[ IMAGES: Images ON turn off | ACCOUNT: User Status is LOCKED why? ]

How I feel about the Phil Jackson situation (great article from last month)
Author Thread
mreinman
Posts: 37827
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 7/14/2010
Member: #3189

4/20/2016  10:02 AM
http://knickerblogger.net/phil-jackson-destroyed-the-stability-he-created-with-knicks/

The attraction of Phil Jackson running the New York Knicks was he would bring a sensibility to the organization that often didn’t exist.

Whether you agreed or disagreed with the moves Jackson made through the pre-firing Derek Fisher portion of his tenure, his presence became easier to accept because of a level of stability.

The team owned by James Dolan was going along in a rational manner.

They didn’t return much value for Tyson Chandler, Iman Shumpert and J.R. Smith, but you could see a level of logic behind both trades. Despite it taking longer than it should have – Carmelo Anthony did eventually shut it down for the season due to a knee injury. The dead weight on the team was sent away with Amar’e Stoudemire and Andrea Bargnani being bought out.

First-year head coach Derek Fisher spent about half the season experimenting with a more pick and roll based offense rather than the triangle and giving different players an opportunity to prove themselves.

Yea, they screwed up winning a couple games at the end of the season, but it’s not fair to expect players to not go out and try. It was just unfortunate results.

Drafting Kristaps Porzingis and Jerian Grant brought along hope of Jackson being more open to adjusting New York’s playing style due to their skills sets in a good start to his second full offseason on the job.

Free agency should have been the first sign of slight concern when it came to Jackson’s view of what he wanted the team to be. He went after too many bigs and not enough attention to players who could break down a defense off the dribble.

Nothing Jackson did was overly harmful, but he gave insight into what he was looking for with how he constructed the roster. Individually, none of the contracts he gave out were bad, yet in totality they didn’t make all that much sense.

All that said, it wasn’t the end of the world. Rebuilding the Knicks roster from the tear down was more than a one-offseason process. Jackson needed to be given more time to flesh out what he was trying to accomplish.

The season started and the Knicks overachieved. Fisher implemented a smarter defensive scheme that tried to force teams into mid-range shots and the offense was a decent balance of using triangle principles and modern concepts. It wasn’t perfect, but it was something you could live with.

Fisher worked on developing Porzingis and Grant, maximized Thomas’ versatility on the defensive end, had Anthony playing brilliant all-around basketball and managed minutes in a decent fashion.

Once they hit 22-22, one of the healthiest teams in the league at that point in the season, started getting banged up. The nine-man rotation Fisher settled on could no longer be used and the Knicks lack of quality depth shined through. They played a bunch of close games and battled hard, but couldn’t close anything out.

Thinking back on it, in Fisher’s last games it was almost like he was trying to prove a point. In first halves he Knicks would run mainly triangle based offensive sets leading to them falling behind. In second halves they’d run a ton of spread PnR storming back into the game.

This pattern happened quite frequently.

Was it Fisher trying to prove a point to Jackson?

If he was should have Fisher tried to communicate better with his boss instead of being standoffish? Yep.

Should have Jackson been smart enough to see what was happening and not be stubborn about the type of offense that was being implemented? Yep.

The basketball reasons to fire Fisher didn’t make much sense. If it was other dealings that were more involved with off the court shenanigans so be it. Whatever the case, when Jackson made the decision to fire Fisher he tore down what he had worked so hard to build up – an appearance of stability.

Teams that are stable don’t fire coaches less than two years into a job with a group that was on track to be one of the most improved in the NBA.

Jackson made his buddy Kurt Rambis interim head coach and ever since they’ve gone back to their old cluster**** ways.

Rambis trying to “win now” (poorly by the way, he’s not even good at that) has led to potential bad consequences. Melo is getting overplayed, they’ve swung towards increased base triangle action, the protect the paint screw threes defense is back, Sasha Vujacic’s role has increased while Grant’s has decreased and Porzingis is being used incorrectly.

The scary part of all of this is Rambis and Jackson openly discuss how improved the communication between the two of them is compared to Fisher and Jackson.

Simply put………that’s terrifying.

Even while only winning 17 games what made Jackson’s first year a success was an understanding of where the team was and what needed to be accomplished.

The same hasn’t happened this season – it feels like Jackson has become short sighted.

Outside of unrealistic trade rumors involving Jeff Teague – there’s been no attempt to address their slow, plodding, lack of dribble penetration backcourt.

Lower level guards such as Mario Chalmers, D.J. Augustin, Shelvin Mack and Ish Smith were all traded during the regular season. Maybe getting one of them wasn’t realistic, but a move of that elk could have been made.

They’ve had two players come on 10-day contracts in Thanasis Antetokounmpo and Jimmer Fredette and neither was given a chance to contribute in a meaningful way.

And the Fredette circus should have never been at MSG in the first place.

Jackson been content allowing Lou Amundson, Cleanthony Early and Vujacic eat up roster spots and not contribute in a positive way.

Jackson’s managing of the Knicks roster this season has lacked ingenuity and creativity.

Once the playoffs became unrealistic a smartly run team would have preserved Melo, experimented with an offense revolving around Porzingis and Grant’s skills, and used two or three roster spots to try to find cheap talent to add to the team gong forward.

The reason to be worried about Jackson has nothing to do with what his record is since being in charge of the Knicks. It’s quite the opposite – the bad record shows he understood what needed to be done in his first full year on the job. The roster is in a healthier place than where it was when Jackson took it over.

The question is with the decision-making and vision Jackson has demonstrated this season can he be trusted to be in charge of the Knicks going forward?

If Jackson isn’t able to set aside his ego in regards to the next coach and how the Knicks on court product should be shaped – what needs to happen is so painful I don’t have the will to even spell it out.

Tags: Amare Stoudemire, Andrea BargnaniA, Carmelo Anthony, derek fisher, iman shumpert, J.R. Smith, James Dolan, Jerian Grant, Kristaps Porzingis, new york knicks, Phil Jackson, Simmer Fredette, Thanasis Antetokounmpo, Tyson Chandler

so here is what phil is thinking ....
AUTOADVERT
knicks1248
Posts: 42059
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 2/3/2004
Member: #582
4/20/2016  11:26 AM
mreinman wrote:http://knickerblogger.net/phil-jackson-destroyed-the-stability-he-created-with-knicks/

The attraction of Phil Jackson running the New York Knicks was he would bring a sensibility to the organization that often didn’t exist.

Whether you agreed or disagreed with the moves Jackson made through the pre-firing Derek Fisher portion of his tenure, his presence became easier to accept because of a level of stability.

The team owned by James Dolan was going along in a rational manner.

They didn’t return much value for Tyson Chandler, Iman Shumpert and J.R. Smith, but you could see a level of logic behind both trades. Despite it taking longer than it should have – Carmelo Anthony did eventually shut it down for the season due to a knee injury. The dead weight on the team was sent away with Amar’e Stoudemire and Andrea Bargnani being bought out.

First-year head coach Derek Fisher spent about half the season experimenting with a more pick and roll based offense rather than the triangle and giving different players an opportunity to prove themselves.

Yea, they screwed up winning a couple games at the end of the season, but it’s not fair to expect players to not go out and try. It was just unfortunate results.

Drafting Kristaps Porzingis and Jerian Grant brought along hope of Jackson being more open to adjusting New York’s playing style due to their skills sets in a good start to his second full offseason on the job.

Free agency should have been the first sign of slight concern when it came to Jackson’s view of what he wanted the team to be. He went after too many bigs and not enough attention to players who could break down a defense off the dribble.

Nothing Jackson did was overly harmful, but he gave insight into what he was looking for with how he constructed the roster. Individually, none of the contracts he gave out were bad, yet in totality they didn’t make all that much sense.

All that said, it wasn’t the end of the world. Rebuilding the Knicks roster from the tear down was more than a one-offseason process. Jackson needed to be given more time to flesh out what he was trying to accomplish.

The season started and the Knicks overachieved. Fisher implemented a smarter defensive scheme that tried to force teams into mid-range shots and the offense was a decent balance of using triangle principles and modern concepts. It wasn’t perfect, but it was something you could live with.

Fisher worked on developing Porzingis and Grant, maximized Thomas’ versatility on the defensive end, had Anthony playing brilliant all-around basketball and managed minutes in a decent fashion.

Once they hit 22-22, one of the healthiest teams in the league at that point in the season, started getting banged up. The nine-man rotation Fisher settled on could no longer be used and the Knicks lack of quality depth shined through. They played a bunch of close games and battled hard, but couldn’t close anything out.

Thinking back on it, in Fisher’s last games it was almost like he was trying to prove a point. In first halves he Knicks would run mainly triangle based offensive sets leading to them falling behind. In second halves they’d run a ton of spread PnR storming back into the game.

This pattern happened quite frequently.

Was it Fisher trying to prove a point to Jackson?

If he was should have Fisher tried to communicate better with his boss instead of being standoffish? Yep.

Should have Jackson been smart enough to see what was happening and not be stubborn about the type of offense that was being implemented? Yep.

The basketball reasons to fire Fisher didn’t make much sense. If it was other dealings that were more involved with off the court shenanigans so be it. Whatever the case, when Jackson made the decision to fire Fisher he tore down what he had worked so hard to build up – an appearance of stability.

Teams that are stable don’t fire coaches less than two years into a job with a group that was on track to be one of the most improved in the NBA.

Jackson made his buddy Kurt Rambis interim head coach and ever since they’ve gone back to their old cluster**** ways.

Rambis trying to “win now” (poorly by the way, he’s not even good at that) has led to potential bad consequences. Melo is getting overplayed, they’ve swung towards increased base triangle action, the protect the paint screw threes defense is back, Sasha Vujacic’s role has increased while Grant’s has decreased and Porzingis is being used incorrectly.

The scary part of all of this is Rambis and Jackson openly discuss how improved the communication between the two of them is compared to Fisher and Jackson.

Simply put………that’s terrifying.

Even while only winning 17 games what made Jackson’s first year a success was an understanding of where the team was and what needed to be accomplished.

The same hasn’t happened this season – it feels like Jackson has become short sighted.

Outside of unrealistic trade rumors involving Jeff Teague – there’s been no attempt to address their slow, plodding, lack of dribble penetration backcourt.

Lower level guards such as Mario Chalmers, D.J. Augustin, Shelvin Mack and Ish Smith were all traded during the regular season. Maybe getting one of them wasn’t realistic, but a move of that elk could have been made.

They’ve had two players come on 10-day contracts in Thanasis Antetokounmpo and Jimmer Fredette and neither was given a chance to contribute in a meaningful way.

And the Fredette circus should have never been at MSG in the first place.

Jackson been content allowing Lou Amundson, Cleanthony Early and Vujacic eat up roster spots and not contribute in a positive way.

Jackson’s managing of the Knicks roster this season has lacked ingenuity and creativity.

Once the playoffs became unrealistic a smartly run team would have preserved Melo, experimented with an offense revolving around Porzingis and Grant’s skills, and used two or three roster spots to try to find cheap talent to add to the team gong forward.

The reason to be worried about Jackson has nothing to do with what his record is since being in charge of the Knicks. It’s quite the opposite – the bad record shows he understood what needed to be done in his first full year on the job. The roster is in a healthier place than where it was when Jackson took it over.

The question is with the decision-making and vision Jackson has demonstrated this season can he be trusted to be in charge of the Knicks going forward?

If Jackson isn’t able to set aside his ego in regards to the next coach and how the Knicks on court product should be shaped – what needs to happen is so painful I don’t have the will to even spell it out.

Tags: Amare Stoudemire, Andrea BargnaniA, Carmelo Anthony, derek fisher, iman shumpert, J.R. Smith, James Dolan, Jerian Grant, Kristaps Porzingis, new york knicks, Phil Jackson, Simmer Fredette, Thanasis Antetokounmpo, Tyson Chandler

the painful truth

ES
Nalod
Posts: 72120
Alba Posts: 155
Joined: 12/24/2003
Member: #508
USA
4/20/2016  12:16 PM    LAST EDITED: 4/20/2016  12:18 PM
Its a blog. Its an opinion. Most people have one. We also have azzholes.

Key phrase:

"Should have Jackson been smart enough to see what was happening and not be stubborn about the type of offense that was being implemented? Yep."
Articles like this don't discourage me but galvanize the belief that phil is correct. The path to greatness is not the easy road. Fish was not the man and Phil is all to blame for it. Then what? Take his 48 years of professional experience and say his cred is all wrong because his second choice to coach didn't work out? Freaking comical!!!!!

nixluva
Posts: 56258
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 10/5/2004
Member: #758
USA
4/20/2016  12:19 PM
It's a well written article, but one thing comes to my mind. NONE of the things he got criticized for are really long term detrimental going forward. Missteps for sure but nothing fatal was done. In fact the team is pretty well setup for improvement with the right moves.


PLAYER POS. 2015-16 2016-17 2017-18 2018-19 2019-20
Carmelo Anthony SF $22,875,000 $24,559,380 $26,243,760 $27,928,140 UFA
Robin Lopez C $12,650,000 $13,219,250 $13,788,500 $14,357,750 UFA

Arron Afflalo SG $8,000,000 $8,000,000 UFA - -
Jose Calderon PG $7,402,812 $7,708,427 UFA - -
Derrick Williams PF $4,400,000 $4,400,000 UFA - -
Kristaps Porzingis PF $4,131,720 $4,317,720 $4,503,600 $5,697,054 RFA
Kyle O'Quinn PF $3,750,000 $3,918,750 $4,087,500 $4,256,250 UFA

Kevin Seraphin PF $2,814,000 UFA - - -
Lance Thomas SF $1,636,842 UFA - - -
Louis Amundson PF $1,635,476 UFA - - -
Jerian Grant PG $1,572,360 $1,643,040 $1,713,840 $2,639,314 RFA
Sasha Vujacic SG $947,276 UFA - - -
Cleanthony Early SF $845,059 RFA - - -
Langston Galloway PG $845,059 RFA - - -
Tony Wroten Jr. SG $167,406 $1,050,961 UFA - -
73,673,010 68,817,528 50,337,200 54,878,508 0
mreinman
Posts: 37827
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 7/14/2010
Member: #3189

4/20/2016  4:28 PM
nixluva wrote:It's a well written article, but one thing comes to my mind. NONE of the things he got criticized for are really long term detrimental going forward. Missteps for sure but nothing fatal was done. In fact the team is pretty well setup for improvement with the right moves.


PLAYER POS. 2015-16 2016-17 2017-18 2018-19 2019-20
Carmelo Anthony SF $22,875,000 $24,559,380 $26,243,760 $27,928,140 UFA
Robin Lopez C $12,650,000 $13,219,250 $13,788,500 $14,357,750 UFA

Arron Afflalo SG $8,000,000 $8,000,000 UFA - -
Jose Calderon PG $7,402,812 $7,708,427 UFA - -
Derrick Williams PF $4,400,000 $4,400,000 UFA - -
Kristaps Porzingis PF $4,131,720 $4,317,720 $4,503,600 $5,697,054 RFA
Kyle O'Quinn PF $3,750,000 $3,918,750 $4,087,500 $4,256,250 UFA

Kevin Seraphin PF $2,814,000 UFA - - -
Lance Thomas SF $1,636,842 UFA - - -
Louis Amundson PF $1,635,476 UFA - - -
Jerian Grant PG $1,572,360 $1,643,040 $1,713,840 $2,639,314 RFA
Sasha Vujacic SG $947,276 UFA - - -
Cleanthony Early SF $845,059 RFA - - -
Langston Galloway PG $845,059 RFA - - -
Tony Wroten Jr. SG $167,406 $1,050,961 UFA - -
73,673,010 68,817,528 50,337,200 54,878,508 0

He does mention your point. He is just worried about the stubbornness going forward.

so here is what phil is thinking ....
Nalod
Posts: 72120
Alba Posts: 155
Joined: 12/24/2003
Member: #508
USA
4/20/2016  5:10 PM
One mans "stubbornness" is another mans "Discipline".
mreinman
Posts: 37827
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 7/14/2010
Member: #3189

4/20/2016  5:15 PM
Nalod wrote:One mans "stubbornness" is another mans "Discipline".

sure ... that too.

lets see how this stubbornness pays off in free agency.

so here is what phil is thinking ....
CrushAlot
Posts: 59764
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 7/25/2003
Member: #452
USA
4/20/2016  7:15 PM
Seems like they have some new writers on Knickerblogger. Also, I don't think their blog streams to the home page anymore but it might just be that they aren't pumping out the content like they used to. Read this awhile ago and like Nalod said it is an opinion piece.
I'm tired,I'm tired, I'm so tired right now......Kristaps Porzingis 1/3/18
knicks1248
Posts: 42059
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 2/3/2004
Member: #582
4/20/2016  9:12 PM
CrushAlot wrote:Seems like they have some new writers on Knickerblogger. Also, I don't think their blog streams to the home page anymore but it might just be that they aren't pumping out the content like they used to. Read this awhile ago and like Nalod said it is an opinion piece.

With limited media access to the knicks, it mostly becomes opinionated no matter the level. The thing is we are all looking at the same movie, the same weird stuff that goes on with every general manger/prez that runs the knicks.

This franchise has not been normal since Dolan stepped in.

We had Isiah and The Larry brown reality show

We had Isiah and the harassment scandal

Donnie "Iron Side" Walsh, rolling up in a wheel chair to greet Labron

Grunwald was actually a breath of fresh air, until he hid in the closet because he couldn't Close on Jermey Lin

And now we have "BIG CHIEF TRIANGLE" ( I think it was JVG who gave him that name during a playoff battle... so perfect) who's starting to run the franchise like some CULT, and no ones allowed if don't you bow to the triangle.

He said DOLAN brought him in to build the TRIANGLE CULT-URE. That exactly what it seems like

ES
knicks1248
Posts: 42059
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 2/3/2004
Member: #582
4/20/2016  9:19 PM
nixluva wrote:It's a well written article, but one thing comes to my mind. NONE of the things he got criticized for are really long term detrimental going forward. Missteps for sure but nothing fatal was done. In fact the team is pretty well setup for improvement with the right moves.


PLAYER POS. 2015-16 2016-17 2017-18 2018-19 2019-20
Carmelo Anthony SF $22,875,000 $24,559,380 $26,243,760 $27,928,140 UFA
Robin Lopez C $12,650,000 $13,219,250 $13,788,500 $14,357,750 UFA

Arron Afflalo SG $8,000,000 $8,000,000 UFA - -
Jose Calderon PG $7,402,812 $7,708,427 UFA - -
Derrick Williams PF $4,400,000 $4,400,000 UFA - -
Kristaps Porzingis PF $4,131,720 $4,317,720 $4,503,600 $5,697,054 RFA
Kyle O'Quinn PF $3,750,000 $3,918,750 $4,087,500 $4,256,250 UFA

Kevin Seraphin PF $2,814,000 UFA - - -
Lance Thomas SF $1,636,842 UFA - - -
Louis Amundson PF $1,635,476 UFA - - -
Jerian Grant PG $1,572,360 $1,643,040 $1,713,840 $2,639,314 RFA
Sasha Vujacic SG $947,276 UFA - - -
Cleanthony Early SF $845,059 RFA - - -
Langston Galloway PG $845,059 RFA - - -
Tony Wroten Jr. SG $167,406 $1,050,961 UFA - -
73,673,010 68,817,528 50,337,200 54,878,508 0

Nix when was the last time we had a roster full of bad contracts other than Amare and melo, we've been relatively decent since 09/10 season

ES
CrushAlot
Posts: 59764
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 7/25/2003
Member: #452
USA
4/20/2016  9:48 PM
Nalod wrote:One mans "stubbornness" is another mans "Discipline".
This. We need to rebuild, we need a system, STOP! I know more than the guy with 11 rings. Lets get back to the flavor of the month approach.
I'm tired,I'm tired, I'm so tired right now......Kristaps Porzingis 1/3/18
nixluva
Posts: 56258
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 10/5/2004
Member: #758
USA
4/20/2016  10:01 PM
knicks1248 wrote:
nixluva wrote:It's a well written article, but one thing comes to my mind. NONE of the things he got criticized for are really long term detrimental going forward. Missteps for sure but nothing fatal was done. In fact the team is pretty well setup for improvement with the right moves.


PLAYER POS. 2015-16 2016-17 2017-18 2018-19 2019-20
Carmelo Anthony SF $22,875,000 $24,559,380 $26,243,760 $27,928,140 UFA
Robin Lopez C $12,650,000 $13,219,250 $13,788,500 $14,357,750 UFA

Arron Afflalo SG $8,000,000 $8,000,000 UFA - -
Jose Calderon PG $7,402,812 $7,708,427 UFA - -
Derrick Williams PF $4,400,000 $4,400,000 UFA - -
Kristaps Porzingis PF $4,131,720 $4,317,720 $4,503,600 $5,697,054 RFA
Kyle O'Quinn PF $3,750,000 $3,918,750 $4,087,500 $4,256,250 UFA

Kevin Seraphin PF $2,814,000 UFA - - -
Lance Thomas SF $1,636,842 UFA - - -
Louis Amundson PF $1,635,476 UFA - - -
Jerian Grant PG $1,572,360 $1,643,040 $1,713,840 $2,639,314 RFA
Sasha Vujacic SG $947,276 UFA - - -
Cleanthony Early SF $845,059 RFA - - -
Langston Galloway PG $845,059 RFA - - -
Tony Wroten Jr. SG $167,406 $1,050,961 UFA - -
73,673,010 68,817,528 50,337,200 54,878,508 0

Nix when was the last time we had a roster full of bad contracts other than Amare and melo, we've been relatively decent since 09/10 season


Why ask the question that way. A roster full of bad contracts? Not sure what this has to do with anything. Phil hasn't made any fatal moves, so this meme that he's somehow messing up the team are utter BS. That's the point. We're not stuck and we have some flexibility going forward.

The Simple fact is that Phil has to improve the guard play one way or another. Get that done and this is gonna be a playoff team. There's not some long list of things that needs to be done. It's all pretty clear now, but the hard part is WHO can Phil get and how much can we develop the young talent we have?
We'll have money but who do we spend it on?

knicks1248
Posts: 42059
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 2/3/2004
Member: #582
4/20/2016  10:07 PM
nixluva wrote:
knicks1248 wrote:
nixluva wrote:It's a well written article, but one thing comes to my mind. NONE of the things he got criticized for are really long term detrimental going forward. Missteps for sure but nothing fatal was done. In fact the team is pretty well setup for improvement with the right moves.


PLAYER POS. 2015-16 2016-17 2017-18 2018-19 2019-20
Carmelo Anthony SF $22,875,000 $24,559,380 $26,243,760 $27,928,140 UFA
Robin Lopez C $12,650,000 $13,219,250 $13,788,500 $14,357,750 UFA

Arron Afflalo SG $8,000,000 $8,000,000 UFA - -
Jose Calderon PG $7,402,812 $7,708,427 UFA - -
Derrick Williams PF $4,400,000 $4,400,000 UFA - -
Kristaps Porzingis PF $4,131,720 $4,317,720 $4,503,600 $5,697,054 RFA
Kyle O'Quinn PF $3,750,000 $3,918,750 $4,087,500 $4,256,250 UFA

Kevin Seraphin PF $2,814,000 UFA - - -
Lance Thomas SF $1,636,842 UFA - - -
Louis Amundson PF $1,635,476 UFA - - -
Jerian Grant PG $1,572,360 $1,643,040 $1,713,840 $2,639,314 RFA
Sasha Vujacic SG $947,276 UFA - - -
Cleanthony Early SF $845,059 RFA - - -
Langston Galloway PG $845,059 RFA - - -
Tony Wroten Jr. SG $167,406 $1,050,961 UFA - -
73,673,010 68,817,528 50,337,200 54,878,508 0

Nix when was the last time we had a roster full of bad contracts other than Amare and melo, we've been relatively decent since 09/10 season


Why ask the question that way. A roster full of bad contracts? Not sure what this has to do with anything. Phil hasn't made any fatal moves, so this meme that he's somehow messing up the team are utter BS. That's the point. We're not stuck and we have some flexibility going forward.

The Simple fact is that Phil has to improve the guard play one way or another. Get that done and this is gonna be a playoff team. There's not some long list of things that needs to be done. It's all pretty clear now, but the hard part is WHO can Phil get and how much can we develop the young talent we have?
We'll have money but who do we spend it on?

And what about the coach, because it's becoming crystal clear phil wants a puppet

ES
nixluva
Posts: 56258
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 10/5/2004
Member: #758
USA
4/20/2016  10:35 PM
knicks1248 wrote:
nixluva wrote:
knicks1248 wrote:
nixluva wrote:It's a well written article, but one thing comes to my mind. NONE of the things he got criticized for are really long term detrimental going forward. Missteps for sure but nothing fatal was done. In fact the team is pretty well setup for improvement with the right moves.


PLAYER POS. 2015-16 2016-17 2017-18 2018-19 2019-20
Carmelo Anthony SF $22,875,000 $24,559,380 $26,243,760 $27,928,140 UFA
Robin Lopez C $12,650,000 $13,219,250 $13,788,500 $14,357,750 UFA

Arron Afflalo SG $8,000,000 $8,000,000 UFA - -
Jose Calderon PG $7,402,812 $7,708,427 UFA - -
Derrick Williams PF $4,400,000 $4,400,000 UFA - -
Kristaps Porzingis PF $4,131,720 $4,317,720 $4,503,600 $5,697,054 RFA
Kyle O'Quinn PF $3,750,000 $3,918,750 $4,087,500 $4,256,250 UFA

Kevin Seraphin PF $2,814,000 UFA - - -
Lance Thomas SF $1,636,842 UFA - - -
Louis Amundson PF $1,635,476 UFA - - -
Jerian Grant PG $1,572,360 $1,643,040 $1,713,840 $2,639,314 RFA
Sasha Vujacic SG $947,276 UFA - - -
Cleanthony Early SF $845,059 RFA - - -
Langston Galloway PG $845,059 RFA - - -
Tony Wroten Jr. SG $167,406 $1,050,961 UFA - -
73,673,010 68,817,528 50,337,200 54,878,508 0

Nix when was the last time we had a roster full of bad contracts other than Amare and melo, we've been relatively decent since 09/10 season


Why ask the question that way. A roster full of bad contracts? Not sure what this has to do with anything. Phil hasn't made any fatal moves, so this meme that he's somehow messing up the team are utter BS. That's the point. We're not stuck and we have some flexibility going forward.

The Simple fact is that Phil has to improve the guard play one way or another. Get that done and this is gonna be a playoff team. There's not some long list of things that needs to be done. It's all pretty clear now, but the hard part is WHO can Phil get and how much can we develop the young talent we have?
We'll have money but who do we spend it on?

And what about the coach, because it's becoming crystal clear phil wants a puppet


Rambis and Phil think very much alike so there's no need to actually try and control him. Fish was allowed to do his thing which is obvious by the fact that they said he wasn't focusing on the Triangle the way they would've done if Phil was treating Fish like a puppet. Fish didn't seem to really want the help and Phil left him alone for the most part.

As for Blatt if he is actually brought in my guess is that he would agree to run the Triangle, which in a way makes sense given the amount of focus the team has had on it. This is Phil's prerogative to decide what he wants the team to be. In fact when GM's choose a coach they are in essence deciding what the team is going to run. You think the coach keeps it a secret? No i'm pretty sure they ask any new coach what his philosophy is and how he sees it working with the team he's going to inherit. The Lakers decided not to bring back Phil but instead went with MDA cuz they thought he'd work better with the players they had at the time and they wanted an uptempo PnR offense. So in essence the GM was choosing what the team would run.

NumberTwoPencil
Posts: 20936
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 10/31/2003
Member: #481
USA
4/20/2016  11:22 PM
As long as Phil keeps building/gathering/developing assets and doesn't overcommit to anyone who isn't essential (at this point, only KP is essential, IMO) then I'm fine with stubbornness and more losing . . . it's going to take time . . . years . . . even with good luck. I don't see what Jackson sees in Rambis but as long as he keeps him on a year-to-year contract, then, whatever . . . see what happens and wait for a great coach.
Nalod
Posts: 72120
Alba Posts: 155
Joined: 12/24/2003
Member: #508
USA
4/20/2016  11:46 PM
knicks1248 wrote:
nixluva wrote:
knicks1248 wrote:
nixluva wrote:It's a well written article, but one thing comes to my mind. NONE of the things he got criticized for are really long term detrimental going forward. Missteps for sure but nothing fatal was done. In fact the team is pretty well setup for improvement with the right moves.


PLAYER POS. 2015-16 2016-17 2017-18 2018-19 2019-20
Carmelo Anthony SF $22,875,000 $24,559,380 $26,243,760 $27,928,140 UFA
Robin Lopez C $12,650,000 $13,219,250 $13,788,500 $14,357,750 UFA

Arron Afflalo SG $8,000,000 $8,000,000 UFA - -
Jose Calderon PG $7,402,812 $7,708,427 UFA - -
Derrick Williams PF $4,400,000 $4,400,000 UFA - -
Kristaps Porzingis PF $4,131,720 $4,317,720 $4,503,600 $5,697,054 RFA
Kyle O'Quinn PF $3,750,000 $3,918,750 $4,087,500 $4,256,250 UFA

Kevin Seraphin PF $2,814,000 UFA - - -
Lance Thomas SF $1,636,842 UFA - - -
Louis Amundson PF $1,635,476 UFA - - -
Jerian Grant PG $1,572,360 $1,643,040 $1,713,840 $2,639,314 RFA
Sasha Vujacic SG $947,276 UFA - - -
Cleanthony Early SF $845,059 RFA - - -
Langston Galloway PG $845,059 RFA - - -
Tony Wroten Jr. SG $167,406 $1,050,961 UFA - -
73,673,010 68,817,528 50,337,200 54,878,508 0

Nix when was the last time we had a roster full of bad contracts other than Amare and melo, we've been relatively decent since 09/10 season


Why ask the question that way. A roster full of bad contracts? Not sure what this has to do with anything. Phil hasn't made any fatal moves, so this meme that he's somehow messing up the team are utter BS. That's the point. We're not stuck and we have some flexibility going forward.

The Simple fact is that Phil has to improve the guard play one way or another. Get that done and this is gonna be a playoff team. There's not some long list of things that needs to be done. It's all pretty clear now, but the hard part is WHO can Phil get and how much can we develop the young talent we have?
We'll have money but who do we spend it on?

And what about the coach, because it's becoming crystal clear phil wants a puppet

You make it seem like thats a bad thing? Remember when we had GM's and coach's not in synch with each other? It sucked.

foosballnick
Posts: 21546
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 6/17/2010
Member: #3148

4/21/2016  10:02 AM
knicks1248 wrote:
nixluva wrote:It's a well written article, but one thing comes to my mind. NONE of the things he got criticized for are really long term detrimental going forward. Missteps for sure but nothing fatal was done. In fact the team is pretty well setup for improvement with the right moves.


PLAYER POS. 2015-16 2016-17 2017-18 2018-19 2019-20
Carmelo Anthony SF $22,875,000 $24,559,380 $26,243,760 $27,928,140 UFA
Robin Lopez C $12,650,000 $13,219,250 $13,788,500 $14,357,750 UFA

Arron Afflalo SG $8,000,000 $8,000,000 UFA - -
Jose Calderon PG $7,402,812 $7,708,427 UFA - -
Derrick Williams PF $4,400,000 $4,400,000 UFA - -
Kristaps Porzingis PF $4,131,720 $4,317,720 $4,503,600 $5,697,054 RFA
Kyle O'Quinn PF $3,750,000 $3,918,750 $4,087,500 $4,256,250 UFA

Kevin Seraphin PF $2,814,000 UFA - - -
Lance Thomas SF $1,636,842 UFA - - -
Louis Amundson PF $1,635,476 UFA - - -
Jerian Grant PG $1,572,360 $1,643,040 $1,713,840 $2,639,314 RFA
Sasha Vujacic SG $947,276 UFA - - -
Cleanthony Early SF $845,059 RFA - - -
Langston Galloway PG $845,059 RFA - - -
Tony Wroten Jr. SG $167,406 $1,050,961 UFA - -
73,673,010 68,817,528 50,337,200 54,878,508 0

Nix when was the last time we had a roster full of bad contracts other than Amare and melo, we've been relatively decent since 09/10 season

Knicks were capped out in 2013 at close to $90 Million. This included Stat & Melo both with contracts over $21 Million, Tyson was at $14 Million and Bargnani was almost $12 Million. I believe they also had Camby as contract dead weight along with an unproductive Felton at the time (think they were each in the $4 Million range or so)

newyorker4ever
Posts: 26515
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 5/19/2014
Member: #5816

4/21/2016  10:28 AM    LAST EDITED: 4/21/2016  10:37 AM
nixluva wrote:It's a well written article, but one thing comes to my mind. NONE of the things he got criticized for are really long term detrimental going forward. Missteps for sure but nothing fatal was done. In fact the team is pretty well setup for improvement with the right moves.


PLAYER POS. 2015-16 2016-17 2017-18 2018-19 2019-20
Carmelo Anthony SF $22,875,000 $24,559,380 $26,243,760 $27,928,140 UFA
Robin Lopez C $12,650,000 $13,219,250 $13,788,500 $14,357,750 UFA

Arron Afflalo SG $8,000,000 $8,000,000 UFA - -
Jose Calderon PG $7,402,812 $7,708,427 UFA - -
Derrick Williams PF $4,400,000 $4,400,000 UFA - -
Kristaps Porzingis PF $4,131,720 $4,317,720 $4,503,600 $5,697,054 RFA
Kyle O'Quinn PF $3,750,000 $3,918,750 $4,087,500 $4,256,250 UFA

Kevin Seraphin PF $2,814,000 UFA - - -
Lance Thomas SF $1,636,842 UFA - - -
Louis Amundson PF $1,635,476 UFA - - -
Jerian Grant PG $1,572,360 $1,643,040 $1,713,840 $2,639,314 RFA
Sasha Vujacic SG $947,276 UFA - - -
Cleanthony Early SF $845,059 RFA - - -
Langston Galloway PG $845,059 RFA - - -
Tony Wroten Jr. SG $167,406 $1,050,961 UFA - -
73,673,010 68,817,528 50,337,200 54,878,508 0

Just like it said in the article, the team is in better shape now then they were when Phil took over. This team is not in bad shape at all and like i've been saying in two years which will be the 3rd year of rebuilding this team they'll be a team competing for not only the playoffs but making noise in the playoffs.

newyorker4ever
Posts: 26515
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 5/19/2014
Member: #5816

4/21/2016  10:32 AM
knicks1248 wrote:
nixluva wrote:It's a well written article, but one thing comes to my mind. NONE of the things he got criticized for are really long term detrimental going forward. Missteps for sure but nothing fatal was done. In fact the team is pretty well setup for improvement with the right moves.


PLAYER POS. 2015-16 2016-17 2017-18 2018-19 2019-20
Carmelo Anthony SF $22,875,000 $24,559,380 $26,243,760 $27,928,140 UFA
Robin Lopez C $12,650,000 $13,219,250 $13,788,500 $14,357,750 UFA

Arron Afflalo SG $8,000,000 $8,000,000 UFA - -
Jose Calderon PG $7,402,812 $7,708,427 UFA - -
Derrick Williams PF $4,400,000 $4,400,000 UFA - -
Kristaps Porzingis PF $4,131,720 $4,317,720 $4,503,600 $5,697,054 RFA
Kyle O'Quinn PF $3,750,000 $3,918,750 $4,087,500 $4,256,250 UFA

Kevin Seraphin PF $2,814,000 UFA - - -
Lance Thomas SF $1,636,842 UFA - - -
Louis Amundson PF $1,635,476 UFA - - -
Jerian Grant PG $1,572,360 $1,643,040 $1,713,840 $2,639,314 RFA
Sasha Vujacic SG $947,276 UFA - - -
Cleanthony Early SF $845,059 RFA - - -
Langston Galloway PG $845,059 RFA - - -
Tony Wroten Jr. SG $167,406 $1,050,961 UFA - -
73,673,010 68,817,528 50,337,200 54,878,508 0

Nix when was the last time we had a roster full of bad contracts other than Amare and melo, we've been relatively decent since 09/10 season

A.Bargnani was a bad contract, T.Chandler was a bad contract, R.Felton was a bad contract, E.Curry was a bad contract, S.Marbury was a bad contract, S.Francis was a bad contract, J.Calderon was/is a bad contract...........i feel like i can just keep going and going and going.

newyorker4ever
Posts: 26515
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 5/19/2014
Member: #5816

4/21/2016  10:36 AM
Nalod wrote:
knicks1248 wrote:
nixluva wrote:
knicks1248 wrote:
nixluva wrote:It's a well written article, but one thing comes to my mind. NONE of the things he got criticized for are really long term detrimental going forward. Missteps for sure but nothing fatal was done. In fact the team is pretty well setup for improvement with the right moves.


PLAYER POS. 2015-16 2016-17 2017-18 2018-19 2019-20
Carmelo Anthony SF $22,875,000 $24,559,380 $26,243,760 $27,928,140 UFA
Robin Lopez C $12,650,000 $13,219,250 $13,788,500 $14,357,750 UFA

Arron Afflalo SG $8,000,000 $8,000,000 UFA - -
Jose Calderon PG $7,402,812 $7,708,427 UFA - -
Derrick Williams PF $4,400,000 $4,400,000 UFA - -
Kristaps Porzingis PF $4,131,720 $4,317,720 $4,503,600 $5,697,054 RFA
Kyle O'Quinn PF $3,750,000 $3,918,750 $4,087,500 $4,256,250 UFA

Kevin Seraphin PF $2,814,000 UFA - - -
Lance Thomas SF $1,636,842 UFA - - -
Louis Amundson PF $1,635,476 UFA - - -
Jerian Grant PG $1,572,360 $1,643,040 $1,713,840 $2,639,314 RFA
Sasha Vujacic SG $947,276 UFA - - -
Cleanthony Early SF $845,059 RFA - - -
Langston Galloway PG $845,059 RFA - - -
Tony Wroten Jr. SG $167,406 $1,050,961 UFA - -
73,673,010 68,817,528 50,337,200 54,878,508 0

Nix when was the last time we had a roster full of bad contracts other than Amare and melo, we've been relatively decent since 09/10 season


Why ask the question that way. A roster full of bad contracts? Not sure what this has to do with anything. Phil hasn't made any fatal moves, so this meme that he's somehow messing up the team are utter BS. That's the point. We're not stuck and we have some flexibility going forward.

The Simple fact is that Phil has to improve the guard play one way or another. Get that done and this is gonna be a playoff team. There's not some long list of things that needs to be done. It's all pretty clear now, but the hard part is WHO can Phil get and how much can we develop the young talent we have?
We'll have money but who do we spend it on?

And what about the coach, because it's becoming crystal clear phil wants a puppet

You make it seem like thats a bad thing? Remember when we had GM's and coach's not in synch with each other? It sucked.

Good point. How bad can it be for Phil to have a guy that he can run his system through?? He does have 11 championships.

How I feel about the Phil Jackson situation (great article from last month)

©2001-2025 ultimateknicks.comm All rights reserved. About Us.
This site is not affiliated with the NY Knicks or the National Basketball Association in any way.
You may visit the official NY Knicks web site by clicking here.

All times (GMT-05:00) Eastern Time.

Terms of Use and Privacy Policy