VCoug wrote:NardDogNation wrote:RonRon wrote:he is not leaving because YOU said so?
he can opt out in 2014, so we can still get good value off him if we decided to go this route...
I am not saying we MUST do it but this is something management/Dolan must decide, if they are willing to pay him a Joe Johnson like deal to keep him if he opts out 1 year early, which in would not allow us to go after the FA class of 2015Either of these scenario's would cripple the franchise, however, if Melo would stay and sign a 1 year deal at a MUCH LOWER salary in order for NY to build a team around him with 2015 FA class, Dolan can choose to compensate his pay with a Joe Johnson like deal after 2016
For this to happen, I would need Melo to let go of his opt out clause in his contract for 2014, because he has the ability to have too much leverage over the franchise
I don't have a problem if Dolan wants Melo to be next Joe Johnson or Allan Houston, I have a problem with it if it affects the ability to sign 2015 FA class...
I can care less if we surround ourselves with the talent/score needed to be LEGIT CONTENDERS and not FAKERS for the next 5 years after 2015-2020
That is just me, If i was Knick's management I would not allow Melo to have that leverage on the franchise, call him in, and ask if he wants to be the face of the franchise, retiring as a Knick, or not
If he does not want to let go of his opt out ability in 2014 *like D12 did in Orlando*, there should be NO HESITATION on what must be done for the sake on the franchise and the next 6 years
Getting back as many picks, assets, and players that can turn in to more picks should be easily the road to go if it is going to always be about him and NOT the team/franchise
We did what we could to acquire him and the inability to surround him with the talent needed is because of the price we didn't have to pay to acquire him, had he said "I AM NOT GOING TO SIGN AN EXTENSION TO ANYWHERE BUT NYK's" 2 and half seasons's ago.....
He is not leaving because Melo is highly motivated by money and we can offer him the most money. This the reason he wanted to come to New York and why he demanded it be by trade instead of through free agency; the later benefiting the prospects of us building a more competent team around him. A leopard doesn't change his spots, so there is no need to worry about him leaving us.
And correct me if I'm wrong but Melo stands to earn more money by NOT opting out and re-signing from that figure, no? If that's the case then we really have no reason to preemptively do anything unless he thinks we'll move on from him in 2015. And if he leaves in 2014, then we'll have an amazing pick in 2015 to join our free agent haul in that offseason. Again, I see no downside to our position moving forward AT ALL.
I've read the same thing about opting out, that he and any other player with an option actually make more money by not opting out.
Let's just say, we are unable to keep JR Smith, Kmart, Copeland
Melo say in 2014, wins Scoring Title again in a lower seed with all teams in East healthy and improved
In the play offs, history repeats itself in 1st round or 2nd, Melo is ISO heavy as Woodson is predicates his OFFENSE on
We get knocked out, outmatched, and outcoached, MELO OPT's out, "Either pay me what I am worth for security or I will goto a team that I can contend with at the price you want me to resign for"
What will you do if you are Dolan and/or Grunweld?
You pay him, you cannot build a team that can contend and eventually might not even make play offs as the team continues to age and cannot improve with the salary cap issues....
You don't pay him, he walks to another team, and you get nothing, as you will have to surrender your better draft pick to Denver for the cost of Melo...DOUBLE WHAMMMY!
My whole point is I DO NOT WANT TO BE PUT IN THIS POSITION
I root for Melo as a Knick, even when I don't believe in him, and find ways for him to be successful
However, I am a Knick fan NOT a MELO FAN, NOT A MELO HATOR either because I don't believe in his abilities at the cost of the price we paid, we cannot build a team around him with what was left to be a contender...
I think for Melo who made a lot of money already, his best chance in building a team around him is to take much less, just say around 5-10m with a player option opt out in 2016
He recruits the players needed to form our big 3/4 or whatever, then Dolan rewards him the following year as he opts out....
Otherwise, trade him at good value next year while collecting as many assets/draft picks and using CAP SPACE to lure FA's in 2015 together, while building a foundation of some core players with Iman Shumpert, signing good deals, and trading for more assets