VCoug wrote:.

You're right. Rubio's injury happened near the beginning of March and Shumpert's happened during the playoffs in late April. Shumpert's injury was worse because he tore his meniscus as well while Rubio only tore his ACL. Also, Shumpert had two other knee injuries last season; he sprained the MCL in his right knee to start the year and he had patella tendinitis in his left knee, the one that's currently injured, in February. He also tore the meniscus in his right knee while in College.

Really, there's no reason to be rushing him back before he's healthy. The last thing we would want is to see him play before he's physically ready to and have him re-injure one or both of his knees and possibly ruin his career.

VCoug - you are absolutely correct. The background you provide on Shump's history should be mandatory reading. The whole, "Shump should be back by..." thing is nothing but speculation based on emotion and interpreting sketchy medical information. The Knicks keep the doctors charts on lockdown.

Hopefully, Shumpert will listen to his body carefully and not get caught in a cycle of re-injury. No matter what time it is.

misterearl wrote:Thank Goodness For Context

VCoug wrote:.

You're right. Rubio's injury happened near the beginning of March and Shumpert's happened during the playoffs in late April. Shumpert's injury was worse because he tore his meniscus as well while Rubio only tore his ACL. Also, Shumpert had two other knee injuries last season; he sprained the MCL in his right knee to start the year and he had patella tendinitis in his left knee, the one that's currently injured, in February. He also tore the meniscus in his right knee while in College.

Really, there's no reason to be rushing him back before he's healthy. The last thing we would want is to see him play before he's physically ready to and have him re-injure one or both of his knees and possibly ruin his career.

VCoug - you are absolutely correct. The background you provide on Shump's history should be mandatory reading. The whole, "Shump should be back by..." thing is nothing but speculation based on emotion and interpreting sketchy medical information. The Knicks keep the doctors charts on lockdown.

Hopefully, Shumpert will listen to his body carefully and not get caught in a cycle of re-injury. No matter what time it is.

I always hate it when fans, coaches, owners, etc. try to rush injured guys back before they're ready. Especially in basketball or baseball where the season is so long anyway that missing a role player for an extra couple of weeks or more isn't going to make or break the season. I'd rather have him healthy and ready for the playoffs as opposed to him possibly re-injuring himself in some meaningless February game against Washington.

I also think it's weird we have gotten no up date out of Amare, no even one "phenomenal" and the bench thing coming out last week. Maybe the news on Amare isn't so great and he'll be out til late January-February.

tkf wrote:

IrishKnickFan wrote:one of the main reasons we got off to the 6-0 start was because we kept the ball moving. Then we went 3-4 but shooting to much and too much iso. Last night we got back to what worked.

I didn't see much ball movement last night. well at least the portions I watched.. I saw a lot of three shot jacking, and a horrible played game by the bucks... that is an odd team.. two guards who are elusive but don't penetrate that much..... they do love bad shots..

keep in mind that there hasn't been much if any time for practice with the schedule played so far. With the homestand coming, Woody should be able to get the back to basics.

Anji wrote:If Amare wants to be back by Christmas he needs to start practicing by the end of next week.

I also think it's weird we have gotten no up date out of Amare, no even one "phenomenal" and the bench thing coming out last week. Maybe the news on Amare isn't so great and he'll be out til late January-February.

not sure about any actual practice but, I saw a vid on KnicksXtra of Amare running and doing drills.

Bonn1997 wrote:Here's what it says on his ESPN player profile:

Stoudemire (knee) is targeting Christmas as his return date, the New York Post reports.

Spin: According to a source close to Stoudemire, mid-December is no longer a realistic date to expect him to return, as he still has yet to begin running after his Nov. 1 surgery.

I guess he can't run now but in 3 weeks will be able to play NBA level basketball. Sounds fishy.

Mike Woodson is playing Chris Copeland for a reason. He is preparing the young man for the strong possibility that Amar'e will never play a brutal string of NBA games again.

He punched the fire extinguisher out of frustration with his body.