by "true colors" i mean that they underachieved last year, but we have no real idea how much. the debate is, do we have a team of underacheiving losers, or was it larry's fault? i see no reason this year should be effected by last year. whatever their record is, that is what our team is now. if we win 33 games, IT has assembled an expensive lottery team of losers. if we win 40, we have a borderline playoff team with some youth not yet at their potential that got screwed last season. no excuses.
does that make more sense?
Hmmm, what you say makes absolute sense and it does not contradict what I am saying either.
And let's not forget the original question you asked me: "
oohah- so, if we win somewhere in the mid-30's, then does that mean that IT has actually assembled a cast of losers and should be gone?"
This team is pretty much in the exact same spot they were last year. (This is really the only relevance LB has and why we can use his job as a standard.) They are not improved except slightly on paper with JJ2 and Balkman. They do not know each other on the court the way they should, they still need to establish an identity, who the real leaders are, etc... I don't know if you would consider this to be "effected by last year" or not.
All it means is we should not be expecting miracles just because LB has been ejected and IT is standing in his spot. It will take time. This team will have to learn to play together and they will probably take some lumps along the way.
That is why I am looking for a quite reasonable 37-41. Just like I was last year. I hold IT and LB to the same standard. Other guys seem eager to see "Marsiah" fail and have projected "higher minimum wins for satisfaction" based on what "Should have happened last year". This is absurd. We cannot build on something that never happened. They cannot build on a non-existant result.
What should have happened last year is what better happen this year: The Knicks should be reasonably competitive, contend for a playoff spot and hopefully make the playoffs. But if It wins just 37, he has shown what I would have expected last year, and I will be satisfied, though not happy.
I think that is fair and reasonable, don't you?
oohah
[Edited by - oohah on 08-18-2006 4:36 PM]