- SALBLSRed Hook, NYNYT Pick

Vmart wrote:

misterearl wrote:
I don't usually blame owners, but Dolan is completely to blame for the Knicks. He let Walsh do the first half of his job and then stepped in for the sexy part and sold the future for a great scorer with no court vision, no foot speed and no assists. The "star" mentality. The Stoudamire and Lin mistakes could have been made by anyone; only Dolan could have made the Anthony mistake, against the advice of many people. His ego must be enormous, almost as big as his inability to understand what winning basketball is made of. The Knicks can not be good with Dolan at the Helm or Anthony on the court.

- SALBLSRed Hook, NYNYT Pick

Melo has great court vision. It is Woody that has enabled him to be just an iso superstar and not much else. A coach must demand more from his star player, I shouldn't say star his main player. If your running isolation plays for Melo then he is going to shoot. A good motion offense is needed to get everyone involved that is the key to success. All the players feel involved and everyone has their hands above the waist looking for a pass that will come when open. That's what great passing point guards do they keep the entire team ready because they may get the ball in scoring position at any time of the game. what we have right now is awful PG play. They suck defensively and they aren't very good in the open floor or rarely get in the open floor.

Well Melo had that offense with Dantoni and we were just as bad. At some point it is the player. Melo is what he is. He is not making other players better. He needs great players around him. Which goes back to the question I asked a few weeks ago. Is Carmelo Anthony with $30mil?

Time to move on

gunsnewing wrote:

Vmart wrote:

misterearl wrote:
I don't usually blame owners, but Dolan is completely to blame for the Knicks. He let Walsh do the first half of his job and then stepped in for the sexy part and sold the future for a great scorer with no court vision, no foot speed and no assists. The "star" mentality. The Stoudamire and Lin mistakes could have been made by anyone; only Dolan could have made the Anthony mistake, against the advice of many people. His ego must be enormous, almost as big as his inability to understand what winning basketball is made of. The Knicks can not be good with Dolan at the Helm or Anthony on the court.

- SALBLSRed Hook, NYNYT Pick

Melo has great court vision. It is Woody that has enabled him to be just an iso superstar and not much else. A coach must demand more from his star player, I shouldn't say star his main player. If your running isolation plays for Melo then he is going to shoot. A good motion offense is needed to get everyone involved that is the key to success. All the players feel involved and everyone has their hands above the waist looking for a pass that will come when open. That's what great passing point guards do they keep the entire team ready because they may get the ball in scoring position at any time of the game. what we have right now is awful PG play. They suck defensively and they aren't very good in the open floor or rarely get in the open floor.

Well Melo had that offense with Dantoni and we were just as bad. At some point it is the player. Melo is what he is. He is not making other players better. He needs great players around him. Which goes back to the question I asked a few weeks ago. Is Carmelo Anthony with $30mil?

Time to move on

Let him go. Even by just walking away the Knicks will gain. They need a pick this year and in 2016, trade for that and a garbage contract. Good enough for me.

GoNyGoNyGo wrote:

gunsnewing wrote:

Vmart wrote:

misterearl wrote:
I don't usually blame owners, but Dolan is completely to blame for the Knicks. He let Walsh do the first half of his job and then stepped in for the sexy part and sold the future for a great scorer with no court vision, no foot speed and no assists. The "star" mentality. The Stoudamire and Lin mistakes could have been made by anyone; only Dolan could have made the Anthony mistake, against the advice of many people. His ego must be enormous, almost as big as his inability to understand what winning basketball is made of. The Knicks can not be good with Dolan at the Helm or Anthony on the court.

- SALBLSRed Hook, NYNYT Pick

Melo has great court vision. It is Woody that has enabled him to be just an iso superstar and not much else. A coach must demand more from his star player, I shouldn't say star his main player. If your running isolation plays for Melo then he is going to shoot. A good motion offense is needed to get everyone involved that is the key to success. All the players feel involved and everyone has their hands above the waist looking for a pass that will come when open. That's what great passing point guards do they keep the entire team ready because they may get the ball in scoring position at any time of the game. what we have right now is awful PG play. They suck defensively and they aren't very good in the open floor or rarely get in the open floor.

Well Melo had that offense with Dantoni and we were just as bad. At some point it is the player. Melo is what he is. He is not making other players better. He needs great players around him. Which goes back to the question I asked a few weeks ago. Is Carmelo Anthony with $30mil?

Time to move on

Except from his own admission he did not play for MDA. HE dogged it! He did not like sharing the ball so he didn't do it. He only wants to play ISO ball. He drove Karl crazy too! Why do you think he likes Woodson? Woodson was known as an ISO coach from his Hawk days where he ran the ISO-JOE offense. The Knicks sold out to a selfish star who can only play one way and that is for himself. The fact that he actually was annoyed because LIN got so much credit for the run that year and ran him out of town is enough for me. A real star would have embraced LIN and be thankful that he had another player with him to make it easier.

Let him go. Even by just walking away the Knicks will gain. They need a pick this year and in 2016, trade for that and a garbage contract. Good enough for me.

Yea. If I was Lin I wouldn't want to be in New York and have to deal with a disgruntled Carmelo anyway. It's funny because people keep complaining that Melo has no help and when he did he got jealous and out the door he went because he could t share the spotlight. A happy Melo is when he gets his 30 on 30 shots but the PPG average is not effected. He won the scoring title last year. Can you imagine how satisfying that was for him?

TeamBall wrote:
Dolan loves making money and Lin would have made him a ton. Something personal happened behind the scenes.

TeamBall - same with Grunwald, who probably resented being forced to sign Chris freakin Smith.

The moment Carmelo called the Knicks a “laughingstock" Dolan picked up the phone.

Bulledat.

We all seen melo play unselfish. .

We all seen melo play in the flow of the offense (olympics)

We all seen melo throw some great passes

We all seen melo play some solid defense at times

So why doesn't he do it consistent because the coach doesn't hold him accountable

Bench him?
yell at him?
tell him he can't go out until he cleans his room?

how do you hold a player accountable when he has the franchise by the balls?

GoNyGoNyGo wrote:

gunsnewing wrote:

Vmart wrote:

misterearl wrote:
I don't usually blame owners, but Dolan is completely to blame for the Knicks. He let Walsh do the first half of his job and then stepped in for the sexy part and sold the future for a great scorer with no court vision, no foot speed and no assists. The "star" mentality. The Stoudamire and Lin mistakes could have been made by anyone; only Dolan could have made the Anthony mistake, against the advice of many people. His ego must be enormous, almost as big as his inability to understand what winning basketball is made of. The Knicks can not be good with Dolan at the Helm or Anthony on the court.

- SALBLSRed Hook, NYNYT Pick

Melo has great court vision. It is Woody that has enabled him to be just an iso superstar and not much else. A coach must demand more from his star player, I shouldn't say star his main player. If your running isolation plays for Melo then he is going to shoot. A good motion offense is needed to get everyone involved that is the key to success. All the players feel involved and everyone has their hands above the waist looking for a pass that will come when open. That's what great passing point guards do they keep the entire team ready because they may get the ball in scoring position at any time of the game. what we have right now is awful PG play. They suck defensively and they aren't very good in the open floor or rarely get in the open floor.

Well Melo had that offense with Dantoni and we were just as bad. At some point it is the player. Melo is what he is. He is not making other players better. He needs great players around him. Which goes back to the question I asked a few weeks ago. Is Carmelo Anthony with $30mil?

Time to move on

Except from his own admission he did not play for MDA. HE dogged it! He did not like sharing the ball so he didn't do it. He only wants to play ISO ball. He drove Karl crazy too! Why do you think he likes Woodson? Woodson was known as an ISO coach from his Hawk days where he ran the ISO-JOE offense. The Knicks sold out to a selfish star who can only play one way and that is for himself. The fact that he actually was annoyed because LIN got so much credit for the run that year and ran him out of town is enough for me. A real star would have embraced LIN and be thankful that he had another player with him to make it easier.

Let him go. Even by just walking away the Knicks will gain. They need a pick this year and in 2016, trade for that and a garbage contract. Good enough for me.