KP presents a combination of size and skill that is hard to imagine replacing. Even if he has not peaked in his skill set. But make no mistakes, there are flaws in his game and his conditioning program seems to leave him with weak legs and injury prone throughout the season.
That said, I absolutely see him as a player with Steph Curry-like game changing attributes were he able to capitalize on all his strengths.
I think what people are saying is that they want to enjoy the journey with KP. Whether he takes it to the next level or not, we want to enjoy the show that is the KP legend in the making. And if he fails he fails. But he can be a top 5 player and a premier player in this league and we, as fans, want the opportunity to witness that here in NY-- not to cash our chips in early.
By contrast, others are responding with the 'what if' game. What if I agreed to give you KAT and the Wolve's next 99 first round draft picks? How about then? And that is just being cute.
The truth is somewhere in between. There are enough flaws in KP's game that you have to consider trade value as it relates to his contract status. The passive overtures in addition to formally skipping meetings create a risk factor on signability at the end of his rookie contract. Given the increase in the salary cap, many teams will be able to offer a ton of money. So, maybe cashing in while he has significant value makes sense?
He would not be cheap. If you can reset your clock on team control on a talented young player and add assets at the same time, that is one fundamental concept in team growth. The 76ers were jokes for years running. Maybe they still are. But who here wouldn't trade rosters with them at this moment? If you can build assets in what appears to be another re-building year, objectively you have to think about the offers as they come in.