crzymdups wrote:

nyk4ever wrote:

crzymdups wrote:

nyk4ever wrote:the jeter comparison is crap because jeter would have played in the playoffs at "85%" when lin didnt.

the only person who told you lin was 85% is frank isola. some reporters have agendas, just so you know.

really dude? gonna get testy? well thanks for the memo letting me know reporters have agendas. i'll have to keep that in mind from now on.

sorry, dealing with a lot of testiness. didn't mean to be out of line.

but seriously. the report we heard was "sources say Lin was 85% but didn't want to risk injuring himself going into free agency."

we also heard melo say "don't play jeremy. don't risk it."

i think it's funny that fans hold Lin resting torn meniscus in his knee as a grudge... but not many people bring up that Amar'e has had self-inflicted stupid injuries to kill any playoffs chances two years in a row.

it's alright bro - i figured as much. we usually agree on most things and it's not that i disagree with you about this, i'm just not going to lose sleep over it. i want lin back, i think having him makes us a better team, but i'm honestly just not sold on him. yes, he's 24 and hasn't even begun to enter his prime years yet and yes he played absolutely astonishingly during that 2wk stretch and it was the most fun i've had as a knick fan in the past 10 years. with all that said, i'm still not sold on what kind of basketball player he really is. i didn't see a whole lot that made me think he can put up the same numbers in a half-court offense like the knicks are going to employ and he did have some issues defensively last year and it seems to me like we are going to be employing a much more defensive system this year.

i like lin, i like his story and i like his heart. i will be happy if we bring him back but i also just can't overlook that the fact that he is a very smart kid (which is obvious based on his background) and that if he REALLY REALLY REALLY wanted to make sure that it was a slam-dunk that he came back to the knicks, he wouldn't have signed that re-negotiated deal with houston. i know the knicks were offering less money, (same amount guaranteed just over 1 extra year) but for a kid whose family is already rich (i think i read that) then coming back to NY should have been a priority instead of a couple million dollars. he is the one that signed that offer-sheet with houston, so i do think he is at fault here too.

whatever the case - like i said, i hope we match, but i'm not gonna be pissed if we don't.

nyk4ever wrote:

crzymdups wrote:

nyk4ever wrote:

crzymdups wrote:

nyk4ever wrote:the jeter comparison is crap because jeter would have played in the playoffs at "85%" when lin didnt.

the only person who told you lin was 85% is frank isola. some reporters have agendas, just so you know.

really dude? gonna get testy? well thanks for the memo letting me know reporters have agendas. i'll have to keep that in mind from now on.

sorry, dealing with a lot of testiness. didn't mean to be out of line.

but seriously. the report we heard was "sources say Lin was 85% but didn't want to risk injuring himself going into free agency."

we also heard melo say "don't play jeremy. don't risk it."

i think it's funny that fans hold Lin resting torn meniscus in his knee as a grudge... but not many people bring up that Amar'e has had self-inflicted stupid injuries to kill any playoffs chances two years in a row.

it's alright bro - i figured as much. we usually agree on most things and it's not that i disagree with you about this, i'm just not going to lose sleep over it. i want lin back, i think having him makes us a better team, but i'm honestly just not sold on him. yes, he's 24 and hasn't even begun to enter his prime years yet and yes he played absolutely astonishingly during that 2wk stretch and it was the most fun i've had as a knick fan in the past 10 years. with all that said, i'm still not sold on what kind of basketball player he really is. i didn't see a whole lot that made me think he can put up the same numbers in a half-court offense like the knicks are going to employ and he did have some issues defensively last year and it seems to me like we are going to be employing a much more defensive system this year.

i like lin, i like his story and i like his heart. i will be happy if we bring him back but i also just can't overlook that the fact that he is a very smart kid (which is obvious based on his background) and that if he REALLY REALLY REALLY wanted to make sure that it was a slam-dunk that he came back to the knicks, he wouldn't have signed that re-negotiated deal with houston. i know the knicks were offering less money, (same amount guaranteed just over 1 extra year) but for a kid whose family is already rich (i think i read that) then coming back to NY should have been a priority instead of a couple million dollars. he is the one that signed that offer-sheet with houston, so i do think he is at fault here too.

whatever the case - like i said, i hope we match, but i'm not gonna be pissed if we don't.

Well put.

nyk4ever wrote:

crzymdups wrote:

nyk4ever wrote:

crzymdups wrote:

nyk4ever wrote:the jeter comparison is crap because jeter would have played in the playoffs at "85%" when lin didnt.

the only person who told you lin was 85% is frank isola. some reporters have agendas, just so you know.

really dude? gonna get testy? well thanks for the memo letting me know reporters have agendas. i'll have to keep that in mind from now on.

sorry, dealing with a lot of testiness. didn't mean to be out of line.

but seriously. the report we heard was "sources say Lin was 85% but didn't want to risk injuring himself going into free agency."

we also heard melo say "don't play jeremy. don't risk it."

i think it's funny that fans hold Lin resting torn meniscus in his knee as a grudge... but not many people bring up that Amar'e has had self-inflicted stupid injuries to kill any playoffs chances two years in a row.

it's alright bro - i figured as much. we usually agree on most things and it's not that i disagree with you about this, i'm just not going to lose sleep over it. i want lin back, i think having him makes us a better team, but i'm honestly just not sold on him. yes, he's 24 and hasn't even begun to enter his prime years yet and yes he played absolutely astonishingly during that 2wk stretch and it was the most fun i've had as a knick fan in the past 10 years. with all that said, i'm still not sold on what kind of basketball player he really is. i didn't see a whole lot that made me think he can put up the same numbers in a half-court offense like the knicks are going to employ and he did have some issues defensively last year and it seems to me like we are going to be employing a much more defensive system this year.

i like lin, i like his story and i like his heart. i will be happy if we bring him back but i also just can't overlook that the fact that he is a very smart kid (which is obvious based on his background) and that if he REALLY REALLY REALLY wanted to make sure that it was a slam-dunk that he came back to the knicks, he wouldn't have signed that re-negotiated deal with houston. i know the knicks were offering less money, (same amount guaranteed just over 1 extra year) but for a kid whose family is already rich (i think i read that) then coming back to NY should have been a priority instead of a couple million dollars. he is the one that signed that offer-sheet with houston, so i do think he is at fault here too.

whatever the case - like i said, i hope we match, but i'm not gonna be pissed if we don't.

Holy crap a rational discussion without name calling and extremisim!

BasketballJones wrote:

GodSaveTheKnicks wrote:

nyk4ever wrote:

crzymdups wrote:

nyk4ever wrote:

crzymdups wrote:

nyk4ever wrote:the jeter comparison is crap because jeter would have played in the playoffs at "85%" when lin didnt.

the only person who told you lin was 85% is frank isola. some reporters have agendas, just so you know.

really dude? gonna get testy? well thanks for the memo letting me know reporters have agendas. i'll have to keep that in mind from now on.

sorry, dealing with a lot of testiness. didn't mean to be out of line.

but seriously. the report we heard was "sources say Lin was 85% but didn't want to risk injuring himself going into free agency."

we also heard melo say "don't play jeremy. don't risk it."

i think it's funny that fans hold Lin resting torn meniscus in his knee as a grudge... but not many people bring up that Amar'e has had self-inflicted stupid injuries to kill any playoffs chances two years in a row.

it's alright bro - i figured as much. we usually agree on most things and it's not that i disagree with you about this, i'm just not going to lose sleep over it. i want lin back, i think having him makes us a better team, but i'm honestly just not sold on him. yes, he's 24 and hasn't even begun to enter his prime years yet and yes he played absolutely astonishingly during that 2wk stretch and it was the most fun i've had as a knick fan in the past 10 years. with all that said, i'm still not sold on what kind of basketball player he really is. i didn't see a whole lot that made me think he can put up the same numbers in a half-court offense like the knicks are going to employ and he did have some issues defensively last year and it seems to me like we are going to be employing a much more defensive system this year.

i like lin, i like his story and i like his heart. i will be happy if we bring him back but i also just can't overlook that the fact that he is a very smart kid (which is obvious based on his background) and that if he REALLY REALLY REALLY wanted to make sure that it was a slam-dunk that he came back to the knicks, he wouldn't have signed that re-negotiated deal with houston. i know the knicks were offering less money, (same amount guaranteed just over 1 extra year) but for a kid whose family is already rich (i think i read that) then coming back to NY should have been a priority instead of a couple million dollars. he is the one that signed that offer-sheet with houston, so i do think he is at fault here too.

whatever the case - like i said, i hope we match, but i'm not gonna be pissed if we don't.

Holy crap a rational discussion without name calling and extremisim!

Bonn will be back from his lunch break soon.

LOL!!!!

crzymdups wrote:

s3231 wrote:Best article I've read so far on this debacle:

http://espn.go.com/new-york/nba/story/_/id/8168735/ian-oconnor-new-york-knicks-match-houston-rockets-offer-jeremy-lin

The Knicks are making this personal, and letting their emotions shape a decision that should be made at room temperature. There's no good reason to believe that Lin, a better player than Felton last year, won't be a better player than Felton next year and beyond.

This is why I'm done with this team (until Dolan sells) if they don't match on Jeremy. It's a personal decision and this doesn't make sense from a basketball or financial perspective.

same boat.

Right now, I'm operating on the theory that even a blind squirrel finds a nut. I don't know long I can hold out.

BasketballJones wrote:

GodSaveTheKnicks wrote:

nyk4ever wrote:

crzymdups wrote:

nyk4ever wrote:

crzymdups wrote:

nyk4ever wrote:the jeter comparison is crap because jeter would have played in the playoffs at "85%" when lin didnt.

the only person who told you lin was 85% is frank isola. some reporters have agendas, just so you know.

really dude? gonna get testy? well thanks for the memo letting me know reporters have agendas. i'll have to keep that in mind from now on.

sorry, dealing with a lot of testiness. didn't mean to be out of line.

but seriously. the report we heard was "sources say Lin was 85% but didn't want to risk injuring himself going into free agency."

we also heard melo say "don't play jeremy. don't risk it."

i think it's funny that fans hold Lin resting torn meniscus in his knee as a grudge... but not many people bring up that Amar'e has had self-inflicted stupid injuries to kill any playoffs chances two years in a row.

it's alright bro - i figured as much. we usually agree on most things and it's not that i disagree with you about this, i'm just not going to lose sleep over it. i want lin back, i think having him makes us a better team, but i'm honestly just not sold on him. yes, he's 24 and hasn't even begun to enter his prime years yet and yes he played absolutely astonishingly during that 2wk stretch and it was the most fun i've had as a knick fan in the past 10 years. with all that said, i'm still not sold on what kind of basketball player he really is. i didn't see a whole lot that made me think he can put up the same numbers in a half-court offense like the knicks are going to employ and he did have some issues defensively last year and it seems to me like we are going to be employing a much more defensive system this year.

i like lin, i like his story and i like his heart. i will be happy if we bring him back but i also just can't overlook that the fact that he is a very smart kid (which is obvious based on his background) and that if he REALLY REALLY REALLY wanted to make sure that it was a slam-dunk that he came back to the knicks, he wouldn't have signed that re-negotiated deal with houston. i know the knicks were offering less money, (same amount guaranteed just over 1 extra year) but for a kid whose family is already rich (i think i read that) then coming back to NY should have been a priority instead of a couple million dollars. he is the one that signed that offer-sheet with houston, so i do think he is at fault here too.

whatever the case - like i said, i hope we match, but i'm not gonna be pissed if we don't.

Holy crap a rational discussion without name calling and extremisim!

Bonn will be back from his lunch break soon.