[quote]
Posted by HARDCOREKNICKSFAN:When was that ever dsisputed? The point was that Dolan's "family friendly" pitch caters more to those suburbanites than to the urban fans who are more Pro-Spree. That is rediculous. It has nothing to do with being suburban, maybe it has to do with age and the fact that they arent in touch with what youth finds appealing but you are throwing them all into a single category because of what you perceive.
Now if you read what each of us wrote, you would see that there must be a possibility that we could be drawing these references from something other than having heard with our own ears that what we are complaining about. Actually I did read both of your posts and I find them to be baseless.
from post 1:
Some of you may remember that I hypothesized that Dolan is trying to lure more middle-aged white suburbanites to the games, knowing that he can't satisfy the real basketball fans in this town.
from your first post:
What D&R is referring to is Dolan's apparent attempt to make the Knicks more "family friendly". Yes, that cross section of people does seem to be what he's shooting for. Most of the NYC based fans identified with Spree, his outlook, his game, style and his unwillingness to back down- even from team management. In fact, most of those who hated Spree and made it known in the Garden (by saying things that led me to believe that they were clearly racist themselves) were all too often white and from the suburbs.
Not a team player... when he has either come off the bench or played the 3 (NOT a natural position for him). Yeah, is that isn't a team player, then I don't want one.
...and who the hell said anything about a "thug"? Is that all you got from the whole thread? People associating that look or demeanor as that is part of the problem we were discussing in the first place.He isnt a team player because he shows up late, he doesnt tell the team when he is injured, he does things his own way even if it hurts the team. While he is a rebel and he has an image to uphold, he also let it get in the way of what it means o be part of a TEAM. There is no I in team, and Spree was all about Spree.
OK, firstly, D&R said : "Of course, not all white suburbanites are like that, and there are plenty of basketball fans that don't live in the city." Ok, so that one sentence makes everything he said in post #1, and what you said in your first post ok? I dont think so - you guys started off by generalizing about a specific group of people and then you try and say you arent.
Now just how did u extract "And yes, you are generalizing about all whites from the suburbs" from the previous statement?See above.
We don't need to be astrophysicists to figure this stuff out.
If that doesn't apply to you, why are you so defensive? And who's turning something into a color issue? Remember sonny, how this country was founded... That last comment was an ill-advised one. Don't take it there.I am not defensive, I am pointing out that the comments you guys made were generalizations that have nothing to do with why the Knicks currently suck. It isnt Dolans ideal to have a crowd of white people from the suburbs watching, yet you seem to think there is some huge conspiracy by Dolan and Layden to get that demographic to come to Knicks games. To me it seems like you are the one who is getting defensive here because someone actually doesnt agree with your view. I do remember how this country was founded, I also live in 2003 not 1776.
With that said, have you ever watched the commercials? watch (I mean really watch)MSG's programming and see for yourself. Analyze who they are advertising to. I bet you never even noticed. Ok..I dont watch the commercials because I dont care what they are selling. Do you think I care that tampon commercials are in my face every 10 second when I am trying to watch TV? Does that mean that prime time television is only trying to get tampon wearers to watch their shows? I dont think so. Would you feel better about buying a Knicks ticket if the advertising was more "urban"? Last time I checked, the NBA seemed to market itself as pretty urban. However, you may be right that the Knicks dont push it as much as the NBA does, I will give you that - I still dont see where this whole middle aged white from the suburbs comes from. What about black families that live out there? Asian? Hispanic?
You completely missed the point. We are not talking about violence or "thug" behavior. That part of the convo was about the possible target audience that Dolan is trying to attract. As for fans who waste their money, I am sure they all felt like they wasted their money last year. You went off on that tangent all on your own. I think it is you who missed my point. You both claim that by whitewashing this team and bringing in more friendly looking players that it will immediately appeal to the demographic you believe Dolan is appealing to. My point is, that demographic doesnt care about how "clean" a team looks, they just care about winning. You think Portland has a problem selling tickets when Rasheed and Stoudamire got busted for smoking weed or when Sheed threatened a ref? No, and I have been to Portland many times - that crowd is middle aged and white.
While I completely agree with you that Dolan has ruined this team, I have to disagree with you that he is taking aim at suburban whites. If that makes me sound defensive then so be it, I happen to be a suburban white and your comments to me are offensive so I am voicing my opinion against you. You can think whatever you want, but when you start bringing it to the forum you gotta expect someone will be offended by comments like that. And to be honest with you, if I thought Dolan was purposely making this team more user friendly and non urban in order to get more white people to come to the garden, then I wouldnt bother showing up to watch a basketball game - who wants to watch a game with a bunch of middle aged white stiffs from the burbs anyway?
[Edited by - oasisbu on 10/29/2003 17:09:14]