ohhah, don't think I don't have a response to your reply above. But unlike many, I don't just come with hollow rhetoric, like "If we played uptempo everything would have been fine" or "any other coach could have done better." I come with evidence and substance and I just don't have the time yet to put it all together..
But these beatwritters and broadcasters are around these guys a lot and know a hell of a lot more than we do. Things don't need to be chisled into tablets to have meaning, sometimes a mountain of hearsay which doesn't get refuted becomes telling enough. For instance you don't see guys on this board dissecting articles with razor precision to defend
rumored malcontents like Patterson and Miles during Portland's league worst season, but for brooklyn's finest unless Dolan declares "Marbury is Cancer" he'll get every benefit of the doubt.
Then when guys like KT, TT, Q, Steven A, Isiah, and Brown do evidence it typically their credibilities will be attacked.
It's amazing to me that fans could witness our franchise worst plummet that coincided exactly with his "I'm the best" proclamation, and all the rancor, turmoil and defiance of this year, and still not see it clear as day, whether it was carved in stone or not.
Allow me to import one of my efforts from another board regarding the situation last year ('04-'05):
------
BBALLER4FR wrote:
-= original quote snipped =-
What was IT? You have yet to explain it. Did the team not like Steph proclaiming he was the best and quit on him because of it? Did Steph throw it out there and proceed intentionally prove himself wrong....for the remainder of his career? It's just seems like one of those "Unsolved Mysteries" people are expected to buy into.
Here's my take on it.
We were a fragile team to begin with. Recall we started with our worst home opener in franchise history (against Boston). We gave up the most points in a half in team history. Wilkens was on the hotseat even with a .500 record. Shandon was being tweaked around by Isiah. Marbury was the guy who said we'd never win with Ward, one of our team leaders. Marbury shat on Wilkens when he coached Steph's defensive deficiencies. Marbury was giving speaches about self sacrifice only to stay behind for a massage while the rest scrimmaged. Wilkens had his long time friend and only self-chosen assistant fired out from under him. Reports surfaced that Steph got KVH traded, etc, etc, etc... We were on shaky emotional ground without a lot of love in the locker room.
We had a winning record (16-13.) We had won the 3 games prior to Steph's comments. He had the GM and the city in his pocket. He was feeling Brash. He was asked who's the best PG in the NY metro area and without a shred of humility or diplomacy he answered with this:
"Don't get me wrong -- I love Jason Kidd. He's a great point guard," Marbury said. "(But) how am I comparing myself to him when I think I'm the best point guard to play basketball? That doesn't make any sense. I mean, how can I sit here and compare myself to somebody if I already think I'm the best?
"I'm telling you what it is: I know I'm the best point guard in the NBA. I don't need anybody else to tell me that. When I go on the basketball court, if I think about what you're all saying, I'll lose my mind."
"He's just like me," Marbury said of Kidd at yesterday's morning shootaround before the Nets beat the Knicks, 93-87. "He's a loser. We're both losers. Neither of us have won a championship. Tim Duncan is a winner. Kevin Garnett is a loser just like me. Charles Barkley is a loser just like me. [TNT partner] Kenny Smith is a winner.
"Magic [Johnson], Michael Jordan, [Larry] Bird, those guys are winners. Kobe [Bryant] and Shaquille [O'Neal] are winners. Isiah Thomas is a winner. Until you win championships, we're just like everyone else. It doesn't matter how far you get in the playoffs. It doesn't matter if you get to the Finals. You lost."
Marbury didn't back down from his New Year's boast that he considers himself the "best point guard in basketball."
"I'm just saying reality and answered a question," Marbury said. "I already know I'm the best point guard. It's like asking if it's raining outside. You're going to tell them it's raining."
Now I'm sorry, but when a team doesn't particularly care for your style of play to begin with (remember Kurt and TT saying they were happy to go play with PGs who share the ball, and who didn't glare at teammates, and who didn't turn locker rooms into funeral parlors) and you start spouting off like that it can rub people the wrong way. And a club as fragile as ours can't have a bunch of guys out there with diverse agendas and contempt in their hearts.
Here were Brian Scalabrini's thoughts on the matter:
WFAN interview:
Carlin: A couple of weeks ago Stephon Marbury makes the comment that he feels like he's the best point guard in the league. When the Nets hear something like that, and you have Jason Kidd on the team, are their any raised eyebrows going around?
Scalabrine: OK here's the difference. When Steph makes that comment, I dont know, I mean I'm not in the locker room, but I don't know if the Knicks have his back. But when Steph makes that comment about Jason, we were like "we are not losing this game against the Knicks, we can't let this happen." We have Jason's back and Jason has our back. And I think you know Steph is a very good player, you know he's very talented. But you know I'd run through a wall for Jason and Jason would run through a wall for us. That pretty much shows that he's the best point guard. When you have a guy like that and you'll do anything for him and he'll do anything for you that pretty much sums up the best point guard ever.
Consequently from a 3 game win streak and a 16-13 record, we turned, on the exact day of those comments (Jan 1, 2005), into a 2-15 skid that was THE WORST MONTH IN FRANCHISE HISTORY. With a 9 game losing streak to follow later in the next month.
here's a telling snippet from the time:
Sweetney Shows N.Y. How to Play Nice With Others
By Greg Sandoval
Washington Post Staff Writer
Monday, March 7, 2005; Page D01
Against a chaotic backdrop of locker-room squabbles, coaching changes and roster shuffles, New York Knicks forward Michael Sweetney can boast three triumphs.
First, Sweetney is one of three holdovers, along with Kurt Thomas and Allan Houston, from the Knicks' opening day roster last season. Secondly, the former Georgetown standout and all-American at Oxon Hill High in Prince George's County says proudly, "I have not gotten into one fight or argument with anyone on the team."
A peaceful coexistence with teammates and two years of longevity are what pass for accomplishments these days for the Knicks (25-34), who host the Wizards tomorrow night. The turmoil within the New York franchise has begun to create rifts. One yearlong feud boiled over in January when Marbury and Thomas nearly came to blows following a game against Cleveland, according to the New York Daily News.
Swap out Sweets for frye, and kurt for Q, and one might think they were talking about this year, no?
Here's another:
But trading Thomas simply to placate Marbury and not getting equal value in return could prove disastrous. The Knicks still are licking their wounds from including Dikembe Mutombo in the Jamal Crawford deal last summer and then giving Shandon Anderson a $19 million buyout one week into the season. Both players could have given the Knicks two things they clearly lack: defense and leadership. Those transactions seemed to have more to do with personality conflicts than basketball as Isiah Thomas, the Knicks president, had a famous falling out with both players. And in a recently published book about Sebastian Telfair called "The Jump", the father of the rookie point guard recounts a conversation he had with Marbury in which Marbury takes credit for getting Keith Van Horn traded. Kurt Thomas is one of just 11 players in the league averaging a double-double. He can play two positions and is the team's best low-post defender. "You don't win without guys like that," Herb Williams said
You don't win without guys like that...
See, all of the business with chemistry that gets dumped on Brown was already present last year and then we took a step backwards in terms of defense, rebounding and leadership by losing Sweets, Nazr and Kurt.
Here's another:
And on this night, [kurt] Thomas cracked up Stoudemire by telling the Suns forward something he'd been pondering for weeks: "I can't stand playing with Stephon Marbury."
Of course, all NBA players want to win - an overwhelming drive to succeed is one difference between good athletes and those who are among the best in the world. But Marbury has never understood that he can't get by on talent alone, that there are concessions and sacrifices superstars have to make to lift their teams. That became apparent the moment Marbury stepped into the Knicks' locker room: Hours after greeting his new team and before playing his first game, Marbury was shocking his teammates by blasting music from his cubicle. It wasn't the crude rap lyrics that stunned the players; it was the idea that music - a definite no-no during the Pat Riley and Jeff Van Gundy years unless a player was wearing headphones - was filling the space.
It didn't help that Marbury already had one strike against him with many of his new teammates: They weren't happy about remarks he made about Charlie Ward years earlier.
Marbury had told reporters in 1998 that the Knicks would never win a championship with Ward as their point guard, and his prediction proved to be accurate. But Ward was a key contributor when the Knicks reached the '99 Finals, and he was a popular figure in the locker room, respected for his toughness and leadership. That fact that Ward was shipped to Phoenix as part of the deal that brought Marbury to the Garden only inflamed tensions.
Still, Marbury was the key player in Isiah Thomas' first major transaction at the Garden, and the Knicks' president wasted no time in handing the keys to the franchise to his new point guard. Whenever Marbury was unhappy, he went straight upstairs to complain to Thomas. It was an arrangement that created division in the locker room. Many of Marbury's teammates felt he hadn't earned the right to be treated like Tim Duncan, Shaquille O'Neal or Kobe Bryant.
Some of Marbury's teammates also were outraged by what they saw as the guard's double standard. At a team meeting last season, as rumors swirled that Wilkens was on the verge of being fired, the coach spoke to his team, telling them to concentrate on playing basketball and not worry about outside distractions.
When Wilkens was finished speaking, Marbury repeated most of the coach's message to the team, using profanity to puncuate his words and get his point across. When he was finished, the Knicks took the floor for practice with one exception: Marbury remained in the locker room for a massage.
And lastly:
February 9, 2005
Marbury led a fourth-quarter comeback and scored 36 points for the Knicks, who lost for the 17th time in their past 20 games.
Isiah Thomas even tried to put a positive spin on the Knicks' chemistry issues, including a recent heated argument on the bench between Marbury and Kurt Thomas...
"Those are positive things, because our guys are getting sick and tired of losing, and frustration is setting in," Isiah Thomas said. "At some point in time, those 12 men in the locker room have to bond."
Have to bond? And if they don't? And if it carries over into the next season, then what? And if similar scenarios followed a certain "best player" at too many of his stops, what should one think?
If you have a team that plays woeful defense and has no chemistry and is posting franchise worst efforts left and right across a season which ended in a sputtering tailspin, and then subtract from that almost all of the defenders, all the leaders, and the only guy who can shoot, what would happen? Were would we be?
-------
More to come later, if I can find some time.