playa2 wrote:Woodson doesn't run an offense with off the ball movement. Reddick would be useless in NY.

and useless defensively. It's hard enough to get Felton, Kidd, Shump, Tyson, Melo & Amare to switch on defense. Sheed is probably the only one who understands it having down it under Woodson in Detroit

NYKBocker wrote:

knickscity wrote:The Knicks are not stuopid enough to trade Shump for a rental of Redick.

We are talking about an outfit that let go a promising young PG for nothing.

AnubisADL wrote:

3G4G wrote:

AnubisADL wrote:Knicks offense is heavily dependant on Melo. Having another shooter will only help.

I love the idea of adding more offense to the offense...Redick better get behind our Blackholes in Melo/Earl/Amar'e

You do realize Melo has no problem passing to guys who can make shots. A contested shot from Melo is more likely to go in than an open shot from our other players except Novak.

Bonn1997 wrote:Shumpert's perceived value greatly outweighs his actual value. The Knicks need to dump him for a back-court player who can help more. It could be Reddick but doesn't have to be. They just need to find the GM who will pay the most out of a belief in Shumpert's upside.

Finally we see that people are realizing what we have been saying for a long time.

mrKnickShot wrote:

Bonn1997 wrote:Shumpert's perceived value greatly outweighs his actual value. The Knicks need to dump him for a back-court player who can help more. It could be Reddick but doesn't have to be. They just need to find the GM who will pay the most out of a belief in Shumpert's upside.

Finally we see that people are realizing what we have been saying for a long time.

We usually overrate our young talent until we finally find out what the trade will be....then we start back pedaling and crapping on the young player given up.

gunsnewing wrote:

CrushAlot wrote:

NYKBocker wrote:

knickscity wrote:The Knicks are not stuopid enough to trade Shump for a rental of Redick.

We are talking about an outfit that let go a promising young PG for nothing.

He was a restricted free agent that signed a poison pill contract. Knicks couldn't resign him. Lots more stuff out there about the new cba that confirms this. Harden and Gay were moved from teams that were competing for a championship because of the cap. I have seen two articles that have said trade deadline will be quieter because teams are so afraid of taking on a big contract.

Money is nothing to Dolan. Especially when competing with the other team in Brooklyn

Nahhh money is definitely something to Dolan just ask Walsh and Lin

DurzoBlint wrote:

DJMUSIC wrote:Rumor is crazy ny has NO PG trustworthy

Thus can't win title this yr without a PG & DON'T TELL ME FELTON

Thus no trade of shump we don't need to have conversation bout Iman going anywhere

If Woodson is smart move Iman back to bench & Let Kidd shoot his load at PG With limit to minutes
Bring Iman off bench & increase min. As SG

Let Paublo.& Jkidd back up PG Felton ..until Raymond is outta here

to be honest Woodson said Shump was starting to give Kidd a couple of days off. Don't expect to see him starting much unless the matchup is just way too much for Kidd. I'm not sold on Shumps health. Also, I read someone saying he had trimmed down. To me, he looks heavy, especially in the lower body.

Thus let Felton, Kidd Paublo PG play out

Until ny gets real young at PG ny ain't beating Miami now until next yr.

Ny will/must draft Ray McCullum their AI PG OF FUTURE & he will be available in draft
Once ny works him out & other teams pass on him

Our time is next season

knickscity wrote:The Knicks are not stuopid enough to trade Shump for a rental of Redick.

Řight, well said

You don't trade Shump only exception is when IMAN value on market is at highest level
& after ACL his market val is N/A or lower so Ny is scrooed on any return val for Iman

Iman will come back & haunt MSG thus you don't deal this guy cause your rate of return now
Stinks..

Iman stays & we will be pleased later on
Write it

gunsnewing wrote:

CrushAlot wrote:

NYKBocker wrote:

knickscity wrote:The Knicks are not stuopid enough to trade Shump for a rental of Redick.

We are talking about an outfit that let go a promising young PG for nothing.

He was a restricted free agent that signed a poison pill contract. Knicks couldn't resign him. Lots more stuff out there about the new cba that confirms this. Harden and Gay were moved from teams that were competing for a championship because of the cap. I have seen two articles that have said trade deadline will be quieter because teams are so afraid of taking on a big contract.

Money is nothing to Dolan. Especially when competing with the other team in Brooklyn