Posted by TMS:
not really... Tabata is a very good prospect & Nady, tho having a great year, has not been a very good player historically throughout his career... Marte is nice but not worth a top prospect... i woulda wanted Jason Bay if we were giving up a Jose Tabata... i'm just whatever on this trade to tell u the truth... if they go on to get to the WS then it's a good trade, but if not & Tabata turns out to be the goods then u gotta seriously rethink whether it was a good move or not.
Totally disagree TMS.
Tabata had a ton of issues, he's been suspended a few times and heres a little blurb on one of the reasons he was suspended most recently.
Could not agree more with a scouting report I saw on Jose Tabata that says he tends to turn his talent on and off. I can’t tell you how many times I’ve seen him make no effort on catchable balls that are hit right at him that end up landing. Anthony Hatch hit a ball off of Melancon in the 5th that was right to him, but he barely moved and watched it land about three feet in front of him. I hate to rip the guy, but enough already…
Nady is a solid platoon starting OF'er and he's going to be solid here, hitting around 7th or 8th in the order, he should really do well there. He's also already played in NY and knows how to deal with the fan, media whatever. The bottomline here is that the Yankees held onto all their top-propsects and I say that because Tabata was not deemed one with all his recent run-ins. Austin Jackson had passed him as the top OF prospect.
[Edited by - nyk4ever on 07-25-2008 8:59 PM]