islesfan
Posts: 9999
Alba Posts: 37
Joined: 7/19/2004
Member: #712
|
Posted by TMS:
an interesting development w/the Teixeira signing as reported on Olney's blog today:
Losers: The Brewers. Part of their rationale in making the blockbuster trade for Sabathia was that, at season's end, they could recoup the value of the lefty, in part, by receiving a first-round draft pick from the team that signed him. Well, because Teixeira ranks higher than Sabathia in the Elias rankings, then it is the Angels -- and not the Brewers -- who get the Yankees' first round pick. The Brewers, rather, will get the Yankees' second round pick, an enormous disappointment for Milwaukee.
Doug Melvin, the Brewers' general manager, believes the draft compensation system needs to be revamped, as he explained in an e-mail this morning:
"The Angels had a better record than us and the Blue Jays, and the Brewers and the Blue Jays got shoved down the food chain. The Elias rankings have never been changed, and there are so many smart statistical gurus -- Bill James, etc. -- that could create a fair model for both players and teams, who should be compensated fairly according to the value of each player to that team. Last year, Geoff Jenkins, who had a nice career with us and was arguably one of our better players, was not even ranked last year, and Tony Graffanino, a part-time player, was ranked. We have dropped 46 slots in the 2009 draft, and we will be dropping even more because there are so many compensation picks. The second round will be almost the third round, in the way that it will develop."
"The Yankees will lose some draft picks, but they can draft unsignable players in fourth and fifth rounds, and pay over-slot, as they did with Andrew Brackman (the Yankees' No. 1 pick in 2007).
"The Draft Elias rankings and compensation needs to be changed. I do not want to sound like I'm whining, but teams who have to build with draft picks get frustrated. I had interest in Juan Cruz, and because I thought we had extra first-round picks for CC and for Ben Sheets, I had considered a Type A signing. Now I have to reconsider."
"We will keep having fun with scouting and player development, and finding our role players. Brian [Cashman] has to do what his owners and market asks him to do." Joel Sherman made an interesting point that it was between signing Texeira this year or Holliday next year in a very weak free agent year. By signing Texeira now, they fill a greater need, with a better player and they don't lose another first rd pick next year, assuming they don't sign a top A free agent.
If it didn’t work in Phoenix with Nash and Stoutamire... it’s just not a winning formula. It’s an entertaining formula, but not a winning one. - Derek Harper talking about D'Antoni's System
|