newyorknewyork wrote:
I agree with most of this. Though I will say Phil could have made some better decisions in terms of who he acquired to try and win now with without giving up picks. Tyson Chandler for Calderon was a big blunder which he overvalued Calderon. Giving out 4 yrs 70mil to Noah.Really thinking about it, Phil should have had 2 guys under him. Mills would be forced to be apart of the equation so he would be one. With the other being in the Ujiri, Hinkie, Morey analytical mold. The analytical studs goal should have been to collect, collect, collect assets. He should have been in charge of making these trades to acquire draft picks. Moving Tyson, Shumpert, Hardaway for draft picks. Taking on short term ugly contracts for draft picks, getting something for Melo. Phil's job with Gaines and head coach would have been the basketball minds. Turning these assets into a *team* that fits as a cohesive unit.
Today
Hornacek and I guess if he is still with us Gaines are the only real basketball minds now. So we need an analytical guy to complete the cipher. But we still need to see how good Hornaceks basketball mind is. But we need a complete front office. Strong basketball minds with strong analytical minds.
It comes to the third critical mistakes Phil Jackson had made. It is not about tactics, it is all about who he is. I am not sure if it is a common flaw for any great coach but Larry Brown has it too.
The flaw is that they are a teacher. They want to teach a.k.a they want to change their players. When Phil was looking at Melo, he didn't see the present Melo, but the future one. The ultimate, true MVP Melo. Phil foresaw this Melo would pass the ball, move around, and lead other players. It is very ironic because Phil was actually the biggest Melo fan. Even the most loyal Melo fan here probably admit Melo is not LBJ, but Phil compared him to MJ and Kobe.
But Melo is who he is, not who he would be. Especially he was surrounded by his posse who said nothing but praise. When Phil wants to be a teacher, Melo had no mood to be a student. He thought he was a top 3 player and didn't need anyone to teach him to play basketball. So Phil failed.
Noah, same case. Phil thought he would be a triangle center and be back to his DPOY form.
Rose, Phil thought he would change him to be a triangle PG.
JR Smith, Shump, and Hardaway Jr. He thought he could change them so he missed the prefect time to trade them.
Phil signed and traded players not because of who they are, but who they would be. When he wanted to change them, some of them could, some of them couldn't. Most players of Knicks couldn't.
Then it leads to his fourth biggest mistake. People always thought Phil was very good at ego management of players. He knew mind-games. He could make players buy into what he wanted to do. When he was able to do all of above, it is not because he was very diplomatic. It is just because he won.
I mean, if he was good at ego management then he could have done it at the office of MSG too, right? He was like Napoleon. Players listened to Phil because he won, and he won just because he was a brilliant tactician. People always say MJ and Kobe could win in any offense, but how many of us would realize Phil could have as well?
And this is exactly why he lost his magic now just because he no longer sit on the bench. He is powerless when he is not in the battleground. He could lead because he won. He can no longer lead just because he is no longer a coach. The fourth mistake is that he overestimated his ability to lead when he is not on the floor.
Agein I write too much, I think I should stop for now.