Papabear wrote:RonRon wrote:Papabear wrote:RonRon wrote:Isola is a troll that gets paid to be one, I am sure plenty of NYK players want to kick his ass with the way he talks/tone/be littles players and the Knick's
While some get paid NOTHING on here to do the same, anyone wonder if these writers lurk inside here on UK.com
I think some do although they might not even post, they could just read the boards for inspiration
Papa Bear, it took some time, but you finally are seeing that The Knick's make questionable moves, welcome to the "DARK SIDE"
I know you bleed orange and blue, just like I do, but you use to see almost all the moves as positives for the franchise, defend the moves of the franchise, and get defensive when posters get negative about the moves they make
Now some players take it to the extreme, but not all do, some sincerely wish the best for the Knick's but just question don't agree with the moves that the franchise makes
With this post you are starting to question the franchise itself as you have every right to do so
Papabear Says
Hey Ron Ron! No NO No! I'm not on the Dark side yet TKF have not bit me on the neck yet.
So I'm still in the lite but asking more questions and seeing clearly about Dolan and the way the Knicks machine runs. They really want to win but making money loyalty when you disagree comes before a title.
no, I am not putting you in the TFK Darkside, i meant a more grey area,
Where as back then you would be more PRO KNICKS no matter what they did, you would justify it, defend it, and believe it was for the better of the franchise
But now you see things with a little bit different perspective, questioning if the moves of the franchise are really for the better of the team or for other reasons
I know we have had our fair amount on different opinions/perspectives for the better of the team, in the past, and probably will continue to have some in the future
I am not as evil (anti Knicks) as you once thought I was, I put myself more in a grey area
In fact, I actually try to give examples on how I think we can improve the team by utilizing players/rotations differently or/and with trading players, and all for the better of the KNICKS, not individual players
Anyway, hope we can have more respectful debates and share our own 2 cent's in a appropriate manner, some we may agree on and some we might not
I am sorry for some of the words I have said to you, hope we can move along and continue to cheer for the same team
Papabear Says
I agree. And hell will break loose if Melo decides to up and leave the knicks. Two big mistakes the team make. 1 they could have gotten Amare for less with 4 years and 3 guaranteed and 4th partialed. 2 They should have never signed Tyson Chandler for that kind of money. We should have waited for Chris Paul. Amare really hurt bad. Over 20 million. Damn we could have gotten 3 damn good player for 20 million. And border line all-stars or all-stars.
Hey Papa Bear,
Where do you put me in your eyes?
Interested see where you label me, am in the "dark side" with TFK?
No, I don't always agree with the decisions management makes, head coaching decisions, roster and ways to acquire and keep assets/value for development and future uses in possible trades
In fact, most of the times, I am usually against most of the decisions that they make
There are times that I am completely wrong and sometimes I hit it right on the spot
I can't help it but I am always looking for ways in which I think could improve the TEAM and maximize the talents/roster on the Knicks
Just because a player is a Knick or is no longer a Knick, I won't praise them or bash them because of their team, I try to evaluate talent on my own
I am a basketball fan first then a Knicks' fan 2nd
But I consider myself a big Knick's fan which makes it very tough because disagree with many decisions they make, some of which are VERY simple like playing Lin when we need penetration, moving Melo to PF *in Dantoni's era*, if he wanted him to play the Point/Forward role to create for the team, and not at SF because we need to create mismatches in Dantoni's philosophy with speed/quickness/3pt shoot with spacing and penetration/ opening lanes for PnR, cuts, post up opportunities, and a lane to penetrate with a mobile PF to play Center
I post more negative posts about the team than positives because I feel that the franchise makes too many dumb moves, making it very hard to swallow because I think they could always be better than they actually were
I think I am somewhere in between a grey area, in the end, I look for many ways that I think could improve the Knicks with the way players are utilized/trades/signing players/rotations/a philosophy that fits and maximizes the talents/rotations of the roster
No, I did not like the trade for Melo, but I do think he is by far the Knick's best player, just not worth what we payed for and is NOT worth a max extension
I don't want to get in full detail about the trade for Melo but no team trades 4 starters, the cap space we gave Denver to save over 60million in salary/tax, with 1 1st round pick, 2 predicted high 2nd round picks that we acquired for David Lee on a struggling/rebuilding GS team *at the time*, and a swap of the 2016 pick when Melo could opt out next season and we could be a top 10 pick
Melo is a very good scorer but he is NOT the franchise LEGEND that Melo thinks he is
He isn't a leader by any means and that was why we signed Kidd with all the old guys like Sheed/Camby, to bring leadership instead of talent to go with leadership that we need
To help Melo's ego and be the super hero that Lin stole from him and (during Lin's run) the NYK fan's from around the world were more interested in Lin running the team than Melo
Melo is NOT a leader or ELITE player, he is a high volume scorer, and he should not be treated like a Lebron/Durant and even a more complete player like Paul George/Harden
Even Rudy Gay has abilities that Melo does not, with his combination of athleticism, ability to be a lock down defender, versatility from SG-PF with the skills to penetrate off the dribble and finish/POST UP/ and RISE UP for a jump shot in the midrange,
Like Melo, Rudy Gay is very talented and has to elevate his overall game, DEFENSE, learn to create for his team, and learn to play OFF THE BALL
In my opinion, if Rudy Gay was in NYK instead of Melo, in my opinion, he would be able to put up similar numbers that Melo does because of the fact that Woodson gives the freedom to Melo with
ISO plays - OUR PG literally just brings up the ball then passes to Melo 85% of the time, instead of actually creating/attacking/breaking down the opponents DEF, and giving the ball to whoever is open, hot, or has the mismatch
Green light - *he can get his shot off easier than Melo because Gay is physically more skilled than Melo with his size/length/agility, athleticism, speed/quickness/handle, ability to rise up for a jump shot that not many can contest, ability to post up down low or mid range
OPPORTUNITIES - as the #1 option as the rest of the team spreads out the floor for him to score almost every play, willing to take 30 shots in a row, causing a lack of chemistry/ability to get in rhythm for role players
I am saying a lot of Melo's numbers are very misleading because the ball is in his hands a lot but he does not look to create like Lebron does or does have such abilities
Where Melo would constantly look to create STATs, Lebron/Durant/Paul George does not have ego issues and is looking to looking to make the "correct" play for the team
In the end, we all here are Knick fans but we have different opinions/perspectives on how the team should be utilized and what players to sign/trade for
One day, I do hope, we all can post here with much more respect to each other's opinions even when we don't agree with them
The bashing/disrespect/trolling is just a multiplied effect that is a chain reaction, never ending, and people will likely NEVER change their opinions anyway