[ IMAGES: Images ON turn off | ACCOUNT: User Status is LOCKED why? ]

I dont see any formula for this team to win big for years with Melo
Author Thread
CrushAlot
Posts: 59764
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 7/25/2003
Member: #452
USA
11/3/2015  10:30 PM
dk7th wrote:
CrushAlot wrote:
dk7th wrote:
CrushAlot wrote:
dk7th wrote:
Uptown wrote:
mreinman wrote:Melo is passing more, trying harder on defense, rebounding well. Getting some steals ........

If he could only stop forcing those shots and move the ball even more. DONT FORCE!!!! NEVER!

Barring injury, this guy is still an excellent player he just needs someone to get through to him and give him a mental adjustment. Impossible task? We'll see. I am still hopeful because he already looks like much less of a black hole than last year.

Name an NBA Scorer that NEVER FORCED a shot..EVER?! You are putting unrealistic expectations on Melo and then call him out for not doing it. Scorers force shots! Its what they do...

he averages 4-6 bad shots a game since a knick. the only expectation you can have with that as a given on a nightly basis is underachievement and basically mediocrity. but what it comes down to for me is his lack of mental toughness. fisher called timeout after two melo ill-advise shots that bricked in the 1st quarter. then he used coded language to critique melo in the postgame. this season is shyt or get off the pot for melo. it's about fukkin' time.


Coded language. I am amazed at your ability to know what people are saying when they say something else. We're you cued into the hidden meaning by an 'irresponsible' Herring tweet or did you come up with this one on your own?

you didn't watch the post game interview with fisher.


I had it on. I was half watching and checking twitter to see if Kristaps was ok. I missed the coded language you were able to decode.

if you were half-listening then you missed the coded language.


Glad you got it and shared it. Same with Melo on media day despite the 'irresponsible' tweet from Herring and Melo not saying what you decoded. Maybe instead of post game observation threads you should do a thread on coded messages from post game interviews. I think you could provide valuable information that might otherwise be misinterpreted.
I'm tired,I'm tired, I'm so tired right now......Kristaps Porzingis 1/3/18
AUTOADVERT
mreinman
Posts: 37827
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 7/14/2010
Member: #3189

11/3/2015  10:32 PM
not coded at all. Very clear IMHO. Listen from the 2 to 3 minute mark.

http://www.nba.com/knicks/video/teams/knicks/2015/11/03/dropboxnykfisher220151102msgi2528k1280w.mp4-92473

so here is what phil is thinking ....
dk7th
Posts: 30006
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 5/14/2012
Member: #4228
USA
11/3/2015  10:37 PM    LAST EDITED: 11/5/2015  8:43 AM
CrushAlot wrote:
dk7th wrote:
CrushAlot wrote:
dk7th wrote:
Uptown wrote:
mreinman wrote:Melo is passing more, trying harder on defense, rebounding well. Getting some steals ........

If he could only stop forcing those shots and move the ball even more. DONT FORCE!!!! NEVER!

Barring injury, this guy is still an excellent player he just needs someone to get through to him and give him a mental adjustment. Impossible task? We'll see. I am still hopeful because he already looks like much less of a black hole than last year.

Name an NBA Scorer that NEVER FORCED a shot..EVER?! You are putting unrealistic expectations on Melo and then call him out for not doing it. Scorers force shots! Its what they do...

he averages 4-6 bad shots a game since a knick. the only expectation you can have with that as a given on a nightly basis is underachievement and basically mediocrity. but what it comes down to for me is his lack of mental toughness. fisher called timeout after two melo ill-advise shots that bricked in the 1st quarter. then he used coded language to critique melo in the postgame. this season is shyt or get off the pot for melo. it's about fukkin' time.


Coded language. I am amazed at your ability to know what people are saying when they say something else. We're you cued into the hidden meaning by an 'irresponsible' Herring tweet or did you come up with this one on your own?

you didn't watch the post game interview with fisher.


I had it on. I was half watching and checking twitter to see if Kristaps was ok. I missed the coded language you were able to decode.

http://www.nba.com/knicks/video/teams/knicks/2015/11/03/dropbox_nyk_fisher2_20151102_MSGI_2528k_1280w.mp4-92473

listen carefully at the 2-minute mark on especially the 2:50-3:10 mark. unmistakable.

knicks win 38-43 games in 16-17. rose MUST shoot no more than 14 shots per game, defer to kp6 + melo, and have a usage rate of less than 25%
dk7th
Posts: 30006
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 5/14/2012
Member: #4228
USA
11/3/2015  10:38 PM
CrushAlot wrote:
dk7th wrote:
CrushAlot wrote:
dk7th wrote:
CrushAlot wrote:
dk7th wrote:
Uptown wrote:
mreinman wrote:Melo is passing more, trying harder on defense, rebounding well. Getting some steals ........

If he could only stop forcing those shots and move the ball even more. DONT FORCE!!!! NEVER!

Barring injury, this guy is still an excellent player he just needs someone to get through to him and give him a mental adjustment. Impossible task? We'll see. I am still hopeful because he already looks like much less of a black hole than last year.

Name an NBA Scorer that NEVER FORCED a shot..EVER?! You are putting unrealistic expectations on Melo and then call him out for not doing it. Scorers force shots! Its what they do...

he averages 4-6 bad shots a game since a knick. the only expectation you can have with that as a given on a nightly basis is underachievement and basically mediocrity. but what it comes down to for me is his lack of mental toughness. fisher called timeout after two melo ill-advise shots that bricked in the 1st quarter. then he used coded language to critique melo in the postgame. this season is shyt or get off the pot for melo. it's about fukkin' time.


Coded language. I am amazed at your ability to know what people are saying when they say something else. We're you cued into the hidden meaning by an 'irresponsible' Herring tweet or did you come up with this one on your own?

you didn't watch the post game interview with fisher.


I had it on. I was half watching and checking twitter to see if Kristaps was ok. I missed the coded language you were able to decode.

if you were half-listening then you missed the coded language.


Glad you got it and shared it. Same with Melo on media day despite the 'irresponsible' tweet from Herring and Melo not saying what you decoded. Maybe instead of post game observation threads you should do a thread on coded messages from post game interviews. I think you could provide valuable information that might otherwise be misinterpreted.

nah i am not that charitable with ingrates.

knicks win 38-43 games in 16-17. rose MUST shoot no more than 14 shots per game, defer to kp6 + melo, and have a usage rate of less than 25%
meloshouldgo
Posts: 26565
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 5/3/2014
Member: #5801

11/3/2015  11:11 PM
Melo should go
I cannot teach anybody anything. I can only try to make them think - Socrates
CrushAlot
Posts: 59764
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 7/25/2003
Member: #452
USA
11/3/2015  11:18 PM
dk7th wrote:
CrushAlot wrote:
dk7th wrote:
CrushAlot wrote:
dk7th wrote:
CrushAlot wrote:
dk7th wrote:
Uptown wrote:
mreinman wrote:Melo is passing more, trying harder on defense, rebounding well. Getting some steals ........

If he could only stop forcing those shots and move the ball even more. DONT FORCE!!!! NEVER!

Barring injury, this guy is still an excellent player he just needs someone to get through to him and give him a mental adjustment. Impossible task? We'll see. I am still hopeful because he already looks like much less of a black hole than last year.

Name an NBA Scorer that NEVER FORCED a shot..EVER?! You are putting unrealistic expectations on Melo and then call him out for not doing it. Scorers force shots! Its what they do...

he averages 4-6 bad shots a game since a knick. the only expectation you can have with that as a given on a nightly basis is underachievement and basically mediocrity. but what it comes down to for me is his lack of mental toughness. fisher called timeout after two melo ill-advise shots that bricked in the 1st quarter. then he used coded language to critique melo in the postgame. this season is shyt or get off the pot for melo. it's about fukkin' time.


Coded language. I am amazed at your ability to know what people are saying when they say something else. We're you cued into the hidden meaning by an 'irresponsible' Herring tweet or did you come up with this one on your own?

you didn't watch the post game interview with fisher.


I had it on. I was half watching and checking twitter to see if Kristaps was ok. I missed the coded language you were able to decode.

if you were half-listening then you missed the coded language.


Glad you got it and shared it. Same with Melo on media day despite the 'irresponsible' tweet from Herring and Melo not saying what you decoded. Maybe instead of post game observation threads you should do a thread on coded messages from post game interviews. I think you could provide valuable information that might otherwise be misinterpreted.

nah i am not that charitable with ingrates.

Be sure to drink your ovaltine
I'm tired,I'm tired, I'm so tired right now......Kristaps Porzingis 1/3/18
gunsnewing
Posts: 55076
Alba Posts: 5
Joined: 2/24/2002
Member: #215
USA
11/3/2015  11:27 PM
dk7th wrote:
CrushAlot wrote:
dk7th wrote:
CrushAlot wrote:
dk7th wrote:
Uptown wrote:
mreinman wrote:Melo is passing more, trying harder on defense, rebounding well. Getting some steals ........

If he could only stop forcing those shots and move the ball even more. DONT FORCE!!!! NEVER!

Barring injury, this guy is still an excellent player he just needs someone to get through to him and give him a mental adjustment. Impossible task? We'll see. I am still hopeful because he already looks like much less of a black hole than last year.

Name an NBA Scorer that NEVER FORCED a shot..EVER?! You are putting unrealistic expectations on Melo and then call him out for not doing it. Scorers force shots! Its what they do...

he averages 4-6 bad shots a game since a knick. the only expectation you can have with that as a given on a nightly basis is underachievement and basically mediocrity. but what it comes down to for me is his lack of mental toughness. fisher called timeout after two melo ill-advise shots that bricked in the 1st quarter. then he used coded language to critique melo in the postgame. this season is shyt or get off the pot for melo. it's about fukkin' time.


Coded language. I am amazed at your ability to know what people are saying when they say something else. We're you cued into the hidden meaning by an 'irresponsible' Herring tweet or did you come up with this one on your own?

you didn't watch the post game interview with fisher.


I had it on. I was half watching and checking twitter to see if Kristaps was ok. I missed the coded language you were able to decode.

http://www.nba.com/knicks/video/teams/knicks/2015/11/03/dropbox_nyk_fisher2_20151102_MSGI_2528k_1280w.mp4-92473

listen carefully at the 2-minute mark on especially the 2:50-3:10 mark. unmistakable.

yea lets see how the geniuses spin this one

gunsnewing
Posts: 55076
Alba Posts: 5
Joined: 2/24/2002
Member: #215
USA
11/3/2015  11:28 PM    LAST EDITED: 11/3/2015  11:28 PM
meloshouldgo wrote:Melo should go

I don't know why but this had me LMFAO

mreinman
Posts: 37827
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 7/14/2010
Member: #3189

11/3/2015  11:29 PM
gunsnewing wrote:
dk7th wrote:
CrushAlot wrote:
dk7th wrote:
CrushAlot wrote:
dk7th wrote:
Uptown wrote:
mreinman wrote:Melo is passing more, trying harder on defense, rebounding well. Getting some steals ........

If he could only stop forcing those shots and move the ball even more. DONT FORCE!!!! NEVER!

Barring injury, this guy is still an excellent player he just needs someone to get through to him and give him a mental adjustment. Impossible task? We'll see. I am still hopeful because he already looks like much less of a black hole than last year.

Name an NBA Scorer that NEVER FORCED a shot..EVER?! You are putting unrealistic expectations on Melo and then call him out for not doing it. Scorers force shots! Its what they do...

he averages 4-6 bad shots a game since a knick. the only expectation you can have with that as a given on a nightly basis is underachievement and basically mediocrity. but what it comes down to for me is his lack of mental toughness. fisher called timeout after two melo ill-advise shots that bricked in the 1st quarter. then he used coded language to critique melo in the postgame. this season is shyt or get off the pot for melo. it's about fukkin' time.


Coded language. I am amazed at your ability to know what people are saying when they say something else. We're you cued into the hidden meaning by an 'irresponsible' Herring tweet or did you come up with this one on your own?

you didn't watch the post game interview with fisher.


I had it on. I was half watching and checking twitter to see if Kristaps was ok. I missed the coded language you were able to decode.

http://www.nba.com/knicks/video/teams/knicks/2015/11/03/dropbox_nyk_fisher2_20151102_MSGI_2528k_1280w.mp4-92473

listen carefully at the 2-minute mark on especially the 2:50-3:10 mark. unmistakable.

yea lets see how the geniuses spin this one

have no fear. There is an emergency UK breakout session in full panic mode as we speak

so here is what phil is thinking ....
CrushAlot
Posts: 59764
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 7/25/2003
Member: #452
USA
11/3/2015  11:31 PM
mreinman wrote:
gunsnewing wrote:
dk7th wrote:
CrushAlot wrote:
dk7th wrote:
CrushAlot wrote:
dk7th wrote:
Uptown wrote:
mreinman wrote:Melo is passing more, trying harder on defense, rebounding well. Getting some steals ........

If he could only stop forcing those shots and move the ball even more. DONT FORCE!!!! NEVER!

Barring injury, this guy is still an excellent player he just needs someone to get through to him and give him a mental adjustment. Impossible task? We'll see. I am still hopeful because he already looks like much less of a black hole than last year.

Name an NBA Scorer that NEVER FORCED a shot..EVER?! You are putting unrealistic expectations on Melo and then call him out for not doing it. Scorers force shots! Its what they do...

he averages 4-6 bad shots a game since a knick. the only expectation you can have with that as a given on a nightly basis is underachievement and basically mediocrity. but what it comes down to for me is his lack of mental toughness. fisher called timeout after two melo ill-advise shots that bricked in the 1st quarter. then he used coded language to critique melo in the postgame. this season is shyt or get off the pot for melo. it's about fukkin' time.


Coded language. I am amazed at your ability to know what people are saying when they say something else. We're you cued into the hidden meaning by an 'irresponsible' Herring tweet or did you come up with this one on your own?

you didn't watch the post game interview with fisher.


I had it on. I was half watching and checking twitter to see if Kristaps was ok. I missed the coded language you were able to decode.

http://www.nba.com/knicks/video/teams/knicks/2015/11/03/dropbox_nyk_fisher2_20151102_MSGI_2528k_1280w.mp4-92473

listen carefully at the 2-minute mark on especially the 2:50-3:10 mark. unmistakable.

yea lets see how the geniuses spin this one

have no fear. There is an emergency UK breakout session in full panic mode as we speak


Glad there are geniuses and a decoder on the seen.
I'm tired,I'm tired, I'm so tired right now......Kristaps Porzingis 1/3/18
newyorknewyork
Posts: 30169
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 1/16/2004
Member: #541
11/4/2015  12:06 AM
Melo has been trying harder on defense, and looking to pass a lot more. His stats accross the board are pretty solid and the only thing killing him right now is his fg & 3pt %. But 6.8rebs, 3.5ast, 1.3stls, 1.5 Tos, 7.8ftatt, 90ft% are all good(though I would like at least 1 more ast per game).

Yet even with his horrible fg% he holds a 206 win share per 48(which would be good for #10 in the nba last yr) and is tied for 12th in Win shares at the moment. So he clearly is doing more good then bad despite the forcing up of shots. While I agree with the critique about him forcing shots. Melo is who he is and will resort to habits out of desperation. The answer has always been to bring in a top quality lead guard that we can trust to control these situations. It has been proven (Billups,Kidd, Galloway 1 game ago acting like one).

And threw these 5 yrs, with the one main ingredient which has proven to be successful. With basically every winning team in the league and not just Melo. We haven't gotten consistent contributions from the guard position.

https://vote.nba.com/en Vote for your Knicks.
Nalod
Posts: 71379
Alba Posts: 155
Joined: 12/24/2003
Member: #508
USA
11/4/2015  6:57 AM    LAST EDITED: 11/4/2015  6:58 AM
Melo has played under 3 coaches in 5 seasons.
There was measured success with woodson when a decent team was rostered.
Last year he played mostly hurt with a new coach, new system, new assistants and struggled with the triangle with a roster that was dysfunctional and lacked talent.
This season he physically looks good but is rusty, has 9 new players to get with and they have to learn the triangle and get it instinctive.

For a player, even an 12 year vet all-star to need games to get the groove and 9 others to learn its not really that much a stretch to think it could take a while for Melo to get comfortable.

We talking about first 4 games people.
We talking about .500 after 4 games.

PresIke
Posts: 27671
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 7/26/2001
Member: #33
USA
11/4/2015  7:14 AM
CrushAlot wrote:
yellowboy90 wrote:This is not as bad of game as people make it out to be. He played 35+ minutes and shot the ball 17 times, 2 more than Porzingis who played only 24+ minutes. He only shot the ball twice in the 4th, one on a good look for three after Porzingis passed up an wide open look and the other attempt was when he fell on the Unicorn, he was actually moving the ball when he came back in. For most of the time he in the 4th they barely ran the offense through him. He was not forcing the issue and the team did not force it into him. The problem was that the knicks had a bad stretch of mistakes, a Gallo ill advised pass was sandwich in between 2 TOs by the Unicorn.

What I didn't like was that he was getting stuck on Duncan Screens. Unfortunately everyone on the knicks were getting stuck on Duncan screens. Despite that he still needs to fight harder to get around screens. He also lost Kawai in transition a few times which is bad. I did like his 3rd qtr D late and his D in the 4th. He was diving for loose balls and competing on D. What he has to do is get used to playing hard and shooting well. I'l give him to mid November to assess his play.

I agree. His hip seemed to be getting caught on Duncan on those screens. He is trying to fight through them and did dive on the floor for that loose ball when he had the ridiculous foul called on him. I thought overall there were a lot of positives in regards to the team and how they played in a loss. The Spurs didn't rest anyone tonight on the second night of a back to back and they played tenacious d and were allowed to be very physical. The Knicks are 2-2 and have played hard in every game. I wonder if the Knicks push Afflalo back if KP is out on Wednesday.

We actually look like a team again.

Forum Po Po and #33 for a reason...
Uptown
Posts: 31326
Alba Posts: 3
Joined: 4/1/2008
Member: #1883

11/4/2015  7:57 AM    LAST EDITED: 11/4/2015  8:00 AM
mreinman wrote:
Uptown wrote:
mreinman wrote:
Uptown wrote:
mreinman wrote:Melo is passing more, trying harder on defense, rebounding well. Getting some steals ........

If he could only stop forcing those shots and move the ball even more. DONT FORCE!!!! NEVER!

Barring injury, this guy is still an excellent player he just needs someone to get through to him and give him a mental adjustment. Impossible task? We'll see. I am still hopeful because he already looks like much less of a black hole than last year.

Name an NBA Scorer that NEVER FORCED a shot..EVER?! You are putting unrealistic expectations on Melo and then call him out for not doing it. Scorers force shots! Its what they do...

No its very realistic expectation and I am sure / I hope its phils expectation. Its fans like you who don't demand it from him.

No, its not realistic. I've been playing ball and watching for close to 35 years, coaching for 10. Asking a scorer to never force a shot ever is unrealistic. As a coach, you can demand perfection, if you get close, you've done your job. Scorers score and thats what they do. Jordan has forced shots, Bird forced shots, Dominique, Kobe, Lebron, Steph, Durant, Harden etc...Scorers shoot over 20 shots per. No way is every single one of those 20+ shots every single night is going to be perfect or in the flow. At least 5 of them will be forced. The great ones can some of them...That's reality

what???? what the heck are you talking about? Everyone forces shots!

The term "scorer" in the way that you use it and the way that it was used 10 years ago is no longer applicable or acceptable. You are either efficient and a ball mover or you just a prettier rudy gay.

I know what I'm talking about! In todays game, are you telling me that Durant NEVER, EVER forces a shot?! Are you telling me that LeBron NEVER, EVER forces a shot?! These are you words, not mine. You mentioned nothing of being efficient in the original post that I quoted. You said Melo, should NEVER, EVER force A shot! I'm telling you that all shooters, scorers etc will force several shots per game. ALL of them...Dispute what YOU Said!

mreinman
Posts: 37827
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 7/14/2010
Member: #3189

11/4/2015  9:12 AM
Uptown wrote:
mreinman wrote:
Uptown wrote:
mreinman wrote:
Uptown wrote:
mreinman wrote:Melo is passing more, trying harder on defense, rebounding well. Getting some steals ........

If he could only stop forcing those shots and move the ball even more. DONT FORCE!!!! NEVER!

Barring injury, this guy is still an excellent player he just needs someone to get through to him and give him a mental adjustment. Impossible task? We'll see. I am still hopeful because he already looks like much less of a black hole than last year.

Name an NBA Scorer that NEVER FORCED a shot..EVER?! You are putting unrealistic expectations on Melo and then call him out for not doing it. Scorers force shots! Its what they do...

No its very realistic expectation and I am sure / I hope its phils expectation. Its fans like you who don't demand it from him.

No, its not realistic. I've been playing ball and watching for close to 35 years, coaching for 10. Asking a scorer to never force a shot ever is unrealistic. As a coach, you can demand perfection, if you get close, you've done your job. Scorers score and thats what they do. Jordan has forced shots, Bird forced shots, Dominique, Kobe, Lebron, Steph, Durant, Harden etc...Scorers shoot over 20 shots per. No way is every single one of those 20+ shots every single night is going to be perfect or in the flow. At least 5 of them will be forced. The great ones can some of them...That's reality

what???? what the heck are you talking about? Everyone forces shots!

The term "scorer" in the way that you use it and the way that it was used 10 years ago is no longer applicable or acceptable. You are either efficient and a ball mover or you just a prettier rudy gay.

I know what I'm talking about! In todays game, are you telling me that Durant NEVER, EVER forces a shot?! Are you telling me that LeBron NEVER, EVER forces a shot?! These are you words, not mine. You mentioned nothing of being efficient in the original post that I quoted. You said Melo, should NEVER, EVER force A shot! I'm telling you that all shooters, scorers etc will force several shots per game. ALL of them...Dispute what YOU Said!

uh ... uhkay.

One should never force. That being said I understand that it happens and that even smart players force sometimes.

Melo, please force as many shots as other smart players who are known to take mostly smart shots.

Happy now?

so here is what phil is thinking ....
holfresh
Posts: 38679
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 1/14/2006
Member: #1081

11/4/2015  9:18 AM
mreinman wrote:
Uptown wrote:
mreinman wrote:
Uptown wrote:
mreinman wrote:
Uptown wrote:
mreinman wrote:Melo is passing more, trying harder on defense, rebounding well. Getting some steals ........

If he could only stop forcing those shots and move the ball even more. DONT FORCE!!!! NEVER!

Barring injury, this guy is still an excellent player he just needs someone to get through to him and give him a mental adjustment. Impossible task? We'll see. I am still hopeful because he already looks like much less of a black hole than last year.

Name an NBA Scorer that NEVER FORCED a shot..EVER?! You are putting unrealistic expectations on Melo and then call him out for not doing it. Scorers force shots! Its what they do...

No its very realistic expectation and I am sure / I hope its phils expectation. Its fans like you who don't demand it from him.

No, its not realistic. I've been playing ball and watching for close to 35 years, coaching for 10. Asking a scorer to never force a shot ever is unrealistic. As a coach, you can demand perfection, if you get close, you've done your job. Scorers score and thats what they do. Jordan has forced shots, Bird forced shots, Dominique, Kobe, Lebron, Steph, Durant, Harden etc...Scorers shoot over 20 shots per. No way is every single one of those 20+ shots every single night is going to be perfect or in the flow. At least 5 of them will be forced. The great ones can some of them...That's reality

what???? what the heck are you talking about? Everyone forces shots!

The term "scorer" in the way that you use it and the way that it was used 10 years ago is no longer applicable or acceptable. You are either efficient and a ball mover or you just a prettier rudy gay.

I know what I'm talking about! In todays game, are you telling me that Durant NEVER, EVER forces a shot?! Are you telling me that LeBron NEVER, EVER forces a shot?! These are you words, not mine. You mentioned nothing of being efficient in the original post that I quoted. You said Melo, should NEVER, EVER force A shot! I'm telling you that all shooters, scorers etc will force several shots per game. ALL of them...Dispute what YOU Said!

uh ... uhkay.

One should never force. That being said I understand that it happens and that even smart players force sometimes.

Melo, please force as many shots as other smart players who are known to take mostly smart shots.

Happy now?


U never see Curry force threes?
jrodmc
Posts: 32927
Alba Posts: 50
Joined: 11/24/2004
Member: #805
USA
11/4/2015  10:40 AM
holfresh wrote:
mreinman wrote:
Uptown wrote:
mreinman wrote:
Uptown wrote:
mreinman wrote:
Uptown wrote:
mreinman wrote:Melo is passing more, trying harder on defense, rebounding well. Getting some steals ........

If he could only stop forcing those shots and move the ball even more. DONT FORCE!!!! NEVER!

Barring injury, this guy is still an excellent player he just needs someone to get through to him and give him a mental adjustment. Impossible task? We'll see. I am still hopeful because he already looks like much less of a black hole than last year.

Name an NBA Scorer that NEVER FORCED a shot..EVER?! You are putting unrealistic expectations on Melo and then call him out for not doing it. Scorers force shots! Its what they do...

No its very realistic expectation and I am sure / I hope its phils expectation. Its fans like you who don't demand it from him.

No, its not realistic. I've been playing ball and watching for close to 35 years, coaching for 10. Asking a scorer to never force a shot ever is unrealistic. As a coach, you can demand perfection, if you get close, you've done your job. Scorers score and thats what they do. Jordan has forced shots, Bird forced shots, Dominique, Kobe, Lebron, Steph, Durant, Harden etc...Scorers shoot over 20 shots per. No way is every single one of those 20+ shots every single night is going to be perfect or in the flow. At least 5 of them will be forced. The great ones can some of them...That's reality

what???? what the heck are you talking about? Everyone forces shots!

The term "scorer" in the way that you use it and the way that it was used 10 years ago is no longer applicable or acceptable. You are either efficient and a ball mover or you just a prettier rudy gay.

I know what I'm talking about! In todays game, are you telling me that Durant NEVER, EVER forces a shot?! Are you telling me that LeBron NEVER, EVER forces a shot?! These are you words, not mine. You mentioned nothing of being efficient in the original post that I quoted. You said Melo, should NEVER, EVER force A shot! I'm telling you that all shooters, scorers etc will force several shots per game. ALL of them...Dispute what YOU Said!

uh ... uhkay.

One should never force. That being said I understand that it happens and that even smart players force sometimes.

Melo, please force as many shots as other smart players who are known to take mostly smart shots.

Happy now?


U never see Curry force threes?

No, and you'll also never see:
Paul George take an ill-advised shot.
Lebron not make a teammate better.
Kwami Leonard dog it for one second on either side of the court.
The Spurs collectively ever make a bad decision.
James Harden ever be inefficient.
Anyone play with more talent than Melo has.
Smart people not admit (in secret codes, if need be) that Melo is a LOSER DOUCHE.
Star players not named Melo who don't get obvious calls being called "dinosaur bully ball players".
Jeremy Lin not be able to improve the lot of almost any situation better than Melo would.

jrodmc
Posts: 32927
Alba Posts: 50
Joined: 11/24/2004
Member: #805
USA
11/4/2015  10:43 AM
fishmike wrote:
blkexec wrote:
BRIGGS wrote:
GustavBahler wrote:In the not so distant future, this will be Porzingis's team. When that happens, Melo's role will diminish wether he likes it or not. If the team isn't a legit contender by then, I wouldn't be surprised if Melo waves his no trade clause and tries to go to a contender, can tell fans the team is in good hands.

In the meantime, I expect some growing pains from this team, including Melo. We have the worst starting backcourt in the league right now, thats putting us at a disadvantage from the start. I dont know if the answer is Grant and Galloway, or Grant and Afflalo, but once we get some consistent production from the starting backcourt, Melo should play his role better. My biggest problem with his game is that he makes things much too hard on himself by not using screens.

Porzingis and Grant are showing that the future for this team is bright, some of you might add a few years to your life if you focus on that instead of your very strong feelings about Melo.

Yep there are some pieces here. Hopefully Melo shows off well enough that we can move him for something reasonably valuable for the future that also benefits Melo.

I rather keep melo and move fans like you. I hope you only represent the minority of knick fans. It's really getting old. The only player you would be happy with is Jesus in a tang top. And I bet you would still find something to complain about. I disliked Melos game more than anybody, but you would never know. I appreciate what you bring to this forum. Your view points creates several threads all the time, which is good. But damn man, if melo was that bad then Phil ( who forgot more about basketball than u would ever know) wouldnt have gave him a max contract with a no trade clause.

You better off trying to see how this will work with melo, instead of taking the easy route by pushing the reset button every freaking year. Fans like this is why it's so difficult to find a top player to come here. I'm from NY and I would turn down this team in a second because of groutchy impatient fickle fans. Melo is a knick....get over it and move on. We finally have more good things than bad things to talk about, but yet the hatred keeps over flowing.

spot on. 4 games into a new season with a new roster that is also the first roster this GM can say is his.

I enjoy Briggs posts but he also has no perspective. 5x a year he posts about a guy who can save the franchise after watching him for 8 minutes.

Best case Melo is a finisher for a great team for the next few years. Worst case is he's here to sell some tickets until the next guy is ready as mentioned above.

In any case "lets trade the guy with a no trade clause" threads are a wankfest.


+1 and +1

And don't forget the endless adamant BRIGGS threads about obscure players no one's heard of that would turn this franchise and the league around. Who you wind up never hearing about.

jrodmc
Posts: 32927
Alba Posts: 50
Joined: 11/24/2004
Member: #805
USA
11/4/2015  10:45 AM    LAST EDITED: 11/4/2015  11:49 AM
holfresh wrote:
ChuckBuck wrote:
holfresh wrote:
ChuckBuck wrote:
newyorknewyork wrote:After the Knicks win vs the Wiz, there were no Carmelo Anthony threads after his quality performance. Chuckbuck was nowhere to be seen or heard from. The only person consistent in there critique or praise of Melo is Mreinman.

Melo post up some poor shooting fg%s so far which are all career lows at the moment. He does hold a 206win share per 48 though, and is tied for 12 in the NBA in win shares. He is shooting 7.8ft attempts per game at 90ft%, has only 1.5 Tos per game and 3.5ast. 6.8rebs and 1.3stls. If he upped his FG and 3pt % by finding his stoke, I would take those numbers all day.

I understand the frustration as Melo is frustrating to watch sometimes. Yea the offense got stagnant and Melo tried to take over and put the team on his back the only way he thinks he knows how. We need ball handler that can take that pressure off of him. Grant isn't ready for that, Calderon looks cooked. This is all a process though. Phil has improved the team drastically from last season and may have found a future franchise player, the front courts looks solid. Now the next step is we need to upgrade our guard play.

Hey I let the homers and Melo dik suckers have their 1 (out of 4 games) day in the sun.

No need to piss in the kool aid, if it leads to a Knick win, amirite?

Listen, I am all for the Knicks success. That said, I am a realist at the same time. The way this team is currently constructed is contrarian to what Melo's MO is. Melo's personal goals and team goals are: A)Shoot the rock. B)Win the championship without sacrificing shooting the rock. C)If championship eludes you with the Knicks, be a hired gun for a future team willing to take on your salary.

Knicks are sooooo far from competing for a championship during Melo's remaining tenure, it's safe to see where this is headed. Could be sooner rather than later.

I have to wonder about this phony outrage you have suddenly come to embrace...You remind me a lot of those republican congressman who gets arrested in the bathroom stall of an airport trying to pick up men...The same ones who draft the most anti-gay legislation imaginable...

No need to tell us about your weekend activities holfresh!

No phony outrage. If the $124m man isn't up to snuff, I will call him out. Every. Single. Time.

Big Melo supporter suddenly turn Melo hater over the top extraordinaire in his resurgence...Hmmmmmmmm...tkf and guns are believable, you my friend, not...

tkf...I've never heard a guy who's been gone so long, mentioned so much. Oh wait, shit! I talk about him more than anyone else.

jrodmc
Posts: 32927
Alba Posts: 50
Joined: 11/24/2004
Member: #805
USA
11/4/2015  10:47 AM
mreinman wrote:
gunsnewing wrote:
newyorknewyork wrote:
mreinman wrote:Melo is passing more, trying harder on defense, rebounding well. Getting some steals ........

If he could only stop forcing those shots and move the ball even more. DONT FORCE!!!! NEVER!

Barring injury, this guy is still an excellent player he just needs someone to get through to him and give him a mental adjustment. Impossible task? We'll see. I am still hopeful because he already looks like much less of a black hole than last year.

At this moment, in critical situations, who can we trust as a ball handler to create and make the right reads. Its clearly not Melo's strength on a night in and night out basis. We might need to sink or swim with Grant and let him fail yet learn and grow.

Melo and the Knicks will continue to struggle with ball movement for as long as Calderon is starting. Start Grant. Get the ball in his hands and allow him to make all the decisions. Like a PG should. Get the ball out of Melo's hands. He will be better for it. Melo only knows one way and that is to shot it. Almost 5yrs and we are still complaining about the same exact things

I do see some change but anyway ... queue the excuse mob. Guns you usually get a pass anyway. You are allowed to hate melo for some reason.

guns refuses to use the standard melo hate mostly CAPS screaming posting style. Makes his brand of hate more readable.

I dont see any formula for this team to win big for years with Melo

©2001-2025 ultimateknicks.comm All rights reserved. About Us.
This site is not affiliated with the NY Knicks or the National Basketball Association in any way.
You may visit the official NY Knicks web site by clicking here.

All times (GMT-05:00) Eastern Time.

Terms of Use and Privacy Policy