great post by Nalod, very well said/written...
I agree, our window is short, possibly only 2-3 years.
There are many "Wild Cards" this season for the Knicks but I think one would be the most important for our chances in play offs.
I believe Iman Shumpert, is the most important one for the team when he is back.
Whether he can get healthy, improve from where he left off, and continue to develop with our core.
He will become the apprentice of Kidd/Pablo with the Robin of Felton/Brewer/Camby/Tyson on defense
Other than Felton, only Iman, if healthy, has the ability to penetrate to break down defenses and finish off the dribble.
Whether he can ever become a PG, or at least, be a better SG/combo guard with better PG skills in facilitating, leadership, and of course his LOCK DOWN potential at the PG/SG spot.
Felton plays his best with 4 shooters on the floor for better spacing, in an uptempo offense.
Again, I think Melo would be much more effective playing the PF for himself, the team, and building on an identity.
It would allow Melo and the rest of the team to play off each other much better.
Amare isn't that stretch 4, hopefully is able to execute his lessons of Hakeem, and improves his defense/rebounding/shot blocking/boxing out.
I hope if we continue to show the poor execution/spacing as last year, Amare would be used in the 2nd unit for the benefit of the team.
Knicks are improved much on paper but I think we have to see how Woodson impliments his philosophy and how the team gels before giving them too much credit of 52+ wins and a Eastern Conference Finals appearance.
I am not saying they cannot do it, but rather saying it is more optimistic thinking.
Just like how many of us, including me, thought we were much improved last season with Tyson Chandler/Iman/Jorts etc....
I think we will miss much of what Jeffries brings with his defense/length/versatility/quick feet on DEF and has still not been replaced.
His man on man defense, team defense, unselfishness, and TEAM first mentality cannot be measured by STATS.
Chandler/Camby are both players that anchors our defense, but we are missing a forward that makes it difficult for the Bosh/Dirks/KG/Gasols/Love/Ibaka and biggs that have range that have the ability to go inside/out.
We also still do not have a Lebron stopper as well, Brewer is needed to stop the 2nd tier like Wade, probably the only one that can give Wade a problem posting up 1v1.
Having a Jeffries, allows us to defend Lebron much better with Tyson/Camby behind him.
Anthony Tolliver and James Singleton, are 2 players that can bring similar skills to what Jeffries brought for us.
Kenyon Martin and Sean Williams would be my next choices.
I think that a glue player/role player like that is very crucial.
It can significantly improve our defense/rebounding/hustle, build on a philosophy/identity that we have been missing, and would make us a top 5 defensive team in the league.
It isn't a question about the talent, rather getting the TEAM to play at it's highest level/production/ and creating that IDENTITY that we have lacked for many years since JVG left...
I have to pick, my prediction for the current squad is 48-34, depending on play off seeding anywhere from a 1st round exit to a ECF appearance.
If Iman comes back healthy/continues to improve and our aged VETs can still can contribute at their age, our best shot would be the following season, in 2013-14.
With a mini MLE acquisition and a few trades and upgrades...
If we can add a players Brandon Rush or/and JJ Barea this season during the deadline, it would change my predictions and say we have a legit shot at going to the finals.