IrishKnickFan wrote:

mrKnickShot wrote:

IrishKnickFan wrote:

mrKnickShot wrote:

IrishKnickFan wrote:

Jmpasq wrote:This team needs an unreal amount of Luck to get to the Finals. They need the whole team to be healthy for the playoffs and Dwayne Wade or Lebron out for the playoffs. They get that they would have a shot then. Miami is the only team that scares me in the East. The other teams the Knicks can Beat. Those teams can beat the Knicks 2 but they could play with them. If Miami is healthy the Knicks cant win

Reminds be of the 90's if we were able to get past the bulls we would have at least 2 titles

Only, when we did, we lost.

Yes we know but the knicks would have won one of the other years i feel

The year it was theirs was the CHARLES FUKKIN SMITH play. Ouch - I did not want to think about that.

That was painful i hate Smith for that embarrassing sequence

That play scarred me for life

mrKnickShot wrote:

ChuckBuck wrote:

IrishKnickFan wrote:

mrKnickShot wrote:

IrishKnickFan wrote:

mrKnickShot wrote:

IrishKnickFan wrote:

Jmpasq wrote:This team needs an unreal amount of Luck to get to the Finals. They need the whole team to be healthy for the playoffs and Dwayne Wade or Lebron out for the playoffs. They get that they would have a shot then. Miami is the only team that scares me in the East. The other teams the Knicks can Beat. Those teams can beat the Knicks 2 but they could play with them. If Miami is healthy the Knicks cant win

Reminds be of the 90's if we were able to get past the bulls we would have at least 2 titles

Only, when we did, we lost.

Yes we know but the knicks would have won one of the other years i feel

The year it was theirs was the CHARLES FUKKIN SMITH play. Ouch - I did not want to think about that.

That was painful i hate Smith for that embarrassing sequence

That play scarred me for life

Wow! I forgot that Ewing passed him the ball. He never passed - probably did cause he was falling down

knicks1248 wrote:

mrKnickShot wrote:

knicks1248 wrote:

mrKnickShot wrote:

knicks1248 wrote:

mrKnickShot wrote:
A starting team of:

Felton
Shump
Melo
Chandler
anyone other than Amare

Would be sick!!

so if amre came in and said the same thing, what then??

Said what?

everything felton just said only pertaining to himself...I mean your constantly bashing amre like his sitting aroung eating hot dogs and watch old reruns of "whats happing"

That is not the case - I saw him miss both playoffs and dealing with numerous injuries - I have low expectations for him staying healthy and explosive and would love nothing better than to be wrong. He is a good guy and we don't have to talk about defense ...

I just find it funny that he gets a pass from many of the MDAers/MeloHaters but thats fine - to each their own. MDA was very lovable and I understand how people are still pining for him and his brilliant non-ISO offensive.

The only person I hated on the knicks was TD and jeferies, and JJ turned it arnd and my opinion on him changed..

I don't give no one a pass who doesn't work hard and Amare is one of the hardest working players in the league..He's not that brightest on the defensive end, and his injuries have been self inflicted almost comical in some sense..but I don't think he's wash up or falling off and any shape or fashion..tough year, and we all expect more from him

The "he is not so bright on defense" is horse sh1t and you know it. I don't know who came up with that lame excuse buts its gotta go.

He needs to get that deadly J back if he has any shot.

Baron Davis was the only player last year that I hated - AND I FREAKIN HATED HIM SO MUCH!

FELTON/KIDD/FOREIGN DUDE >>>> LIN/DAVIS/TD

knicks1248 wrote:

mrKnickShot wrote:

knicks1248 wrote:

mrKnickShot wrote:

knicks1248 wrote:

mrKnickShot wrote:

knicks1248 wrote:

mrKnickShot wrote:
A starting team of:

Felton
Shump
Melo
Chandler
anyone other than Amare

Would be sick!!

so if amre came in and said the same thing, what then??

Said what?

everything felton just said only pertaining to himself...I mean your constantly bashing amre like his sitting aroung eating hot dogs and watch old reruns of "whats happing"

That is not the case - I saw him miss both playoffs and dealing with numerous injuries - I have low expectations for him staying healthy and explosive and would love nothing better than to be wrong. He is a good guy and we don't have to talk about defense ...

I just find it funny that he gets a pass from many of the MDAers/MeloHaters but thats fine - to each their own. MDA was very lovable and I understand how people are still pining for him and his brilliant non-ISO offensive.

The only person I hated on the knicks was TD and jeferies, and JJ turned it arnd and my opinion on him changed..

I don't give no one a pass who doesn't work hard and Amare is one of the hardest working players in the league..He's not that brightest on the defensive end, and his injuries have been self inflicted almost comical in some sense..but I don't think he's wash up or falling off and any shape or fashion..tough year, and we all expect more from him

The "he is not so bright on defense" is horse sh1t and you know it. I don't know who came up with that lame excuse buts its gotta go.

He needs to get that deadly J back if he has any shot.

Baron Davis was the only player last year that I hated - AND I FREAKIN HATED HIM SO MUCH!

dude i saw amare run all the way down court to get back on defense never once turning around til he was practicly under the basket..by the time he turned around the pg went coast to coast and was right on top of amare laying it in the hoop..had Amare look back for one second he would have easily made a stop..

It's not horse sht dude, his defensive IQ is low as hell..

So why did we sign such a "dumb" guy when there was nobody else bidding? The only other bid I remember was PHX at 3/60.

Perhaps it would have been nice if for most of his career nobody taught him how to play defense nor held him in contempt for missing assignments (if there were any)

mrKnickShot wrote:

knicks1248 wrote:

mrKnickShot wrote:

knicks1248 wrote:

mrKnickShot wrote:

knicks1248 wrote:

mrKnickShot wrote:

knicks1248 wrote:

mrKnickShot wrote:
A starting team of:

Felton
Shump
Melo
Chandler
anyone other than Amare

Would be sick!!

so if amre came in and said the same thing, what then??

Said what?

everything felton just said only pertaining to himself...I mean your constantly bashing amre like his sitting aroung eating hot dogs and watch old reruns of "whats happing"

That is not the case - I saw him miss both playoffs and dealing with numerous injuries - I have low expectations for him staying healthy and explosive and would love nothing better than to be wrong. He is a good guy and we don't have to talk about defense ...

I just find it funny that he gets a pass from many of the MDAers/MeloHaters but thats fine - to each their own. MDA was very lovable and I understand how people are still pining for him and his brilliant non-ISO offensive.

The only person I hated on the knicks was TD and jeferies, and JJ turned it arnd and my opinion on him changed..

I don't give no one a pass who doesn't work hard and Amare is one of the hardest working players in the league..He's not that brightest on the defensive end, and his injuries have been self inflicted almost comical in some sense..but I don't think he's wash up or falling off and any shape or fashion..tough year, and we all expect more from him

The "he is not so bright on defense" is horse sh1t and you know it. I don't know who came up with that lame excuse buts its gotta go.

He needs to get that deadly J back if he has any shot.

Baron Davis was the only player last year that I hated - AND I FREAKIN HATED HIM SO MUCH!

dude i saw amare run all the way down court to get back on defense never once turning around til he was practicly under the basket..by the time he turned around the pg went coast to coast and was right on top of amare laying it in the hoop..had Amare look back for one second he would have easily made a stop..

It's not horse sht dude, his defensive IQ is low as hell..

So why did we sign such a "dumb" guy when there was nobody else bidding? The only other bid I remember was PHX at 3/60.

Perhaps it would have been nice if for most of his career nobody taught him how to play defense nor held him in contempt for missing assignments (if there were any)

It was huge mistake and one of the only grudges I hold against Walsh. 5 yrs 75 should have been the max we gave him. But we were trying to lure Lebron and show him that we were ready to throw money around.

ChuckBuck wrote:

IrishKnickFan wrote:i always liked felton and didnt want him to go in the melo trade. Hey at least we are getting back some the assets we lost in that trade

The way I see it we're net positive after Felton's return, especially since Novak is a way better shooter than Gallinari. Shumpert, once healthy, should exceed Wilson Chandler, and the Moz is well the Moz.

Don't forget that we got Chandler as an indirect result of that trade as well! And we picked up JR off Denver via China.
Let's see: Melo, Chandler, Felton and JR. I think that easily exceeds Gallinari, Chandler and Moz.

FeltonandAmare wrote:

ChuckBuck wrote:

IrishKnickFan wrote:i always liked felton and didnt want him to go in the melo trade. Hey at least we are getting back some the assets we lost in that trade

The way I see it we're net positive after Felton's return, especially since Novak is a way better shooter than Gallinari. Shumpert, once healthy, should exceed Wilson Chandler, and the Moz is well the Moz.

Don't forget that we got Chandler as an indirect result of that trade as well! And we picked up JR off Denver via China.
Let's see: Melo, Chandler, Felton and JR. I think that easily exceeds Gallinari, Chandler and Moz.

what about the 28 draft picks that we gave up?

Funny how things go full circle - Felton is great, Melo trade sucked, Lin goes, Felton signs, Felton now sux, the result?

MELO TRADE NOW GREAT

Gotta love it!

IrishKnickFan wrote:

Jmpasq wrote:This team needs an unreal amount of Luck to get to the Finals. They need the whole team to be healthy for the playoffs and Dwayne Wade or Lebron out for the playoffs. They get that they would have a shot then. Miami is the only team that scares me in the East. The other teams the Knicks can Beat. Those teams can beat the Knicks 2 but they could play with them. If Miami is healthy the Knicks cant win

Reminds be of the 90's if we were able to get past the bulls we would have at least 2 titles

Yeah and the melo lbj matchup is like Hakeem/Patrick.