Posted by rojasmas:

For the record, Kidd didn't have a very good finals last year either. And he was vastly outplayed by Tony Parker. If he is second team all-defense, then some coaches better go back and watch some tape of more Nets games! Coaches vote on reputation as much as players do.

Coaches and players play against Kidd. You watch on TV - who do you think knows more?

come on oldfan, reps are clearly overrated, like the defense of gary payton... same sometimes applies to kidd.