Posted by VDesai:
Neither Boldin or Edwards will demand the package that was given up for Roy Williams. Dallas was out of their mind there.
I like Boldin quite a bit better than Edwards, but I have reason to believe Edwards is the Giants no.1 target and I think he has one or two things working in his favor- youth and potentially durability. Boldin took some really bad hits last year and there might be some concern there. Also the money may work out to be the same but the cost in terms of picks may be slightly less for Edwards. I also think Miami is going to be hot after Boldin and the competition may drive up the price the Giants would pay.
The man had his face welded back together and was back on the field in like two weeks (or something).
I wouldn't have paid what Dallas paid for Williams but I don't think they overpaid. The way I look at the deal, Williams was had in season for a first rounder that turned out to be #20, and a pick that could have decreased in value if Williams improved the club the way Jones thought. Williams is not a worse "prospect" (he's young) than anyone outside of Crabtree. I'll weigh the first and Williams as a wash. Meaning the Cowboys paid a third round premium on Williams. Maybe you can argue that wasn't worth it, but I won't--even though the price paid was steep.
As for Boldin, I can't see Boldin getting dealt for less than what Williams was had for, unless he's become such an ******* that it's in the best interest for Cards to move forward without him... in which case, I don't want him.
A 2 and 5 for Edwards is essentially an injured Shockey for Edwards. Okay. I can see that. A 2 for Tony Gozalez is like Jason Taylor for Gonzalez. Could see that. I can't see Boldin being traded for any of those players. Jay Cutler wasn't technically worth what the Bears paid, but that's what you pay in a trade for franchise level talent. Just like Eli technically wasn't worth the price paid, but no one seems to be complaining (now)
And, yes, I consider Boldin a franchise level talent. I would pay a first, plus a reasonable premium. I think swapping our second for a 3/4 is a reasonable premium that's needed to entice the Cardinals to make the deal.