Posted by eViL:
Posted by Rich:
You are flat out wrong. O'Neal's first season playing for the Lakers was '96-'97. That was the very same year that Houston began playing for the Knicks. Houston was signed as a free agent, and so was Shaq.
First things first, I should have said pre-CBA not pre-cap. the current CBA would have made it a lot more difficult for the Lakers (even armed with cap room) to sign Shaquille O'Neal. Whether it would or would not have happened doesn't matter because it wasn't the bulk of my point anyway. So sure, I'm "flat out wrong" for typing that one sentence, but you didn't address anything else in my post.
The point is that the Lakers had to get under the cap to sign Shaq. That was the only way he was going to be able to join the Lakers. If he didn't sign with the Lakers, they don't win anyone of those championships. You said you were clearing some things up, but your facts were wrong. My point remains valid.
I never said getting under the cap was the ONLY way to assemble a championship team, but if you are unable to draft franchise players who are usually taken in the top three to five picks in the draft, it is the best way to build a championship team, not merely a contender, like Indiana, the Nets, Kings, or Dallas (although Nowitski was drafted at around seven, IIRC).
Yes, there are exceptions to the rule, like the Pistons. They got very lucky. How many people thought that when they traded Grant Hill for a package that included Ben Wallace, that he would turn out to be one of the most dominant players in the NBA?
I hope Isiah is able to pull off a similar building process on the Knicks. My point remains: unless they can get a franchise big man with their expiring contracts (TT's, Penny's, Moochie's, Nazr's) next year, getting under the cap when Houston's, JYD's, and Anderson's contracts expire in three years, is their best opportunity to get one.
Getting under the cap not only enables a team to sign free agents, it also makes completing trades a lot easier.
From my perspective, the soft cap is the worst system in pro sports. If the NBA won't permit unlimited spending, like in MLB, they should have a hard cap like the NFL. It enforces discipline, and prevents people like Layden from making moronic decisions that can destroy a franchise for five or more years.