[ IMAGES: Images ON turn off | ACCOUNT: User Status is LOCKED why? ]

POR v NY Thread 3/29
Author Thread
DefAndReb
Posts: 20459
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 10/9/2002
Member: #336
3/30/2004  5:28 PM
You guys are funny.

Anyway, let me try once more and this will be the last time I'll bring it up. I promise. I won't post anything until playoff time, and that's if the team gets in without Allan.

Nothing bad happened to me, and I'm not bitter about Frank, despite how the posts may read to some. TRU is part right. I despise communism. I'm against statism. I don't believe people are all equal nor should they be forced to be equal, as everyone's potential is different. That's not saying people shouldn't be held to the same standard. Allow me to explain:

If two guys are gunning for the same job, and one guy was raised in an orphanage and struggled for everything and the other comes from power and money, the guy who gets the job is ... the one who is best suited for it based on skills and performance. Their life stories are irrelevant. I guess that makes me Un-American. To be an American, I guess I'm either supposed to give the job to the orphan because he's had a tough life, or to the rich guy because he's got friends in high places or because he must be rich because he's smarter than the orphan. Yeah, I'm just like my good buddy Rush "Destroy the Liberals" Limbaugh or Karl "Workers Paradise" Marx. Uh-Huh, you got me. You so smart.

I simply asked martin what's up with FWill. He produced a quote that FWill said he didn't think he could play ball the rest of the season, because he was too sad about his mother dying. I fully sympathize with him for feeling bad, as I've gone through the same thing, and I explained that, but I do not agree that he should get to take the rest of the season off, paid mind you, just because he's heartbroken. And that's IF the reason is because of his mother. Like I said, if it's because he's still physically hurt, fine. If it's because Wilkens or Thomas wants him to stay on the IR, fine. I apologize to Frank Williams if I offended him by implying he was not playing because he's sad, if that isn't the case. But if, IF, it was my team, which admittedly it is NOT, and the reason was because of his mother, I would give him a stern talking to about it, then get him some psychiatric help while he takes paid leave. If he still doesn't want to play (this is a scenario, mind you, not saying it's really the reason) then I would suspend him without pay or waive him. I would not, as a businessperson, pay someone not to work who has had ample time to grieve. Life goes on, and time stops for no one. Funny how fishy wants to turn my own beliefs back at me, as though I wasn't saying that in the first place. Life isn't fair? No duh, which is why we have to fight for fairness. Since when is fairness part of Communism OR ultra-conservativism? Both are anti-fairness. But I guess I was wrong. Fighting for fairness, given that life is by nature unfair, is wrong. I guess we should accept cancer and earthquakes, as we puny humans are no match for Mother Nature. My mistake.

And yes, in a corporation, like the one I work for, people are given ample time to grieve. If they need more time, they can use their sick days. More time? Then it's time to talk about what they want to do with their lives, because, as a businessperson, I cannot afford to let them grieve forever. I'm a Capitalist. With a big "C". It has its drawbacks, but it is a better economic system than Socialism.

Okay? Do we all get it now?

Simrud. Yes, it would be nice if we could give the guy as much time as he wants, and IF that's the situation with Frank, it's Dolan's investment. I think it sends the wrong message to the other players and the fans, and it hurts the team. That's just mean bitter old ultra right-wing commie-pinko Un-American character assassin me. It must be because I didn't get enough hugs or because my sister touched me funny, I can't remember which.

See ya'.
Posted by TRU:
Posted by fishmike:

go with what he said... I came off too harshly, there is something to be said for being subtle.

Nah, fish. For a $2 psychoanalysis of someone you don't know, I think you did a stellar job.

As for D&R's "communist" rhetoric, I think he's just the opposite-- his opinions are way towards the ultra-conservative right. "Fighting the battle against those who get special treatment" sounds alot more like Rush Limbaugh than Karl Marx.

Either way, it's patently un-American. But he's entitled to voice his opinion.
AUTOADVERT
simrud
Posts: 23392
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 10/13/2003
Member: #474
USA
3/30/2004  7:03 PM
Bro relax, nobody says you should not post anywhere. Everybody is entitled to their own opinions. Last thing I wanted to do is have you feel unwelcome anywhere. I just don't agree with you. I think we should strive to make things better, not fairer. Fairness is worthless, I’d rather be good then fair any day. We place too much emphasis on "fairness" in our society instead of caring about whether something is good. That is why so much court ruling seem complexly out of whack to any normal person. Basically I'm saying that if we strive to make things better rather then fair or even, which is for the most what people perceive the word as, we'll get to much better places much faster. And yes your view is also somewhat in line with the corporate way, which by the way is not a pretty set of convictions, Enron being a prime example.
A glimmer of hope maybe?!?
tkf
Posts: 36487
Alba Posts: 6
Joined: 8/13/2001
Member: #87
3/30/2004  8:54 PM
Posted by fishmike:

Def... your sounding like an idiot. Say we are all held to the same standards isnt a smart comment. These guys are managed differently than Bob from accounting and Joe from advertising. Sorry, thats a fact of life.

Also *speculating* that Frank isnt playing again because he doesnt want to or cant and attacking his character is pretty sad.

Did it occur to anyone that between missing time for a pulled groin then a death in the family it just didnt make sense to try an integrate Frank back into the rotation with 15 games left and the Knicks one or two losses away from missing the playoffs? Moochie isnt good and Frank has more talent but Moochie isnt terrible either. You can see he contributes when he gets enough time to develop a little rythm.

Sorry if I come off like an ass but attacking a guys character based on ones speculation just irritates me.

fish I agree these guys are held to different standards than the average guy, and I don't want to at all sound insenstive to frankie because I know what it is like to lose a mother, that was killer for me man, but what I want to clarify is that I don't know why frankie is not playing, but my advice to someone like him is to mourn, I mean you will never get over losing your mother, so mourn, but remember that it is your responsibility now to carry on like men, and take care of himself and his family and that means taking hold of himself and his career, right now to me it looks like frankie is just losing his foothold with the knicks, I want to see him get better personally and get it together in the NBA weither it is with the knicks or another team, but get it together....
Anyone who sits around and waits for the lottery to better themselves, either in real life or in sports, Is a Loser............... TKF
GoNyGoNyGo
Posts: 23559
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 5/29/2003
Member: #411
USA
3/31/2004  11:50 AM
Posted by DefAndReb:

You guys are funny.

Anyway, let me try once more and this will be the last time I'll bring it up. I promise. I won't post anything until playoff time, and that's if the team gets in without Allan.

Nothing bad happened to me, and I'm not bitter about Frank, despite how the posts may read to some. TRU is part right. I despise communism. I'm against statism. I don't believe people are all equal nor should they be forced to be equal, as everyone's potential is different. That's not saying people shouldn't be held to the same standard. Allow me to explain:

If two guys are gunning for the same job, and one guy was raised in an orphanage and struggled for everything and the other comes from power and money, the guy who gets the job is ... the one who is best suited for it based on skills and performance. Their life stories are irrelevant. I guess that makes me Un-American. To be an American, I guess I'm either supposed to give the job to the orphan because he's had a tough life, or to the rich guy because he's got friends in high places or because he must be rich because he's smarter than the orphan. Yeah, I'm just like my good buddy Rush "Destroy the Liberals" Limbaugh or Karl "Workers Paradise" Marx. Uh-Huh, you got me. You so smart.

I simply asked martin what's up with FWill. He produced a quote that FWill said he didn't think he could play ball the rest of the season, because he was too sad about his mother dying. I fully sympathize with him for feeling bad, as I've gone through the same thing, and I explained that, but I do not agree that he should get to take the rest of the season off, paid mind you, just because he's heartbroken. And that's IF the reason is because of his mother. Like I said, if it's because he's still physically hurt, fine. If it's because Wilkens or Thomas wants him to stay on the IR, fine. I apologize to Frank Williams if I offended him by implying he was not playing because he's sad, if that isn't the case. But if, IF, it was my team, which admittedly it is NOT, and the reason was because of his mother, I would give him a stern talking to about it, then get him some psychiatric help while he takes paid leave. If he still doesn't want to play (this is a scenario, mind you, not saying it's really the reason) then I would suspend him without pay or waive him. I would not, as a businessperson, pay someone not to work who has had ample time to grieve. Life goes on, and time stops for no one. Funny how fishy wants to turn my own beliefs back at me, as though I wasn't saying that in the first place. Life isn't fair? No duh, which is why we have to fight for fairness. Since when is fairness part of Communism OR ultra-conservativism? Both are anti-fairness. But I guess I was wrong. Fighting for fairness, given that life is by nature unfair, is wrong. I guess we should accept cancer and earthquakes, as we puny humans are no match for Mother Nature. My mistake.

And yes, in a corporation, like the one I work for, people are given ample time to grieve. If they need more time, they can use their sick days. More time? Then it's time to talk about what they want to do with their lives, because, as a businessperson, I cannot afford to let them grieve forever. I'm a Capitalist. With a big "C". It has its drawbacks, but it is a better economic system than Socialism.

Okay? Do we all get it now?

Simrud. Yes, it would be nice if we could give the guy as much time as he wants, and IF that's the situation with Frank, it's Dolan's investment. I think it sends the wrong message to the other players and the fans, and it hurts the team. That's just mean bitter old ultra right-wing commie-pinko Un-American character assassin me. It must be because I didn't get enough hugs or because my sister touched me funny, I can't remember which.

See ya'.
Posted by TRU:
Posted by fishmike:

go with what he said... I came off too harshly, there is something to be said for being subtle.

Nah, fish. For a $2 psychoanalysis of someone you don't know, I think you did a stellar job.

As for D&R's "communist" rhetoric, I think he's just the opposite-- his opinions are way towards the ultra-conservative right. "Fighting the battle against those who get special treatment" sounds alot more like Rush Limbaugh than Karl Marx.

Either way, it's patently un-American. But he's entitled to voice his opinion.

Def and Reb, you and I see eye to eye on the issues of Capialism vs Socialism. I am in the first generation of my family born in this country. My ancestors hail from a republic in the former USSR. Statism, commuminism, whatever you call it, is pure EVIL. It makes no moral sense. To take away from the producers and GIVE to the non-producers simply sucks the life out of man. Man cannot be free in a socialist system in my opinion. Man has no rights there as his whole existence is to serve others and NEVER himself! It goes against the basic logic!





As for FWILL, yeah, I am sad for him and I do NOT know what he is going thru, but he is getting paid to play hoops. MJ quit bball when his dad was murdered! He did go on and play baseball however....the point is that his team needs him and he needs to play if he is healthy.
POR v NY Thread 3/29

©2001-2012 ultimateknicks.comm All rights reserved. About Us.
This site is not affiliated with the NY Knicks or the National Basketball Association in any way.
You may visit the official NY Knicks web site by clicking here.

All times (GMT-05:00) Eastern Time.

Terms of Use and Privacy Policy