Posted by islesfan:
O'Neal is a franchise player, Curry is not.
The Pacers upside was far greater and even then they underachieved under Isiah in his 3 years there.
Curry being a franchise player remains to be seen. He's still five or six years younger than JOneal.
I'm sorry, while I can see some of your other points - how can the youngest team ever to make the playoffs be considered "underachieving"? They were right on course in Isiah's third year at 35-15, best record in the East, when both Artest and O'neal had serious problems with their parents and Tinsley got injured. That's not underachieving, that's circumstantial. And it's worth noting that Isiah controlled Artest better than anyone else in the league. The first season after Isiah left Artest had that embarassing incident with Riley on the sideline, cost the Pacers a chance at the Finals by imploding against Detroit and commiting flagrants all over the place and then the start of the following season Artest totally lost his mind. An incident which was made worse by Bird trading Al Harrington for the powder keg known as Stephen Jackson.