[ IMAGES: Images ON turn off | ACCOUNT: User Status is LOCKED why? ]

Fire Thibs
Author Thread
GustavBahler
Posts: 42663
Alba Posts: 15
Joined: 7/12/2010
Member: #3186

5/29/2025  10:45 AM
Knicks starters have played 700 more minutes than the Pacers starters in the playoffs. Thats absolutely insane.

Thibs will likely be back, but I dont see us getting any further in the postseason if this is what we will see next season. 700 minutes!

New assts and a mandate from Leon to stop overplaying the starters, is the only way I see us not repeating the mistakes of this season.

AUTOADVERT
VDesai
Posts: 42499
Alba Posts: 44
Joined: 10/28/2003
Member: #477
USA
5/29/2025  10:53 AM
Thibs getting beat in this series doesn't really outweigh 30+ years of coaching accomplishments. I am frustrated with how he has countered Carlisle the last 2 years and in general with the way he has countered teams that press and trap Brunson. Brunson already a below average defender, but he's in a place where he's using up a ton of energy bringing the ball up the floor and trying to shake loose, and getting called for a ton of fouls, so now they literally have him at his weakest point to exploit. Thibs is so fixated on having size out there that he avoids using 2 PGs....meanwhile when we have gone to the two PG look on rare occasion, the results are pretty good, especially offensively.

People are fixated on Brunson having one assist to KAT last game....btw where are the catch and shoot opportunities for Brunson? The guy thrived on catch and shoot 3's and at this point either he or KAT is our best shooter. Both are scoring mainly off of ISO situations where they are creating for themselves with the help of screen. Neither are getting catch and shoots. This isn't a new thing in the Pacers series....its been the case since around January of this year when team's started to counter by putting wings on KAT and effectively negated the pick and pop game that was pretty potent early in the season.

Even with all that - scoring hasn't exactly been our issue in the series, but I think we could probably make the process easier which would give us more energy to compete on the defensive end.

GustavBahler
Posts: 42663
Alba Posts: 15
Joined: 7/12/2010
Member: #3186

5/29/2025  11:14 AM
Im not predicting anything. Still believe Thibs will back. But a blowout at home in front of Dolan. Leon might be pressured to make a change. At some point Rose's job security will be tied to Thibs if we cant get to the Finals. Only Dolan knows when.
martin
Posts: 75966
Alba Posts: 108
Joined: 7/24/2001
Member: #2
USA
5/29/2025  11:26 AM
Panos wrote:
Uptown wrote:
HofstraBBall wrote:
DLeethal wrote:The East is never going to be *easy*, but next year is shaping up with be arguably easier than this year with Boston eliminated from the picture. Yes teams are gonna get better, and we should get better too in our second year.

I see Miami, Milwaukee and Orlando, Detroit, Hawks and Sixers making personnel moves to move up a level and compete with top teams now that Tatum is out for the year.
We will have to improve internally. Which I think we can.

In order for Internal improvement to occur, the coach has to be willing to open up the bench and insert Dadiet and or McCullar into the rotation. With the ramifications of the 2nd apron, internal, cheap improvements is a must. We need another elite wing defender and to get more athletic. Hopefully our two rookies can provide that next year.

What exactly have you seen from Dadiet or McCullar to think they are worthy of NBA minutes?

You have to project their paths, just like with Deuce.

I was surprised at how quickly McCullar in particular moved from injured list to GLeague to NBA minutes, for the few that he did get. I'd guess that he'll get playing time because he knows his role and knows how to perform within that role well. He will be a glue guy that does all the dirty work, defends, passes, scores on cuts and will not be afraid to take an open shot within the flow. He was regarded as the best guard/wing defender in college during his last year. He is the type of guy that won't get lost within an offense and he'll pick it up right away (that's my guess).

For me, if the FO has confidence in McCullar, it'll make Deuce available in trades, as he and Mitch are your most moveable players that have value other teams can see and relate to. McCullar can replace Deuce's defense and perhaps offensive productively but in a different way. IMO, and this is projecting, McCullar will be a better more versatile 1-on-1 defender than Deuce and a much better team defender. He may not have the spacing capabilities right away but his mid range and downhill game is legit. McCullar obviously has to prove his is beyond his injuries.

Dadiet for me is a wild card. Could take another year, could also burst onto the scenes. He has super smarts in off ball movement and is a lights out shooter, but he absolutely needs to show his shot at the NBA level. For me, he has that touch that just suggests that it's a sky high ceiling, that good. When he shoots, it just seems very Curry or Durant like when it leaves his hands. Needs to translate though, and that'll come with a ****ton of reps and playing time. We shall see what he brings on D, that's TBD on moving his feet but he has shown a willingness.

No clue on Kolek.

Official sponsor of the PURE KNICKS LOVE Program
ToddTT
Posts: 30417
Alba Posts: 53
Joined: 8/30/2001
Member: #105
5/29/2025  10:59 PM
Guys c’mon stay focused! Don’t let one win distract you.
Oh good lord... https://www.youtube.com/shorts/XkmGrX7O0lQ
EwingsGlass
Posts: 27448
Alba Posts: 2
Joined: 4/29/2005
Member: #893
USA
5/29/2025  11:35 PM
Fuck. Indiana. Renew. Expectations.

Teamwork. Hustle. Intensity. Boards. Stops.

It was in front of us the entire time.

Light em up.

T.H.I.B.S. is on F.I.R.E.

Hit the 3 and they win by 40. Gotta find that 3 before they get dusty in OKC.

You know I gonna spin wit it
DLeethal
Posts: 22887
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 7/19/2023
Member: #9126

5/29/2025  11:56 PM
Would think Thibs job is officially marked safe now. A blowout at home in game 5 was probably the final thing that could’ve done him in. I suppose an egregious 30-40pt blowout could change that but let’s just assume for all of our sake that won’t happen
blkexec
Posts: 28291
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 9/3/2004
Member: #748
5/30/2025  6:49 AM
DLeethal wrote:Would think Thibs job is officially marked safe now. A blowout at home in game 5 was probably the final thing that could’ve done him in. I suppose an egregious 30-40pt blowout could change that but let’s just assume for all of our sake that won’t happen

In game adjustments is Thibs weakness, but I bet that’s changing right before our eyes.

Pre game adjustments is Thibs strength, and that hasn’t changed.

Thibs is a hard nose coach who puts in the hours to get his team prepared and ready for the next game. Now the pressure is on Rick Carlisle to make his adjustments. But if Thibs plays shammet and wright again, that’s the guard defense we need. Precious was also a key addition to the rotation. He’s the perfect small ball center And he can hit free throws.

Born in Brooklyn, Raised in Queens, Lives in Maryland. The future is bright, I'm a Knicks fan for life!
foosballnick
Posts: 21529
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 6/17/2010
Member: #3148

5/30/2025  7:37 AM
Knicks lose = Fire Thibs

Knicks win = Thibs has changed and might now be safe

At Giants games the guys sitting in front of us for years would get ****-faced drunk every game and shout out "BENCH ELI" after every bad pass or interception....then would high-five and hug each other and hail Eli after a Touchdown or great play.

DLeethal
Posts: 22887
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 7/19/2023
Member: #9126

5/30/2025  7:53 AM
foosballnick wrote:Knicks lose = Fire Thibs

Knicks win = Thibs has changed and might now be safe

At Giants games the guys sitting in front of us for years would get ****-faced drunk every game and shout out "BENCH ELI" after every bad pass or interception....then would high-five and hug each other and hail Eli after a Touchdown or great play.

To some degree most coaches are coaching for their lives in the playoffs. Thibs is in a spot as a long tenured coach on a team with huge expectations now so that’s how it goes. Coaching is the most unfair job in the world with regards to getting fired

Clean
Posts: 30299
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 8/22/2004
Member: #743
5/30/2025  7:55 AM
foosballnick wrote:Knicks lose = Fire Thibs

Knicks win = Thibs has changed and might now be safe

At Giants games the guys sitting in front of us for years would get ****-faced drunk every game and shout out "BENCH ELI" after every bad pass or interception....then would high-five and hug each other and hail Eli after a Touchdown or great play.

That does not explain me at all. I want him gone no matter what. This is the second playoffs in a row where bench players would have helped if he trusted them. Last year we played Burks too late to matter. This year it was close to being too late but we are finally trusting some players from our bench. Now think to yourself, if they can help in the Eastern Conference Finals why can't they help through the whole year? There was never a need to rely on our starters as much as he always does. That added to my normal problems with him and my stance is still the same. He also needs to be able to sit Hart when he is going brain dead.

Swishfm3
Posts: 23309
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 3/28/2003
Member: #392
5/30/2025  8:32 AM
HofstraBBall wrote:
DLeethal wrote:The East is never going to be *easy*, but next year is shaping up with be arguably easier than this year with Boston eliminated from the picture. Yes teams are gonna get better, and we should get better too in our second year.

I see Miami, Milwaukee and Orlando, Detroit, Hawks and Sixers making personnel moves to move up a level and compete with top teams now that Tatum is out for the year.
We will have to improve internally. Which I think we can.

You need a new crystal ball, bro

Half those teams you mentioned are in no position either financially or asset wise, to make any kind of major move this off season.

I do agree that we can improve internally..but I have a feeling that, if Thibs sticks around, Bridges will be moved.

Nalod
Posts: 71028
Alba Posts: 155
Joined: 12/24/2003
Member: #508
USA
5/30/2025  8:36 AM
Context of the moment.
Deuce had leg issues on and off.
Payne did play well early.
Dadiet and Kolek were tried. They did not perform.
Huk had injury issues early, then got it going, then got hurt. Thibs played him. There was a need.
We did have Sims off the bench.
Mitch had 20 games to get ready after being out 11 months.
Shamet shoulder was an issue.
Jalen missed 15 games in March.
It all matters in some form.
Precious in. Then he was out.
Minutes Police regret did not factor this year.

Now your not 100% wrong but what you have now on the bench was not there all season. What does another coach do differently that is bonafide fact? I respect your opinion and had it been known this bench could do all this perhaps you rethink but you don't have that luxury when it actually matters.

Swishfm3
Posts: 23309
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 3/28/2003
Member: #392
5/30/2025  8:36 AM
blkexec wrote:
Swishfm3 wrote:The words “defensive genius” should never be used to describe Thibs ever again

It’s clear now that Thibs can not turn offensive players into defenders. I was hoping to see that in towns, especially solace they have history. But you can’t teach defensive IQ.

The other issue I have with Thibs as a defensive coach. I was expecting some adjustments on defense as a defensive team strategy.

So if Thibs is not a defensive guru. And he’s not an offensive genius. Then what is he? A development coach?

If we bring back this same roster, their defense will not improve enough to make a significant difference. But there’s room to improve the teams offense.

He’s an assistant coach

fishmike
Posts: 53800
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 7/19/2002
Member: #298
USA
5/30/2025  8:45 AM
Swishfm3 wrote:
blkexec wrote:
Swishfm3 wrote:The words “defensive genius” should never be used to describe Thibs ever again

It’s clear now that Thibs can not turn offensive players into defenders. I was hoping to see that in towns, especially solace they have history. But you can’t teach defensive IQ.

The other issue I have with Thibs as a defensive coach. I was expecting some adjustments on defense as a defensive team strategy.

So if Thibs is not a defensive guru. And he’s not an offensive genius. Then what is he? A development coach?

If we bring back this same roster, their defense will not improve enough to make a significant difference. But there’s room to improve the teams offense.

He’s an assistant coach

lol
"winning is more fun... then fun is fun" -Thibs
DLeethal
Posts: 22887
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 7/19/2023
Member: #9126

5/30/2025  8:56 AM
Nalod wrote:Context of the moment.
Deuce had leg issues on and off.
Payne did play well early.
Dadiet and Kolek were tried. They did not perform.
Huk had injury issues early, then got it going, then got hurt. Thibs played him. There was a need.
We did have Sims off the bench.
Mitch had 20 games to get ready after being out 11 months.
Shamet shoulder was an issue.
Jalen missed 15 games in March.
It all matters in some form.
Precious in. Then he was out.
Minutes Police regret did not factor this year.

Now your not 100% wrong but what you have now on the bench was not there all season. What does another coach do differently that is bonafide fact? I respect your opinion and had it been known this bench could do all this perhaps you rethink but you don't have that luxury when it actually matters.

I think it’s indisputable that Thibs failed the bench this year. It’s OK to criticize the guy. At the end of the day he has us 2 wins from the Finals. But he made no effort to develop a bench all year long. His usage of the bench was simply to spot the starters a few minutes. Worst bench in the league by far in production and minutes. Shamet is a bench player on any team in the league and Payne was horrible 80% of the time yet was the only mainstay. Leon traded for Wright and he’s proven to be a much better and more stable fit off the bench yet never got a shot until we were down 0-2 in the ECF.

fishmike
Posts: 53800
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 7/19/2002
Member: #298
USA
5/30/2025  9:52 AM
DLeethal wrote:
Nalod wrote:Context of the moment.
Deuce had leg issues on and off.
Payne did play well early.
Dadiet and Kolek were tried. They did not perform.
Huk had injury issues early, then got it going, then got hurt. Thibs played him. There was a need.
We did have Sims off the bench.
Mitch had 20 games to get ready after being out 11 months.
Shamet shoulder was an issue.
Jalen missed 15 games in March.
It all matters in some form.
Precious in. Then he was out.
Minutes Police regret did not factor this year.

Now your not 100% wrong but what you have now on the bench was not there all season. What does another coach do differently that is bonafide fact? I respect your opinion and had it been known this bench could do all this perhaps you rethink but you don't have that luxury when it actually matters.

I think it’s indisputable that Thibs failed the bench this year. It’s OK to criticize the guy. At the end of the day he has us 2 wins from the Finals. But he made no effort to develop a bench all year long. His usage of the bench was simply to spot the starters a few minutes. Worst bench in the league by far in production and minutes. Shamet is a bench player on any team in the league and Payne was horrible 80% of the time yet was the only mainstay. Leon traded for Wright and he’s proven to be a much better and more stable fit off the bench yet never got a shot until we were down 0-2 in the ECF.

2 wins from the finals and the big cry is he's not getting the most from the vet min guys on the bench. Just put that into perspective.
"winning is more fun... then fun is fun" -Thibs
martin
Posts: 75966
Alba Posts: 108
Joined: 7/24/2001
Member: #2
USA
5/30/2025  10:44 AM
DLeethal wrote:
foosballnick wrote:Knicks lose = Fire Thibs

Knicks win = Thibs has changed and might now be safe

At Giants games the guys sitting in front of us for years would get ****-faced drunk every game and shout out "BENCH ELI" after every bad pass or interception....then would high-five and hug each other and hail Eli after a Touchdown or great play.

To some degree most coaches are coaching for their lives in the playoffs. Thibs is in a spot as a long tenured coach on a team with huge expectations now so that’s how it goes. Coaching is the most unfair job in the world with regards to getting fired

What do you think the expectations where for Thibs at the beginning of the year? And especially linked to any 3rd round playoff expectations on 1 particular game? Cause that's how I'm reading you on your above?

Official sponsor of the PURE KNICKS LOVE Program
martin
Posts: 75966
Alba Posts: 108
Joined: 7/24/2001
Member: #2
USA
5/30/2025  10:49 AM
DLeethal wrote:
Nalod wrote:Context of the moment.
Deuce had leg issues on and off.
Payne did play well early.
Dadiet and Kolek were tried. They did not perform.
Huk had injury issues early, then got it going, then got hurt. Thibs played him. There was a need.
We did have Sims off the bench.
Mitch had 20 games to get ready after being out 11 months.
Shamet shoulder was an issue.
Jalen missed 15 games in March.
It all matters in some form.
Precious in. Then he was out.
Minutes Police regret did not factor this year.

Now your not 100% wrong but what you have now on the bench was not there all season. What does another coach do differently that is bonafide fact? I respect your opinion and had it been known this bench could do all this perhaps you rethink but you don't have that luxury when it actually matters.

I think it’s indisputable that Thibs failed the bench this year. It’s OK to criticize the guy. At the end of the day he has us 2 wins from the Finals. But he made no effort to develop a bench all year long. His usage of the bench was simply to spot the starters a few minutes. Worst bench in the league by far in production and minutes. Shamet is a bench player on any team in the league and Payne was horrible 80% of the time yet was the only mainstay. Leon traded for Wright and he’s proven to be a much better and more stable fit off the bench yet never got a shot until we were down 0-2 in the ECF.

Mitch, Deuce, Cam, Shamet, Precious, Wright, Sims. Hukkporti, Dadiet, McCullar, Kolek. Gleague bros.

How did you come to your conclusion? Like, by what measure did the bench fail? I'm kinda lost on that. I dont think you are paying attention to the context at all.

Official sponsor of the PURE KNICKS LOVE Program
GustavBahler
Posts: 42663
Alba Posts: 15
Joined: 7/12/2010
Member: #3186

5/30/2025  10:52 AM    LAST EDITED: 5/30/2025  10:53 AM
fishmike wrote:
DLeethal wrote:
Nalod wrote:Context of the moment.
Deuce had leg issues on and off.
Payne did play well early.
Dadiet and Kolek were tried. They did not perform.
Huk had injury issues early, then got it going, then got hurt. Thibs played him. There was a need.
We did have Sims off the bench.
Mitch had 20 games to get ready after being out 11 months.
Shamet shoulder was an issue.
Jalen missed 15 games in March.
It all matters in some form.
Precious in. Then he was out.
Minutes Police regret did not factor this year.

Now your not 100% wrong but what you have now on the bench was not there all season. What does another coach do differently that is bonafide fact? I respect your opinion and had it been known this bench could do all this perhaps you rethink but you don't have that luxury when it actually matters.

I think it’s indisputable that Thibs failed the bench this year. It’s OK to criticize the guy. At the end of the day he has us 2 wins from the Finals. But he made no effort to develop a bench all year long. His usage of the bench was simply to spot the starters a few minutes. Worst bench in the league by far in production and minutes. Shamet is a bench player on any team in the league and Payne was horrible 80% of the time yet was the only mainstay. Leon traded for Wright and he’s proven to be a much better and more stable fit off the bench yet never got a shot until we were down 0-2 in the ECF.

2 wins from the finals and the big cry is he's not getting the most from the vet min guys on the bench. Just put that into perspective.

We wouldnt have won two of the last three games without an expanded rotation, and it has absolutely nothing to do with what they're being paid.

We would likely have been swept if Thibs had stuck to a 7 man rotation. Thats all the perspective we need.

Fire Thibs

©2001-2025 ultimateknicks.comm All rights reserved. About Us.
This site is not affiliated with the NY Knicks or the National Basketball Association in any way.
You may visit the official NY Knicks web site by clicking here.

All times (GMT-05:00) Eastern Time.

Terms of Use and Privacy Policy