ChuckBuck wrote:Nalod wrote:Silverfuel wrote:Wow, just read a page of posts where NardDogNation is schooling posters. Walsh definitely hurt the Knicks. That Amare contract is going to kill the next 2 years.
Really think Walsh was the driver to bring in Amare? You really think this is a signiture Walsh move? With everything you know about Dolan, the starphuch manifest, and impatience that this is the kind of contract he would build his legacy on to return to new york and bring a championship?
Everyone entitled to his opinion.
Yes. He(Walsh) even stated as so, back in 2010 that he was going to sign 1 maybe 2 free agents with the cap space HE freed up for the Knicks the last few years. He said Lebron was one Plan A, then he said he Plan B etc.
Plan A) Lebron B)Wade C)Bosh or Boozer D)Nowitzki E)Kobe F)Joe Johnson etc....Z)Amare Stoudemire
All his contingency plans fell through the sewer as everyone shafted the Knicks...Walsh signed STAT in desperation to save face.
Lets be clear, the record speaks for itself so Im not here to defend the legacy, just my interpretation.
I am forever thinking that an owner is the ultimate driver of a team. Nobody signs a 100million player with the health issues and insurance issues without the owners blessing. There are countless owners who are involved in many phases of decisions and I would have to say that the one constant thru the Jimmy era is the starphuch.
Ultimately the job of a president or GM is to take the hit for owner becuase the brand identity has to continue when a change is made. We celebrated Layden departure, Isiah's arrival, his departure, Donnie, and all the coach's over the years because we love our team. When the owner becomes the defacto face of the franchise there is a bigger problem because he won't go away so fast. Cube has made a positive impact and he has his trophy, as did Al Davis of the Raiders, but when it goes bad its hard to wipe the image away unless you hire people around you and fade away.
LIke Steinbrenner did. After a great run in the late 70's George had pissed off Reggie, made the whole Winfield debacle a mess and when he stepped away and let baseball people run things they became a modern dynasty!
Dolan is awful and he won't put his face on the franchise which is a good thing, but that does not mean he does not have big imput thru the organization.
NY and the Knicks have to take a big approach to be successful. Knicks have to compete with other entertainment to attract the $. There are 3 NHL teams, another NBA team, Two NFL teams, Two MLB teams, and minor league baseball and pro soccer. Indy has the Colts and the Pacers. Portand has the Blazers. OKC is also a one team city.
Back to Walsh and the job he did, my take is if you look at the way the Pacers were constructed over the many years there were few where they were bad. Even Isiah as the coach was a regular season success. Walsh's teams were tough and home grown and while no championships, in teh same time frame we did not win either.
So the real question is "who to blame" becomes the real focus? Since Checketts was let go we as fans love to blame the coach's (a long list) and Grunfeld, Layden, Isiah, Donnie and in time Grunfeld will get his. The one constant has been the owner. Dolan made the presentation to Lebron, Dolan was the one who finished the Melo trade when Walsh was resisting the price. Im going to guess Dolan had his hand in Amare. Donnie is long gone.
I started this thread not to rub in the face the knicks were going down but the view that Donnie/Bird have had a long vision and system to which their teams are built. Even bringing in Vogel, the youngest NBA coach and one without the star power is much different than what the knicks do. Woodson was not a starphuch but MDA and to me was a solid addition. The kind of non star moves we should be making!
With Hill's concussion its a sudden turn that gives a glimmer of hope that maybe we can turn this around and in the end the knicks will prevail and Walsh won't have the laugh.
Walsh was at the helm when we signed Amare so if you want to pin it on him I guess its fair game. He has proven to be an organizational kind of guy who never said a bad word about the team or Dolan. He played the MSG game as it is written.
A guy like that I defend because he returned order to the team and paved the way for what we have now. Love my knicks but don't love this roster. That don't make me a hater, its just my take.
I am discouraged the knicks fiscal health is not consistant with what hard core fans want.