Posted by MS:
I just think that he tries to play his hand to much. Mobley's contract may prove to be useful, but taking the 2nd round pick and not taking up roster spots in the zach deal was the right play. As was moving jefferies at the deadline with Nate if you're not going to resign him.
I do think not moving Jefferies with Nate for Kenny Thomas - if that was the deal - was not a good move in the long run. But I don't know you can say that getting Mobely+TT is better than recieving a 2nd round pick IF that was the deal. The Knicks needed outside shooting, they needed someone at the SG position after Crawford left, they needed veteran leadership, and they got all and a player in Tim Thomas who knew the MDA system.
Posted by MS:
If we needed a point guard so badly, I don't know why we just didn't draft one, same goes for a two guard last year or this year.
The Knicks also needed bigs this year, and I am guessing if any of the PGs drafted before Hill fell, we would have had a new future starting PG. And really, you wanted to draft an undersized guard 2-guard last year? I guess Eric was #2 on Donnie's list behind Gallo at #6, but I still feel Gallo has better upside.
Posted by MS:
So far this offseason Walsh has only played into the fact that no one want to play here. Kidd was a nice idea but at the end of the day what is really the difference between giving him the full mid level at his age and sessions.
Take your blinder off dude, Donnie has a crap team with a very limited salary cap. You expect a rush of players?
Posted by MS:
He is ****ing around with Grant Hill, Jason Williams, Tinsly. A number of players that really don't make sense.
I take it that you would rather have Donnie taking more naps instead of looking for any player that could plug a hole for a year? If those players were healthy and in shape, all of them would make sense on 1 year deals. Tell me why they wouldn't...
Just not impressed with the guys he has brought in so far. At the end of the day the moves he made apparently weren't all that tough to pull of since Crawford and Zach were moved. Three players he passed on after Gallo look like future all stars. He thought Roberson was a better fit than Wafer, traded for Larry Hughes for some reason, didn't pull the trigger to shed 7 million of the cap and then is going to sign the player he wanted to keep to a one year deal. I would like to see some sort of plan. If we lose Lee, Jordan Hill is not going to pick up the slack, and without Lebron we are in the lottery for the third season in a row under Donnie.
His job isn't easy, but right now he isn't doing anything of merrit.
Rant, rant, rant.... So far I do think that Nate/Jefferies deal was a swing and miss, but both players still could be gone, time has not run out. Otherwise, I don't think anything else you have said really adds up.