[ IMAGES: Images ON turn off | ACCOUNT: User Status is LOCKED why? ]

Not Melo, not Stout but Jason Kidd healthy is easily MVP of 2012/13 NY Knickerbockers period !
Author Thread
NUPE
Posts: 21221
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 4/29/2012
Member: #4205

12/11/2012  2:25 PM    LAST EDITED: 12/11/2012  2:28 PM
yellowboy90 wrote:
NUPE wrote:
gunsnewing wrote:I don't see how you can put Wade in the conversation. 1) He is breaking down 2) Heat were a lottery team before adding Lebron and Bosh

Lottery team? LoL.

Wade is not in the running for MVP. However, I consider Wade to be a better player than Durant despite Wade's slow start this year. As I said earlier in this thread, MVP is not a best player in the NBA award. It is a best player on one of the 4 best teams award.

LOL how did they get Micheal Beasley again? Like most players he needs the right core around him. The great thing for him is that he played with some great players. IS that his fault no but did he benefit yes.

I am pretty sure Wade sat out a good chunk of that year. I guess Wade gets blamed for the losses even if he was not playing. LoL! I will leave this topic alone as Wade is not relevant to this thread and I don't seek to de-rail.

AUTOADVERT
gunsnewing
Posts: 55076
Alba Posts: 5
Joined: 2/24/2002
Member: #215
USA
12/11/2012  2:31 PM    LAST EDITED: 12/11/2012  2:33 PM
Every great player needs help to win a ring. Kobe, Wade, Lebron, Duncan, KG, Shaq, Jordan, Dirk. Some just need less help I guess. Wade benefitted greatly from Shaq and Lebron. Kobe won with Gasol who is decent but not great
fishmike
Posts: 53861
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 7/19/2002
Member: #298
USA
12/11/2012  2:37 PM
NUPE wrote:
fishmike wrote:
gunsnewing wrote:Knicks are a lottery team without Melo. Miami was more of an aberration. The ugliness of the Chicago game would be more of the norm if we ever lost melo for an extended period of time. Can't rely on Amare being healthy. The team is built around Melo. Melo will certainly be considered for MVP. Lebron still deserves it and who cares about individual awards and accolades
no way man... take Melo and Stat off this team its still a .500 team at least. Probably not much more but Felton/JR/Novak/Kidd/Brewer/Shump/CAmby/Sheed/Prigo/Chandler etc etc is NOT a lottery team. Cmon now.

This team would not even make the playoffs if Melo and Stat are off the team.

A starting five of:

Felton
Kidd
Brewer
Kurt Thomas
Tyson Chandler

That team would struggle to score more often than not. Kidd will not get all these open threes. They'd be chucking up low % contested jump shots night after night. It would be atrocious. Felton and JR would take the majority of the shot attempts which is not a recipe for success night in and night out. This team would get maybe 35ish wins at best.

42 wins. ITs Woody remember? Still would be a top defensive team in the NBA, unless you think Melo is the reason behind that also? Just as good as Phili last year and good depth.

And Durant 7th? Thats a joke. Durant and Melo are similar? Sure... but as I clearly illustrated Durant is better... at everything. Literally every category. Also he's got the individual awards also, so this isnt my opinion, its the opinion of the NBA world as well.

Again... silly. Why the need to make Melo into something he clearly isnt? Are you saying this is the year he's closed the gap? Maybe... Its been 20 games. God forbid we discuss sample size

"winning is more fun... then fun is fun" -Thibs
Uptown
Posts: 31324
Alba Posts: 3
Joined: 4/1/2008
Member: #1883

12/11/2012  3:40 PM
NUPE wrote:
JrZyHuStLa wrote:
fishmike wrote:
JrZyHuStLa wrote:
fishmike wrote:
NUPE wrote:
fishmike wrote:this tells you what many have been saying around here for awhile. Less Melo is more. You cant ask him to be Lebron. He's not that caliber of player. But he's damn good at what he does so let him do what he's good at. You can call this MElo's team, but the reality is he's not that kind of player, and now that he's realizing it he's playing his best ball. Seems he's learned the way to make others around him better is to actually let them touch the ball

Knicks dont have an MVP candidate, and there is nothing wrong with that. I would rather have a team like Larry's Piston's (looking like we might) then the Laker teams they beat.

KNicks are deep and riding this to the top of the Eastern conference. Melo is our best player, but as demonstrated in the Heat game its a good team. When Amare comes back and Shump to the rotation gets deeper and more talented. Amare+Shump >>>> Brewer and Sheed.

With PGs like Kidd and FElton expect a smooth transition


Well players, analyst, ex-players, sports reporters, etc. all disagree with you on this. You are free to have your opinion though.

all of them? Wow!

Again... the Meloites cant just be happy with a great season. They need to elevate their mascot to something he isnt, then when others disagree label them haters who would prefer to see their team lose.

Enjoy the season, and try not to get too upset when Lebron, KD, or someone else wins the award.

Ok, so they don't have an MVP candidate. That's your opinion, fine.

So please tell us in your own words, what your requirements are to be an MVP candidate.

Tell me exactly why Lebron, Durant, Randolph, Curry, etc. are on it but why Anthony should not be on it.

sure. As soon as you answer my question you never answered. Why does Melo get a pass for all his playoff failures as his teams were bad, but MDA was a total failure here his first 2 years when his team was bad. I dont even care

May the circle begin anew!

Sorry... I digressed.

Is it my opinion? Because it seems that others feel the same way. Of course, I dont get to vote but apparently some think Melo isnt even the discussion. He has been voted 2nd (once) and 3rd (once) best at his position, so there's that: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/All-NBA_Team

Again... why cant you just be happy with the team? Melo is an all star. Thats not good enough? Why do you have to pretend your mascot is the best in the league? Just enjoy what he brings to the table. Shockingly I do. This is a fun team to watch. Let Melo be Melo. Stop pretending he's Lebron or KD or whatever make believe player you think he is. Dude's a scorer.

I don't think anyone ever said he was robbed of MVP multiple times in his career. In fact, I never once thought he was even close to even being a candidate in all of his years in the league.

But so far this year, that's not the case. Again, I think everyone who is saying he is a candidate says so because he has the good fortune of being on a top team. That automatically puts him the contention. No one here made the rules or requirements, nor did the league's players.

The requirements sometimes work against you. Kobe averaged 35 PPG during the 05-06 campaign. Those are ridiculous numbers. The only thing that held him back was the fact that the team only had 45 wins. If it was 55+, he would've easily won it.

The requirements sometimes go in your favor. This season, they're going in Carmelo's favor. He's not as good as Lebron and Durant, nor will he ever be. But the fact that Kidd, Chandler, Felton, etc are all meshing and having succes just puts him in the race.

To say that he does not even deserve to be in the top 10 of candidates takes away from everything that the rest of the team has done so far.

Melo is a legitimate MVP candidate because he is putting up great numbers on a team that can conceivably win the East.

The MVP does not go to the best player in the league. This has never been the criteria. It goes to a top player on one of the top 3 or 4 teams in the NBA. It sometimes goes to a top player on a top team where the team has greatly exceeded expectations. Melo needs to play well and the Knicks need to be a top two seed for Melo to have a shot at winning the MVP. It's possible. Time will tell.

Is Melo the best player in the NBA? Absolutely not. Is Melo amongst the best? Sure. Is he on a top team and playing well right now? Yes. I would say that makes him a legit candidate rather than a faux candidate.

Agreed. Its the MVP nor the MOP. If the MVP always went to th ebest player, Kobe should have 4-5 MVP awards to his name instead of 1.

JrZyHuStLa
Posts: 25677
Alba Posts: 3
Joined: 1/5/2007
Member: #1241

12/11/2012  3:43 PM
fishmike wrote:
JrZyHuStLa wrote:
fishmike wrote:
JrZyHuStLa wrote:You're borderline flip flopping, Fish.

not at all man. Not at all. Ewing was ALWAYS a top 10 player. I never thought him as an MVP. And he was MY guy.

Top 10 means one could argue there are 9 other guys better than you, which in Melo's case is close to true. MVP means your not only a top 2-3 player, your also the key player on an elite team.

How is that flopping or the same?

Again... stop HEARING that Melo not MVP = Melo is trash. Only TFK says that

Melo is a good player, but isnt ironic his best start to his best season he's letting the ball go through someone else? You know the one season Melo played with a guy who took more shots than him was ALSO his best statistical season? Go look up the year Iverson took a trillion shots. Melo was pretty much 2nd option playing off him and has a MONSTER season and I believe his best FG% ever. Less is more.

Happy Melo is playing like a top 10 guy. Even happier if he still is this spring. I dont give a phuck about awards he's got no shot to win. I want to win some playoff games. Its been a long time.

What Ewing did to be in the race is NO different than what Anthony is doing to be in it. It's not because of points, rebounds, assists, defense.
It's about being on a winning team. It's instant recognition to be in the MVP race.

And Ewing never won it because there were always a few players who were better and also had better records. Same applies with Anthony. There's better guys out there with better records.

But it doesn't exclude him from the race.


and here is where your just dead wrong man, and to me is the heart of the MVP arguement. Knicks built a defensive team around Ewing that advanced in the playoffs for a decade AND the guy was their leading scorer. 7 times all NBA, 3 times all NBA defense. Those along WITH all the playoff wins = quantifying proof that Ewing was 'more valuable' that Melo. Does Melo anchor this team's defense? Is he a stopper like Kobe has been in his career? NO NO NO NO NO NO

Your off on this one amigo. Surely you can see this?

Is Ewing a better player than Anthony? Yea, when Anthony is all done, I think I'll be able to say that he had a good career, but not as good as Patrick. I'm with you on that.

Being the best player on a top 5 team is what made Ewing a consistent MVP candidate though, the same way it makes Carmelo a candidate.

What do you not see?

fishmike
Posts: 53861
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 7/19/2002
Member: #298
USA
12/11/2012  3:53 PM
the part where Ewing was a "consistent MVP candidate"

He never was considered that. Being 5th-8th isnt in the race in my opinion.

Ewing:
MVP Award Shares
1988-89 NBA 0.235 (4)
1989-90 NBA 0.176 (5)
1990-91 NBA 0.021 (11)
1991-92 NBA 0.104 (5)
1992-93 NBA 0.366 (4)
1993-94 NBA 0.252 (5)
1994-95 NBA 0.219 (4)
1996-97 NBA 0.050 (8)

Melo:
MVP Award Shares
2003-04 NBA 0.001 (14)
2006-07 NBA 0.001 (15)
2007-08 NBA 0.002 (13)
2009-10 NBA 0.053 (6)
Active 0.057 (20)
Career 0.057 (97)


picture getting clearer?

Durant:
MVP Award Shares
2009-10 NBA 0.495 (2)
2010-11 NBA 0.157 (5)
2011-12 NBA 0.735 (2)
Active 1.387 (7)
Career 1.387 (27)

Yea.... Lets move on shall we?

"winning is more fun... then fun is fun" -Thibs
Uptown
Posts: 31324
Alba Posts: 3
Joined: 4/1/2008
Member: #1883

12/11/2012  3:59 PM
fishmike wrote:the part where Ewing was a "consistent MVP candidate"

He never was considered that. Being 5th-8th isnt in the race in my opinion.

Ewing:
MVP Award Shares
1988-89 NBA 0.235 (4)
1989-90 NBA 0.176 (5)
1990-91 NBA 0.021 (11)
1991-92 NBA 0.104 (5)
1992-93 NBA 0.366 (4)
1993-94 NBA 0.252 (5)
1994-95 NBA 0.219 (4)
1996-97 NBA 0.050 (8)

Melo:
MVP Award Shares
2003-04 NBA 0.001 (14)
2006-07 NBA 0.001 (15)
2007-08 NBA 0.002 (13)
2009-10 NBA 0.053 (6)
Active 0.057 (20)
Career 0.057 (97)


picture getting clearer?

Durant:
MVP Award Shares
2009-10 NBA 0.495 (2)
2010-11 NBA 0.157 (5)
2011-12 NBA 0.735 (2)
Active 1.387 (7)
Career 1.387 (27)

Yea.... Lets move on shall we?

This year, thus far, Melo is a top 3 mvp candidate. Will it last? Who knows. But on this day, at this moment he is a top 3 candiate. So whats wrong with discussing that RightNow?!

NUPE
Posts: 21221
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 4/29/2012
Member: #4205

12/11/2012  4:55 PM
I don't even see why Ewing is relevant to this discussion.
Anji
Posts: 25523
Alba Posts: 9
Joined: 4/14/2006
Member: #1122
USA
12/11/2012  5:20 PM    LAST EDITED: 12/11/2012  5:21 PM
It sucks that fishmike throws out the bait and get's you guys everytime.

There is no point guys, even if Melo does well he is choosing his words so that he can still stand on "this is just what I wanted" or "he is just a cog" or "I was waiting for him to prove me wrong, go look at my posts".

Fish doesn't like Melo, but if they win he can look past him, end of story. There is no changing his stripes, TFK or DK7e or what ever his name is who quit posting on Realgm because of the Melo trade. Leave it be. They don't like Melo, end of the story.

"Really, all Americans want is a cold beer, warm p***y, and some place to s**t with a door on it." - Mr. Ford
NYKMentality
Posts: 23995
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 11/12/2012
Member: #4385

12/11/2012  5:45 PM    LAST EDITED: 12/11/2012  5:48 PM
Kevin Durant isn't a better basketball player than Melo. They're pretty much even amongst one another.

Career averages:

Durant:: 26.3 points, 6.7 rebounds, 2.9 assists, 1.2 steals, 1.0 blocks and 3.1 turnovers per game. .470 FG%.
Carmelo: 24.7 points, 6.4 rebounds, 3.1 assists, 1.1 steals, 0.5 blocks and 3.0 turnovers per game. .456 FG%.

So, if Durant is "better" than Melo? It's only been by (+)1.6 points, (+).3 rebounds, (-).2 assists, (+).1 steals, (+).5 blocks and (-)-.1 turnovers per game. A difference of only .14 in FG percentage.

A marginal difference at best.

On the flip side, some can also state that Durant has had (alot) more help when compared to Melo (over the years). Durant's had an elite PG in Westbrook. Has played alongside a franchise type of player in James Harden. Has played next to a top of the line type of PF in Serge Ibaka over the past 4 years. Etc, etc.

Durant has had alot more help (team help) when compared to Melo over the years, but yet, there's only a difference of (+)1.6 points, (+).3 rebounds, (-).2 assists, (+).1 steals, (+).5 blocks and (-)-.1 turnovers per game. A difference of only .14 in FG percentage.

In closing... Melo has been (and is) every bit as good, great, productive and/or elite as Kevin Durant.

Papabear
Posts: 24373
Alba Posts: 2
Joined: 3/31/2007
Member: #1414

12/11/2012  6:33 PM
tkf wrote:
Papabear wrote:
tkf wrote:
CashMoney wrote:
tkf wrote:
NUPE wrote:
tkf wrote:
so really don't buy into Nupe's foolishness here..

Foolishness would be asserting that Gallo is a better player than Melo. LoL! As for Kidd, many stated the signing was questionable and were infatuated with Lin. I specifically said, throughout the off season, that the three pg we signed were a vast improvement over what we had previously, without any sort of qualifier regarding age or health or whatever.

or foolishness would be calling melo a star or mvp candidate after 4 games... when we clearly know who the stars of the league are.... fair enough... try staying on topic, I seem to have you so rattled now that you are chomping at the bit to try to one up me... dude calm down.... this is not a good look fella....

Melo's been a star for 9 years. Know you don't like it but it is the truth.

i honestly think you and some other definition of a star is a lot different than mine....carmelo= Allstar..... lebron, wade, kobe, duncan, = star......


Papabear Says

TKF Get this in your head! Without Melo we win nothing. What kind of fan are you?? Hating our star player. Melo is our super star.Some one like you would love to see Melo gone and be happy with a 40 win season and out in the first playoffs. Or maybe not even make the playoffs. Thats sick. You must be related to Barkley who just hate the Knicks and can't get himself to admit the Knicks are for real.

with him we have won nothing.. and what is this crap without melo we win nothing as if the knicks are doomed for eternity had he not come here, is that what you are saying.. without melo we win nothing regardless of who we get? are you really saying that? you act as if we have won multiple titles with this clown.... you keep spewing that same line. it is not only false but breathtakingly ridiculous considering we have not won a thing with this guy..

I rather have the picks, players and flexibility back.. if you think we were going to be a 40 win team forever then you just didn't have any faith in this organization.. so what kind of fan are you papabear?!!

Papabear Says

TKF I said with the team we have now. Everyone knows how muck you hate Melo. And speaking about Melo and Kid if Melo was on the trading block now almost every team out there would be making offers. But not for Jason Kidd and I love and respect Kidd. I don't know about you maybe Melo did something to you. Did he ?? Maybe he did something inapporiate to you.LOL maybe touched you, been naughty to you? Well get over it TKF. I know that if we win the championship and Melo is the MVP you would hate that. You would not reconize this as a championship team because of Melo and you would not give him the props he deserve.

Papabear
knickstorrents
Posts: 21121
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 1/23/2010
Member: #3050
Hong Kong
12/11/2012  11:13 PM
I am also a wounded knick fan. A diehard Melo hater. Maybe it is because he reminds me of all the losing ways we had in the past? You have to admit aside from this season, character wise he was always suspect. The iso style of play, playing basketball the wrong way, etc all remind me of the losing culture and teams of the Knicks in the past 20+ years.

I just hate that it seemed history repeated itself when we mortgaged the farm to get him. To me it was another example of a dysfunctional organization mortgaging its future on a player that was only interested in his own payday.

The upside to that whole trade were the players we got for 'free'. Kidd, Chandler, Rasheed Wallace, JR Smith (though I hate JR Smith as a player he has his uses). Without those players this team is at a dead end, just like the organization that runs it.

Rose is not the answer.
mrKnickShot
Posts: 28157
Alba Posts: 16
Joined: 5/3/2011
Member: #3553

12/11/2012  11:17 PM
knickstorrents wrote:I am also a wounded knick fan. A diehard Melo hater. Maybe it is because he reminds me of all the losing ways we had in the past? You have to admit aside from this season, character wise he was always suspect. The iso style of play, playing basketball the wrong way, etc all remind me of the losing culture and teams of the Knicks in the past 20+ years.

I just hate that it seemed history repeated itself when we mortgaged the farm to get him. To me it was another example of a dysfunctional organization mortgaging its future on a player that was only interested in his own payday.

The upside to that whole trade were the players we got for 'free'. Kidd, Chandler, Rasheed Wallace, JR Smith (though I hate JR Smith as a player he has his uses). Without those players this team is at a dead end, just like the organization that runs it.

You need a "team" to win

How is Boston without Garnett?

Miami without Lebron or Wade?

SA without Manu or Parker?

The Lakers without Gasol or Shaq?

etc ...

You cant win without complimenters

Anji
Posts: 25523
Alba Posts: 9
Joined: 4/14/2006
Member: #1122
USA
12/11/2012  11:19 PM
"Really, all Americans want is a cold beer, warm p***y, and some place to s**t with a door on it." - Mr. Ford
ChuckBuck
Posts: 28851
Alba Posts: 11
Joined: 1/3/2012
Member: #3806
USA
12/11/2012  11:37 PM
Anji wrote:

Lol what's Van Gundy talking about. Stackhouse clearly ran into Kidd's leg in the middle of Kidd's shot motion. Kidd didn't kick his leg forward ala Reggie Miller.

He's been working too many telecasts with Mike Breen with that subtle anti-Knick bias.

Anji
Posts: 25523
Alba Posts: 9
Joined: 4/14/2006
Member: #1122
USA
12/12/2012  12:13 AM    LAST EDITED: 12/12/2012  12:13 AM
Im just wondering did Kidd get his kiss back from JR when hit the game winner tonight.

We are a team that shares and cares now!!!!

"Really, all Americans want is a cold beer, warm p***y, and some place to s**t with a door on it." - Mr. Ford
GodNa7ion
Posts: 20109
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 7/7/2012
Member: #4269

12/12/2012  1:47 AM
Carmelo is either #1 or #2 right now with Durant, its going to be crazy when we get Stoudemire/Shumpert/Camby back because he can do more things like rebound and get some assists while still scoring easier...........this is the year
NYKMentality
Posts: 23995
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 11/12/2012
Member: #4385

12/12/2012  2:07 AM    LAST EDITED: 12/12/2012  2:19 AM
This is getting pretty old. I should just stop responding to Melo haters and simply enjoy our run. But with all that said...

knickstorrents wrote:I am also a wounded knick fan.
True Knick fans aren't wounded as of right now. Not when we're 16-5 overall for the first time since the 1993-1994 season. 19 years to be exact. We're also the current first seed of the Eastern Conference. And none of this was possible without Carmelo Anthony.

knickstorrents wrote:A diehard Melo hater.
Good for you.

knickstorrents wrote:Maybe it is because he reminds me of all the losing ways we had in the past?
How exactly does Melo remind you of all the "losing ways" we've had during the 2000's? At least make some sense.

Syracuse University has landed 35 NCAA Tournament appearances dating back to 1957, but yet only have 1 National Championship. Thanks to Carmelo Anthony's Freshman season of 2003 (NCAA Tournament Most Outstanding Player). It only took Melo one season to do what this college program has never done dating back to 1957. Losing ways in regards to Melo? Explain.

How exactly does Melo remind you of our losing ways of the 2000's? Because the last time I checked, the Denver Nuggets as a franchise missed the postseason during 9 consecutive seasons prior to the drafting of Melo. 9 long years of losing basketball. But yet after selecting Melo with the 3rd overall pick during the 2003 NBA draft, Melo then went on to lead his Nuggets franchise to 8 consecutive seasons of playoff basketball. 9 losing seasons prior to the drafting of Melo followed by 8 consecutive seasons of winning basketball after the drafting of Melo. Not a coincidence either. Melo changed the culture of their franchise while turning them into a winning franchise despite the fact you've compared him to the Knicks of the 2000's in regards to "losing ways". Melo has never seen a losing (below .500) season and Melo has never missed the playoffs. Losing ways in regards to Melo? Please explain.


knickstorrents wrote:You have to admit aside from this season, character wise he was always suspect.
Now you're digging. Attacking this mans character? He graduated from High School as a kid and went to Syracuse University as a young man. Melo never became a product of his environment either. When Anthony turned eight, his family moved to Baltimore, where he honed not only his athletic skills, but his survival skills. Kenny Minor, one of Anthony's childhood friends, said, "from drugs, to killings, to anything you can name that goes on in the roughest parts of town, we've seen and witnessed hands on. Those are the things that teach you toughness and keep you mentally focused on your goals." Kenny Minor stated. Would you still like to attack his character? Funny how you failed to mention the fact that Melo grew up without a father. His dad passed away when Melo was only two years of age. Never had a father but yet became a loving father in his own right. His sister died in 2010. In 2004, Anthony became engaged to La La. Their son was born in 2007. Anthony and La La became married in 2010. This man seems like both a loving husband and loving father, but yet, you're telling us to "admit" that his character has been "suspect"? How many times has he beat woman? What about raped them? What about been to jail and/or prison due to drugs and/or especially violence? I rest my case.

knickstorrents wrote:The iso style of play, playing basketball the wrong way, etc all remind me of the losing culture and teams of the Knicks in the past 20+ years.

Why aren't you blaming George Karl for Melo's ISO ball and/or "playing the wrong way"? Lets be honest here, Melo was only in Denver for 8 years. George Karl on the other hand? 25 years as a head coach with zero championships. Karl as a head coach has a career losing postseason record of only 78-101. Seems to me as if coach Karl was the one holding Melo back, not the other way around, because under coach Woodson? Melo is performing on an MVP level while leading his Knicks team to current greatness (or close to it).

Also, how long have you been a Knicks fan? I only ask because, 20+ years ago the Knicks were enjoying our golden years under Starks, Oakley and Ewing. We were 16-5 19 years ago from today. That was back in 1993-1994. The Knicks enjoyed lots of success throughout the entire 90's. So, which 20 years are you talking about?

knickstorrents wrote:I just hate that it seemed history repeated itself when we mortgaged the farm to get him.
Really? "mortgaged the farm"? Where is Eddy Curry now? He's a free agent after eating his way out of the league. Raymond Felton has returned, but where is Anthony Randolph as of right now now? He's Denver's 13th man off the bench while only averaging 6.3 minutes per game. Where is the Russian rookie project in Timofey Mozgov? He's the Nuggets 3rd string Center behind both Kosta Koufos and JaVale McGee. Where is Wilson Chandler as of right now? The last time I checked, he only played 6 games last season and has only played 4 games here in 2012-2013 due to injury. He's still injured. And during the 6 games he's played here in 2012-2013 he's only averaged 6.5 points per game off an awful .313 field goal percentage (%).

That only leaves Danilo Gallinari, unless you believe that we "mortgaged the farm" for the likes of Anthony Randolph, Wilson Chandler, Eddy Curry and Timofey Mozgov. So once again, that leaves Danilo Gallinari. Are you really trying to state that we "mortgaged the farm" for Danilo Gallinari? Because when in reality, we traded Gallo for the greatest Knicks talent since Patrick Ewing himself (key word being 'since').

Mortgaged the farm during the trade for Melo? Funny, because the last time I checked the Knicks are currently 16-5, 11 games above .500 and first place of the Eastern Conference (with Carmelo Anthomy). The Nuggets on the other hand are 11-11, .500 and only 8th place of the Western Conference (without Carmelo Anthony). It seems to me as if Denver was the only who mortgaged their farm and/or future once they traded Carmelo Anthony and/or once Melo forced his way out of Denver (for the Knicks).

knickstorrents wrote:To me it was another example of a dysfunctional organization mortgaging its future on a player that was only interested in his own payday.
Please explain. I just broke down our trade for you pretty much piece by piece. Now please expian (with in-depth detail) how the Knicks "mortgaged its future during the trade for Melo". Seems to me as if we're on the rise while Denver is on the decline (dating back to the trade).

knickstorrents wrote:The upside to that whole trade were the players we got for 'free'. Kidd, Chandler, Rasheed Wallace, JR Smith (though I hate JR Smith as a player he has his uses). Without those players this team is at a dead end, just like the organization that runs it.

You're wrong as wrong could be. A.) We don't land Tyson Chandler (during a trade) without using our amnesty clause on Chauncey Billups. We landed Billups during the Melo trade, you do know that... Right? Without the Melo trade, there is no Tyson Chandler.

You're also wrong in regards to J.R Smith. J.R Smith and Carmelo Anthony were teammates in Denver for many of years. J.R Smith came here to win alongisde of Carmelo Anthony. If J.R Smith (himself) never believed in Melo the player/person? He would have A.) never came to New York to begin with (as a free agent) and B.) Never extended for cheap during this past offseason. Kidd came to New York to win another championship, but this time alongside of Carmelo Anthony. A future HOF veteran such as Kidd (a ring chaser) doesn't come here to New York unless he believes in Melo's ability to lead.

It's also funny how you consider this team a "dead end" just like the "Organization that runs it" after talking up the likes of J.R Smith, Kidd, Wallace and Chandler. You do know which organization A.) Signed Kidd, J.R Smith and Wallace as free agents and B.) traded for Chandler... Right? Now you sound like a hypocritical hypocrite.

That was fun, but now I'm done with you. Your post had too much fail in it, and as a sports fan I enjoyed tackling it before breaking it down.

Silverfuel
Posts: 31750
Alba Posts: 3
Joined: 6/27/2002
Member: #268
USA
12/12/2012  6:33 AM
I think Jason Kidd is the x-factor but Melo is definitely the Knicks MVP. He had 62% FG and scored 45 points. Kidd made a clutch 3 but we wouldn't need that clutch 3 if Melo hadn't scored the points.
A journey of a thousand miles begins with a single step.
Not Melo, not Stout but Jason Kidd healthy is easily MVP of 2012/13 NY Knickerbockers period !

©2001-2025 ultimateknicks.comm All rights reserved. About Us.
This site is not affiliated with the NY Knicks or the National Basketball Association in any way.
You may visit the official NY Knicks web site by clicking here.

All times (GMT-05:00) Eastern Time.

Terms of Use and Privacy Policy