[ IMAGES: Images ON turn off | ACCOUNT: User Status is LOCKED why? ]

Fire Thibs
Author Thread
HofstraBBall
Posts: 27937
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 11/21/2015
Member: #6192

5/28/2025  12:09 PM
DLeethal wrote:The East is never going to be *easy*, but next year is shaping up with be arguably easier than this year with Boston eliminated from the picture. Yes teams are gonna get better, and we should get better too in our second year.

I see Miami, Milwaukee and Orlando, Detroit, Hawks and Sixers making personnel moves to move up a level and compete with top teams now that Tatum is out for the year.
We will have to improve internally. Which I think we can.

'Knicks focus should be on players that have grown up playing soccer or cricket' - Triplethreat 8/28/2020
AUTOADVERT
martin
Posts: 75974
Alba Posts: 108
Joined: 7/24/2001
Member: #2
USA
5/28/2025  2:23 PM
DLeethal wrote:
Nalod wrote:
DLeethal wrote:If Thibs is back I hope we force a high level offensive mind on his bench like we did with Woodson/D'Antoni. And I hope we can convince him to develop a bench over the course of the season.

5th best rated offense this season. what is really missing on the bench? Who does what and who is not getting it done?
With Mikal and KAT the team went thru a big change from last year.
Indy mostly ran it back and once healthy making a run to the finals!
They are far from invincible but they are getting it done.
OKC had a treasure trove of picks and giddy to make moves with and salary flex to sign iHart.
They have a window before they have to pay Williams and Chet. They are succeeding in the new CBA better than most.
Teams like Bulls and Grizz have not! Teams with talent that did not work or injury issues.

Knicks were last in bench points, last in bench minutes, and 9th in bench NET. Which means they had a good enough bench to be 9th in NET yet were not trusted to play and thus didn't produce.

https://www.nba.com/stats/teams/traditional?SeasonType=Regular%20Season&StarterBench=Bench&dir=A&sort=PTS

In my opinion, Knicks had a good enough bench this year to be middle of the pack. Especially later in the year. Deuce, Mitch, Wright, Shamet is a potent bench. Deuce should be much closer to Hart in minutes than he is. Wright is an analytics darling on defense and it lines up with the eye test. And Shamet can shoot and play disruptive defense. We wasted away the season playing Cam Payne who is most likely the worst backup in the league by far. Not to mention Tyler Kolek is good enough to warrant a developing and does things no one else on our team can do in the playmaking department.

It's a potent bench if they all were available the whole season. 3 of those guys were realistically not available for 75% of the season (either flat missing or nowhere near full). And Deuce had a wild time with injuries this year that slowed him repeatedly; during the majority of the season, Deuce missed like a 1/3 of the games each month except Dec and Feb. And Cam Payne was unfortunately a faux PG.

Official sponsor of the PURE KNICKS LOVE Program
martin
Posts: 75974
Alba Posts: 108
Joined: 7/24/2001
Member: #2
USA
5/28/2025  2:26 PM
DLeethal wrote:
GustavBahler wrote:
blkexec wrote:Thibs didn’t have a great series, but neither did the players. Leon was great. He provided Thibs with defensive wings, shooters and a roster talented enough to win it all. Unfortunately all the pieces together wasn’t enough to beat the pacers. Still have a chance but the light is fading...

I’m not on this “fire Thibs” stuff. He hasn’t lost the locker room and players respect him. But like the players, Thibs needs to reflect and grow from this experience. I’m not going to react off an emotional loss, But I will guarantee this. Leon is already cooking up a few strategies to improve the team. So I’m happy we have a competent GM who knows how to improve a team incrementally, without gutting the core.

We have a team with potential and a culture is developing. Just need a tuneup / upgrade on the off season. I can’t put my finger on that one upgrade that’s needed, so I’m just going to enjoy the bright lights of the ECF and be grateful we made it to the ELITE 4. Nobody expected us to make it this far.

If it’s another season of running the starters ragged. To the point where the NBA’s Ironman is complaining. We will be lucky to make the ECF again because the competition is going to get tougher. It’s not just Boston in our way now. It’s Indy.

Leon seems to have a hands off approach when it comes to how Thibs runs the team. But I don’t believe he can or should stay silent, if Thibs plans on spending another season ghosting his bench for the most part. No one else in the league does it like that.

I don't think we can predict the competition getting tougher. Yes Indiana will be there, and yes Cleveland will be there. But DET and BOS was not an easy road to the ECF. In fact it could be easier next year where we don't have to play a 60 win team in the second round. Knicks are well positioned to make another run at it again next year, but we have to get better, we aren't going to make the ECF again with double digit 4th quarter comebacks in every win, that's for sure.

I do agree that Leon needs to get more involved if Thibs is gonna stay. Beef up his staff, put some ultimatums on developing a bench.

It's my opinion that they have done this very deliberately already. That's why relatively no Kolek, etc. There are only a few opinions behind not playing the kids.

Official sponsor of the PURE KNICKS LOVE Program
ToddTT
Posts: 30417
Alba Posts: 53
Joined: 8/30/2001
Member: #105
5/28/2025  4:16 PM
I vote for continuity. Thibs ain't perfect, but I assume he has the player's respect and trust... for the most part. And that he hasn't lost the locker room.

We mainly need better players, IMO. And better fitting players.

Oh good lord... https://www.youtube.com/shorts/XkmGrX7O0lQ
GustavBahler
Posts: 42663
Alba Posts: 15
Joined: 7/12/2010
Member: #3186

5/28/2025  4:28 PM    LAST EDITED: 5/28/2025  4:29 PM
ToddTT wrote:I vote for continuity. Thibs ain't perfect, but I assume he has the player's respect and trust... for the most part. And that he hasn't lost the locker room.

We mainly need better players, IMO. And better fitting players.

Continuity at head coach and one or more new asssistant coaches. As I said upthread, new players wont matter if Thibs runs another tight rotation next season. Maybe some new assts will help Thibs coach a deeper bench. Make more adjustments in game.

Uptown
Posts: 31285
Alba Posts: 3
Joined: 4/1/2008
Member: #1883

5/28/2025  7:26 PM    LAST EDITED: 5/28/2025  9:00 PM
HofstraBBall wrote:
DLeethal wrote:The East is never going to be *easy*, but next year is shaping up with be arguably easier than this year with Boston eliminated from the picture. Yes teams are gonna get better, and we should get better too in our second year.

I see Miami, Milwaukee and Orlando, Detroit, Hawks and Sixers making personnel moves to move up a level and compete with top teams now that Tatum is out for the year.
We will have to improve internally. Which I think we can.

In order for Internal improvement to occur, the coach has to be willing to open up the bench and insert Dadiet and or McCullar into the rotation. With the ramifications of the 2nd apron, internal, cheap improvements is a must. We need another elite wing defender and to get more athletic. Hopefully our two rookies can provide that next year.

Swishfm3
Posts: 23309
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 3/28/2003
Member: #392
5/28/2025  8:19 PM
The words “defensive genius” should never be used to describe Thibs ever again
Panos
Posts: 30045
Alba Posts: 3
Joined: 1/6/2004
Member: #520
5/28/2025  9:49 PM
Uptown wrote:
HofstraBBall wrote:
DLeethal wrote:The East is never going to be *easy*, but next year is shaping up with be arguably easier than this year with Boston eliminated from the picture. Yes teams are gonna get better, and we should get better too in our second year.

I see Miami, Milwaukee and Orlando, Detroit, Hawks and Sixers making personnel moves to move up a level and compete with top teams now that Tatum is out for the year.
We will have to improve internally. Which I think we can.

In order for Internal improvement to occur, the coach has to be willing to open up the bench and insert Dadiet and or McCullar into the rotation. With the ramifications of the 2nd apron, internal, cheap improvements is a must. We need another elite wing defender and to get more athletic. Hopefully our two rookies can provide that next year.

What exactly have you seen from Dadiet or McCullar to think they are worthy of NBA minutes?

martin
Posts: 75974
Alba Posts: 108
Joined: 7/24/2001
Member: #2
USA
5/28/2025  9:57 PM
ToddTT wrote:I vote for continuity. Thibs ain't perfect, but I assume he has the player's respect and trust... for the most part. And that he hasn't lost the locker room.

We mainly need better players, IMO. And better fitting players.

So trade for Randle?

Official sponsor of the PURE KNICKS LOVE Program
ToddTT
Posts: 30417
Alba Posts: 53
Joined: 8/30/2001
Member: #105
5/28/2025  10:40 PM
martin wrote:
ToddTT wrote:I vote for continuity. Thibs ain't perfect, but I assume he has the player's respect and trust... for the most part. And that he hasn't lost the locker room.

We mainly need better players, IMO. And better fitting players.

So trade for Randle?

I wouldn’t wish New York on Randle.

But I do love me some bully ball. Maybe Giannis is what I would like to see. I don’t know.

What I do know is… screw KD. No thank you.

Oh good lord... https://www.youtube.com/shorts/XkmGrX7O0lQ
Nalod
Posts: 71029
Alba Posts: 155
Joined: 12/24/2003
Member: #508
USA
5/28/2025  10:58 PM
GustavBahler wrote:
DLeethal wrote:
GustavBahler wrote:
blkexec wrote:Thibs didn’t have a great series, but neither did the players. Leon was great. He provided Thibs with defensive wings, shooters and a roster talented enough to win it all. Unfortunately all the pieces together wasn’t enough to beat the pacers. Still have a chance but the light is fading...

I’m not on this “fire Thibs” stuff. He hasn’t lost the locker room and players respect him. But like the players, Thibs needs to reflect and grow from this experience. I’m not going to react off an emotional loss, But I will guarantee this. Leon is already cooking up a few strategies to improve the team. So I’m happy we have a competent GM who knows how to improve a team incrementally, without gutting the core.

We have a team with potential and a culture is developing. Just need a tuneup / upgrade on the off season. I can’t put my finger on that one upgrade that’s needed, so I’m just going to enjoy the bright lights of the ECF and be grateful we made it to the ELITE 4. Nobody expected us to make it this far.

If it’s another season of running the starters ragged. To the point where the NBA’s Ironman is complaining. We will be lucky to make the ECF again because the competition is going to get tougher. It’s not just Boston in our way now. It’s Indy.

Leon seems to have a hands off approach when it comes to how Thibs runs the team. But I don’t believe he can or should stay silent, if Thibs plans on spending another season ghosting his bench for the most part. No one else in the league does it like that.

I don't think we can predict the competition getting tougher. Yes Indiana will be there, and yes Cleveland will be there. But DET and BOS was not an easy road to the ECF. In fact it could be easier next year where we don't have to play a 60 win team in the second round. Knicks are well positioned to make another run at it again next year, but we have to get better, we aren't going to make the ECF again with double digit 4th quarter comebacks in every win, that's for sure.

I do agree that Leon needs to get more involved if Thibs is gonna stay. Beef up his staff, put some ultimatums on developing a bench.

It will be another year of growing for the Pacers. I doubt the Cavs will be as easy to take out next season, with Atkinson as coach in year 2. Boston might be out of the picture next season, but they’ll be back. Pistons took a big step this season.

I don’t believe we should put the same starting lineup out there again next season. It could be chemistry that needs time to improve, or it’s just a bad fit in the postseason. I’m hoping we have a different starting lineup next season. Move a starter to the bench so we aren’t so top heavy.

And then that new "different starting lineup" will need time to gel/chemistry also?
If there is a trade that Leon can conjure Im sure he'll look at it if it plugs wholes.
But that great unknown most clamping for is not always improvement. Its change with a concept.

as said, we a 51 win team that made the ECF's. Indy was a game under us but surging. I think they finished 30-14 in the last 44 games after an injury laden start to the season.

Our bench did improve with Mitch but reality is he needed a lot to games to get it together even in the playoffs.
Most teams don't go more than 8 deep in playoffs traditionally. This deep team thing may be changing that.

Uptown
Posts: 31285
Alba Posts: 3
Joined: 4/1/2008
Member: #1883

5/28/2025  11:08 PM
Panos wrote:
Uptown wrote:
HofstraBBall wrote:
DLeethal wrote:The East is never going to be *easy*, but next year is shaping up with be arguably easier than this year with Boston eliminated from the picture. Yes teams are gonna get better, and we should get better too in our second year.

I see Miami, Milwaukee and Orlando, Detroit, Hawks and Sixers making personnel moves to move up a level and compete with top teams now that Tatum is out for the year.
We will have to improve internally. Which I think we can.

In order for Internal improvement to occur, the coach has to be willing to open up the bench and insert Dadiet and or McCullar into the rotation. With the ramifications of the 2nd apron, internal, cheap improvements is a must. We need another elite wing defender and to get more athletic. Hopefully our two rookies can provide that next year.

What exactly have you seen from Dadiet or McCullar to think they are worthy of NBA minutes?

Not a thing because they haven't been given a chance. My point is, because of the salary cap, we will be hard-pressed to add significant talent in the off season. If we can add talent via free agency, great. If not, hopefully, Dadiet and McCullar can improve during the off season, show up during trainging camp with more confidence, more experience, and some added skill. Hopefully, they ball out during training camp and earn roster spots. Their size and athleticism will be needed next year.

EwingsGlass
Posts: 27448
Alba Posts: 2
Joined: 4/29/2005
Member: #893
USA
5/29/2025  5:46 AM
EwingsGlass wrote:Listen, if it’s the players, we’d be saying things like, “man, they aren’t that good but they do put in a lot of effort and the are at least well coached. They just don’t have the ability to compete with [______].” Or “man, that was a great looking play, the players just failed to finish”. Or, “wow, the defense did everything they could to stop that play, you just can’t stop Giannis”

What we are saying are things like “man, I can believe they keep missing their rotations” and “I can’t believe he took that many shots without hitting” and “ I can’t believe how good [___] is playing but he doesn’t seem to get enough minutes].” Or “he pulled him while he was hot?” Or “Is anyone going close out on him”

If we can’t tell if it’s the players or the coach, it’s the coach. Utah traded every star they had and Snyder’s team executed on offense with clean, crisp plays. Our offense is dribble until you get stuck and then look for a pass or force a shot.

I don’t see us being more than a borderline team. In a year where we have draft picks and a deep draft, might as well switch the coach to a more modern style coach that realizes that coaching (and not just shot selection) has an impact on eFG. His defense style seems to still be protecting against the 18 foot jumper. You can give that away all day if you are taking the right shots and executing on solid plays.

You aren’t beating a coach like Budenholzer with this coach or personnel. Go get your Wems or Scoot and find a Bud.

As for the FO, biggest question mark for me is the Trevor Keels pick. Only place that makes sense is where someone saw his age and fitness and said, he is innately strong and talented, I can fix his flaws and make a solid player. Not sure I believe, but man, besides coming from Duke I saw no indications this guy belongs in the NBA.

This post aged poorly in context. Shortly after, the team started passing a bit more and went on a pretty solid winning streak. Something clicked.

That said, a lot of the criticisms are relevant again today. Teams go through cycles but they aren’t clicking. The “extra pass” is out of desperation and not teamwork. The guys talk about “sticking together” and not “making the extra pass”. It’s like it’s a band of brothers that watches each other fight individually. I’m hoping for a winning streak that quiets me, but I don’t think our offense is championship caliber. We have elite offensive players. But not an elite offense. Forget ORtg during the season - running scores up on bad teams isn’t what I’m talking about. I really just want to see better passing.

You know I gonna spin wit it
DLeethal
Posts: 22888
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 7/19/2023
Member: #9126

5/29/2025  7:33 AM
Uptown wrote:
HofstraBBall wrote:
DLeethal wrote:The East is never going to be *easy*, but next year is shaping up with be arguably easier than this year with Boston eliminated from the picture. Yes teams are gonna get better, and we should get better too in our second year.

I see Miami, Milwaukee and Orlando, Detroit, Hawks and Sixers making personnel moves to move up a level and compete with top teams now that Tatum is out for the year.
We will have to improve internally. Which I think we can.

In order for Internal improvement to occur, the coach has to be willing to open up the bench and insert Dadiet and or McCullar into the rotation. With the ramifications of the 2nd apron, internal, cheap improvements is a must. We need another elite wing defender and to get more athletic. Hopefully our two rookies can provide that next year.

We definitely need to develop at least 1-2 of those guys into serviceable pieces. All teams have to develop cheap talent on the bench nowadays. Just look what Boston has done with Pritchard, Hauser, Kornet.

DLeethal
Posts: 22888
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 7/19/2023
Member: #9126

5/29/2025  7:37 AM
I’m open to pretty much anything this offseason. There’s precedent for staying the course with moves on the margins being the right path for this team. Frankly we probably did too much big game hunting last offseason and could’ve done a more prudent job by staying the course. Adding a new starter for more defense, better quality depth etc might be all we need. And some tweaks on Thibs side either to staff or philosophy.

I’m open to legit moves too though. There are enough red flags to warrant it.

Nalod
Posts: 71029
Alba Posts: 155
Joined: 12/24/2003
Member: #508
USA
5/29/2025  8:04 AM
Panos wrote:
Uptown wrote:
HofstraBBall wrote:
DLeethal wrote:The East is never going to be *easy*, but next year is shaping up with be arguably easier than this year with Boston eliminated from the picture. Yes teams are gonna get better, and we should get better too in our second year.

I see Miami, Milwaukee and Orlando, Detroit, Hawks and Sixers making personnel moves to move up a level and compete with top teams now that Tatum is out for the year.
We will have to improve internally. Which I think we can.

In order for Internal improvement to occur, the coach has to be willing to open up the bench and insert Dadiet and or McCullar into the rotation. With the ramifications of the 2nd apron, internal, cheap improvements is a must. We need another elite wing defender and to get more athletic. Hopefully our two rookies can provide that next year.

What exactly have you seen from Dadiet or McCullar to think they are worthy of NBA minutes?

They are Legit prospects and thus have to earn their place in the rotation.
They have yet to prove "Worthy" but teams have to develop from within even if to be traded at some point.

DLeethal
Posts: 22888
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 7/19/2023
Member: #9126

5/29/2025  8:13 AM
Thibs had Dadiet in the rotation to start the season. He obviously sees something there to do that. He was too raw but Thibs wouldn’t experiment with that if he didn’t see a good prospect there.
blkexec
Posts: 28291
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 9/3/2004
Member: #748
5/29/2025  8:13 AM
Swishfm3 wrote:The words “defensive genius” should never be used to describe Thibs ever again

It’s clear now that Thibs can not turn offensive players into defenders. I was hoping to see that in towns, especially solace they have history. But you can’t teach defensive IQ.

The other issue I have with Thibs as a defensive coach. I was expecting some adjustments on defense as a defensive team strategy.

So if Thibs is not a defensive guru. And he’s not an offensive genius. Then what is he? A development coach?

If we bring back this same roster, their defense will not improve enough to make a significant difference. But there’s room to improve the teams offense.

Born in Brooklyn, Raised in Queens, Lives in Maryland. The future is bright, I'm a Knicks fan for life!
MS
Posts: 27059
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 7/28/2004
Member: #724
5/29/2025  8:32 AM
Honestly, I don’t think the issue is the bench.

There’s plenty of talent in the starting lineup — it’s about staggering and maximizing each player’s strengths. Thibs coaches every game like it’s Game 7, and instead of using the regular season (or even early playoff games) to refine rotations, we end up in a spot like this.

You can get 12–15 solid minutes from Shamet, Wright, and Precious — especially when they’re paired with OG and KAT.

Possible rotations:
• Brunson, Wright, Bridges, OG, Mitch
• McBride, Shamet, Bridges, Precious, KAT
• Hart, Brunson, OG, McBride, Mitch
• Brunson, Shamet, Bridges, OG, Precious
• Bridges, McBride, Shamet, Precious, KAT

Payne should never have seen the floor — we should’ve handled the Pistons in 5. We should be up in this series. Not taking control of Game 1, starting Payne in the 4th in Game 2, and the constant overuse of Hart — it’s on the coaching.

I’m not even a big Bridges guy, but he can run an offense when needed — I don’t want to hear about the bench. There was no reason to overplay everyone last postseason and absolutely no reason to wait until Game 3 of the Eastern Conference Finals to adjust.

And when was the last hard foul this team committed?

ccch
Posts: 20205
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 1/28/2012
Member: #3876

5/29/2025  9:50 AM
Swishfm3 wrote:The words “defensive genius” should never be used to describe Thibs ever again

^^^^Spot on...He's definitely being out coached by Carlisle.

Fire Thibs

©2001-2025 ultimateknicks.comm All rights reserved. About Us.
This site is not affiliated with the NY Knicks or the National Basketball Association in any way.
You may visit the official NY Knicks web site by clicking here.

All times (GMT-05:00) Eastern Time.

Terms of Use and Privacy Policy