Posted by jaydh:
Posted by VDesai:
Yanks got a great value. Proctor's not more than an average relief pitcher. Betemit's got a lot of pop, plate discipline and upside potential. Plus he gives the Yanks a backup plan in case something happens with Arod.
Proctor was one of the yanks better relievers, he has just been overused this season. A guy who put up 3.52ERA, with a 1.19 WHIP in over 100 IP last season in the AL is more than just an average pitcher. Again, this seemed like another panic move to get a replacement for Arod. Btw, Texas must be praying Arod opts out.
A 3.52 ERA is ok- but you look around the league and look at most team's primary setup man and that is pretty average to below average. When you consider his inconsistency and the fact that he walks so many batters this year I think its ok to conclude he's average.
Furthermore, he was a crutch for Joe Torre. Every single scenario in every game he went to Proctor. And why? Was he a shutdown reliever? No. The guy is a nice 3rd or 4th part of a bullpen, but Torre overused him here.
This wasn't a panic move at all- I don't know how you can see trading a 30+ year old, heavily used reliever for a 27 yr old infielder with upside a panic move. It was a long range outlook move and a value move. The fact that he can be used as a hedge against A-Rod is a bonus, but there's still a lot of long range potential with Betemit. He was one of the highest rated prospects in the Atlanta org.- considered another Chipper Jones type for a while. He hasn't panned out quite as predicted, but at the same time he's got a solid OPS of over .800 and a lot of pop. He's had about 19 home runs 330 at bats for the Dodgers.