Sinix wrote:yellowboy90 wrote:fishmike wrote:Sinix wrote:fishmike wrote:every GM that fails has these "things" happen to him. What makes GMs great is their ability to minimize these things and move forward. Every issue for Phil was a dramatic disaster. He failed to deliver on his promises for transparency for starters. He rarely communicated with the media and his use of twitter was idiotic. Phil made just enough mistakes to get himself chopped. There is very little more this this story than that.
What I came away with is that the team and franchise was a circus before he got there. He tried to fix it but the carnies want and are comfortable with their circus.
Not every gm walks into situations like these. Not every gm has to deal with a melo type that gets everyone fired. Not every new gm is stuck with no rookies and no draft picks going forward.
Yea... Melo's fault. We get it.
See you just don't get it. It was really Melo's fault.
That post I made didn't even mention melo. Guys like him are just melo fan boys first.
Actually my point went beyond melo, that melo is more a symptom of a problem than the total underlining problem. We still gotta deal with the symptom though.
But nothing would change if we dropped melo and didn't change the overall culture of the Knicks. There's no firm leadership or vision in management.
The culture is the problem and Phil was trying to change it (the triangle is a tool to effect the change)
What he knows is that, on the court, Melo is the driving force of the culture. What he didn't count on was that Dolan would stick up for his boy Melo over him (Dolan is the ultimate driving force of the culture). I think Phil might have even given Dolan the ultimatum of its either Melo or me. He gambled and lost but my guess is that he was ok with the outcome either way. If Dolan backed Phil, it was a big win for moving the organization forward. If Dolan backed Melo, which he did, then Phil gets to go home and his big headache becomes someone else's problem.
Dolan is Melo's enabler (AA term here...Dolan is a recovering alcoholic). He got him here, IMO gave him the new deal with the NTC and now is keeping him here. UNtil Melo is gone the team will not improve on the court. Until Dolan is gone the organizational culture will not change.
It's sad to be a Knicks fan...yet again.