Listen, you don't need me telling you why people like Lee, we have a 4 page thread right here, all you need to do is consider the merits people offer without degrading their arguments with racial innuendo.
I don't believe stating that Lee is somewhat overrated because of a non-basketball reason is degrading the argument. The question is whether he is better than Randolph, and the answer should be obvious.
I think Balkman is generally as well liked and respected as Lee, but, he's had one less year to show his stuff and been more injured. Oh, and Bips thread was supposed to be absurd, to point out the absurdity of assuming fans love Lee's contributions because of his color when they love Balkman's similar attributes just as well, in spite of their difference in color.
Balkman as well liked as Lee? I think that is an exaggeration. If I had never seen Lee play and just read this board, I would think Lee was Chris Mullin!
You're right though, Balkman hasn't been able to show his stuff, Lee has been stealing his time.

I don't want to gloss over the "Great White Hope" theory, but nor should it be overstated. For, instance I think you'll find a similar occurrence among blacks concerning black managers - they want to see Isisha nd others succeed in order to break the glass ceiling to pave the way to more and more black managers and owners in sports. I respect that, and if someone were to say to, say, misterearl after Isiah is fired "I'm sorry earl, I know you had high hopes for Isiah as a black manager and I feel for your disappointment," I'd honor and respect that.
I think the disconnect here is the difference between "high hopes" and just straight up overrating people. If everyone was saying Herman Edwards was as good as Bill Parcells, that would be similar to what we have going on with Lee.
But consider that in contrast to a hypothetical with that guy Cossellout, who put together a seriously minded defense of Isiah. If in a discussion with Cosellout someone suggested he must be black because only a black would defend Isiah I would consider that disrespectful of the diligent effort he put in.
I think you have changed the focus. Nobody is saying: "The only reason people like Lee is because he is white."
I and some others do notice that Lee is a little overrated around these parts, and we are hypothesizing that perhaps he is regarded more highly by some of those he resembles racially, than he might be otherwise.
Is it possible Lee's color is an additional attribute for some whites? Sure, what do I know, why not. Hell, as awful as it is for me to acknowledge, there are probably whites who'd sooner drag a black man behind a truck than welcome him as a neighbor, - just like there are some blacks who'd sooner stab and mug a white man than give him directions out of the projects - but I wouldn't use poster's feelings about Lee and Zach to try to determine who they are.
I really think the point you make above is far and away beyond what I am describing: Brazilians having a particularly high opinion of Brazilian players, Africans thinking an African player is a little better than he might be, Blacks rooting for Black coaches to break down that door, or White Folks getting a little over-excited about a white player who plays hard, dunks with authority, and rebounds great.
This is natural, and not a bad thing.
By the way, I like seeing white guys dunk. The NBA has been missing that for a while. I think it makes things more interesting.
P.S. Black on Black crime is a much worse problem than Black on White crime.
oohah
[Edited by - oohah on 18-11-2007 12:33 AM]