Posted by GKFv2:
Please stop making Marbury into some sort of martyr and also blaming his entire past on Isiah Thomas. Isiah Thomas didn't force him to leave his team when he did. That was a selfish act he committed on his own. I'm just talking about once incident though. Marbury is no angel and deserves no respect. I agree that this should have been handled in the summer and Walsh has failed in that regard.
Let me also add that you must stop reading any article/blog associated with Marc Berman, especially when it comes to Marbury. Berman has no sources besides Marbury himself and we all know his love-affair with Dickbury. Berman also is the least reliable beat writer in quite possibly the entire USA. He really has no sources to anything he says regarding "other players around the league." Peter Vescey is more reliable.
[Edited by - gkfv2 on 11-18-2008 3:49 PM]
I have never said he is a martyr. However you cannot ignore the facts here.
*He was asked to come into camp in shape, he did that.
*He has been asked to take a lesser role, he did that.
*He was promised minutes, given them in preseason, praised for how he played and told he was in their plans.
*He has done nothing crazy this entire summer.
*Waltoni said all players get a clean slate.
Now, what has transpired? He's been sat out without explanation other than "he's not in our plans".
They have thus far refused to handle the situation - seemingly happy with trying to sit him out for an entire year.
...none of this is professional and none of this is helpful to the team.
I also did NOT blame his entire past on Isiah Thomas but if you want to ignore the facts of how Marbury's NY career has gone so be it.
*He was brought here to be our top gun.
*Isiah goes out and gets Crawful and makes him top gun asking Marbury to turn into Eric Snow.
*Larry furthers that cause giving Crawful full control of the team asking Marbury to turn into Eric Snow.
*Isiah did the same thing when he took over coaching.
*Isiah and Dolan tried to get over on Marbury with the trial and Marbury sniffed it out and buried them.
*Isiah and Dolan then tried to mistreat Marbury - Isiah with his insane attempt and destroying Marbury's season - the fight on the plane - the sitting out - the eventual decision to "have surgery".
Hey, you can dislike Marbury all you want but this franchise screwed up royally with how they used him and treated him and now the new regime is also dumping on him in an incredibly unprofessional manner.
The facts are there. Choose to acgnowledge them or not that's up to you.
...as to Berman, hey, maybe we should stop reading every piece of news on the Knicks because I've found no one writer is any worse than the other they all make crap up and over dramatize things but if you think everything written on Marbury is fiction regarding the friction the front office has called, the NBAPA getting involved in the matter, Marbury being cast away in an unprofessional matter, and other NBA players and execs taking notice in a negative way, then I guess you've just got a real hate for the guy and don't really care about every little fact.
I mean, that's fine and all, Marbury has been a disaster here and should be gone,
...so...
know what?
GET RID OF HIM.
Why keep him here and cause all these continued problems?
Like it or not when this franchise decided to do that they indeed turned him into a sympathetic figure. They made the mistake, not Marbury, to handle things this way.
Not sure what else to say on this topic so I guess I'll just say anyone who replies to my posts here on out just know I'll just be repeating myself.
As a post earlier in this thread stated "this just keeps going in circles."
Yeah, it does, so I'm done.