Author | Thread |
AUTOADVERT |
SupremeCommander
Posts: 34057 Alba Posts: 35 Joined: 4/28/2006 Member: #1127 |
![]() This is my plan Q
DLeethal wrote:
Lol Rick needs a safe space
|
scoshin
Posts: 20584 Alba Posts: 0 Joined: 1/23/2004 Member: #568 |
![]() martin wrote:scoshin wrote:martin wrote:TMS wrote:loweyecue wrote:After tree million threads on it, I still don't get all the negativity aimed at Melo. He is a bad defender (except when he wants to be good) and may not be the best character guy but he does what he does better than ANYBODY in the league RIGHT NOW. Now we cant give up three starters for him because then we wont have a team to put on the floor, but he should remain our primary target. Uhh, it does work salary wise? http://www.realgm.com/src_checktrade.php?tradeid=5783567 And I actually agree, Ridnour + a late 1st seems a bit of a stretch for just AR, but I got that proposed trade from a Minny fan. It'd probably be more balanced if we included GS' 2012 2nd or give them both AR and TD (and redirect Mason's expiring to Denver), but the deal essentially allows Minny to get out of Ridnour's 4-year contract obligation (with Rubio coming next year), while also getting Randolph, a player they reportedly coveted back when he was with the Warriors. Still, you're arguing that we won't have flexibility after a Melo trade, but that's hardly the case. We'd actually have more flexibility than if we sign Melo this summer. As long as we keep 2 out of Gallo, Chandler, or Fields, we still have the trade chips and depth to round out the team. You make it sound like we're gutting our team like Miami did to acquire Melo. We'd have the MLE next summer, possible S&T with Chandler (or we can choose to keep him), and whatever veterans flock to us for the minimum. |
martin
Posts: 76268 Alba Posts: 108 Joined: 7/24/2001 Member: #2 USA |
![]() TMS wrote:martin wrote:TMS wrote:martin wrote:TMS wrote:loweyecue wrote:After tree million threads on it, I still don't get all the negativity aimed at Melo. He is a bad defender (except when he wants to be good) and may not be the best character guy but he does what he does better than ANYBODY in the league RIGHT NOW. Now we cant give up three starters for him because then we wont have a team to put on the floor, but he should remain our primary target. Jared Dudley has like a 5 year contract. Same with Collison. Goran Dragic is on rookie contract and has QO and PHO is keeping that kid. Matt Barnes is going to split the MLE to leave the Lakers and come to the Knicks? Big Z and Mario Chalmers gonna leave MIA to come to the Knicks? I guess thanks for keeping things realistic. The main point of my whole thread was to create a Plan B that didn't involve Melo. If you think you can build a team with Melo, show me. This is not fantasy land where you can just list 20 dudes and say they are all options on a team, that's not what Donnie is dealing with. It's not that hard to go down a list of salaries and check it out and add up the numbers. You are building a team that can't be put together and you haven't taken a minute to even try to show us that it could be done. Here is where I am getting my salaries from: http://hoopshype.com/salaries/new_york.htm I guess I just think it's fairly impossible to build a team up after you trade away assets and cap out after getting Melo. I could be wrong, but can anyone show me a realistic scenario? I gave salaries to Nene and an explanation as to why I think he would take it. I tried to put together a realistic trade for Ridnour. I showed a bench, a backup PG, a starting 5 and then qualified that the team would be deep playoff but that one of Fields/Chandler/Gallo would have to step up game more to get to championship. Are you or anyone up to the challenge of putting a realistic team up with semi reasonable trades and salaries? Otherwise you keep posting the same list of nonsense. Official sponsor of the PURE KNICKS LOVE Program
|
martin
Posts: 76268 Alba Posts: 108 Joined: 7/24/2001 Member: #2 USA |
![]() scoshin wrote:martin wrote:scoshin wrote:martin wrote:TMS wrote:loweyecue wrote:After tree million threads on it, I still don't get all the negativity aimed at Melo. He is a bad defender (except when he wants to be good) and may not be the best character guy but he does what he does better than ANYBODY in the league RIGHT NOW. Now we cant give up three starters for him because then we wont have a team to put on the floor, but he should remain our primary target. sorry, should have been more specific. I was looking at Camby when thinking about the "doesn't work salary wise" comment. Also, do you really think Donnie/MDA takes back Harrington after last year? I say HELL NO. MDA HATED him, and as much as Donnie liked the dude, I don't think he would bring him back. I could be wrong on that. Also, I am looking at the trade, mostly the DEN-NY part. I think that Gallo/Curry/AR for Melo is a borderline reasonable trade. All of a sudden, you are adding in TD and dead weight Azubuike and getting back Melo/Harrington/Ridnour. So, value for value (while disregarding salary for a moment), TD+Azu = Harrington+Ridnour? That's doesn't seem realistic, doesn't pass the trade smell test, does it? Official sponsor of the PURE KNICKS LOVE Program
|
TMS
Posts: 60684 Alba Posts: 617 Joined: 5/11/2004 Member: #674 USA |
![]() martin wrote:TMS wrote:martin wrote:TMS wrote:martin wrote:TMS wrote:loweyecue wrote:After tree million threads on it, I still don't get all the negativity aimed at Melo. He is a bad defender (except when he wants to be good) and may not be the best character guy but he does what he does better than ANYBODY in the league RIGHT NOW. Now we cant give up three starters for him because then we wont have a team to put on the floor, but he should remain our primary target. i based my list off the list of FA's on ESPN.com... if Dudley & Collison were already signed to a contract extension, fine take him off the list... who the F cares? you're still left with like 30 other options i just gave you... i've already stepped up to your challenge & answered it with a list of many different options that we can possibly target w/our exceptions this summer... i took the time to look up & list all these names for you & you're telling me i haven't taken any effort in trying to answer your question... cherry picking a few that no longer qualify & calling my list nonsense just because you don't have a legitimate answer to why the rest of these options aren't suitable to fill bench roles on this team doesn't make it so...there are a ton of other ways to fill bench roles on this team than to target guys like Nene & Mikael Pietrus & take yourself totally out of the running at any chance at Melo or any other star player for that matter. & again, putting some ridiculous arbitrary dollar figure next to their names is pointless... i think most of the names on that list can be signed to the MLE or less... use some common sense, that means you can put anywhere from ~$5.5M or less on a contract offer in their 1st year of that contract... do u really need me to put that dollar figure down next to each of their names for you to understand this? After 7 years & 40K+ posts, banned by martin for calling Nalod a 'moron'. Awesome.
|
martin
Posts: 76268 Alba Posts: 108 Joined: 7/24/2001 Member: #2 USA |
![]() TMS wrote:martin wrote:TMS wrote:martin wrote:TMS wrote:martin wrote:TMS wrote:loweyecue wrote:After tree million threads on it, I still don't get all the negativity aimed at Melo. He is a bad defender (except when he wants to be good) and may not be the best character guy but he does what he does better than ANYBODY in the league RIGHT NOW. Now we cant give up three starters for him because then we wont have a team to put on the floor, but he should remain our primary target. yes. and list out your starting 5 and bench. Official sponsor of the PURE KNICKS LOVE Program
|