games are won on the court not by writers saying the knicks failed to land a star player.
We are rebuilding even with Amare. Dude wanted the big bucks and we do need a box office draw.
We finished 2nd in the Lebron-a-Thon and blew some assets trying.
Two years ago melo was seen as a punk ass 2nd tier me first player. Maybe Walsh really did not want him? Maybe he just played along to make sure the price went up and if Carmelo was real about the deal he would have not compromised by signing his extension.
Avery likley wanted Harris out and the big price was Favors. Nets were be miserable at the box office without a draw. Melo does that for them.
This can't always be about "Who's coming" cuz that savior starphuch don't win games.
Maybe we don't make the playoffs without melo but mortgage the future with what he have as assets would be akin to over borrowing on credit and that all catches up with you.
there is always a sale. there are always opportunities to pick up good players.
Melo is not the generational player that Lebron is. Melo is Glenn Robinson or Glen Rice or at best Bernard King. Players who have brief great windows in their career and put up big numbers but body types that break down. Maybe Melo grows strong and has another 5 years at this level. Bernard King we remember as being great but it took a few years and discipline to get it together.
I liked Melo at the right price. He likley found out the knicks were not going to chase him and wanted him to come to them than them mortgaging the future. Melo in the end wanted his money. Can't blame him, but he could have orchestrated his move here at a low low price and THEN we could have used Gallo or AR for a CP3 type deal to take us over the top. Melo at a big price does not take us over the top.
Gallo might be a 24ppg scorer if you give him the touches. 5 years younger and taller he COULD give us something very similar IN the future. The future is uncertain. Starphuching takes the fear of the future out and makes us feel good about NOW. The problem is the reality is the price you pay for that certainty.
Either way, we don't win a title with just Melo and Amare as the dynamic duo.
Whats right for the Nets is not right for the Knicks.
Fear the russian, but not quite yet. We all knew he was going to make a big splash at some point