As many of you know, I have been going back and forth with seemingly half the board about my view that LB mishandled the roster until about a week ago.
I have based my arguments on the games that we all watch: LB yanked the minutes from the vets, gave them to the youth, started playing a faster tempo and VOILA! a much better team.
My opposition's arguments have been based on four assumptions, one that nobody can prove/disprove and three that are totally false.
1)The assumption that nobody can know and therefore is made up is: The rookies had to learn 'how to play the right way' and once they did, they got the minutes and that led to the Knicks recent success. This view is conjecture and nothing else. I won't be addressing that in this post.
2)The second assumption is that the Knicks should have expected to start the worst of any team in the NBA because that is historically how LB teams are. They play badly for the first season or most of the first season then they explode as excellent teams. This is false.
3)The third assumption is that LB really is concerned with the long-term winning of the Knicks. This contradicts his entire career.
4)The fourth assumption is that LB 'turns around' or 'resurrects' franchises. False again. He is an excellent coach, but his success has varied.
Now to the facts:
Larry Brown's coaching record:
Reg Season Playoffs
Year Tm Lg W L WPct W L WPct
+--------------+-----+----+-----+----+---+-----+
1973 CAR ABA 57 27 .679 7 5 .583
1974 CAR ABA 47 37 .560 0 4 .000
1975 DNA ABA 65 19 .774 7 6 .538
1976 DNA ABA 60 24 .714 6 7 .462
1977 DEN NBA 50 32 .610 2 4 .333
1978 DEN NBA 48 34 .585 6 7 .462
1979 DEN NBA 28 25 .528
1982 NJN NBA 44 38 .537 0 2 .000
1983 NJN NBA 47 29 .618
1989 SAS NBA 21 61 .256
1990 SAS NBA 56 26 .683 6 4 .600
1991 SAS NBA 55 27 .671 1 3 .250
1992 SAS NBA 21 17 .553
LAC NBA 23 12 .657 2 3 .400
1993 LAC NBA 41 41 .500 2 3 .400
1994 IND NBA 47 35 .573 10 6 .625
1995 IND NBA 52 30 .634 10 7 .588
1996 IND NBA 52 30 .634 2 3 .400
1997 IND NBA 39 43 .476
1998 PHI NBA 31 51 .378
1999 PHI NBA 28 22 .560 3 5 .375
2000 PHI NBA 49 33 .598 5 5 .500
2001 PHI NBA 56 26 .683 12 11 .522
2002 PHI NBA 43 39 .524 2 3 .400
2003 PHI NBA 48 34 .585 6 6 .500
2004 DET NBA 54 28 .659 16 7 .696
2005 DET NBA 54 28 .659 15 10 .600
+--------------+-----+----+-----+----+---+-----+
4 Seasons ABA 229 107 .682 20 22 .476
22 Seasons NBA 987 741 .571 100 89 .529
+--------------+-----+----+-----+----+---+-----+
26 Seasons 1216 848 .589 120 111 .519
+--------------+-----+----+-----+----+---+-----+
Breakdown:Caroline Cougars 1973,1974: Cougars record the season before LB: 35/49. The Cougars had an excellent first season and got considerably worse in LB's second season.
Denver Nuggets (ABA) 1975,1976: Nuggets record the season before LB: NA. The Nuggets have a great first season under LB. They are still good the next year, but they are 5 games worse by record.
Denver Nuggets (NBA) 1977, 1978, 1978: The Nuggets were steadily mediocre with a declining record under LB until he leaves mid season in 1979.
New Jersey Nets 1982, 1983: Nets' record the season before LB: 24/58. The Nets improved under LB to mediocre during Brown's tenure.
San Antonio Spurs 1990, 1991, 1992: Spur's record the season before LB: 31/51. LB had a good record from his first season with the Spurs, due in no small part to rookie sensation David Robinson, who was allowed to play from the get go and he played great. LB leaves within 3 seasons, during mid-season once again, this time to coach the Clippers during the same season.
Los Angeles Clippers 1992, 1993: Clipper's record the season before LB: 31/51. Lb's Clipper teams were decent, no better. LB was gone in 1.5 seasons.
Indiana Pacers 1994, 1995, 1996, 1997: Pacers's record the season before LB: 41/41. The Pacers are a pretty decent team under LB, never anything great despite having Reggie Miller in his prime, Rik Smits in his prime and solid team throughout. They start out decent, get slightly better, then crap out in '97, Larry decides he does not want to coach there anymore...then the Pacers get much better under LB, Larry Bird: 58/24!
Philidelphia 76'ers 1998, 1999, 2000, 2001, 2002: 76'ers record the season before LB: 22/60. LB's first 2 season with Philly are abysmal, then the talent gets much better, and so does the team's record! In his best coaching job ever, LB's 2001 team escapes the weakest eastern conference in history and gets manhandled by the Lakers in the finals. The Sixers then drift back into mediocrity until LB is wooed by Detroit.
Detroit Pistons 2004, 2005: Piston's record the season before LB: 54/28. Larry takes over a Pistons team that had progressed from a second round playoff team to a conference final team the previous 2 years under Rick Carlisle. (Incidentally Carlisle took over a team that had a 32-50 record).
LB actually does worse than Carlisle until Rasheed Wallace is traded to the Pistons! LB takes this ready-made team to the finals, where the slaughter they injured Lakers who hate each other. In 2005 LB takes the ready-made Piston to the finals again and is stomped by the Spurs.
New York Knicks 2006: LB has the worst starting record of his career 7/21. New York fans parrot media regarding how LB starts slow historically, LB is a franchise saver etc. without having any idea of what he has actually done in his career or the context he has done it in.
LB is a great coach historically. But let us get the facts right please:
LB has had great starts and slow starts.
LB's success has been directly related to talent. Less talent less wins.
LB has never ressurected or turned around a franchise. He has done well with some, less so with others.
LB likes to move on. If you think he is looking towards long-term anything you are completely ignoring his career tendecies. He will leave any team at the drop of a hat.
oohah
[Edited by - oohah on 01-11-2006 05:52 AM]