3G4G wrote:tkf wrote:nixluva wrote:Knick fans still can't get past the loser mentality. Doom and Gloom is still the order of the day. We've got to look at the team as it is today and not as they used to be. This team is stronger everywhere. Woody as able to get great results with a flawed team last year, why be pessimistic when he has a FAR better team now? IMO Boston had a hard time beating the broke down and out of sync Knicks, but this is a new team. I think the Knicks will surpass them this time. We won't be seeing a 1st rd exit this year.
it is a new team that was put together the same way that led to 12 years of losing... why should anyone not be a bit skeptical..
Yeah Melo was no better ranked a player than Marbury when we acquired him. Nixluva has been on on the usual must spin positivity because if I don't don't do it then who will schtik. He's also waiting for his payday of it finally paying off and being right after misjudging this team being wrong year after year after year after year after year after year. This is the other "FAN BORROWING TIME" formula.
While we put together a mix of offense and defense, we still didn't put together a correct mix of offense and defense. We still STARGFUDGED, we still are on a "LOVERS & FRIENDS"...."EARN STRIPES" kick, we still throw away assets like they don't matter, we still bloat payroll, and a lot of the same corny stuff is going on too....
For example....
Remember the off-season Curry hired a personal trainer out of Detroit to lose weight? I believe he was consulting with WWW on what it would take to turn his career around. Fans were hopping on this big time. They said Curry would be "MOTIVATED". He needed to play well to get "ANOTHER PAYDAY". He's going to get down to his CHICAGO PLAYING WEIGHT and be the NEXT BEST BIG TO D-12. Sound familiar folks? Nixluva was big upping this crap to no end. Guess what, it's the same with Amar'e spending 2weeks with Hakeem trying to re-invent himself. Listen if all it took was 2 weeks to work with Hakeem to be special ummmmmmm this would be a Big Man's game and not a Little Man's game. No Amar'e is not a Curry level of player(Curry's best year with us was 19.5ppg and 7.5reb lest we forget) but the point, players don't get motivated after a decade in the league and morph into something they've never been. This isn't like some near career ending injury a great player had to face and adjust forcing a change in his game. No these are players who have been either stubborn/lazy/too prideful in their approach and style of play only to have failed results.....now are searching for feeble options, hoping they work.
I'm not saying Amar'e completely wasted his time working out with Hakeem but Amar'e should have been working out with someone like Charles Oakley instead for several weeks not Hakeem. There was nothing Hakeem was showing him that was revolutionary, not one thing. OTOH seeing a player like Javele McGee work with Hakeem who is 24yrs old 5th year in the league this makes sense, because of the raw skills he possesses. He needs more of a solid base of skills to work with.
Here's another example....
Remember Marbury wouldn't welcome Duhon to the team the same way Melo wasn't feeling a return of Lin? We have the same kind of wild/selfish/jerkish/needy/must be coddled athletes. Looking below at all these players we have now and the others when at their best as Knicks
The high personality ego mistaken, misunderstood, bad guys, or their own brand not necessarily more talented
For example
Melo=Marbury(flat out jerks... Starbury shoes and Melo 5s.....family and friends getting gigs and whatnot)
Smith=Nate(immature wannabes)
Amar'e=Curry(good dudes but distracted when they aren't the focal point)
Sheed=No Sharrington(volatile, too passionate)
Yes we do have good guys on this team just like we had a few yrs back and not necessarily more talented
For example
Chandler=Lee(play hard, play within themselves, good teammates)
Felton=Duhon(play hard, full of flaws, limited)
Shumpert=Jamal(very talented, good dudes likeable, coachable, helter skelter)
Pablo=Sergio(Nuff Said)
Ronnie Brewer=Effries(very good defense and a hella liability offensively)
Camby=Frye(solid bigs who balances the team in many different ways)
Novak=Sean Williams(dead eye shooters if open one just sips less lean)
Kurt Thomas=Malik Rose( )
James White=Jonathan Bender(one had better knees)
Chris Copeland=Bill Walker(DREADFUL)
Chris Smith=Anthony Roberson(why were they ever Knicks)
Jason Kidd=Lin(uuuuuhhhhh Nope Melo likes Kidd) Jason Kid=Toney Douglas(Nope because Toney Douglas had a stretch where he was being compared to Chauncy Billups) Jason Kidd=Chauncy Billups(yes if Toney Douglas was inaccurately assessed as Chauncy Billups) Jason Kidd=Steve Francis(Washed & Liquored Up.... we may have a winner here)
Notice what we don't have on this team? No Gallo/Chandler/Mozgov not 1 player adequately suits their persona or what they brought to this team. NOT ONE
Not sure I agree with any aspect of your analysis. Its like you took every single current Knick player at their worst, every rumor as fact and poor logic to create terrible comparisons (try this one... Marbury drives a truck, Melo drives a truck --- Marbury is Melo?).
Amare is Curry cause they are "good guys" but distracted without the ball? I think the criticism on Amare is that he tries to do too much and the criticism on Eddy was that he tries to eat too much. C'mon. Amare working on his low block post moves isn't nearly as important as becoming a spot shooter from 15 feet, but Amare will be primary in the offense once Melo is off the floor. I see a guy that was working in the offseason to get better?
Camby = Frye? A seasoned vet who is rated the most efficient rebounder (given his limited minutes) is the same as an outside in player?
Copeland is Walker? I would have guessed that White is more like Walker...
Kidd = every other historical PG for the Knicks, even though he is a legit Hall of Famer that has taken a leadership role?
Kurt Thomas is Malik Rose? Cause they are both black? Malik never has a jump shot. Thomas does. Thomas is like 10 years older then any time that Malik played for us. Malik was an undersized bulldog who brought defensive prowess not not necessarily toughness.
Pablo = Sergio cause they both have Spanish names?
Felton = Duhon cause they both play PG?
Chandler = Lee cause they are both big? You do realize that Chandler won the Defensive Player of the Year, right? Avi Lee could not do that. Chandler also had the highest fg% in the league (limited shots though)
Shump = Crawford? Again, what? If there is any "Crawford" on this team, its more likely to be Smith, given both player's proclivity to take bad shots. AND since Smith got here, what trouble has he really gotten into?
James White = Jon Bender -- again, a SG who developed overseas is the same as a 6'10 player who tried to make a comeback with the Knicks?
Brewer = Jeffries cause they both play defense? Brewer is a perimeter defender that is playing here for minimum dollars. Jeffries signed for the full MLE.
How about these -- Novak = Gallo cause they both 6'10 and shoot 3s? Is that a fair comparison? I don't think so, but it follows the stupid logic. In any event, I assume you meant Shawne (Extra E) Williams in your comparison. Actually, here, I miss Shawne, notwithstanding his history, in NY he was stellar and played hard D. You could see his talent trying to shake through.
Ty Chandler = what Mozgov would hope to be in his wildest dreams.
Seriously. I'll agree the starting lineup doesn't complement each other very well. But these comparisons are forced at best and contrived at worst. This team looks pretty decent on paper and is the best set of talent to start the season that we have had in over a decade. I think this team could seriously be the top rated defensive team in the league. No joke. That's what I am hoping for. If Melo and Stat play D, like everyone else on the roster, this team is legit. It has to happen on the court, but why not look forward to that?