[ IMAGES: Images ON turn off | ACCOUNT: User Status is LOCKED why? ]

If you had to choose for the future, Tim Hardway JR or Giannis Antetokuounmpo
Author Thread
RonRon
Posts: 25531
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 5/22/2002
Member: #246
2/4/2014  1:26 AM
If you had to choose for the future, Tim Hardway JR or Giannis Antetokuounmpo??
He is really young with a lot of upside but a lot of work, development needed ahead of him

Currently Tim Hardaway JR is the better basketball player today, he is much better than I thought he was in the PRO level, he also improved much since summer league/start of the season
Obviously JR is going to be a very good shooter, a Ray Allen but needs to learn how to move without the ball in catch and shoot situations like RIP improved drastically by watching Reggie Miller
He has a great quick release, is quicker, stronger, and more athletic than I thought he would be in the pro level this early in his career
I see him giving much effort in DEF, putting pressure on guards, and trying to push the ball, grab rebounds, but he could still improve on this area
Regardless, I think he actually was a steal for us and I was wrong about him


I am now even questioning if I could go back and draft Giannis Antetokounmpo or Tim Hardaway JR, who should I choose?
Because of his age, upside, possibility to still grow to possibility 7foot +, add more skills, room for improvement, I think I will still pick Antetokounmpo, even though he is still a baby
You cannot teach what he has, guard skills, HUGE hands, ability to penetrate, decent athleticism to go with great length, and his potential is virtually untapped
I believe we will not get a sense of what kind of player he will become till at least 2-3 years later till he at least fills out his body a bit.
He is a gamble a bit vs Hardaway JR but the upside is just too high for me to pass as good as Hardaway JR has been looking
Was wondering what you guys thought about the two players in comparison?

I figure as of right now, having Caron Butler and Ilyasova (another skilled F with length that played in Europe first, which the game is approached very differently) as decent mentors to him. Also Carlos Delfino is another TOUGH Euro player than can guide him and help him with his shot, if he can improve his shot to half of Durant's confidence, he will be a very good player. Also I think Marion would be another great mentor, something teams don't seem to emphasize enough of compared to the NBA in the 80s-90s

Anyone know when is younger brother is eligible to be drafted?
He would have been a great STASH player if we had a 2nd round pick to utilize?
Would anyone here go for him or his younger brother?
I see him as the SF/PF with the ability to give PG and SG's a nightmare by the time he learns how to use his body, physical abilities, combined with skills


I was really hoping we would have somehow moved up to grab Giannis Antetokounmpo or allow him to drop all the way to us

but

Tim Hardaway JR looks to be better than I thought he would be
I was wrong about him, I thought Glen Rice JR would be the better pick due to his body build
I thought Tim Hardaway JR would be a gunner, but not as athletic, shorter, smaller, than JR Smith, but without the headaches/immaturity which makes a big difference
With Iman, JR playing his best last season, I thought SG is the least position we needed to address, with Gobert still on the board who I think could also be risk/reward guy, like Jeremy Tyler was with Iman Shumpert's draft, who I wanted Vuvuvic only over Iman and not Faried because 6-4 PF with a 6-9 C in STAT just wouldn't make sense *it was the lock out year, so Billups was expected to be part of the team, and Tyson Chandler was not thought to be available*

back on Giannis Antetokounmpo

Though I think Giannis Antetokounmpo's potential is incredibialy high with his combination of HUGE hands *DR. Jay had HUGE HANDS despite being 6'4*, length, athleticism, and guard skills/handle

We would need a coaching staff that actually values development and have to bring in a mentor/player but he has the tools to be a huge hit or a big bust, but it was a good selection considering where he was selected for reward/gamble

He will likely take at least 2-3 full years to fill up his body and develop, needing much work with at least 2 years before we can get an idea what positions he could play, but he does have the handle, passing ability, defensive ability, to be a 2 way player


Unfortunately, we don't believe in developing players, if he does begin to show his potential, we might have traded him for Kobe Bryant in 2 years, thats the NYK way


Will he be between Scotty Pippen, Durant (doesn't have his shooting touch but his body build), Paul George, Rudy Gay, Tmac, Battum, Trevor Ariza, James Johnson, or a Hakeem Warrick, I don't know

but

he will likely be able to defend 3-4 positions if he does become an NBA player, possible a lock down defender if he builds his body properly with the right training
He cannot lose is mobileness/finess, he isn't going to be a Lebron type player as in DOMINANCE

but

he has a younger brother I believe, with a similar body build
He should train with Durant's trainers because of their similarities in body builds
Kevin Durant might be a toothpick but he is NOT weak and plays VERY STRONG on the court, he utilizes his length, quickness, athleticism, and core strength very well
I didn't think he would be such a great all round player that he is now and not get dominated playing the PF position
In fact, he can actually even play C at times, I think Durant is actually skinny strong, if that makes any sense at all

But this youngster has A LOT OF WORK AHEAD of him, just like Paul George and Tmac, they were not "big contributors" and didn't have a position till later in their careers
Paul George played SG when he is now a true SF that could play SF/PF with SG abilities, just 2 years ago it was still Danny Grangers team and it was Granger vs Melo when Indiana played, while Chandler vs Hibbert, and Lance Stephenson was glued to the bench as Fields was the "steal of the draft"

Funny how much things change in 2 years

Chandler > Hibbert

Melo > Granger and Paul George *I said Paul George was better last season already watching his performance in the playoffs*

Fields > Lance Stephenson

STAT (>> for half the season) >=< David West (he is the tough guy, undersized a bit, but is a true TOUGH VET

but tides have changed dramatically


And to answer Playa, that is why YOUTH is so IMPORTANT

Younger players have higher potentials, although not all will reach their ceilings, you cannot stop believing in drafting instead opting to BUY talent all the time
There is only so much you are allowed to spend with this CBA, you need to be able to find steals, one way or another, with picks, good signings, trades, etc....
Every team that has won in the league or even contenders for many years, have either developed through youth, or used their youth/picks as assets to trade for a older ALL STAR with generally expirings and a combination of 1-3 picks, depending on if they are 2 way ALL STARS and age

Youth can bring the greatest return as assets, costs (especially with this CBA), as foundations/core, and because of (their contracts are low if not top 3 pick) it allows you to use the $$$ elsewhere while your 1-4m contract player can produce just as high as a 15m+ player, making timing VERY IMPORTANT in building a team


We cannot predict injuries, how a player sometimes fits/develops, and how their potential matches up to higher competition
Sometimes, by being picked later than they thought they should have, they work harder on to develop their games, sometimes with the right combination of talents/coaches/systems/vets
So ultimately how a player develops is up NOT just up to the player but his surroundings, some of which has no control over, in additional to their talent/potential/ceilings/risk and reward

Some players are content with one contract like Eddy Curry or Jerome James
And sometimes you get it right consecutively like OKC, hitting it big, or even Larry Bird and Isiah Thomas had some success in rather late picks
Lets not forget players sometimes get better contracts by getting drafted in the 2nd round or not drafted at all like Jeremy Lin, Gilbert Areanas, and Isiah Thomas (The King's PG)

AUTOADVERT
callmened
Posts: 24448
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 5/26/2012
Member: #4234

2/4/2014  2:38 AM
i have no idea...too early to tell. the "greek freak" is intruiging but thats all he is for now. I need to see him shoot more and do other things besides fast break. When i watch him play (i signed up for NBA league pass cuz i cant stand the bad bball the knicks are playing), he doesnt do much on the court. im not saying hes bad or will never be good...im saying i dont know

to answer youre question, im fine with picking timmy over greekfreak. Hes a traditionally scoring SG that im used to and i would feel safe betting on

Knicks should be improved: win about 40 games and maybe sneak into the playoffs. Melo, Rose and even Noah will have some nice moments however this team should be about PORZINGUS. the sooner they make him the primary player, the better
callmened
Posts: 24448
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 5/26/2012
Member: #4234

2/4/2014  2:38 AM
i have no idea...too early to tell. the "greek freak" is intruiging but thats all he is for now. I need to see him shoot more and do other things besides fast break. When i watch him play (i signed up for NBA league pass cuz i cant stand the bad bball the knicks are playing), he doesnt do much on the court. im not saying hes bad or will never be good...im saying i dont know

to answer youre question, im fine with picking timmy over greekfreak. Hes a traditionally scoring SG that im used to and i would feel safe betting on

Knicks should be improved: win about 40 games and maybe sneak into the playoffs. Melo, Rose and even Noah will have some nice moments however this team should be about PORZINGUS. the sooner they make him the primary player, the better
H1AND1
Posts: 21747
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 9/9/2013
Member: #5648

2/4/2014  5:57 AM    LAST EDITED: 2/4/2014  6:01 AM
Giannis' ceiling is higher just on physical gifts alone. He is truly a "Freak" and if he can harness that potential the guy is going to be a wrecking ball. Think the evolutionary Andrei Kirilenko with a guard's handle and stroke. Will he put it all together and reach those lofty heights? Who knows.

Look at his fuh-king hands!!!
http://probasketballtalk.nbcsports.com/2013/10/21/bucks-giannis-antetokounmpos-hands-are-freakishly-large/giannis-hand/

CrushAlot
Posts: 59764
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 7/25/2003
Member: #452
USA
2/4/2014  7:12 AM
Giannis is really good but he was taken 9 picks before Tim. Glad this isn't about who the Knicks missed on. I still struggle with not drafting Artest, about three centers in the 06 draft, all of the point guard talent in the Hill draft, and Rautins over Stephenson.
I'm tired,I'm tired, I'm so tired right now......Kristaps Porzingis 1/3/18
ToddTT
Posts: 30629
Alba Posts: 53
Joined: 8/30/2001
Member: #105
2/4/2014  7:19 AM
Hardaway. So much easier to say.
Oh good lord... https://www.youtube.com/shorts/XkmGrX7O0lQ
playa2
Posts: 34922
Alba Posts: 15
Joined: 5/15/2003
Member: #407

2/4/2014  8:20 AM    LAST EDITED: 2/4/2014  8:21 AM
RonRon wrote:If you had to choose for the future, Tim Hardway JR or Giannis Antetokuounmpo??
He is really young with a lot of upside but a lot of work, development needed ahead of him

Currently Tim Hardaway JR is the better basketball player today, he is much better than I thought he was in the PRO level, he also improved much since summer league/start of the season
Obviously JR is going to be a very good shooter, a Ray Allen but needs to learn how to move without the ball in catch and shoot situations like RIP improved drastically by watching Reggie Miller
He has a great quick release, is quicker, stronger, and more athletic than I thought he would be in the pro level this early in his career
I see him giving much effort in DEF, putting pressure on guards, and trying to push the ball, grab rebounds, but he could still improve on this area
Regardless, I think he actually was a steal for us and I was wrong about him


I am now even questioning if I could go back and draft Giannis Antetokounmpo or Tim Hardaway JR, who should I choose?
Because of his age, upside, possibility to still grow to possibility 7foot +, add more skills, room for improvement, I think I will still pick Antetokounmpo, even though he is still a baby
You cannot teach what he has, guard skills, HUGE hands, ability to penetrate, decent athleticism to go with great length, and his potential is virtually untapped
I believe we will not get a sense of what kind of player he will become till at least 2-3 years later till he at least fills out his body a bit.
He is a gamble a bit vs Hardaway JR but the upside is just too high for me to pass as good as Hardaway JR has been looking
Was wondering what you guys thought about the two players in comparison?

I figure as of right now, having Caron Butler and Ilyasova (another skilled F with length that played in Europe first, which the game is approached very differently) as decent mentors to him. Also Carlos Delfino is another TOUGH Euro player than can guide him and help him with his shot, if he can improve his shot to half of Durant's confidence, he will be a very good player. Also I think Marion would be another great mentor, something teams don't seem to emphasize enough of compared to the NBA in the 80s-90s

Anyone know when is younger brother is eligible to be drafted?
He would have been a great STASH player if we had a 2nd round pick to utilize?
Would anyone here go for him or his younger brother?
I see him as the SF/PF with the ability to give PG and SG's a nightmare by the time he learns how to use his body, physical abilities, combined with skills


I was really hoping we would have somehow moved up to grab Giannis Antetokounmpo or allow him to drop all the way to us

but

Tim Hardaway JR looks to be better than I thought he would be
I was wrong about him, I thought Glen Rice JR would be the better pick due to his body build
I thought Tim Hardaway JR would be a gunner, but not as athletic, shorter, smaller, than JR Smith, but without the headaches/immaturity which makes a big difference
With Iman, JR playing his best last season, I thought SG is the least position we needed to address, with Gobert still on the board who I think could also be risk/reward guy, like Jeremy Tyler was with Iman Shumpert's draft, who I wanted Vuvuvic only over Iman and not Faried because 6-4 PF with a 6-9 C in STAT just wouldn't make sense *it was the lock out year, so Billups was expected to be part of the team, and Tyson Chandler was not thought to be available*

back on Giannis Antetokounmpo

Though I think Giannis Antetokounmpo's potential is incredibialy high with his combination of HUGE hands *DR. Jay had HUGE HANDS despite being 6'4*, length, athleticism, and guard skills/handle

We would need a coaching staff that actually values development and have to bring in a mentor/player but he has the tools to be a huge hit or a big bust, but it was a good selection considering where he was selected for reward/gamble

He will likely take at least 2-3 full years to fill up his body and develop, needing much work with at least 2 years before we can get an idea what positions he could play, but he does have the handle, passing ability, defensive ability, to be a 2 way player


Unfortunately, we don't believe in developing players, if he does begin to show his potential, we might have traded him for Kobe Bryant in 2 years, thats the NYK way


Will he be between Scotty Pippen, Durant (doesn't have his shooting touch but his body build), Paul George, Rudy Gay, Tmac, Battum, Trevor Ariza, James Johnson, or a Hakeem Warrick, I don't know

but

he will likely be able to defend 3-4 positions if he does become an NBA player, possible a lock down defender if he builds his body properly with the right training
He cannot lose is mobileness/finess, he isn't going to be a Lebron type player as in DOMINANCE

but

he has a younger brother I believe, with a similar body build
He should train with Durant's trainers because of their similarities in body builds
Kevin Durant might be a toothpick but he is NOT weak and plays VERY STRONG on the court, he utilizes his length, quickness, athleticism, and core strength very well
I didn't think he would be such a great all round player that he is now and not get dominated playing the PF position
In fact, he can actually even play C at times, I think Durant is actually skinny strong, if that makes any sense at all

But this youngster has A LOT OF WORK AHEAD of him, just like Paul George and Tmac, they were not "big contributors" and didn't have a position till later in their careers
Paul George played SG when he is now a true SF that could play SF/PF with SG abilities, just 2 years ago it was still Danny Grangers team and it was Granger vs Melo when Indiana played, while Chandler vs Hibbert, and Lance Stephenson was glued to the bench as Fields was the "steal of the draft"

Funny how much things change in 2 years

Chandler > Hibbert

Melo > Granger and Paul George *I said Paul George was better last season already watching his performance in the playoffs*

Fields > Lance Stephenson

STAT (>> for half the season) >=< David West (he is the tough guy, undersized a bit, but is a true TOUGH VET

but tides have changed dramatically


And to answer Playa, that is why YOUTH is so IMPORTANT

Younger players have higher potentials, although not all will reach their ceilings, you cannot stop believing in drafting instead opting to BUY talent all the time
There is only so much you are allowed to spend with this CBA, you need to be able to find steals, one way or another, with picks, good signings, trades, etc....
Every team that has won in the league or even contenders for many years, have either developed through youth, or used their youth/picks as assets to trade for a older ALL STAR with generally expirings and a combination of 1-3 picks, depending on if they are 2 way ALL STARS and age

Youth can bring the greatest return as assets, costs (especially with this CBA), as foundations/core, and because of (their contracts are low if not top 3 pick) it allows you to use the $$$ elsewhere while your 1-4m contract player can produce just as high as a 15m+ player, making timing VERY IMPORTANT in building a team


We cannot predict injuries, how a player sometimes fits/develops, and how their potential matches up to higher competition
Sometimes, by being picked later than they thought they should have, they work harder on to develop their games, sometimes with the right combination of talents/coaches/systems/vets
So ultimately how a player develops is up NOT just up to the player but his surroundings, some of which has no control over, in additional to their talent/potential/ceilings/risk and reward

Some players are content with one contract like Eddy Curry or Jerome James
And sometimes you get it right consecutively like OKC, hitting it big, or even Larry Bird and Isiah Thomas had some success in rather late picks
Lets not forget players sometimes get better contracts by getting drafted in the 2nd round or not drafted at all like Jeremy Lin, Gilbert Areanas, and Isiah Thomas (The King's PG)

When they (yoots)lead the way and win the Chip get back at me.

JAMES DOLAN on Isiah : He's a good friend of mine and of the organization and I will continue to solicit his views. He will always have strong ties to me and the team.
SupremeCommander
Posts: 34064
Alba Posts: 35
Joined: 4/28/2006
Member: #1127

2/4/2014  8:39 AM
I love THJ but Giannis is more of a can't miss prospect
DLeethal wrote: Lol Rick needs a safe space
NYKBocker
Posts: 38419
Alba Posts: 474
Joined: 1/14/2003
Member: #377
USA
2/4/2014  9:21 AM
Giannis but we did not have a chance to get him.
Moonangie
Posts: 24766
Alba Posts: 5
Joined: 7/9/2009
Member: #2788

2/4/2014  9:37 AM
THjr... pedigree counts for a lot. Giannis has freaky physical abilities, and may yet develop into a star. MAY being the key word there.
NardDogNation
Posts: 27405
Alba Posts: 4
Joined: 5/7/2013
Member: #5555

2/4/2014  9:51 AM
I'm leaning toward Giannas. It'll take him sometime but he'll be a beast in this league. I wish we could've found a way to move up to get him.
Sangfroid
Posts: 24681
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 7/7/2009
Member: #2784

2/4/2014  1:09 PM
ToddTT wrote:Hardaway. So much easier to say.

I'm just calling him Giannis. You are looking at the future of the game. Just turned 19, amazing handle and energy. Haven't seen his jumper, but I would be moving his family to my house if I was an owner. Barring injury, this kid is gonna be a monster.

"We are playing a game. We are playing at not playing a game..."
tkf
Posts: 36487
Alba Posts: 6
Joined: 8/13/2001
Member: #87
2/4/2014  1:15 PM    LAST EDITED: 2/4/2014  1:16 PM
RonRon wrote:If you had to choose for the future, Tim Hardway JR or Giannis Antetokuounmpo??
He is really young with a lot of upside but a lot of work, development needed ahead of him

Currently Tim Hardaway JR is the better basketball player today, he is much better than I thought he was in the PRO level, he also improved much since summer league/start of the season
Obviously JR is going to be a very good shooter, a Ray Allen but needs to learn how to move without the ball in catch and shoot situations like RIP improved drastically by watching Reggie Miller
He has a great quick release, is quicker, stronger, and more athletic than I thought he would be in the pro level this early in his career
I see him giving much effort in DEF, putting pressure on guards, and trying to push the ball, grab rebounds, but he could still improve on this area
Regardless, I think he actually was a steal for us and I was wrong about him


I am now even questioning if I could go back and draft Giannis Antetokounmpo or Tim Hardaway JR, who should I choose?
Because of his age, upside, possibility to still grow to possibility 7foot +, add more skills, room for improvement, I think I will still pick Antetokounmpo, even though he is still a baby
You cannot teach what he has, guard skills, HUGE hands, ability to penetrate, decent athleticism to go with great length, and his potential is virtually untapped
I believe we will not get a sense of what kind of player he will become till at least 2-3 years later till he at least fills out his body a bit.
He is a gamble a bit vs Hardaway JR but the upside is just too high for me to pass as good as Hardaway JR has been looking
Was wondering what you guys thought about the two players in comparison?

I figure as of right now, having Caron Butler and Ilyasova (another skilled F with length that played in Europe first, which the game is approached very differently) as decent mentors to him. Also Carlos Delfino is another TOUGH Euro player than can guide him and help him with his shot, if he can improve his shot to half of Durant's confidence, he will be a very good player. Also I think Marion would be another great mentor, something teams don't seem to emphasize enough of compared to the NBA in the 80s-90s

Anyone know when is younger brother is eligible to be drafted?
He would have been a great STASH player if we had a 2nd round pick to utilize?
Would anyone here go for him or his younger brother?
I see him as the SF/PF with the ability to give PG and SG's a nightmare by the time he learns how to use his body, physical abilities, combined with skills


I was really hoping we would have somehow moved up to grab Giannis Antetokounmpo or allow him to drop all the way to us

but

Tim Hardaway JR looks to be better than I thought he would be
I was wrong about him, I thought Glen Rice JR would be the better pick due to his body build
I thought Tim Hardaway JR would be a gunner, but not as athletic, shorter, smaller, than JR Smith, but without the headaches/immaturity which makes a big difference
With Iman, JR playing his best last season, I thought SG is the least position we needed to address, with Gobert still on the board who I think could also be risk/reward guy, like Jeremy Tyler was with Iman Shumpert's draft, who I wanted Vuvuvic only over Iman and not Faried because 6-4 PF with a 6-9 C in STAT just wouldn't make sense *it was the lock out year, so Billups was expected to be part of the team, and Tyson Chandler was not thought to be available*

back on Giannis Antetokounmpo

Though I think Giannis Antetokounmpo's potential is incredibialy high with his combination of HUGE hands *DR. Jay had HUGE HANDS despite being 6'4*, length, athleticism, and guard skills/handle

We would need a coaching staff that actually values development and have to bring in a mentor/player but he has the tools to be a huge hit or a big bust, but it was a good selection considering where he was selected for reward/gamble

He will likely take at least 2-3 full years to fill up his body and develop, needing much work with at least 2 years before we can get an idea what positions he could play, but he does have the handle, passing ability, defensive ability, to be a 2 way player


Unfortunately, we don't believe in developing players, if he does begin to show his potential, we might have traded him for Kobe Bryant in 2 years, thats the NYK way


Will he be between Scotty Pippen, Durant (doesn't have his shooting touch but his body build), Paul George, Rudy Gay, Tmac, Battum, Trevor Ariza, James Johnson, or a Hakeem Warrick, I don't know

but

he will likely be able to defend 3-4 positions if he does become an NBA player, possible a lock down defender if he builds his body properly with the right training
He cannot lose is mobileness/finess, he isn't going to be a Lebron type player as in DOMINANCE

but

he has a younger brother I believe, with a similar body build
He should train with Durant's trainers because of their similarities in body builds
Kevin Durant might be a toothpick but he is NOT weak and plays VERY STRONG on the court, he utilizes his length, quickness, athleticism, and core strength very well
I didn't think he would be such a great all round player that he is now and not get dominated playing the PF position
In fact, he can actually even play C at times, I think Durant is actually skinny strong, if that makes any sense at all

But this youngster has A LOT OF WORK AHEAD of him, just like Paul George and Tmac, they were not "big contributors" and didn't have a position till later in their careers
Paul George played SG when he is now a true SF that could play SF/PF with SG abilities, just 2 years ago it was still Danny Grangers team and it was Granger vs Melo when Indiana played, while Chandler vs Hibbert, and Lance Stephenson was glued to the bench as Fields was the "steal of the draft"

Funny how much things change in 2 years

Chandler > Hibbert

Melo > Granger and Paul George *I said Paul George was better last season already watching his performance in the playoffs*

Fields > Lance Stephenson

STAT (>> for half the season) >=< David West (he is the tough guy, undersized a bit, but is a true TOUGH VET

but tides have changed dramatically


And to answer Playa, that is why YOUTH is so IMPORTANT

Younger players have higher potentials, although not all will reach their ceilings, you cannot stop believing in drafting instead opting to BUY talent all the time
There is only so much you are allowed to spend with this CBA, you need to be able to find steals, one way or another, with picks, good signings, trades, etc....
Every team that has won in the league or even contenders for many years, have either developed through youth, or used their youth/picks as assets to trade for a older ALL STAR with generally expirings and a combination of 1-3 picks, depending on if they are 2 way ALL STARS and age

Youth can bring the greatest return as assets, costs (especially with this CBA), as foundations/core, and because of (their contracts are low if not top 3 pick) it allows you to use the $$$ elsewhere while your 1-4m contract player can produce just as high as a 15m+ player, making timing VERY IMPORTANT in building a team


We cannot predict injuries, how a player sometimes fits/develops, and how their potential matches up to higher competition
Sometimes, by being picked later than they thought they should have, they work harder on to develop their games, sometimes with the right combination of talents/coaches/systems/vets
So ultimately how a player develops is up NOT just up to the player but his surroundings, some of which has no control over, in additional to their talent/potential/ceilings/risk and reward

Some players are content with one contract like Eddy Curry or Jerome James
And sometimes you get it right consecutively like OKC, hitting it big, or even Larry Bird and Isiah Thomas had some success in rather late picks
Lets not forget players sometimes get better contracts by getting drafted in the 2nd round or not drafted at all like Jeremy Lin, Gilbert Areanas, and Isiah Thomas (The King's PG)

i like THJ, think he is a fine player.. but I easily go with Giannis.. kid has length, ability and a lot of upside.. his length , huge hands can't be taught...

Chandler > Hibbert

Melo > Granger and Paul George *I said Paul George was better last season already watching his performance in the playoffs*

Fields > Lance Stephenson

STAT (>> for half the season) >=< David West (he is the tough guy, undersized a bit, but is a true TOUGH VET

I never thought most if any of those things.. I never thought carmelo was better than paul george alone last year..

lance kind of blew up late, but people, most were well aware of his upside..

I don't think i would have said last year, chandler over hibbert..

But I see what you are saying.. these things were said, or hinted, and boy how they have changed..

And to answer Playa, that is why YOUTH is so IMPORTANT

BINGO!!

Anyone who sits around and waits for the lottery to better themselves, either in real life or in sports, Is a Loser............... TKF
Cartman718
Posts: 29069
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 10/12/2007
Member: #1694

2/4/2014  6:03 PM
Nixluva is posting triangle screen grabs, even when nobody asks - Fishmike. LOL So are we going to reference that thread like the bible now? "The thread of Wroten Page 14 post 9" - EnySpree
fitzfarm
Posts: 25165
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 10/28/2010
Member: #3285

2/4/2014  7:45 PM
I feel he is the new Jonathan bender pre injuries .. Kids gonna be a beast in this league as long as his knees hold up
StarksEwing1
Posts: 32671
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 12/28/2012
Member: #4451

2/4/2014  7:47 PM
Hardaway has the better skills. Remember the Knicks make anybody look like a star so cant take last ngiht for much value
RonRon
Posts: 25531
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 5/22/2002
Member: #246
2/4/2014  10:24 PM
tkf wrote:
RonRon wrote:If you had to choose for the future, Tim Hardway JR or Giannis Antetokuounmpo??
He is really young with a lot of upside but a lot of work, development needed ahead of him

Currently Tim Hardaway JR is the better basketball player today, he is much better than I thought he was in the PRO level, he also improved much since summer league/start of the season
Obviously JR is going to be a very good shooter, a Ray Allen but needs to learn how to move without the ball in catch and shoot situations like RIP improved drastically by watching Reggie Miller
He has a great quick release, is quicker, stronger, and more athletic than I thought he would be in the pro level this early in his career
I see him giving much effort in DEF, putting pressure on guards, and trying to push the ball, grab rebounds, but he could still improve on this area
Regardless, I think he actually was a steal for us and I was wrong about him


I am now even questioning if I could go back and draft Giannis Antetokounmpo or Tim Hardaway JR, who should I choose?
Because of his age, upside, possibility to still grow to possibility 7foot +, add more skills, room for improvement, I think I will still pick Antetokounmpo, even though he is still a baby
You cannot teach what he has, guard skills, HUGE hands, ability to penetrate, decent athleticism to go with great length, and his potential is virtually untapped
I believe we will not get a sense of what kind of player he will become till at least 2-3 years later till he at least fills out his body a bit.
He is a gamble a bit vs Hardaway JR but the upside is just too high for me to pass as good as Hardaway JR has been looking
Was wondering what you guys thought about the two players in comparison?

I figure as of right now, having Caron Butler and Ilyasova (another skilled F with length that played in Europe first, which the game is approached very differently) as decent mentors to him. Also Carlos Delfino is another TOUGH Euro player than can guide him and help him with his shot, if he can improve his shot to half of Durant's confidence, he will be a very good player. Also I think Marion would be another great mentor, something teams don't seem to emphasize enough of compared to the NBA in the 80s-90s

Anyone know when is younger brother is eligible to be drafted?
He would have been a great STASH player if we had a 2nd round pick to utilize?
Would anyone here go for him or his younger brother?
I see him as the SF/PF with the ability to give PG and SG's a nightmare by the time he learns how to use his body, physical abilities, combined with skills


I was really hoping we would have somehow moved up to grab Giannis Antetokounmpo or allow him to drop all the way to us

but

Tim Hardaway JR looks to be better than I thought he would be
I was wrong about him, I thought Glen Rice JR would be the better pick due to his body build
I thought Tim Hardaway JR would be a gunner, but not as athletic, shorter, smaller, than JR Smith, but without the headaches/immaturity which makes a big difference
With Iman, JR playing his best last season, I thought SG is the least position we needed to address, with Gobert still on the board who I think could also be risk/reward guy, like Jeremy Tyler was with Iman Shumpert's draft, who I wanted Vuvuvic only over Iman and not Faried because 6-4 PF with a 6-9 C in STAT just wouldn't make sense *it was the lock out year, so Billups was expected to be part of the team, and Tyson Chandler was not thought to be available*

back on Giannis Antetokounmpo

Though I think Giannis Antetokounmpo's potential is incredibialy high with his combination of HUGE hands *DR. Jay had HUGE HANDS despite being 6'4*, length, athleticism, and guard skills/handle

We would need a coaching staff that actually values development and have to bring in a mentor/player but he has the tools to be a huge hit or a big bust, but it was a good selection considering where he was selected for reward/gamble

He will likely take at least 2-3 full years to fill up his body and develop, needing much work with at least 2 years before we can get an idea what positions he could play, but he does have the handle, passing ability, defensive ability, to be a 2 way player


Unfortunately, we don't believe in developing players, if he does begin to show his potential, we might have traded him for Kobe Bryant in 2 years, thats the NYK way


Will he be between Scotty Pippen, Durant (doesn't have his shooting touch but his body build), Paul George, Rudy Gay, Tmac, Battum, Trevor Ariza, James Johnson, or a Hakeem Warrick, I don't know

but

he will likely be able to defend 3-4 positions if he does become an NBA player, possible a lock down defender if he builds his body properly with the right training
He cannot lose is mobileness/finess, he isn't going to be a Lebron type player as in DOMINANCE

but

he has a younger brother I believe, with a similar body build
He should train with Durant's trainers because of their similarities in body builds
Kevin Durant might be a toothpick but he is NOT weak and plays VERY STRONG on the court, he utilizes his length, quickness, athleticism, and core strength very well
I didn't think he would be such a great all round player that he is now and not get dominated playing the PF position
In fact, he can actually even play C at times, I think Durant is actually skinny strong, if that makes any sense at all

But this youngster has A LOT OF WORK AHEAD of him, just like Paul George and Tmac, they were not "big contributors" and didn't have a position till later in their careers
Paul George played SG when he is now a true SF that could play SF/PF with SG abilities, just 2 years ago it was still Danny Grangers team and it was Granger vs Melo when Indiana played, while Chandler vs Hibbert, and Lance Stephenson was glued to the bench as Fields was the "steal of the draft"

Funny how much things change in 2 years

Chandler > Hibbert

Melo > Granger and Paul George *I said Paul George was better last season already watching his performance in the playoffs*

Fields > Lance Stephenson

STAT (>> for half the season) >=< David West (he is the tough guy, undersized a bit, but is a true TOUGH VET

but tides have changed dramatically


And to answer Playa, that is why YOUTH is so IMPORTANT

Younger players have higher potentials, although not all will reach their ceilings, you cannot stop believing in drafting instead opting to BUY talent all the time
There is only so much you are allowed to spend with this CBA, you need to be able to find steals, one way or another, with picks, good signings, trades, etc....
Every team that has won in the league or even contenders for many years, have either developed through youth, or used their youth/picks as assets to trade for a older ALL STAR with generally expirings and a combination of 1-3 picks, depending on if they are 2 way ALL STARS and age

Youth can bring the greatest return as assets, costs (especially with this CBA), as foundations/core, and because of (their contracts are low if not top 3 pick) it allows you to use the $$$ elsewhere while your 1-4m contract player can produce just as high as a 15m+ player, making timing VERY IMPORTANT in building a team


We cannot predict injuries, how a player sometimes fits/develops, and how their potential matches up to higher competition
Sometimes, by being picked later than they thought they should have, they work harder on to develop their games, sometimes with the right combination of talents/coaches/systems/vets
So ultimately how a player develops is up NOT just up to the player but his surroundings, some of which has no control over, in additional to their talent/potential/ceilings/risk and reward

Some players are content with one contract like Eddy Curry or Jerome James
And sometimes you get it right consecutively like OKC, hitting it big, or even Larry Bird and Isiah Thomas had some success in rather late picks
Lets not forget players sometimes get better contracts by getting drafted in the 2nd round or not drafted at all like Jeremy Lin, Gilbert Areanas, and Isiah Thomas (The King's PG)

i like THJ, think he is a fine player.. but I easily go with Giannis.. kid has length, ability and a lot of upside.. his length , huge hands can't be taught...

Chandler > Hibbert

Melo > Granger and Paul George *I said Paul George was better last season already watching his performance in the playoffs*

Fields > Lance Stephenson

STAT (>> for half the season) >=< David West (he is the tough guy, undersized a bit, but is a true TOUGH VET

I never thought most if any of those things.. I never thought carmelo was better than paul george alone last year..

lance kind of blew up late, but people, most were well aware of his upside..

I don't think i would have said last year, chandler over hibbert..

But I see what you are saying.. these things were said, or hinted, and boy how they have changed..

And to answer Playa, that is why YOUTH is so IMPORTANT

BINGO!!

when comparing all the players above, I was talking about Tyson Chandler's 1st year in NYK, when Iman Shumpert was still a rookie
That was only 2.5 seasons ago


Playa, yoots don't win themselves, they are a piece to the puzzle,

Much like one player doesn't win a championship, the entire team needs to produce, even the role players

The point is players that are under rookie contract's are either developed to be the Tony Parker, Manu, Bynums, or used as assets to acquire KG to Boston, Ray Allen to Boston, Rasheed

Wallace and Ben Wallace to Detroit, Prince/Affalo/Okur

picks = assets

drafted developed players are under rookie contracts, allowing you to spend the money elsewhere to acquire talent


Spur's was build on their draft picks, contenders for over a decade with consintency, won multiple times

Laker's acquired Pau Gasol with Marc Gasol and cap space, in addition to drafting Bynum, in addition to building with Kobe and Shaq the first time around, and have won multiple times

I showed you how Boston used draft picks to compete for a couple of years and have won

I showed you how Detroit competed for a couple of years as contenders and won

Pacer's core has been built with rookies, none of which are even top 5 picks, they have made it to game 7 in the ECF 3 years in a row, with a bright future,
==============

George Hill *traded for with rights to Kawaii Leanard*
Paul George
Lance Stephenson
Hibbert


OKC didn't win but they have been contenders for much of the past seasons
====

Westbrook
Harden (turned to Lamb, Steven Adams, and still picks coming)
Durant
Ibaka
Nick Collison


Reggie Jackson
Perry Jones

Jeff Green used in trade

Houston Rockets
================

collected assets, recycling assets, got Harden *which lead to D12 and a core*

Drafted Parsons
Drafted Terrence Jones

Signed D12


DRAFT PICKS and YOOTS are needed shown above to contend, era after era

going back further, I don't need to name all the players drafted

Jordan/Pippen/Kukoc/ many of their ROLE PLAYERS Bulls

Lakers Magic Johnson, Kareem

Detroit with "BAD BOYS"

Celtics "with Bird, McHale, Parish"


You hold no value in draft picks, I get it, but Dynasty's have been build repetitively around draft picks development, or/and used to compete for short amount of years to acquire proven talent with CAP SPACE and DRAFT PICKS


History tells you that you are wrong, I have provided examples with Dynasties with yoots, era's, and short term contending teams to buy talent with draft picks for proven players with the recent Celtics, Pistons, Laker's with without SHAQ

YOOT's don't win, themselves, they are just needed to BUILD A CONTENDING TEAM, you can only sign so much talent, Wade was drafted by the Heat and the trio was the main reason they won that was a RARE chance to retool 3 ALL STAR's in one season
But even Wade, Chalmers/Cole, Haslem, in addition to the draft picks they used in order use the MLE for

And that is why 2015 is so important, with our lack of draft picks, we need to continue to collect talent in draft picks, and then SIGN a core in 2015 much like the Heat did in order for us to contend

We are unable to currently to contend because

Amare
Melo
Tyson

both make up the entire salary cap themselves, limiting our ability to acquire talent with flawed players, and that is why every year we need to pray for vet min steals and trade for garbage that their own team doesn't even want and still collect assets for them


Lebron is great but he even couldn't do it himself in Cleveland despite triple double numbers with 30+ pts games

Kobe was unable to do without a core of players, once with shaq and role players, and then with Bynum, Gasol, and even Odom Ariza/MWP playing vital roles
His BEST CAREER YEAR, lead him to the lottery to get Bynum, scoring multiple amazing 50+ games and performances that year for a top 10 pick

And that is why you cannot pay Melo if we want to contend, because he cannot win without a core, and we cannnot build or buy a core around him if he is going to take 1/2 the cap first
So the answer is to trade Melo with the rest of the team to empty salary beyond 2015 and collect as many assets that draft picks so we can spend the $$$ to on FA to build a core

H1AND1
Posts: 21747
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 9/9/2013
Member: #5648

2/5/2014  8:40 AM    LAST EDITED: 2/5/2014  8:41 AM
StarksEwing1 wrote:Hardaway has the better skills. Remember the Knicks make anybody look like a star so cant take last ngiht for much value

I love THjr as much as the next Knicks fan and yes he is currently more polished than Giannis A. HOWEVER, Giannis' probably has the highest upside in the league right now. He has the chance to be ridiculously good. He has physical gifts which are unmatched and already has a nice stroke and handle (and he's what 6'11"?!?). And he's only been playing for a couple years I believe. If he puts it all together he's going to be a monster.

EnySpree
Posts: 44919
Alba Posts: 138
Joined: 4/18/2003
Member: #397

2/5/2014  9:32 AM
Giannis has Tracy McGrady/Scottie Pippen potential. Im hoping the kid can put that together. He's very driven drum what I read about him.

Seeing Thjr I see his determination and killer instinct. Kid wants to be good too. I can see him starting at the 2 next year if the coach gives him a chance and put up 14pts per.

So it's a wash to me. The knicks really could use both.

Subscribe to my Podcast https://youtube.com/c/DiehardknicksPodcast https://twitter.com/DiehardknicksPC https://instagram.com/diehardknickspodcast
djsunyc
Posts: 44929
Alba Posts: 42
Joined: 1/16/2004
Member: #536
2/5/2014  9:38 AM
knicks fans would be the only one to say hardaway but giannis is dripping with star potential. he can be a defensive lockdown type of player and a matchup nightmare everywhere on the court. hardaway can develop into a catch and shoot 3 point guy (like korver) but his defense is not good at all.
If you had to choose for the future, Tim Hardway JR or Giannis Antetokuounmpo

©2001-2025 ultimateknicks.comm All rights reserved. About Us.
This site is not affiliated with the NY Knicks or the National Basketball Association in any way.
You may visit the official NY Knicks web site by clicking here.

All times (GMT-05:00) Eastern Time.

Terms of Use and Privacy Policy