[ IMAGES: Images ON turn off | ACCOUNT: User Status is LOCKED why? ]

Game: NYK visit JuJu, DiVo (and dem Wolves) 12/23 8pm (on MSG)
Author Thread
martin
Posts: 78084
Alba Posts: 108
Joined: 7/24/2001
Member: #2
USA
12/24/2025  10:52 AM
Ian did the mailbag thing

When will Shamet and McBride get reevaluated again?

I think we’ll have an update on Landry Shamet by the end of the month. At the time of the shoulder injury, there was a strong belief/optimism that Shamet could avoid surgery. I believe that is still the case. Shamet continues to rehab the injury but hasn’t needed a surgical procedure. That’s a good sign for a Knick team that leaned on Shamet before he got hurt.

With regards to Miles McBride, he has been working vigorously on the court with Knicks coaches. I don’t know if he is fully sprinting yet, but he has been cleared for contact; he just hasn’t had the chance to take contact in a scrimmage setting because the Knicks haven’t practiced (NBA teams rarely practice during the heart of the regular season). But based on the available information, I would guess that McBride is back before the end of the calendar year.

Official sponsor of the PURE KNICKS LOVE Program
AUTOADVERT
Nalod
Posts: 71672
Alba Posts: 155
Joined: 12/24/2003
Member: #508
USA
12/24/2025  1:31 PM
Philc1 wrote:
martin wrote:Sounds right

Rumor is Minnesota wants Deuce in return for DDV. Deuce is a better player. Not a disrespect to DDV more of a compliment to Deuce.

About an 8Million differenc in salary. Who else was included in that "rumor"?

Clean
Posts: 30420
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 8/22/2004
Member: #743
12/24/2025  1:52 PM

I mean, it is the truth.
LivingLegend
Posts: 26157
Alba Posts: 2
Joined: 8/13/2007
Member: #1645

12/24/2025  2:48 PM
ToddTT wrote:This guy must have listened to Gus Johnson growing up.

These guys - particularly former T-Wolves PF/C Jim Peterson were killing Kat for boneheaded plays.

Used to listen when Kat was on Wolves and Peterson didn’t hold back then either.

Basically acknowledged his offensive greatness but we’re laughing at his dumb push off fouls and whining for calls like they’d seen them 1,000 times before.

Rarely does a guy go for 40 & 13 and in only 24 shots yet leave you feeling disappointed with just dumb stuff.

LivingLegend
Posts: 26157
Alba Posts: 2
Joined: 8/13/2007
Member: #1645

12/24/2025  2:51 PM    LAST EDITED: 12/24/2025  2:54 PM
martin wrote:
LivingLegend wrote:
martin wrote:
LivingLegend wrote:
martin wrote:Need Deuce to get loose again

Would you do Yalu/Deuce for T Eason (assuming #s work)?

Eason gives us long versatile wing defender off bench (only 25) and we still have Mikal/Clarkson/Shamet to fill lost Deuce minutes/shot-making.

Eason’s not perfect…..injuries, high turnovers but along with D, some scoring he’s a good offensive rebounder.

I don't know Eason well enough. Is he a 6'8 version of Deuce? Meaning, McBride is a sure-fire, every day playoff rotation player. Zero doubts and he steps up big time.

I don't now if that is Eason but that's what the Knicks would need in return or probably more cause Eason gets extended this summer and wants $25+M

Deuce definitely more reliable jump shooter and in knowing his role on this team. After that advantage may shift to Eason especially on a Knick team that needs legit wing size/defense.

Hard to get good read on Eason 1 because just back from abdominal injury and in Houston offense everyone basically stands around watching KD/Sengun go at it.

Watched Eason guard Harden 1 v 1 at foul line last night - blocked the shot and threw down breakaway dunk but Harden got best of Rockets. One play but an example of how disruptive he can be.

Contract situation is tricky - I guess for both players.

I'll start off by saying I like the idea of an Eason type on the Knicks, and then follow it up with mentioning I haven't watched him much as well.

Eason is nearly as injury prone as Mitch. He wants $25M and I don't know what to make of that for a non starter who hasn't proven anything. Knicks would start from scratch with his contract negotiations as opposed to knowing and being able to talk to Deuce and his extension expectation for years.

The Knicks also need a POA guard defender as much as what Eason brings. Theoretically, Mo may do the things that Eason already does.

Eason is not a proven spacer, 37% shooter from 3 but also a below average FT% shooter. Not a good combo for the type of player that will really strive at shooting long term.

Bird in hand theory also applies here between both. Practice habits, team cohesiveness, locker room vibes, etc. Those things count on a deep playoff team. FO already knows Deuce.

I don't know how FO's look at player trades but those are some of things they would consider?

Tend to agree — while interesting and I’d be intrigued if we landed him he does seem like a high error player with only a semi-reliable jumper ( add in injury concerns and contract situation).

Not sure if Knicks could work that into their favor though - could they sign and trade him in summer if he’s restricted free agent - if they decide to let him walk?

LivingLegend
Posts: 26157
Alba Posts: 2
Joined: 8/13/2007
Member: #1645

12/24/2025  2:53 PM
Clean wrote:
I mean, it is the truth.

Complete FUGAZY in my mind / view.

I know many loved Julius and he’s super talented but haven’t missed him a lick even with Kat dumb stuff.

BlueKnickers
Posts: 20198
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 12/13/2025
Member: #11677

12/24/2025  4:11 PM
LivingLegend wrote:
BlueKnickers wrote:
LivingLegend wrote:
BlueKnickers wrote:My coaching critique is Brown should have done everything he could to feature Bridges on offense. Kolek and Bridges have good chemistry together and they should have been running screens and play action all night to free up Bridges as the # 1 option. Minny is not good at defending Bridges when he gets a good set-up. Missed opportunity.

Use KAT as a decoy now.

Sorry but Mikal could not do much of anything against pressure. He could barely get over screens and continues to fadeaway from contact.

Think he was 0-1 on FTs tonight. Plenty of opportunity but he shied away from the moment.

Mikal is a rhythm player. When he gets going he can carry you for a quarter.

KAT cooled off in the second half and I'd like to have seen an effort to feed Mikal in good scoring position.

You may be right that he didn't step up and it wouldn't have mattered, but we didn't have a true hot hand in the 2nd half. Maybe Clarkson then.

I wonder if Jemison was available. As soon as I saw Yabby Flabby Doo on the floor, I thought "Where's Jemison?"

Clarkson’s been frustrating many nights as he seems lost in space - per his reputation. Expected him to be very aggressive with Jalen out and nothing. Jamison should have got some of Mitch/Huck minutes tonight because both were SOFT.

Martin made good point that Mikal could be fatigued —- need to keep his minutes down.

Another point —- when Hart plays heavy minutes his D and decision making suck. Keep him fresh and keep his minutes around 30 otherwise he turns into sloppy Kat on D and turnovers.


In order of "Rest to stay fresh" are:

OG - Most likely to decompose before your eyes once fatigued
Hart - Goes from "That was an awesome pass Josh" to "WTF Man?!" when tired
Brunson - Superman becomes a mere NBA starter if overplayed
Mikal - Most durable, but his game is best when running laps all over the court to get open. It works beautifully until he's gassed.

Brown is doing a far better job of managing work loads than Thibs, but he still has to learn to what's the right moment to pull them BEFORE they deplete their reserves, not after

Mikal has been scapegoated by NY fans more than he deserves. He's definitely in a more suitable system with Brown now.

BlueKnickers
Posts: 20198
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 12/13/2025
Member: #11677

12/24/2025  4:13 PM
LivingLegend wrote:
martin wrote:
BlueKnickers wrote:Does anyone feel ambivalent about KAT's performance?

His bad decisions tend to sour my ability to enjoy his scoring tonight.

I can never love KAT cause of those things. Really fixable too and nope

SAME.

Brief moments of yeah — way to go Kat followed by Kat you dumb mofo.

and you can bet the FO sees that too and thinks if they can use KAT + Holiday Leftovers to get Giannis it is a done deal

I don't feel like KAT is our core

For me it's the freaking Wildcats + OG. That's your championship core IMO

martin
Posts: 78084
Alba Posts: 108
Joined: 7/24/2001
Member: #2
USA
12/24/2025  4:17 PM
BlueKnickers wrote:
LivingLegend wrote:
martin wrote:
BlueKnickers wrote:Does anyone feel ambivalent about KAT's performance?

His bad decisions tend to sour my ability to enjoy his scoring tonight.

I can never love KAT cause of those things. Really fixable too and nope

SAME.

Brief moments of yeah — way to go Kat followed by Kat you dumb mofo.

and you can bet the FO sees that too and thinks if they can use KAT + Holiday Leftovers to get Giannis it is a done deal

I don't feel like KAT is our core

For me it's the freaking Wildcats + OG. That's your championship core IMO

Yes.

And I agree with your KAT + leftovers. Giannis gotta push it. Push it good, push it real good, push it good, p-push it real good

Official sponsor of the PURE KNICKS LOVE Program
BlueKnickers
Posts: 20198
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 12/13/2025
Member: #11677

12/24/2025  4:21 PM
Clean wrote:
I mean, it is the truth.

I'll take KAT over Randle every time even if I'm not a giant KAT fan.

Moving Randle was a huge relief. Rose was a crafty SOB to pull it off.

Imagine Giannis wants to come to NY and we had to offer the Bucks Randle instead of KAT. They'd hang up on us.

BlueKnickers
Posts: 20198
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 12/13/2025
Member: #11677

12/24/2025  4:26 PM
martin wrote:
BlueKnickers wrote:
LivingLegend wrote:
martin wrote:
BlueKnickers wrote:Does anyone feel ambivalent about KAT's performance?

His bad decisions tend to sour my ability to enjoy his scoring tonight.

I can never love KAT cause of those things. Really fixable too and nope

SAME.

Brief moments of yeah — way to go Kat followed by Kat you dumb mofo.

and you can bet the FO sees that too and thinks if they can use KAT + Holiday Leftovers to get Giannis it is a done deal

I don't feel like KAT is our core

For me it's the freaking Wildcats + OG. That's your championship core IMO

Yes.

And I agree with your KAT + leftovers. Giannis gotta push it. Push it good, push it real good, push it good, p-push it real good

The only person stopping Giannis from being a Knick is Giannis.

If he tries to be too polite about it the talks will dissolve into a pool of tears

But if he pulls a dagger out of his socks and plunges it into Jon Horst's desk and says "You can tell the rest of the league I'm not extending a contract with anyone but Leon Rose, now get it done" then he'll be a Knick and we'll keep our core

LivingLegend
Posts: 26157
Alba Posts: 2
Joined: 8/13/2007
Member: #1645

12/24/2025  6:58 PM
martin wrote:
BlueKnickers wrote:
LivingLegend wrote:
martin wrote:
BlueKnickers wrote:Does anyone feel ambivalent about KAT's performance?

His bad decisions tend to sour my ability to enjoy his scoring tonight.

I can never love KAT cause of those things. Really fixable too and nope

SAME.

Brief moments of yeah — way to go Kat followed by Kat you dumb mofo.

and you can bet the FO sees that too and thinks if they can use KAT + Holiday Leftovers to get Giannis it is a done deal

I don't feel like KAT is our core

For me it's the freaking Wildcats + OG. That's your championship core IMO

Yes.

And I agree with your KAT + leftovers. Giannis gotta push it. Push it good, push it real good, push it good, p-push it real good

I will say I go back and forth on this - in terms of Kat or OG for Giannis.

Kat does all his knucklehead stuff BUT is big time offensive weapon with SKILL and 2nd in NBA in rebounding. Kat has also held up against some really good centers.

OG on the other hand brings the D and physicality BUT he can’t get his own shot, he’s often wildly flopping around to the floor and he doesn’t rebound a lick.

If OG were a cleaner offensive player with some dribble/passing/shot creation this could be a no brainer.

Another positive for Kat is he really doesn’t need to dominate the ball to get his and in a world where we had all 3 of Giannis/Jalen/Kat if one is injured or resting you still have 2 studs leading your offense.

Just wish OG was more fluid and rebounded more.

ramtour420
Posts: 26501
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 3/19/2007
Member: #1388
Russian Federation
12/25/2025  4:25 PM
BlueKnickers wrote:
martin wrote:
BlueKnickers wrote:
LivingLegend wrote:
martin wrote:
BlueKnickers wrote:Does anyone feel ambivalent about KAT's performance?

His bad decisions tend to sour my ability to enjoy his scoring tonight.

I can never love KAT cause of those things. Really fixable too and nope

SAME.

Brief moments of yeah — way to go Kat followed by Kat you dumb mofo.

and you can bet the FO sees that too and thinks if they can use KAT + Holiday Leftovers to get Giannis it is a done deal

I don't feel like KAT is our core

For me it's the freaking Wildcats + OG. That's your championship core IMO

Yes.

And I agree with your KAT + leftovers. Giannis gotta push it. Push it good, push it real good, push it good, p-push it real good

The only person stopping Giannis from being a Knick is Giannis.

If he tries to be too polite about it the talks will dissolve into a pool of tears

But if he pulls a dagger out of his socks and plunges it into Jon Horst's desk and says "You can tell the rest of the league I'm not extending a contract with anyone but Leon Rose, now get it done" then he'll be a Knick and we'll keep our core

This is how legacies are built. The big 3 in Boston, the Heatles

Everything you have ever wanted is on the other side of fear- George Adair
Game: NYK visit JuJu, DiVo (and dem Wolves) 12/23 8pm (on MSG)

©2001-2025 ultimateknicks.comm All rights reserved. About Us.
This site is not affiliated with the NY Knicks or the National Basketball Association in any way.
You may visit the official NY Knicks web site by clicking here.

All times (GMT-05:00) Eastern Time.

Terms of Use and Privacy Policy