bigbasketballs wrote:WaltLongmire wrote:Once again, and I'm almost embarrassed to repeat it, because I continually say this- what is going on with KP shows how little many "expert" analysts really know about the players in the draft. This also includes many/most of us, and the guys who are being paid big bucks to make the picks for NBA teams.
I disagree with this somewhat.
KP has been projected as a top 5 pick long before he got on Knicks fans radars (we were looking higher). He was a potential lottery pick the year before.
The hardcore draft guys were pretty much in the ballpark the whole time.
A bunch of narrative crap then took over when mainstream attention turned to the top 4.
Understand I'm not suggesting I predicted this, but i did say KP was no more or less NBA ready than any other of the top freshmen.
Buying into the "two years away narrative" was a failure to whoever bought into it.
And he isn't being physically overwhelmed and hasn't missed a min due to injury. That too is just thumbnail thinking.
Following professional sports should teach you to - if nothing else - have an open mind. The most predictable thing about them is how hard they are to predict.
There was a lot of talk about how long it would take him be be really competitive and what his MPG would be.
Even Jackson and Fisher were hesitant to project that he would be playing the minutes he's been playing with the success he's been showing.
I thought he would be playing 30MPG by the end of the year. I think by projected numbers were closer to the 10/6 range, with a few 20 pt games at the end of the year.
I always thought saying he was not as ready as other rookies was foolish, because he had played against better competition than most of the other guys is the draft. A big issue was his weight and strength, and when we found he was up to about 240, that made me think he might be more competitive than I had expected him to be.
I expect a lot of folks who thought he could have some success thought he would be more of a perimeter player, and not mix it up as much, and NONE of us would have predicted the rebounding numbers he's been putting up. Even a guy like Fran Fraschilla, who thought he could be the best player in the draft down the line cautioned people not to expect too much early on.
KP has been projected as a top 5 pick long before he got on Knicks fans radars (we were looking higher). He was a potential lottery pick the year before. The hardcore draft guys were pretty much in the ballpark the whole time.
Was quite aware of this...I think the issue for some around here was that they fell in love with certain players- Mudiay, Winslow, WCS, etc., while also buying into the common wisdom that the "Big Three" included Towns, OK4, and Russell. And of course there was the Bargs/Weiss factor.
It does seem that we've been fortunate in getting him. Finally a little bit of luck for the franchise.
EnySpree: Can we agree to agree not to mention Phil Jackson and triangle for the rest of our lives?