[ IMAGES: Images ON turn off | ACCOUNT: User Status is LOCKED why? ]

Is D Lee really that good
Author Thread
knicks1248
Posts: 42059
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 2/3/2004
Member: #582
3/21/2010  10:36 PM
I watch most of the Rockets game and was completely thrown off guard when i heard breen say, thats david lee's 20th rebound to go along with his 27pts and 6 ast. I'm like "you got to be kidding me" when in the hell did he do that. You would think that having a game like that would result in a sure nuff win, but as usually it doesn't. It's amazing how his stats seem so empty, yet JJ had 3 blocks took 4 charges and had a couple steals and had the biggest impact of the game, essentially winning it for them.

I'm dead even on weather we should really look to re-sign him, and i would hate see this guy putting those numbers up with some other team all the way to the finals. I think If we manage to sign LBJ, him a david lee would make an unbelievable tandem. With LBJ's leadership skills and work ethic, along with Dlee's work ethic and high character, we can be a very good team.

ES
AUTOADVERT
Caseloads
Posts: 27725
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 7/29/2001
Member: #41
3/22/2010  12:10 AM
knicks1248 wrote:I watch most of the Rockets game and was completely thrown off guard when i heard breen say, thats david lee's 20th rebound to go along with his 27pts and 6 ast. I'm like "you got to be kidding me" when in the hell did he do that. You would think that having a game like that would result in a sure nuff win, but as usually it doesn't. It's amazing how his stats seem so empty, yet JJ had 3 blocks took 4 charges and had a couple steals and had the biggest impact of the game, essentially winning it for them.

I'm dead even on weather we should really look to re-sign him, and i would hate see this guy putting those numbers up with some other team all the way to the finals. I think If we manage to sign LBJ, him a david lee would make an unbelievable tandem. With LBJ's leadership skills and work ethic, along with Dlee's work ethic and high character, we can be a very good team.

d lee sucks

oohah
Posts: 26600
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 4/7/2005
Member: #887
3/22/2010  12:13 AM
knicks1248 wrote:I watch most of the Rockets game and was completely thrown off guard when i heard breen say, thats david lee's 20th rebound to go along with his 27pts and 6 ast. I'm like "you got to be kidding me" when in the hell did he do that. You would think that having a game like that would result in a sure nuff win, but as usually it doesn't. It's amazing how his stats seem so empty, yet JJ had 3 blocks took 4 charges and had a couple steals and had the biggest impact of the game, essentially winning it for them.

I'm dead even on weather we should really look to re-sign him, and i would hate see this guy putting those numbers up with some other team all the way to the finals. I think If we manage to sign LBJ, him a david lee would make an unbelievable tandem. With LBJ's leadership skills and work ethic, along with Dlee's work ethic and high character, we can be a very good team.

Just take a look at other past stars in D'Antoni's system like Shawn marion and Boris Diaw and then observe what happens when they go back to playing normal basketball. Then consider that Lee is the only player at his position on the Knicks. Then Look at the team's record.

The answer will then be apparent.

oohah

Good luck Mike D'Antoni, 'cause you ain't never seen nothing like this before!
BRIGGS
Posts: 53275
Alba Posts: 7
Joined: 7/30/2002
Member: #303
3/22/2010  12:48 AM    LAST EDITED: 3/22/2010  12:51 AM
knicks1248 wrote:I watch most of the Rockets game and was completely thrown off guard when i heard breen say, thats david lee's 20th rebound to go along with his 27pts and 6 ast. I'm like "you got to be kidding me" when in the hell did he do that. You would think that having a game like that would result in a sure nuff win, but as usually it doesn't. It's amazing how his stats seem so empty, yet JJ had 3 blocks took 4 charges and had a couple steals and had the biggest impact of the game, essentially winning it for them.

I'm dead even on weather we should really look to re-sign him, and i would hate see this guy putting those numbers up with some other team all the way to the finals. I think If we manage to sign LBJ, him a david lee would make an unbelievable tandem. With LBJ's leadership skills and work ethic, along with Dlee's work ethic and high character, we can be a very good team.

knicks1248--the problem all year is that the Knicks did not play with a second big and had problems at the PG position while Gallo +Harrington were very inconsistent.

Now as we have had some consistency from Gallo and the PG position--we have stabilized. The way to turn the differential is to bring in a premium second big man. I also think we need a consistent 6th man with TD moving into the starting line up. We need a C a back up PG and Im more inclined to go young than old because of expense. If I need to improve my bench--I can do that before the deadline. I have an ending contract and a 1 in 2011. We would aheva good unit and we would need to see it in action for 40 games. If Tmac wants to stay and be part of the second unit--he would be in the 9 rotation.

A huge mistake is blaming problems on D lee--we had many other problems that caused the demise.

RIP Crushalot😞
BigDaddyG
Posts: 40211
Alba Posts: 9
Joined: 1/22/2010
Member: #3049

3/22/2010  12:52 AM
oohah wrote:
knicks1248 wrote:I watch most of the Rockets game and was completely thrown off guard when i heard breen say, thats david lee's 20th rebound to go along with his 27pts and 6 ast. I'm like "you got to be kidding me" when in the hell did he do that. You would think that having a game like that would result in a sure nuff win, but as usually it doesn't. It's amazing how his stats seem so empty, yet JJ had 3 blocks took 4 charges and had a couple steals and had the biggest impact of the game, essentially winning it for them.

I'm dead even on weather we should really look to re-sign him, and i would hate see this guy putting those numbers up with some other team all the way to the finals. I think If we manage to sign LBJ, him a david lee would make an unbelievable tandem. With LBJ's leadership skills and work ethic, along with Dlee's work ethic and high character, we can be a very good team.

Just take a look at other past stars in D'Antoni's system like Shawn marion and Boris Diaw and then observe what happens when they go back to playing normal basketball. Then consider that Lee is the only player at his position on the Knicks. Then Look at the team's record.

The answer will then be apparent.

oohah

In Marion's defense, he was putting up good numbers long before the I think Lee is that good offensively. I think Lee's offensive game is up there with other solid power forwards like David West, Jamison, Boozer etc. It's his defense that's bad. As far as Lee's rebounding, per minute rebound rates have always been high. That's even includes the wasted year under Larry Brown.

Always... always remember: Less is less. More is more. More is better and twice as much is good too. Not enough is bad, and too much is never enough except when it's just about right. - The Tick
Nalod
Posts: 71761
Alba Posts: 155
Joined: 12/24/2003
Member: #508
USA
3/22/2010  10:07 AM
The is that good.

ON a better team his numbers will drop but his passing and rebounding will enhance the others.

He does get better every year. That shot is impressive now. Come out to get him and he'll go around you, double him up and he'll pass it.

arkrud
Posts: 32217
Alba Posts: 7
Joined: 8/31/2005
Member: #995
USA
3/22/2010  10:53 AM
Caseloads wrote:
knicks1248 wrote:I watch most of the Rockets game and was completely thrown off guard when i heard breen say, thats david lee's 20th rebound to go along with his 27pts and 6 ast. I'm like "you got to be kidding me" when in the hell did he do that. You would think that having a game like that would result in a sure nuff win, but as usually it doesn't. It's amazing how his stats seem so empty, yet JJ had 3 blocks took 4 charges and had a couple steals and had the biggest impact of the game, essentially winning it for them.

I'm dead even on weather we should really look to re-sign him, and i would hate see this guy putting those numbers up with some other team all the way to the finals. I think If we manage to sign LBJ, him a david lee would make an unbelievable tandem. With LBJ's leadership skills and work ethic, along with Dlee's work ethic and high character, we can be a very good team.

d lee sucks

As Knick fan said... That's why we deserve to suck as a team.
We never appreciate anybody so we never get anywhere.

"There are more things in heaven and earth, Horatio, Than are dreamt of in your philosophy." Hamlet
s3231
Posts: 23162
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 1/16/2004
Member: #544
USA
3/22/2010  10:59 AM    LAST EDITED: 3/22/2010  11:00 AM
I think in some games, you will see his rebounding stats be naturally inflated a bit because of the lack of rebounders on this team.

With that said though, Lee had 6 offensive boards against the Rockets and almost all of them were HUGE for us. You can't tell me with a straight face that if Lee doesn't get those offensive boards, someone else definitely would have. He really had a terrific all-around game against the Rockets and I think his numbers were definitely justified for that particular game. Offensively, he hit several big jump shots for us that just made you shake your head and stare in awe at how lethal his jump shot has gotten. One particular shot stood out to me when McGrady ran the shot clock all the way down and just passed off to Lee with one second remaining. Lee just calmly sank a difficult jumper that was very well contested, the type of shot that you want your star player to make.

I mean, I still don't understand why people continue to bash on him. He is an impact player and the only guy we have that shows up every night. If we replace him with Bosh, I'll definitely be ok with that but outside of that idea, I think we definitely have to do whatever we can to bring him back. A lot of what he does goes unnoticed because people have come to expect his production.

"This is a very cautious situation that we're in. You have to be conservative in terms of using your assets and using them wisely. We're building for the future." - Zeke (I guess not protecting a first round pick is being conservative)
tkf
Posts: 36487
Alba Posts: 6
Joined: 8/13/2001
Member: #87
3/22/2010  11:13 AM
BRIGGS wrote:
knicks1248 wrote:I watch most of the Rockets game and was completely thrown off guard when i heard breen say, thats david lee's 20th rebound to go along with his 27pts and 6 ast. I'm like "you got to be kidding me" when in the hell did he do that. You would think that having a game like that would result in a sure nuff win, but as usually it doesn't. It's amazing how his stats seem so empty, yet JJ had 3 blocks took 4 charges and had a couple steals and had the biggest impact of the game, essentially winning it for them.

I'm dead even on weather we should really look to re-sign him, and i would hate see this guy putting those numbers up with some other team all the way to the finals. I think If we manage to sign LBJ, him a david lee would make an unbelievable tandem. With LBJ's leadership skills and work ethic, along with Dlee's work ethic and high character, we can be a very good team.

knicks1248--the problem all year is that the Knicks did not play with a second big and had problems at the PG position while Gallo +Harrington were very inconsistent.

Now as we have had some consistency from Gallo and the PG position--we have stabilized. The way to turn the differential is to bring in a premium second big man. I also think we need a consistent 6th man with TD moving into the starting line up. We need a C a back up PG and Im more inclined to go young than old because of expense. If I need to improve my bench--I can do that before the deadline. I have an ending contract and a 1 in 2011. We would aheva good unit and we would need to see it in action for 40 games. If Tmac wants to stay and be part of the second unit--he would be in the 9 rotation.

A huge mistake is blaming problems on D lee--we had many other problems that caused the demise.

aND BRIGGS you bring up a good point.. lets say you keep gallo at SF, lee at PF and you want to get a Big this summer? who is available? becuase if all we come away with this summer is a center, fans are going to go nuts, but the thing is, we need a real center more than we need a bosh, amare or joe johnson...

Anyone who sits around and waits for the lottery to better themselves, either in real life or in sports, Is a Loser............... TKF
fishmike
Posts: 53902
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 7/19/2002
Member: #298
USA
3/22/2010  11:22 AM
arkrud, your 100% right.

Every year Knick fans bitch and moan about all the players we pass in the draft and all the players we should have. Then we pick a guy with the last pick in the first round as a nice bench/huslte type guy. In 5 years all the guy does through 4 coaches and plenty of other crap is work hard every year, become a better player every year and eventually become and ALL star. Now Knick fans are obsessing about paying him and would rather see him replaced by inferior players. Its idiotic. Knick fans dont deserve a guy like Lee.

Its an endless source of amusement for me when guys talk about whats wrong with this team how they start with David Lee. We have no PG, no playmakers and no size. So lets focus on the only legit frontcourt player we have who gets 20/12/55% every single night. Oh right... those are inflated #s. Yawn.

"winning is more fun... then fun is fun" -Thibs
kam77
Posts: 27664
Alba Posts: 25
Joined: 3/17/2004
Member: #634
3/22/2010  11:28 AM
He is good enough to be a borderline all-star. nothing more. nothing less.
lol @ being BANNED by Martin since 11/07/10 (for asking if Mr. Earl had a point). Really, Martin? C'mon. This is the internet. I've seen much worse on this site. By Earl himself. Drop the hypocrisy.
martin
Posts: 78441
Alba Posts: 108
Joined: 7/24/2001
Member: #2
USA
3/22/2010  11:31 AM
kam77 wrote:He is good enough to be a borderline all-star. nothing more. nothing less.

you can say that this year, but DLee has shown to improve on a weakness every summer.

3 years ago hardly anyone thought he could improve his outside shot....

Official sponsor of the PURE KNICKS LOVE Program
MS
Posts: 27060
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 7/28/2004
Member: #724
3/22/2010  11:34 AM
This guy never gets any credit. People that think they know basketball are always so dismissive of this kid. He came into the league as a one dimensional hustle guy.

He is now
-One of the best passing big men in the entire NBA
-One of the best rebounders in the league
-One of the best finishers/efficient bigs in the league
-Led the entire NBA in double doubles last year
-One of the better shooting fowards from the outside in this league

He has done all of this while shutting his mouth and playing hard being unfairly benched, jerked in and out of the starting line-up, and coached by mutliple guys. He cares about the fans, he cares about the team. There is nothing inflated about his stats. He can score and rebound with anyone in this league.

Is it his fault that Duhon didn't play well, Gallo and Wilson are hot and cold and our coach doesn't know that he had two rookies that could have made the team better?

Lay off the guy and accept that at 9-10 million he is better investment than 90% of the big men out there.

BRIGGS
Posts: 53275
Alba Posts: 7
Joined: 7/30/2002
Member: #303
3/22/2010  11:50 AM
tkf wrote:
BRIGGS wrote:
knicks1248 wrote:I watch most of the Rockets game and was completely thrown off guard when i heard breen say, thats david lee's 20th rebound to go along with his 27pts and 6 ast. I'm like "you got to be kidding me" when in the hell did he do that. You would think that having a game like that would result in a sure nuff win, but as usually it doesn't. It's amazing how his stats seem so empty, yet JJ had 3 blocks took 4 charges and had a couple steals and had the biggest impact of the game, essentially winning it for them.

I'm dead even on weather we should really look to re-sign him, and i would hate see this guy putting those numbers up with some other team all the way to the finals. I think If we manage to sign LBJ, him a david lee would make an unbelievable tandem. With LBJ's leadership skills and work ethic, along with Dlee's work ethic and high character, we can be a very good team.

knicks1248--the problem all year is that the Knicks did not play with a second big and had problems at the PG position while Gallo +Harrington were very inconsistent.

Now as we have had some consistency from Gallo and the PG position--we have stabilized. The way to turn the differential is to bring in a premium second big man. I also think we need a consistent 6th man with TD moving into the starting line up. We need a C a back up PG and Im more inclined to go young than old because of expense. If I need to improve my bench--I can do that before the deadline. I have an ending contract and a 1 in 2011. We would aheva good unit and we would need to see it in action for 40 games. If Tmac wants to stay and be part of the second unit--he would be in the 9 rotation.

A huge mistake is blaming problems on D lee--we had many other problems that caused the demise.

aND BRIGGS you bring up a good point.. lets say you keep gallo at SF, lee at PF and you want to get a Big this summer? who is available? becuase if all we come away with this summer is a center, fans are going to go nuts, but the thing is, we need a real center more than we need a bosh, amare or joe johnson...


The market does not have a C that will be available in 2010 that is young enough to spend big money on. I think you can retain Lee and ADD one of Bosh or Stoudemire --then add a fasenko and pick 40 can be a guy who is 6-11+

MDA wont use the big C much anyway but we have them. We can rotate Gallo at PF with lets say Bosh and Lee

RIP Crushalot😞
fishmike
Posts: 53902
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 7/19/2002
Member: #298
USA
3/22/2010  12:12 PM
MS wrote:This guy never gets any credit. People that think they know basketball are always so dismissive of this kid. He came into the league as a one dimensional hustle guy.

He is now
-One of the best passing big men in the entire NBA
-One of the best rebounders in the league
-One of the best finishers/efficient bigs in the league
-Led the entire NBA in double doubles last year
-One of the better shooting fowards from the outside in this league

He has done all of this while shutting his mouth and playing hard being unfairly benched, jerked in and out of the starting line-up, and coached by mutliple guys. He cares about the fans, he cares about the team. There is nothing inflated about his stats. He can score and rebound with anyone in this league.

Is it his fault that Duhon didn't play well, Gallo and Wilson are hot and cold and our coach doesn't know that he had two rookies that could have made the team better?

Lay off the guy and accept that at 9-10 million he is better investment than 90% of the big men out there.

It really is that simple. People talk this crap about his #s being inflated. Inflated by who? Who is the great playmaker getting Lee all these easy shots that have him scoring 20ppg at 55%? If you offer Lee $9.5mm next year with max raised over 6 years its a very large 6 year $74mm contract. That should fight off other teams and still give us the flexibility to sign a max or near max guy + Lee + $7-$10mm for a 3rd free agent (cap # pending).

You would bring back your best player as MS described him, add an elite guy and add a strong supporting guy as well.

I can only dream of how solid Lee would look playing with a real playmaker like Lebron, Joe Johnson or even Collison. He would look equally good next to another athletic big with an inside outside game like Amare or Bosh. The guy is a self made all star below average talent around him.

We need a star, but we also need building block guys. Homegrown players that give you 20/12/55%/4 assists are what we want. So what if he's only a borderline all star. Pay him like one and lets keep getting better.

"winning is more fun... then fun is fun" -Thibs
TMS
Posts: 60684
Alba Posts: 617
Joined: 5/11/2004
Member: #674
USA
3/22/2010  12:32 PM
i have an idea for D Lee... instead of working on developing a 3 pt shot this summer, try working on playing some defense & blocking shots... he did a nice job yesterday checking Luis Scola, that's more of the type of play all of us would like to see... too bad playing defense is the exception rather than the norm w/him... we all know he's an elite rebounder & terrific finisher at the rim... not even All NBA level defense we're talking about here, just play some solid D & don't let guys waltz into the paint for easy buckets.
After 7 years & 40K+ posts, banned by martin for calling Nalod a 'moron'. Awesome.
s3231
Posts: 23162
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 1/16/2004
Member: #544
USA
3/22/2010  12:53 PM    LAST EDITED: 3/22/2010  12:54 PM
You mean you don't want to see our point forward bring the ball up and shoot 3's? haha jk

This thread has restored some of my faith in Knicks fans. Glad to see there are a few of us out there that wouldn't mind bringing Lee back at $9-$10 million a season...

"This is a very cautious situation that we're in. You have to be conservative in terms of using your assets and using them wisely. We're building for the future." - Zeke (I guess not protecting a first round pick is being conservative)
Finestrg
Posts: 27296
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 1/1/2006
Member: #1069

3/22/2010  1:02 PM    LAST EDITED: 3/22/2010  1:13 PM
TMS wrote:i have an idea for D Lee... instead of working on developing a 3 pt shot this summer, try working on playing some defense & blocking shots... he did a nice job yesterday checking Luis Scola, that's more of the type of play all of us would like to see... too bad playing defense is the exception rather than the norm w/him... we all know he's an elite rebounder & terrific finisher at the rim... not even All NBA level defense we're talking about here, just play some solid D & don't let guys waltz into the paint for easy buckets.

Agree 100%. No one's looking for all world defense outta this guy - just concentrate on giving more effort in this area, that's all we ask. He's really gotta think about putting much more stock into playing defense instead of thinking about the 3 pt. line and reminding reporters all the time that he's playing out of position. Concentrate on getting stops, however you gotta do it..Right now player around the league are all thinking, "No way David Lee is stoppin' me." And for the most part, they're correct to think so. That's gotta change. He's got the physical tools -- he's big enough (esp. if he ever gets around to playing the 4), quick enough and is a good enough leaper. Defense is where these games are won. Instead of telling us how you're gonna be a 3-pt. shooter next year, tell us how you went back and studied film on guys like Rich Mahorn, Dennis Rodman and plan on playing like they did -- learn how to pull the chair out on a guy in the post, become a little bit of a shot-blocker with that leaping ability of yours, etc...I mean if he didn't have enough physical ability to play D, nobody would say a word, but he does...He's gotta realize you win games in the 4th quarter playing D -- dude went for 26 & 20 yesterday and they still lost and at home...The Houston loss definitely isn't on him, he played fantastic -- it's just an overall concept he needs to embrace & put stock into...Very good player though -- if we can't get the big fish, he's gotta still be in the plans..

knicks1248
Posts: 42059
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 2/3/2004
Member: #582
3/22/2010  1:03 PM
I agree with most who thinks he's been under appreciated, at the same time if we were to have say......ben wallace or tyson chnadler, or JJ insted of lee, would we cringe ever time they take a shot outside of 5 ft from the rim, would we be begging management to get a more offensive PF to start along side your defensive center.

Jamison, West, boozer, Scola, even dirk are all sub par defenders and suspect help defenders as well. TD, KG, and bosh are really the only big man in the league that have a complete package. Im starting to warm up to jeff green and J Thompson but the jury still out.
If you balance out the roster with both offensive and defensive players like we had on our 1999 roster(probably our best line up in 23 years) we would be fine.

ES
markvmc
Posts: 22004
Alba Posts: 3
Joined: 1/6/2008
Member: #1797

3/22/2010  1:08 PM
MS wrote:

He is now
-One of the best passing big men in the entire NBA
-One of the best rebounders in the league
-One of the best finishers/efficient bigs in the league
-Led the entire NBA in double doubles last year
-One of the better shooting fowards from the outside in this league

Just curious about the first item on this list (items 2-4 are obviously true, and item 5 seems plausible to me, without checking the figures). Is that item based on stats, or is it your overall impression of Lee's passing?

The reason I ask is because my overall impression (not based on stats) is that Lee often makes quite risky long cross court passes, that either end in turnovers, or just barely avoid being turnovers. Based on this (again, just my impression, not based on stats), I tend not to regard him as being that good a passer.

Is D Lee really that good

©2001-2025 ultimateknicks.comm All rights reserved. About Us.
This site is not affiliated with the NY Knicks or the National Basketball Association in any way.
You may visit the official NY Knicks web site by clicking here.

All times (GMT-05:00) Eastern Time.

Terms of Use and Privacy Policy