Posted by nixluva:
Fred Jones may just be in the perfect situation for him. What Isiah is doing with him fits his skills. Don't be in such a hurry to write him off due to any preconceived notion you may have of him. Remember how good Barnes looked last year with GS. Sometimes it's the situation and not the player. He's got a ton of physical ability and fits well with Nate and the other defensive players we have. He's a ball hawk and we need that. Just remember that we'll need to offset the lack of D from the starters and we have the perfect unit to do that. I like DNic, but let's be real, he's got almost no shot to play unless we have mass injuries and if we do then it won't matter. It's just a number game. I'd rather we kept him and got rid of James, but I doubt that happens. We'll see. We also have H2O in the mix too.
Subzero0, I wouldn't be so harsh on Isiah. He's more than done his share of adding youth tho this team. We have some really talented young players and now they're starting to develop. The loss of one guy isn't going to change out fortunes and i doubt that Isiah is putting his own personal agenda ahead of making this team a winner. I think you underestimate how badly he wants to win. He is the same guy that battled against Magic, Bird and Jordan. He wants his legacy to be that he brought a winner to NY. He has nowhere else to go if this doesn't work, so i'm convinced that he's only thinking of the team and making it the best it can be.
I understand what your saying and I sympathize with Isiah because I feel he made more good moves than bad ones. But by keeping Fred Jones and letting Nichols walk he is showing that he is in fact in full win now mode. We should sign Fred Jones if we are going to compete for a championship this year. I feel that we will not compete for one this year. We should be looking at 2 or 3 years down the road hopefully to be in the conference finals and nba finals. So we should take a chance on Nichols to play now a little and get experience so that he could become the type of player that can contribute in a couple of years. Isiah, if he does this would show that he wants to win as much as possible now, possibly to save his job, in lieu of preparing for the future. If in fact I am right, then that is the thinking I disagree with him on.
Remember I support Isiah, because I believe everyone makes mistakes, but if you fail to see the mistakes that you make and continue to make new ones then I must re-evaluate my endorsement of him (e.g. not buying out JJ(x) and signing Nichols, provided he is allowed to by Dolan).
Even us lovers have limits dammit.