[ IMAGES: Images ON turn off | ACCOUNT: User Status is LOCKED why? ]

Fisher's Biggest Mistake?
Author Thread
nixluva
Posts: 56258
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 10/5/2004
Member: #758
USA
12/11/2015  3:05 PM
After really thinking on the many issues with the Knicks one thing jumped out at me. Where are the highlights of Jerian to KP??? You would think that there should be quite a few at this stage. Player combinations do matter. Our possible future PG+C combo has only played token minutes so far this season.

Jerian has spent the most time with the same players coming off the bench. IMO he hasn't played enough with KP!!! That could be impacting his game too. I think Jerian should be spending a LOT more time with KP so that they can work together and develop chemistry. Their games complement each other and Jerian was drafted as an option to play with KP IMO. Jerian is an excellent PnR PG and can work any style of 2 man game, whether Drag Screen or Give n Go.

Where are all the Jerian to KP highlights??? One reason you don't see any is the strange fact that they've barely been on the floor together! I want Fish to change his approach cuz I don't understand why Jerian and KP have only played a total of 17 minutes together this season!!!

KP has spent a HUGE amount of his minutes this season out there with Jose Calderon. That combo doesn't really help KP IMO. Jose doesn't use screens or penetrate and that also means there are less opportunities for KP. Jose means less plays involving PG and KP in a 2man game!!! I think Playing Jerian and KP would help BOTH players. This is a HUGE issue that Fish needs to address.


Rk Lineup MP FG PF
1 A. Afflalo | C. Anthony | J. Calderon | R. Lopez | K. Porzingis 255:44 +1.0 +1.6
2 C. Anthony | J. Calderon | R. Lopez | K. Porzingis | S. Vujacic 113:03 -2.0 +4.9
3 L. Galloway | J. Grant | K. Seraphin | L. Thomas | D. Williams 76:32 -5.7 +0.9
4 L. Galloway | J. Grant | K. O'Quinn | L. Thomas | D. Williams 67:02 -5.8 -1.5
5 C. Anthony | J. Calderon | L. Galloway | R. Lopez | K. Porzingis 28:55 +10.4 +5.6
6 C. Anthony | L. Galloway | J. Grant | K. Seraphin | L. Thomas 26:27 +9.9 -2.0
7 A. Afflalo | J. Calderon | R. Lopez | K. Porzingis | L. Thomas 25:31 0.0 +2.2
8 A. Afflalo | C. Anthony | J. Calderon | L. Galloway | K. Porzingis 24:25 -3.5 +1.1
9 L. Amundson | L. Galloway | J. Grant | L. Thomas | D. Williams 20:49 -6.2 -4.6
10 A. Afflalo | C. Anthony | J. Calderon | K. Porzingis | L. Thomas 18:29 +2.6 +5.3

11 C. Anthony | L. Galloway | J. Grant | R. Lopez | K. Porzingis 17:24 +11.8 -2.9

12 C. Anthony | L. Galloway | J. Grant | K. O'Quinn | L. Thomas 13:10 -5.6 -9.4
13 A. Afflalo | J. Calderon | K. Porzingis | K. Seraphin | L. Thomas 12:15 +5.0 +7.5
14 A. Afflalo | C. Anthony | J. Calderon | R. Lopez | L. Thomas 11:06 -15.2 -2.0
15 L. Galloway | K. O'Quinn | L. Thomas | S. Vujacic | D. Williams 11:05 -20.0 +2.0
16 C. Anthony | J. Calderon | L. Galloway | R. Lopez | L. Thomas 9:37 -14.3 +2.7
17 L. Galloway | J. Grant | R. Lopez | L. Thomas | D. Williams 9:31 +24.2 0.0
18 A. Afflalo | C. Anthony | J. Calderon | K. Seraphin | L. Thomas 8:59 -11.8 +2.9
19 L. Amundson | L. Galloway | J. Grant | K. O'Quinn | L. Thomas 8:48 +27.9 +18.9
20 L. Galloway | J. Grant | K. O'Quinn | K. Seraphin | L. Thomas 8:26 -15.9 -3.6

One of my oldest principles of a good team is having strength up the middle of your team. The PG and C combination is HUGE. You usually start your team with 2 good players at those spots and your good. It could also be Guard PF but that isn't what is important. A PG and a Big combo can be huge. Jose and KP doesn't work at all. Somehow we need to get Jerian and KP going as a tandem. That's the present and future right there.

AUTOADVERT
ChuckBuck
Posts: 28851
Alba Posts: 11
Joined: 1/3/2012
Member: #3806
USA
12/11/2015  3:09 PM    LAST EDITED: 12/11/2015  3:09 PM
After drafting Jerian in the 1st round and seeing them both gel instantaneously in summer league, I was convinced that these 2 would be inseparable at the hip for most of their career. Great chemistry and feel between each other displayed in that couple of weeks.

The new Stockton t Malone, Payton to Kemp, Action Jackson to Patrick Ewing....but alas Fisher is a complete retard (no offense to the retards).

WaltLongmire
Posts: 27623
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 6/28/2014
Member: #5843

12/11/2015  3:11 PM
Small sample size...and you have no idea who that grouping was playing against.

I'm moving into the camp which feels that Grant might need some DL time to pump up his confidence and get his shot and penetration going.

EnySpree: Can we agree to agree not to mention Phil Jackson and triangle for the rest of our lives?
blkexec
Posts: 28451
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 9/3/2004
Member: #748
12/11/2015  3:13 PM
This is why I said KP shouldn't have been in the starting lineup. If they want to start Calderon to pair a veteran PG with Melo, fine.

Grant to KP in that second unit would've been show time. And guess who would've finished most games.....Grant and KP!

But everybody killed me for that....KP is our future star, who needs to learn how to play like a top star.....instead of playing under Melo's shadow.

Born in Brooklyn, Raised in Queens, Lives in Maryland. The future is bright, I'm a Knicks fan for life!
nixluva
Posts: 56258
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 10/5/2004
Member: #758
USA
12/11/2015  3:16 PM
WaltLongmire wrote:Small sample size...and you have no idea who that grouping was playing against.

I'm moving into the camp which feels that Grant might need some DL time to pump up his confidence and get his shot and penetration going.

I disagree. When you play with guys that don't really complement your game like Seraphin and KOQ for most of your minutes and only spend a COMBINED 17 total minutes the entire season so far with KP, that's a huge issues. Jerkin's game fits with KP PERFECTLY. Jerian can run PnR, Drag Scree and Give n Go at a high level. He was great in college in that role and KP would get WAY more touches playing with a PnR PG like Jerian. It would make the game easier for both players.

nixluva
Posts: 56258
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 10/5/2004
Member: #758
USA
12/11/2015  3:21 PM
blkexec wrote:This is why I said KP shouldn't have been in the starting lineup. If they want to start Calderon to pair a veteran PG with Melo, fine.

Grant to KP in that second unit would've been show time. And guess who would've finished most games.....Grant and KP!

But everybody killed me for that....KP is our future star, who needs to learn how to play like a top star.....instead of playing under Melo's shadow.


Well I do agree with you that it's a crime that Jerian and KP haven't been put together so they can develop that much needed chemistry. They belong together and it's why Phil drafted Jerian in the 1st place. If anyone forgets how good Jerian looks with a Big that can move it's a very strong part of his game. KP adds the jumper to the mix as well as rolling to the basket.

Rather than move KP to the bench I called for Jerian to start. I felt Jerian could do it if he was given a chance and he's never been put in that situation. Playing with KP, Melo and Afflalo would help Jerian much more than some think. A TON of his passes get wasted only playing with the bench guys!!!

blkexec
Posts: 28451
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 9/3/2004
Member: #748
12/11/2015  3:51 PM
nixluva wrote:
blkexec wrote:This is why I said KP shouldn't have been in the starting lineup. If they want to start Calderon to pair a veteran PG with Melo, fine.

Grant to KP in that second unit would've been show time. And guess who would've finished most games.....Grant and KP!

But everybody killed me for that....KP is our future star, who needs to learn how to play like a top star.....instead of playing under Melo's shadow.


Well I do agree with you that it's a crime that Jerian and KP haven't been put together so they can develop that much needed chemistry. They belong together and it's why Phil drafted Jerian in the 1st place. If anyone forgets how good Jerian looks with a Big that can move it's a very strong part of his game. KP adds the jumper to the mix as well as rolling to the basket.

Rather than move KP to the bench I called for Jerian to start. I felt Jerian could do it if he was given a chance and he's never been put in that situation. Playing with KP, Melo and Afflalo would help Jerian much more than some think. A TON of his passes get wasted only playing with the bench guys!!!

I thought we should've started the season with KP on the bench.....Nothing wrong with that. This doesn't mean he's not going to be the franchise player. But doing that allows KP is develop physically and build chemistry with Grant. It also allows Melo to take ownership of this team with veterans around him. When Melo has to share the ball too much, his decision making is questionable. And I don't think Melo prefers playing with a rookie PG.....This was his own words.

Eitherway, they need to play more together.....I just don't know how, with the way Fisher has his substitution paterns. I think we have two teams and thats how it should be until Melo fades away. Melo's veteran team. (Melo, Jose, Rolo, AA)

KP's young team (KP, Dwill, Grant, Gallo)

You can still give KP the same minutes. Run everything through Melo, regardless of the system. Eventually time will tell the truth, and KP / Grant would've built up some momentum.....and the team will switch from Melo to KP's team. Right now, I don't think anybody is being used properly. We are just a major injury away from shaking things up. Everybody is pressing more and more after every loss.

Born in Brooklyn, Raised in Queens, Lives in Maryland. The future is bright, I'm a Knicks fan for life!
Chandler
Posts: 26915
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 11/26/2015
Member: #6197

12/11/2015  5:09 PM    LAST EDITED: 12/11/2015  5:10 PM
Good topic. We need a PG so badly; we should try the in-house guy first

I would definitely like to see this combo. Jerian pushing up the floor for possible quick PnR, etc. You'd see guys running with him for sure.

they had some good chemistry in the SL with a fast tempo (KP with those lefty baby hooks!)

Also his driving would be so much more effective than they are now where he tries to go in on an already crowded lane.

And, he might be one of those guys that if he gets some easy buckets in transition and gets his teammates involved then his shot starts falling. Right now he's pressing

(5)(7)
WaltLongmire
Posts: 27623
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 6/28/2014
Member: #5843

12/11/2015  5:20 PM    LAST EDITED: 12/11/2015  5:22 PM
nixluva wrote:
WaltLongmire wrote:Small sample size...and you have no idea who that grouping was playing against.

I'm moving into the camp which feels that Grant might need some DL time to pump up his confidence and get his shot and penetration going.

I disagree. When you play with guys that don't really complement your game like Seraphin and KOQ for most of your minutes and only spend a COMBINED 17 total minutes the entire season so far with KP, that's a huge issues. Jerkin's game fits with KP PERFECTLY. Jerian can run PnR, Drag Scree and Give n Go at a high level. He was great in college in that role and KP would get WAY more touches playing with a PnR PG like Jerian. It would make the game easier for both players.


Its more than familiarity with Porzingis...honestly.

I'd wager that Grant would be an entirely different player on the Sixers of this season, or on the Knicks of last year, sans Anthony.

Not sure I'd want Grant playing much with Anthony at this time given where his head is presently at. I don't think he'll play freely.

I think I said something like this during yesterday's game thread, or in another one after the game- right now Grant is more concerned with not wanting to do something that would hurt the team, than he is with doing something to help the team win.

He needs some consistency to build up his confidence, and I don't think he will get it playing with the first unit.


By the way, the Lakers moving Russell to the second team might have been done for the very reason I believe Grant should not play much with Melo on the court.

EnySpree: Can we agree to agree not to mention Phil Jackson and triangle for the rest of our lives?
martin
Posts: 80083
Alba Posts: 108
Joined: 7/24/2001
Member: #2
USA
12/11/2015  5:23 PM
blkexec wrote:This is why I said KP shouldn't have been in the starting lineup. If they want to start Calderon to pair a veteran PG with Melo, fine.

Grant to KP in that second unit would've been show time. And guess who would've finished most games.....Grant and KP!

But everybody killed me for that....KP is our future star, who needs to learn how to play like a top star.....instead of playing under Melo's shadow.

For long term grown of KP, regardless of short term wins, you still want KP off the bench? I'm not in that boat

Official sponsor of the PURE KNICKS LOVE Program
crzymdups
Posts: 52018
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 5/1/2004
Member: #671
USA
12/11/2015  5:24 PM
I'm not convinced that Grant and KP need to play together.

I am convinced KP and Melo need to play together. They help each other so much.

Not starting KP at this point would be ludicrous.

¿ △ ?
WaltLongmire
Posts: 27623
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 6/28/2014
Member: #5843

12/11/2015  5:40 PM
martin wrote:
blkexec wrote:This is why I said KP shouldn't have been in the starting lineup. If they want to start Calderon to pair a veteran PG with Melo, fine.

Grant to KP in that second unit would've been show time. And guess who would've finished most games.....Grant and KP!

But everybody killed me for that....KP is our future star, who needs to learn how to play like a top star.....instead of playing under Melo's shadow.

For long term grown of KP, regardless of short term wins, you still want KP off the bench? I'm not in that boat


Its an interesting idea, though- might give him more freedom on the offensive end, and it could help Grant out.

Is there any doubt around here that Porzingis is the franchise building block for the Knicks? He's proven he can play a secondary role as a starter. You can make a case that he's being overlooked too many times on the first unit.

Team politics will not allow him to become the alpha male if he is paired with Anthony, and he is always going to defer to Anthony when they are on the court together at this time. Giving both him and Grant time together on the floor without Anthony might be best for their development, especially if the losing continues.

EnySpree: Can we agree to agree not to mention Phil Jackson and triangle for the rest of our lives?
WaltLongmire
Posts: 27623
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 6/28/2014
Member: #5843

12/11/2015  5:47 PM
crzymdups wrote:I'm not convinced that Grant and KP need to play together.

I am convinced KP and Melo need to play together. They help each other so much.

Not starting KP at this point would be ludicrous.


You shouldn't look upon him not starting as some kind of "demotion."

Grant/KP is much more likely to be the future of this franchise than Porzingis/Anthony.

If the team can't get back on the right track and stay at .500 or above, the only thing that will matter the rest year is KP's development, and to a lesser extent, that of Grant.

EnySpree: Can we agree to agree not to mention Phil Jackson and triangle for the rest of our lives?
crzymdups
Posts: 52018
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 5/1/2004
Member: #671
USA
12/11/2015  5:52 PM
WaltLongmire wrote:
martin wrote:
blkexec wrote:This is why I said KP shouldn't have been in the starting lineup. If they want to start Calderon to pair a veteran PG with Melo, fine.

Grant to KP in that second unit would've been show time. And guess who would've finished most games.....Grant and KP!

But everybody killed me for that....KP is our future star, who needs to learn how to play like a top star.....instead of playing under Melo's shadow.

For long term grown of KP, regardless of short term wins, you still want KP off the bench? I'm not in that boat


Its an interesting idea, though- might give him more freedom on the offensive end, and it could help Grant out.

Is there any doubt around here that Porzingis is the franchise building block for the Knicks? He's proven he can play a secondary role as a starter. You can make a case that he's being overlooked too many times on the first unit.

Team politics will not allow him to become the alpha male if he is paired with Anthony, and he is always going to defer to Anthony when they are on the court together at this time. Giving both him and Grant time together on the floor without Anthony might be best for their development, especially if the losing continues.

There's a stat out there that Melo shoots 47% with KP on the floor and 33% with KP off the floor. I think you can make the case that both help the other. They are clearly our best two players. They complement one another both skill-wise and the spots they like on the floor.

Two guys who may not make sense together? Afflalo and Melo.

Afflalo has shown to be devastating in the low post posting smaller guards when Melo is not in the game. But that's the same spot Melo gets the ball in this offense.

I would like to see a rotation where Afflalo becomes the featured player on offense when Melo sits. I think it would help his effectiveness and bring some stability to the bench unit. I'm not saying send Afflalo to the bench, but I would like to see him get some minutes when Melo sits.

¿ △ ?
martin
Posts: 80083
Alba Posts: 108
Joined: 7/24/2001
Member: #2
USA
12/11/2015  5:53 PM
WaltLongmire wrote:
martin wrote:
blkexec wrote:This is why I said KP shouldn't have been in the starting lineup. If they want to start Calderon to pair a veteran PG with Melo, fine.

Grant to KP in that second unit would've been show time. And guess who would've finished most games.....Grant and KP!

But everybody killed me for that....KP is our future star, who needs to learn how to play like a top star.....instead of playing under Melo's shadow.

For long term grown of KP, regardless of short term wins, you still want KP off the bench? I'm not in that boat


Its an interesting idea, though- might give him more freedom on the offensive end, and it could help Grant out.

Is there any doubt around here that Porzingis is the franchise building block for the Knicks? He's proven he can play a secondary role as a starter. You can make a case that he's being overlooked too many times on the first unit.

Team politics will not allow him to become the alpha male if he is paired with Anthony, and he is always going to defer to Anthony when they are on the court together at this time. Giving both him and Grant time together on the floor without Anthony might be best for their development, especially if the losing continues.

Point taken. On the other hand, I want KP to go head-to-head with each of the opponent's best, see what he's got and let him figure where he needs to get better. He's demanded the ball in the last minute shot where he saw an opportunity once, he's gonna demand to be in Rolo's offense spot soon and then demand Alpha dog over Melo soon after that. As coach that would be my highest priority. I wouldn't give it to him but I would certainly facilitate it (starting role) where I could.

Official sponsor of the PURE KNICKS LOVE Program
BigRedDog
Posts: 22226
Alba Posts: 2
Joined: 1/23/2004
Member: #569
12/11/2015  6:16 PM    LAST EDITED: 12/11/2015  6:19 PM
blkexec wrote:This is why I said KP shouldn't have been in the starting lineup. If they want to start Calderon to pair a veteran PG with Melo, fine.

Grant to KP in that second unit would've been show time. And guess who would've finished most games.....Grant and KP!

But everybody killed me for that....KP is our future star, who needs to learn how to play like a top star.....instead of playing under Melo's shadow.

It was ridiculous when you 1st said it and it still is ridiculous. You don't put your best player on the bench. You would actually be limiting KP's minutes by starting him on the bench. Good pick up Nix about Grant and KP. Need to see more of them together which is by playing Grant more with the 1st team. Not sure about starting him but 1st guard off the bench to sub either Afflalo or caldron depending how each is doing.

fishmike 9/27/2024 11:00 PM Ug I hate this. The idea of Towns is great until you see what a pussy he is. Jules is a dog. DD was a flamethrower locked up cheap for 3 more years. First Leon move I hate
SocraticBallin22
Posts: 23888
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 7/3/2015
Member: #6096

12/11/2015  7:00 PM
I cosign with this post. It's inexcusable for Jerian to be playing such sporadic minutes and not playing at all with the 1st unit. Again, he is the ONLY guard on the roster who can create his own shot and penetrate to the basket. He is also strong and athletic enough to guard quick, athletic point guards. He just needs playing time and confidence from the coach and his jump shot will come (he's not a terrible shooter; has good form). We would be better with him on the court pushing the pace and getting guys like Melo easier shots.
nixluva
Posts: 56258
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 10/5/2004
Member: #758
USA
12/11/2015  7:32 PM
It just seems to me that the idea Phil had was to draft KP and Jerian as a future tandem. Jerian is better than he's looked IMO. When you never play with the best players on the team it's going to effect you as a rookie. Remember the guys Jerian is playing with off the bench are trying to figure things out too. So rather than having some targets that know what they're doing he only has guys that have less talent and aren't sure of what to do either.

With Jerian, KP, Melo and Afflalo I think it boosts Jerian's confidence to see his passes lead to scores. Jerian would not ignore or not see KP if he's open. He's shown that he has good court vision. If KP spent a lot of time working with Jerian they could develop chemistry and it would make a HUGE difference for this team. Jose has nothing in the tank in terms of a 2 man game with KP. Jerian may not be the jump shooting threat yet but perhaps it would help him to be out there with better talent and less attention from the defense. As quick as he is that might give him more openings to attack the rim.

I just wonder when we will get to see Jerian and KP for significant minutes. So far it's been next to NOTHING! I mean 17 total minutes with Jerian and KP on the floor together is insanely low. Meanwhile Jose and KP have been on the floor together for 434 minutes!!! Maybe KP could get some passes that aren't at his hips or behind him.

Vmart
Posts: 31800
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 5/23/2002
Member: #247
USA
12/11/2015  8:05 PM
Fishers biggest mistake is allowing the team to get in big holes. He doesn't know when to use timeouts in the course of the game to stop the bleeding.
WaltLongmire
Posts: 27623
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 6/28/2014
Member: #5843

12/11/2015  8:24 PM
martin wrote:
WaltLongmire wrote:
martin wrote:
blkexec wrote:This is why I said KP shouldn't have been in the starting lineup. If they want to start Calderon to pair a veteran PG with Melo, fine.

Grant to KP in that second unit would've been show time. And guess who would've finished most games.....Grant and KP!

But everybody killed me for that....KP is our future star, who needs to learn how to play like a top star.....instead of playing under Melo's shadow.

For long term grown of KP, regardless of short term wins, you still want KP off the bench? I'm not in that boat


Its an interesting idea, though- might give him more freedom on the offensive end, and it could help Grant out.

Is there any doubt around here that Porzingis is the franchise building block for the Knicks? He's proven he can play a secondary role as a starter. You can make a case that he's being overlooked too many times on the first unit.

Team politics will not allow him to become the alpha male if he is paired with Anthony, and he is always going to defer to Anthony when they are on the court together at this time. Giving both him and Grant time together on the floor without Anthony might be best for their development, especially if the losing continues.

Point taken. On the other hand, I want KP to go head-to-head with each of the opponent's best, see what he's got and let him figure where he needs to get better. He's demanded the ball in the last minute shot where he saw an opportunity once, he's gonna demand to be in Rolo's offense spot soon and then demand Alpha dog over Melo soon after that. As coach that would be my highest priority. I wouldn't give it to him but I would certainly facilitate it (starting role) where I could.


I have to admit that it's been fun watching him go up against so many tough players so far... Allowed me to reach an opinion on how good he can be much sooner than if he had been relegated to playing against backups.

I like the fact that he has faced so many top flight players because you know- success or failure- he is learning as he goes along.

I do have an issue with the fact that he is overlooked so many times when he's put himself into a good position for the ball. Not only is this kind of thing frustrating for KP (or any player), but it also leads to a lack of movement on offense...almost a kind of apathy.

EnySpree: Can we agree to agree not to mention Phil Jackson and triangle for the rest of our lives?
Fisher's Biggest Mistake?

©2001-2025 ultimateknicks.comm All rights reserved. About Us.
This site is not affiliated with the NY Knicks or the National Basketball Association in any way.
You may visit the official NY Knicks web site by clicking here.

All times (GMT-05:00) Eastern Time.

Terms of Use and Privacy Policy