That being said I think Rose being hurt for the 2nd year in a row kills it. Hard to envision Melo going to the Bulls and dealing what he's dealt with here with Amare being hurt.

NardDogNation wrote:

fitzfarm wrote:Yea I hear ya.. But Noah and chandler our similar and I really feel rose will not be the same player because he relies on his quickness witch is gone and he's not a great shooter.. I think if we can pull off a Lowry trade or get him via free agent. A Lowry,thjr,melo,Tyler,chandler might be better esp if thjr becomes a all star.

And in spite of Chandler and Noah being near carbon copies of each other (I actually think that Noah is light-years ahead of Tyson at this point), the Bulls have been and are WAY better than the Knicks. They'll likely have a solid draft pick this year to augment the core and also have Nikola Mirotic (the new Toni Kukoc) coming over as well. Other than the extra $33 million, I'd see no reason for Melo to stick around here if he could get a max deal with the Bulls.

End of the day he's going to do what he wants but he will also have more control and comfort here, and there is more to life than hoops, even for a guy like this...

fitzfarm wrote:

NardDogNation wrote:

fitzfarm wrote:Yea I hear ya.. But Noah and chandler our similar and I really feel rose will not be the same player because he relies on his quickness witch is gone and he's not a great shooter.. I think if we can pull off a Lowry trade or get him via free agent. A Lowry,thjr,melo,Tyler,chandler might be better esp if thjr becomes a all star.

And in spite of Chandler and Noah being near carbon copies of each other (I actually think that Noah is light-years ahead of Tyson at this point), the Bulls have been and are WAY better than the Knicks. They'll likely have a solid draft pick this year to augment the core and also have Nikola Mirotic (the new Toni Kukoc) coming over as well. Other than the extra $33 million, I'd see no reason for Melo to stick around here if he could get a max deal with the Bulls.

I really don't see the bulls as a better option, Noah is chandler and I don't like ether one.. I think Tyler is more talented then ether one esp with that Wingspan. It obviously will show with more time . Amare is a nice guy off the bench or even starting.. Thjr mark my words is going to be a all star, all we are missing is a pg. sure it up this off season .. Lowry,thjr,melo,Tyler,chandler or a Lin,thjr,melo,stat,Tyler. Is better then what the bulls can offer. Rose,blank,jimmy butler,melo,Noah
And rose will prob be injured a lot, so more like Kirk h,blank,jimmy butler,melo,Noah

Dose chi town look better, in my opinion not at all.. Plus we have guys that are only going to get better year after year in Tyler,thjr,murry even shump..

I like his upside also but what you see is what you get. Lets see a bit yea?

fishmike wrote:

fitzfarm wrote:

NardDogNation wrote:

fitzfarm wrote:Yea I hear ya.. But Noah and chandler our similar and I really feel rose will not be the same player because he relies on his quickness witch is gone and he's not a great shooter.. I think if we can pull off a Lowry trade or get him via free agent. A Lowry,thjr,melo,Tyler,chandler might be better esp if thjr becomes a all star.

And in spite of Chandler and Noah being near carbon copies of each other (I actually think that Noah is light-years ahead of Tyson at this point), the Bulls have been and are WAY better than the Knicks. They'll likely have a solid draft pick this year to augment the core and also have Nikola Mirotic (the new Toni Kukoc) coming over as well. Other than the extra $33 million, I'd see no reason for Melo to stick around here if he could get a max deal with the Bulls.

I really don't see the bulls as a better option, Noah is chandler and I don't like ether one.. I think Tyler is more talented then ether one esp with that Wingspan. It obviously will show with more time . Amare is a nice guy off the bench or even starting.. Thjr mark my words is going to be a all star, all we are missing is a pg. sure it up this off season .. Lowry,thjr,melo,Tyler,chandler or a Lin,thjr,melo,stat,Tyler. Is better then what the bulls can offer. Rose,blank,jimmy butler,melo,Noah
And rose will prob be injured a lot, so more like Kirk h,blank,jimmy butler,melo,Noah

Dose chi town look better, in my opinion not at all.. Plus we have guys that are only going to get better year after year in Tyler,thjr,murry even shump..

dude... Tyson Chandler, suspect as his game has become has been a DPOY, anchored the defense on a team that won a title and has been an impact player for a long time. Noah is actually better but hasnt been around as long. Tyler has had 3 good games against garbage teams and failed to impress anyone in a Japanese league where he was the biggest and most athletic player. In the league.

I like his upside also but what you see is what you get. Lets see a bit yea?

NardDogNation wrote:

fitzfarm wrote:

NardDogNation wrote:

fitzfarm wrote:Yea I hear ya.. But Noah and chandler our similar and I really feel rose will not be the same player because he relies on his quickness witch is gone and he's not a great shooter.. I think if we can pull off a Lowry trade or get him via free agent. A Lowry,thjr,melo,Tyler,chandler might be better esp if thjr becomes a all star.

And in spite of Chandler and Noah being near carbon copies of each other (I actually think that Noah is light-years ahead of Tyson at this point), the Bulls have been and are WAY better than the Knicks. They'll likely have a solid draft pick this year to augment the core and also have Nikola Mirotic (the new Toni Kukoc) coming over as well. Other than the extra $33 million, I'd see no reason for Melo to stick around here if he could get a max deal with the Bulls.

I really don't see the bulls as a better option, Noah is chandler and I don't like ether one.. I think Tyler is more talented then ether one esp with that Wingspan. It obviously will show with more time . Amare is a nice guy off the bench or even starting.. Thjr mark my words is going to be a all star, all we are missing is a pg. sure it up this off season .. Lowry,thjr,melo,Tyler,chandler or a Lin,thjr,melo,stat,Tyler. Is better then what the bulls can offer. Rose,blank,jimmy butler,melo,Noah
And rose will prob be injured a lot, so more like Kirk h,blank,jimmy butler,melo,Noah

Dose chi town look better, in my opinion not at all.. Plus we have guys that are only going to get better year after year in Tyler,thjr,murry even shump..

You can actually run an offensive through Joakim Noah with his passing ability, while Tyson can hardly finish alley oop plays anymore. When you factor in that Noah is several years his junior, it becomes hard to make the argument that the two are of the same class anymore. You tried singing Chandler's praises but everything you mentioned was what he USE to be and not what he currently is. And Jeremy Tyler hasn't even played a full season yet, so let's not christen him one of the best center's in the league especially since he's been playing as a 4.

Yea gotta give Noah his due he is one of the best glue players in this league,even though his chicken wing shot makes me want to vomit lol

NardDogNation wrote:

fitzfarm wrote:Yea I hear ya.. But Noah and chandler our similar and I really feel rose will not be the same player because he relies on his quickness witch is gone and he's not a great shooter.. I think if we can pull off a Lowry trade or get him via free agent. A Lowry,thjr,melo,Tyler,chandler might be better esp if thjr becomes a all star.

And in spite of Chandler and Noah being near carbon copies of each other (I actually think that Noah is light-years ahead of Tyson at this point), the Bulls have been and are WAY better than the Knicks. They'll likely have a solid draft pick this year to augment the core and also have Nikola Mirotic (the new Toni Kukoc) coming over as well. Other than the extra $33 million, I'd see no reason for Melo to stick around here if he could get a max deal with the Bulls.