[ IMAGES: Images ON turn off | ACCOUNT: User Status is LOCKED why? ]

With all due respect was Dennis Smith Jr always this bad? We need to build this kid back up!
Author Thread
BigDaddyG
Posts: 39877
Alba Posts: 9
Joined: 1/22/2010
Member: #3049

11/13/2019  3:12 PM
Chandler wrote:
Uptown wrote:
HofstraBBall wrote:
BigDaddyG wrote:
HofstraBBall wrote:
NYKBocker wrote:
fishmike wrote:
Vmart wrote:Knicks PGs are playing in a broken system and it is zapping their confidence.
what is our sample size here? Mudiay, Kadeem Allen, Trey Burke, Frank, DSjr... these have been Fizdale's chess pieces. I get that Fizdale sucks, but folks are in for a rude awakening when the next coach comes here and his "system" stinks also.

It can't be any worse than what Fizdale has done.

Nets, Warriors, Pelicans, Wiz, Hawks, Magic, Piston, Bulls, Hawks, Cavs, Hornets, Kings, Trail blazers, Thunder and Grizz fans are probably saying the same thing about their coaches.


Noooo...I've been lurking in Grizzlies boards and most agree that Fiz is a cool guy, but had to go. Brooks also doesn't get the same level of hate with the Wiz. Haven't followed the Hawks, Nets, Magic, or Warriors, but I can guarantee the coaches of those teams don't generate the same level of disgust or scrutiny from their fanbases.

Point was, winning solves everything and losing creates plenty of finger pointing. Easiest target is always the coach.

This!!!!! Most teams in the NBA run the same stuff...Mostly 5-out-open-paint offense for drive and kicks and high pick and rolls. most of the intricate sets will be run out of time outs and the beginning of each period. During the Sac-town game, the Kings didn't run anything special! Fox penetrated at will, collapsed the defense and either finished himself, kicked it out for Heild and dropped it off to their center. We dont have the guard or shooters to play that style consistently. The NBA is a players league but its All Fiz's fault

I honestly don't get the point or logic of your post.

Is it that most fanbases should just chill because they don't have Harden or Giannis or Lebron?

Fans at least have a right to expect that the coach will get the most out of the roster he's given, whether that's win games or develop players

Coaches do matter. Budenholzer inherited a team and added 16 wins (no real player adds last year) Boston lost Kyrie and Horford but they're kicking ass.

We are worse than last year. Last year had a lot of new faces too. Most were rookies or retreads. This year we supposedly have 70MM+ of professionals plus DSJ

Coaches matter and ours sucks, as does our FO.


Exactly. Yes we were in tank mode last year. I'd argue that still isn't an excuse not to establish the building blocks for but others say otherwise, and they have have valid arguments. This year we have a roster of guys who have established a baseline of success in the league. Those guys, for the most part, have taken steps backwards.
Sure, everyone runs the same sets. But there's also things like establishing pace, putting the right players in to make sure those plays are executed as best as possible, making sure the players have a clear understanding of said plays before they enter the game, having a clear understand of who to put in and which players to put in at the end of games, establishing clear roles for players and making sure they understand those roles etc...Fiz has failed in many of those aspects. I hope, for Natasha's sake, that he figures it out.
Always... always remember: Less is less. More is more. More is better and twice as much is good too. Not enough is bad, and too much is never enough except when it's just about right. - The Tick
AUTOADVERT
Uptown
Posts: 31322
Alba Posts: 3
Joined: 4/1/2008
Member: #1883

11/13/2019  8:41 PM
Chandler wrote:
Uptown wrote:
HofstraBBall wrote:
BigDaddyG wrote:
HofstraBBall wrote:
NYKBocker wrote:
fishmike wrote:
Vmart wrote:Knicks PGs are playing in a broken system and it is zapping their confidence.
what is our sample size here? Mudiay, Kadeem Allen, Trey Burke, Frank, DSjr... these have been Fizdale's chess pieces. I get that Fizdale sucks, but folks are in for a rude awakening when the next coach comes here and his "system" stinks also.

It can't be any worse than what Fizdale has done.

Nets, Warriors, Pelicans, Wiz, Hawks, Magic, Piston, Bulls, Hawks, Cavs, Hornets, Kings, Trail blazers, Thunder and Grizz fans are probably saying the same thing about their coaches.


Noooo...I've been lurking in Grizzlies boards and most agree that Fiz is a cool guy, but had to go. Brooks also doesn't get the same level of hate with the Wiz. Haven't followed the Hawks, Nets, Magic, or Warriors, but I can guarantee the coaches of those teams don't generate the same level of disgust or scrutiny from their fanbases.

Point was, winning solves everything and losing creates plenty of finger pointing. Easiest target is always the coach.

This!!!!! Most teams in the NBA run the same stuff...Mostly 5-out-open-paint offense for drive and kicks and high pick and rolls. most of the intricate sets will be run out of time outs and the beginning of each period. During the Sac-town game, the Kings didn't run anything special! Fox penetrated at will, collapsed the defense and either finished himself, kicked it out for Heild and dropped it off to their center. We dont have the guard or shooters to play that style consistently. The NBA is a players league but its All Fiz's fault

I honestly don't get the point or logic of your post.

Is it that most fanbases should just chill because they don't have Harden or Giannis or Lebron?

Fans at least have a right to expect that the coach will get the most out of the roster he's given, whether that's win games or develop players

Coaches do matter. Budenholzer inherited a team and added 16 wins (no real player adds last year) Boston lost Kyrie and Horford but they're kicking ass.

We are worse than last year. Last year had a lot of new faces too. Most were rookies or retreads. This year we supposedly have 70MM+ of professionals plus DSJ

Coaches matter and ours sucks, as does our FO.

You don't get it because you missed the point...

Is it that most fanbases should just chill because they don't have Harden or Giannis or Lebron?

Where did I imply that we should chill and wait for a generational talent I did mention Fox. Fox aint a generational type player, but was the 5th pick in the draft, and is a lead guard that plays down hill which is desperately missing for the moment in our line up at the moment. He's the type of talent that will be available to us if we continue to rebuild and land a top 5 pick.

Rebuilds are ugly. Did you catch any of the Sixers games when they were in rebuild mode for years? Rebuilds include tons of ugly losses, something our idiot owner can't stomach, years of uneven rosters as you purge and evaluate players and try to develop the young ones that will be a part of our future. It's clear, that most Knick fans who claimed they wanted to rebuild for years, cant handle it. The first sign of adversity and people want to fire the coach. Why fire the coach in the middle of a rebuild?

Coaches do matter. Budenholzer inherited a team and added 16 wins (no real player adds last year) Boston lost Kyrie and Horford but they're kicking ass.

I never said coaching didn't matter. Of course it does, the problem is, the anti-Fiz brigade blames him for everything and rarely holds the players accountable. Check this out: In his first 4 years as the head coach of Philly, Brett Brown won 19, 18, 10, and 28 games. He won 52 and 51 games the last two seasons. Did he all of a sudden learn how to coach or was he given better all star level players which leveled the playing field for him to compete? If he were here, he would have been fired in his second season.

Brad Stevens is kicking ass this year but why couldn't the coaching genius figure out how to make it work with Kyrie? Maybe it wasn't a good fit? You say we are worse than last year. How about we let the season play out then re-evaluate.

dwiley20
Posts: 20756
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 2/18/2014
Member: #5755

11/14/2019  8:26 AM
sure is a lot of excuses for this guy!! he is awful no effort on defense, Bad IQ, all the hype about his shot would be better, doesn't make anyone better
newyorknewyork
Posts: 30118
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 1/16/2004
Member: #541
11/14/2019  9:48 AM
Chandler wrote:
Uptown wrote:
HofstraBBall wrote:
BigDaddyG wrote:
HofstraBBall wrote:
NYKBocker wrote:
fishmike wrote:
Vmart wrote:Knicks PGs are playing in a broken system and it is zapping their confidence.
what is our sample size here? Mudiay, Kadeem Allen, Trey Burke, Frank, DSjr... these have been Fizdale's chess pieces. I get that Fizdale sucks, but folks are in for a rude awakening when the next coach comes here and his "system" stinks also.

It can't be any worse than what Fizdale has done.

Nets, Warriors, Pelicans, Wiz, Hawks, Magic, Piston, Bulls, Hawks, Cavs, Hornets, Kings, Trail blazers, Thunder and Grizz fans are probably saying the same thing about their coaches.


Noooo...I've been lurking in Grizzlies boards and most agree that Fiz is a cool guy, but had to go. Brooks also doesn't get the same level of hate with the Wiz. Haven't followed the Hawks, Nets, Magic, or Warriors, but I can guarantee the coaches of those teams don't generate the same level of disgust or scrutiny from their fanbases.

Point was, winning solves everything and losing creates plenty of finger pointing. Easiest target is always the coach.

This!!!!! Most teams in the NBA run the same stuff...Mostly 5-out-open-paint offense for drive and kicks and high pick and rolls. most of the intricate sets will be run out of time outs and the beginning of each period. During the Sac-town game, the Kings didn't run anything special! Fox penetrated at will, collapsed the defense and either finished himself, kicked it out for Heild and dropped it off to their center. We dont have the guard or shooters to play that style consistently. The NBA is a players league but its All Fiz's fault

I honestly don't get the point or logic of your post.

Is it that most fanbases should just chill because they don't have Harden or Giannis or Lebron?

Fans at least have a right to expect that the coach will get the most out of the roster he's given, whether that's win games or develop players

Coaches do matter. Budenholzer inherited a team and added 16 wins (no real player adds last year) Boston lost Kyrie and Horford but they're kicking ass.

We are worse than last year. Last year had a lot of new faces too. Most were rookies or retreads. This year we supposedly have 70MM+ of professionals plus DSJ

Coaches matter and ours sucks, as does our FO.

I agree.

I do want to state that Bud added 16 wins due to fixing the fundamental flaw on the Bucks roster construction which was spacing. They replaced Monroe, Maker, Henson with Lopez and Ilyiasova. This gave Freak the spacing to reach MVP level given what he does best

What I would have complete faith in with Bud is that he wouldn't tolerate Randle driving into triple teams for turnovers. Or Isos from Morris over and over again. We aren't a team that makes the right decision with the ball. The way he tore down Hardaway's game and built it back up to be more efficient is the credibility he comes with.

https://vote.nba.com/en Vote for your Knicks.
HofstraBBall
Posts: 27987
Alba Posts: 1
Joined: 11/21/2015
Member: #6192

11/14/2019  10:53 AM    LAST EDITED: 11/14/2019  11:14 AM
dwiley20 wrote:sure is a lot of excuses for this guy!! he is awful no effort on defense, Bad IQ, all the hype about his shot would be better, doesn't make anyone better

Your right. Lets just get to the game and boo him after 2 games. Probably helps the Knicks. And pretty fair. Not like he went 15 and 5 in his first year at 20. What does your insight say about every other player on the roster making everyone else better?

'Knicks focus should be on players that have grown up playing soccer or cricket' - Triplethreat 8/28/2020
With all due respect was Dennis Smith Jr always this bad? We need to build this kid back up!

©2001-2025 ultimateknicks.comm All rights reserved. About Us.
This site is not affiliated with the NY Knicks or the National Basketball Association in any way.
You may visit the official NY Knicks web site by clicking here.

All times (GMT-05:00) Eastern Time.

Terms of Use and Privacy Policy