.

Makes KO, Kuz, one of Vet PG's trade bait.

'Knicks focus should be on players that have grown up playing soccer or cricket' - Triplethreat 8/28/2020
nixluva
Posts: 56258
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 10/5/2004
Member: #758
USA
9/20/2017  1:58 PM
The Knicks NEVER ran even 50% Triangle last year. Despite all the Media and some Player complaints there was too much made of this issue. Knicks mostly ran Early Spread PnR and Drag Screens. The only thing stopping them from running more uptempo was poor defense and a lack of willingness to run the floor from certain players. It's more a matter of Hustle and Desire than anything Jeff did or didn't have them doing. Guys have to run the floor with purpose. Jeff wanted them to push the ball, but they didn't.

I suspect that they will still use some Triangle when in the Half Court, but not use all of the Rules heavy aspects of the system. Still even if Jeff completely gets rid of it, he's got plenty of other sets he can use and it will still require players learning how to execute. OK so even if you don't use Triangle but instead use Horns sets or whatever, you still have to master the sets and execute at a high level.

As for the PG spot I think it's good to have guys like Jack and Sessions in there mixed with the young guys. We're not talking about regular season games right now but how the younger players are being instructed in practice. These vets can help get the kids more ready. Last year Rose wasn't even there the whole time to help even if he wanted to. This Camp will be different in that regard. Nitty and Baker are going to play and just who starts is going to be a very interesting decision for Jeff IMO. I think it's going to be between Jack and Baker at the start. Just a hunch on my part.

fishmike
Posts: 53899
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 7/19/2002
Member: #298
USA
9/20/2017  1:59 PM
HofstraBBall wrote:
fishmike wrote:starting with:

What changes does the coach make? No more Phil and triangle.. Is Jeff on his own? Has Mills and/or Perry given him direction?

What does the PG rotation look like? Frank, Baker, Sessions and Jack.
Do any of the invited guards makes the team? Jaramaz? XRM? Randle?

What's Lee's role?

Is Melo a Knick? Or is he waiting for a trade? Is he looking to move the ball or working on getting his shots off?

Who starts at center? Where does Noah fit in? Is KOQ trade bait?

Kuz, Lance, Beasley... who wins those minutes?

Melo's side is expecting a trade before Friday.

Jack or Sessions will be the stating PG with Frank getting most of the second unit minutes.
Think Lee and Baker get most of minutes at 2 and Dotson spot minutes.

Prediction for starting lineup

Noah
KP
THJR
Lee
Jack

2nd. Unit
Willy
Anderson
Beasley
Baker
Frank

Unless they bench Noah and put KP at 5 and Anderson at 4 in starting lineup.

Think JH will also mix in small ball with may KP at 5, Beasley/LT at 4, Timmy at 3, 2 PG's.

Makes KO, Kuz, one of Vet PG's trade bait.

I have heard that about Melo as well... but we have also hear this all summer. There are certainly some mixed message with guys like Beasley talking about being thrilled to play with his buddy Melo. I do think Det is a viable destination for Ryan Anderson thus facilitating a Melo trade but again.. we have head this stuff all summer.

That being said Im thinking similar things you are regarding the rotation.
My first guess was (minus Melo and not factoring in for any players returned)
Noah, KP, Sessions, THjr with the 3 spot up for grabs between Lee, Kuz, Lance, Beas

I REALLY like Frank/Willy being featured in the 2nd unit running the P&R all day. Frank ran it well in EU and Willy sets bruising picks and is a great passer and finisher.

Question... Noah cant play for a month (12 games suspended for PEDs). Who starts? Remember KOQ wasnt handed anything last year, he earned his minutes.

"winning is more fun... then fun is fun" -Thibs
GustavBahler
Posts: 42864
Alba Posts: 15
Joined: 7/12/2010
Member: #3186

9/20/2017  2:30 PM
The young guards in camp can do themselves some good by playing some D. Might be the difference maker when it comes to PT.
nixluva
Posts: 56258
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 10/5/2004
Member: #758
USA
9/20/2017  2:33 PM
GustavBahler wrote:The young guards in camp can do themselves some good by playing some D. Might be the difference maker when it comes to PT.

I agree. The Knicks Coaches are going to be looking for Max Effort guys on D. That's going to be the key to getting PT.
HofstraBBall
Posts: 28047
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 11/21/2015
Member: #6192

9/20/2017  3:00 PM
fishmike wrote:
HofstraBBall wrote:
fishmike wrote:starting with:

What changes does the coach make? No more Phil and triangle.. Is Jeff on his own? Has Mills and/or Perry given him direction?

What does the PG rotation look like? Frank, Baker, Sessions and Jack.
Do any of the invited guards makes the team? Jaramaz? XRM? Randle?

What's Lee's role?

Is Melo a Knick? Or is he waiting for a trade? Is he looking to move the ball or working on getting his shots off?

Who starts at center? Where does Noah fit in? Is KOQ trade bait?

Kuz, Lance, Beasley... who wins those minutes?

Melo's side is expecting a trade before Friday.

Jack or Sessions will be the stating PG with Frank getting most of the second unit minutes.
Think Lee and Baker get most of minutes at 2 and Dotson spot minutes.

Prediction for starting lineup

Noah
KP
THJR
Lee
Jack

2nd. Unit
Willy
Anderson
Beasley
Baker
Frank

Unless they bench Noah and put KP at 5 and Anderson at 4 in starting lineup.

Think JH will also mix in small ball with may KP at 5, Beasley/LT at 4, Timmy at 3, 2 PG's.

Makes KO, Kuz, one of Vet PG's trade bait.

I have heard that about Melo as well... but we have also hear this all summer. There are certainly some mixed message with guys like Beasley talking about being thrilled to play with his buddy Melo. I do think Det is a viable destination for Ryan Anderson thus facilitating a Melo trade but again.. we have head this stuff all summer.

That being said Im thinking similar things you are regarding the rotation.
My first guess was (minus Melo and not factoring in for any players returned)
Noah, KP, Sessions, THjr with the 3 spot up for grabs between Lee, Kuz, Lance, Beas

I REALLY like Frank/Willy being featured in the 2nd unit running the P&R all day. Frank ran it well in EU and Willy sets bruising picks and is a great passer and finisher.

Question... Noah cant play for a month (12 games suspended for PEDs). Who starts? Remember KOQ wasnt handed anything last year, he earned his minutes.

Melo trade depends on how long Knicks pretend keeping him is a viable option. Don't think anyone is buying that. Specially Melo's people.

True forgot about Noah. Guess durin Noah's suspension we will have Willy starting with KP playing some 5. As JH did last year with Noah out. Think KO may be part of Melo deal as may be some other pieces. Knicks will have to play Noah, once he is back, in order to build up his value.

'Knicks focus should be on players that have grown up playing soccer or cricket' - Triplethreat 8/28/2020
GustavBahler
Posts: 42864
Alba Posts: 15
Joined: 7/12/2010
Member: #3186

9/20/2017  3:11 PM
Saw this in the Daily News.


Jarrett Jack, 33, is attempting his playing comeback with the Knicks this season, but had previously outlined a post-career aspiration to lead on the sideline. That should get the thumbs up from at least a couple NBA general managers, who, for consecutive years in their annual survey, voted the point guard in the top-5 for the category, "Which active player will make the best head coach someday?"

It's a good sign for Ntilikina, the eighth overall draft pick who will need more guidance than most rookies will because of his demanding position (point guard), age (19) and inexperience (he's never played in the U.S.).

Jack is eager to begin such a mentorship but is allowing the dynamic to grow organically as the two train together at voluntary workouts.


"For sure he has a lot of tools that you can't teach but just the cerebral side of it, that's where I come into play," Jack said. "Just try to hip him to some little tricks of the trade as the season goes along and just understanding what it means to be a starting PG in this league."

Jack still needs to make the Knicks roster, which is never a given on non-guaranteed contract. Less than two years ago, he was starting across the bridge for the Nets and averaging nearly 13 points per game. But then Jack tore his ACL, suffered a setback in his recovery, and played only two games since January 2016.

Nalod
Posts: 71546
Alba Posts: 155
Joined: 12/24/2003
Member: #508
USA
9/20/2017  3:27 PM
Love the answers. we form our own opinions on what we read and cannot remember if it was reliable source or our own sense from reading all.
I get snarky when I read Isola as if he has all the bad stuff figured out. According to him, KP hates Jeff and will leave.
Validated by the highly profiled KP exit drama.
Moving on, lets see what the real deal is. Rest assured KP will be catered to. Phil was given his money and told to leave because he wanted to trade the kid.
Certainly eating one year of Hornacek's contract to make the unicorn happy is not a problem.
This is a big season for KP also, its time for him to begin to show greater maturity on and off the court. Sure he is a kid and his two year rise to stardom is no doubt a rush for any kid with a dream. But soon the big money will come and he must understand the strings that are attached to it. If he does not its better to trade him before he gains his freedom.
I don't want that to happen. I root for his success.

All the while one should expect the Melo era to end sooner than later. I admire the knicks position and Melo's as well as in the post Phil Era all professionalism that has gone into this. Melo himself has never been a epicenter of drama as he even handled his departure from Denver and his free agency with a certain restrain. Knicks on the other hand finally have shown a level themselves by quietly divorcing from Phil (we have not seen any summertime "Phil files") and instead Mills has constructed a starphuch free front office with experienced personnel.

If there was ever a reason for hope its not in the form of a "Prophet" like Phil, a sage like Walsh, or the snake oil salesmanship of Isiah, its Scott Perry and his boss Steve Mills.
This perhaps more than any other sign shows Dolan is detached from the team. Maybe some of you are not impressed because we don't have guys that are from programs that have won before and we like that sort of thing. Not a bad idea, but before teams win they usually have to make changes and more times that not the "no names" are elevated not from past achievements but the ones they create themselves. Its rare you can import an culture. It takes time and patience.

Spurs were born from Larry Brown but did its greatest work after he had left. Im am thinking that Phil did point the team in the right direction and if it took 60 mil and dolans attention then it was worth every penny. No, Phil did not make any great moves but he cleaned enough house and kept to building thru the draft.

LIke Pop is the true architect, not Larry Brown, This team is now Mill's and Perry.

Lots of questions. Answers soon enough!

knicks1248
Posts: 42059
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 2/3/2004
Member: #582
9/20/2017  3:55 PM
HofstraBBall wrote:
fishmike wrote:
HofstraBBall wrote:
fishmike wrote:starting with:

What changes does the coach make? No more Phil and triangle.. Is Jeff on his own? Has Mills and/or Perry given him direction?

What does the PG rotation look like? Frank, Baker, Sessions and Jack.
Do any of the invited guards makes the team? Jaramaz? XRM? Randle?

What's Lee's role?

Is Melo a Knick? Or is he waiting for a trade? Is he looking to move the ball or working on getting his shots off?

Who starts at center? Where does Noah fit in? Is KOQ trade bait?

Kuz, Lance, Beasley... who wins those minutes?

Melo's side is expecting a trade before Friday.

Jack or Sessions will be the stating PG with Frank getting most of the second unit minutes.
Think Lee and Baker get most of minutes at 2 and Dotson spot minutes.

Prediction for starting lineup

Noah
KP
THJR
Lee
Jack

2nd. Unit
Willy
Anderson
Beasley
Baker
Frank

Unless they bench Noah and put KP at 5 and Anderson at 4 in starting lineup.

Think JH will also mix in small ball with may KP at 5, Beasley/LT at 4, Timmy at 3, 2 PG's.

Makes KO, Kuz, one of Vet PG's trade bait.

I have heard that about Melo as well... but we have also hear this all summer. There are certainly some mixed message with guys like Beasley talking about being thrilled to play with his buddy Melo. I do think Det is a viable destination for Ryan Anderson thus facilitating a Melo trade but again.. we have head this stuff all summer.

That being said Im thinking similar things you are regarding the rotation.
My first guess was (minus Melo and not factoring in for any players returned)
Noah, KP, Sessions, THjr with the 3 spot up for grabs between Lee, Kuz, Lance, Beas

I REALLY like Frank/Willy being featured in the 2nd unit running the P&R all day. Frank ran it well in EU and Willy sets bruising picks and is a great passer and finisher.

Question... Noah cant play for a month (12 games suspended for PEDs). Who starts? Remember KOQ wasnt handed anything last year, he earned his minutes.

Melo trade depends on how long Knicks pretend keeping him is a viable option. Don't think anyone is buying that. Specially Melo's people.

True forgot about Noah. Guess durin Noah's suspension we will have Willy starting with KP playing some 5. As JH did last year with Noah out. Think KO may be part of Melo deal as may be some other pieces. Knicks will have to play Noah, once he is back, in order to build up his value.

why would jh and mills go see melo play in pick up games if they had no interest in keeping him?

riddle me that..

ES
fishmike
Posts: 53899
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 7/19/2002
Member: #298
USA
9/20/2017  3:59 PM
GustavBahler wrote:Saw this in the Daily News.


Jarrett Jack, 33, is attempting his playing comeback with the Knicks this season, but had previously outlined a post-career aspiration to lead on the sideline. That should get the thumbs up from at least a couple NBA general managers, who, for consecutive years in their annual survey, voted the point guard in the top-5 for the category, "Which active player will make the best head coach someday?"

It's a good sign for Ntilikina, the eighth overall draft pick who will need more guidance than most rookies will because of his demanding position (point guard), age (19) and inexperience (he's never played in the U.S.).

Jack is eager to begin such a mentorship but is allowing the dynamic to grow organically as the two train together at voluntary workouts.


"For sure he has a lot of tools that you can't teach but just the cerebral side of it, that's where I come into play," Jack said. "Just try to hip him to some little tricks of the trade as the season goes along and just understanding what it means to be a starting PG in this league."

Jack still needs to make the Knicks roster, which is never a given on non-guaranteed contract. Less than two years ago, he was starting across the bridge for the Nets and averaging nearly 13 points per game. But then Jack tore his ACL, suffered a setback in his recovery, and played only two games since January 2016.

Very cool! Nice nugget!
"winning is more fun... then fun is fun" -Thibs
training camp questions

©2001-2025 ultimateknicks.comm All rights reserved. About Us.
This site is not affiliated with the NY Knicks or the National Basketball Association in any way.
You may visit the official NY Knicks web site by clicking here.

All times (GMT-05:00) Eastern Time.

Terms of Use and Privacy Policy