BRIGGS wrote:jrodmc wrote:Yes, LBJ all alone makes an ex-SMOTY a better person, a better baller and a stellar citizen.Yet, Mr. Love is bailing out.
Yet, I don't think there's a Kyrie-type player anywhere near the Knicks these days, is there?
Of course none of this should factor in, since Melo makes no one better. Ever.
54 wins was JKidd and Rashweed and one game from KrazyEyes.
You people are fuhucking unbelieveable.
Melo is a great individual player but he has never made players around him raise their level of play. I don't think it's up for debate.
Carmelo has played 275 games with the Knicks and we have roughly a .500 record with him--if he played the 2nd half of this year that number wouldve been sub .500. Did the Knicks just not find the right players to play with melo? How much influence did Melo have in shaping the roster. The depletion of assets in the Melo trade itself. It all adds up.
Could this team been .500 for 4-5 years without Melo using the assets elsewhere? Maybe its not a high bar.
So really we can only call our time with melo a fail. Not Melo's fault but he has proven over 5 years to be a player who cant help raise other players levels of play and our record is the bottom line.
So, once again, JR being SMOTY was all on him, nothing to do with Melo.
JR being Jesus Rightside on a Cavs team with LBJ, Kyrie and Love is all about Melo's insufficiencies as a leader. Check.
Raising the levels of DWade, Bosh, Kyrie and Love, of course, take maximum leadership skills.
Raising the levels of Fishlips, random 40 year olds, FluTyson, Raygun Felton and Gumby Shump should be easy to do for anyone with a even a shred of leadership.
Yes indeedy, Melo era = fail.
Please tell me all about how great the 275 games before we got Melo were. I love a good story. Almost as much as how we were going to win chips with SuperGallo and InvisiMayor and Moz, the ultimate five year project.
Oh, I forgot, HOF Center Stat was already going to lead us to a chip before we got Melo and he spoiled our bottom line.