[ IMAGES: Images ON turn off | ACCOUNT: User Status is LOCKED why? ]

Start Lin @ PG
Author Thread
NYKBocker
Posts: 38412
Alba Posts: 474
Joined: 1/14/2003
Member: #377
USA
1/26/2012  1:55 PM
I honestly think that the reason Lin is not playing is not because of any conspiracy theories. I think it is just the plain fact that MDA is loyal to a fault. Lin also joined the team very late. I think if he had the chance to compete with Bibby and TD in the beginning of the very short camp, MDA would have chosen Lin.
AUTOADVERT
upstate
Posts: 20091
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 12/27/2011
Member: #3781

1/26/2012  1:59 PM
EnySpree wrote:I went hard about Lin in my last blog....


It angers me that people use words like raw to describe him. Like what is Toney Douglas and Shumpert at point guard. Those guys are raw prospects at point cuz neittyher are very good at it.

Lin got shipped to the d-league and had a legendary game 28/12/11.....triple ****ing double. That is not raw. Its not a joke either. This guy is better than any point guard Cleveland played last night including the rookie from duke. He damn sure is better than Bibby and he has pure point guard skill and natural instincts. His handle is top notch as well. He's a legit 6'3" too.


Its complete bull**** that this guy is not playing. I personally think this kid can start for us and be the point guard for the future wit Shump at his side at shooting guard for the next 10 years

+1 It's not hard to see that Lin has all of the skills and athleticism. He just needs PT to get accustomed to running an NBA offense. For anyone who has watched him play, he always plays better the more minutes he gets. He is also smart, works hard, and learns. His shot (his biggest weakness) has already improved greatly from last year, as it has gone from questionable to above-average, and I think it will continue to improve.

nyk4ever
Posts: 41010
Alba Posts: 12
Joined: 1/12/2005
Member: #848
USA
1/26/2012  2:03 PM
i always laugh at things like this. you really think d'antoni would hold out lin if he thought he could play? d'antoni has shown that he is more than willing to play young players. i mean come on - look at the hole at pg, you really think d'antoni would hold ANY pg from playing? lin has looked good in garbage time - so did rick brunson.
"OMG - did we just go on a two-trade-wining-streak?" -SupremeCommander
martin
Posts: 76237
Alba Posts: 108
Joined: 7/24/2001
Member: #2
USA
1/26/2012  2:06 PM
NYKBocker wrote:I honestly think that the reason Lin is not playing is not because of any conspiracy theories. I think it is just the plain fact that MDA is loyal to a fault. Lin also joined the team very late. I think if he had the chance to compete with Bibby and TD in the beginning of the very short camp, MDA would have chosen Lin.

this is possible. I have seen Lin 2 times in garbage time and I didn't think he looked good (that 5'8" Isiah kid tied him up). On the other hand he blasted thru his one game in DLeague play.

Official sponsor of the PURE KNICKS LOVE Program
RonRon
Posts: 25531
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 5/22/2002
Member: #246
1/26/2012  2:08 PM
Bippity10 wrote:
nixluva wrote:
Bippity10 wrote:
s3231 wrote:D'Antoni hates young players.

I mean, it's not like he started 2 rookies last season and then inserted another rookie in the lineup this season....oh wait a minute....

Seriously, we don't see the practices and the coaching staff has clearly shown a willingness to play guys that are ready to play, no matter what the age is. It's kind of ridiculous how bad the hate for has gotten.

I never understood where that comes from. Phoenix trades away a couple draft picks becuase they are competing for a championship and what veterans instead. Somehow after that D'Antoni gets labelled a rookie hater. Doesn't matter how many Barbosa's or Field's or Shumperts or Mozgovs' we see, he's still a guy that has an agenda against young guys. If we are criticizing the guy can we just stick to the real stuff instead of the invented conspiracies.

Bip your logic is wasted here on this forum. I too find it funny that a Former PG, who played and coached in Europe, then coached in the NBA and has seen arguably the HIGHEST level of PG play you can imagine, all of a sudden can't tell if a PG can run his system or not! The level of disrespect that MDA gets is unreal at times. ALL these guys know better than the coach who actually designed the system and has coached it to great success. It took a MONTH for Duhon, Felton and CB to get the hang of it. I'm not talking master it, just get to the point where they can play at a decent level. Felton had a full camp and eventually got the hang of it. HE wasn't perfect, but he did pretty good for his talent level.

Lin could be close to getting in there. We don't know how he's looked in practice. They obviously wanted him to get some run when they sent him to the D League. I still have hope that Lin can get in there soon and show us something good. Thing is we don't know what MDA is seeing from this kid in practice. Maybe he's good and maybe he's not. Maybe he gets a shot this weekend.

I agree. For all we know Lin is a game away from playing. But D'Antoni has given every indication in his career that he will play guys when they are ready to play. And for arguments sake, let's say that D'antoni hates Lin and is hiding him. How would any of us know this if we aren't in practice?

Lastly, great point about Felton. The guy was awful for the first month and he was a vet by the time he got to us. Let's give Lin some time. Not sure how we blast a coach without having real facts as to why we are bashing him. Bash him for offense/defense etc. But how can we blast him for somethign that is occuring in practice that none of us see.

We can bash him to continue to allow players to play while they continue to make the same mistakes and show their inability time after time.
Dantoni is putting players on the court time after time, while they are being exploited for these abilities or lack of.
Lin is the best PG we have, at the very least, he is the only PG that has the most speed/quickness/handle and the ability to penetrate that we have lacked all year
There is no excuse, you cannot defend him at this point, I understand the first 10-12 games, but come on, our players are clearly not getting it.

He has given the light to TD, Bibby, Iman, why not give Lin a chance?? Lin can break the defense down and create good shots...
We are unable to spread the floor, while Novak is probably our best shooter, and again our shooters cannot create their own shots, so we need someone to set them up
Jerome Jordan is our biggest guy after Tyson Chandler, but he puts JJ in at center, while Jordan has shown he can defend, rebound, and hit a 15 footer

These are all guys that are not AR type players, that takes bad shots, they have been in enough practices to get a shot if our starters and 2nd unit is unable to perform...

If you play Amare at center, then he can have the speed and quickness which he is showing to score on the opponents center but you must put a lineup
that can spread the floor, not with JJ playing undersized center, that cannot shoot, be a offensive threat, or even defend or grab RB's at that position

How about having a lineup like

TC
Amare
Melo
Iman
Lin

TC
Melo
Novak
TD
Lin/Iman

Jordan
Amare
Novak
Fields
Iman

Amare
Novak
Fields
Iman/TD
TD

Amare
Melo
Fields
TD
Lin

TC
Jordan
Novak/Fields
TD/Iman
Lin

Jordan
Amare
Melo
Fields
Lin

where we can have 4 players that can penetrate and players that can spread the floor
there are so many different ways he utilize his 3rd string players and give an identity their individual roles and a team role
Our players don't compliment each other, especially our starting lineup
There are so many ways we can utilize our lineups, we can't get good shots because we don't have shooters to spread the floor and penetration
We will move the ball all day with no off the ball movement, it won't work, how about have 1 player near the paint and have a PG that can penetrate
with 3 other players that can spread the floor...
Iman doesn't have the speed/quickness at the PG, no where close to Lin, but he can do it at the SG

nixluva
Posts: 56258
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 10/5/2004
Member: #758
USA
1/26/2012  2:35 PM
RonRon, perhaps MDA is soon going to try and insert some of the bench guys to shake things up, but really We've seen this movie before. You want to see the backup QB, cuz he always looks good when the starter is floundering. That is until you get to see him as a starter and can pick apart his flaws. We have no way of knowing what if any improvement the bench guys would make.

I think Novak can help, but he needs to be setup just like everyone else and so far we don't have anyone who can do that consistently. Is Lin that guy? I do know that Lin is not a pure passer. He may be a better version of scoring PG than TD, but he's no Nash type. I do believe he'll get a shot soon tho. I think MDA is doing the right thing by sticking with a set rotation and giving it as much time as possible to gel. Changes don't guarantee better chemistry.

The biggest problem is we're asking players to do something they've never done well. PASS the ball. STAT and Tyson aren't passers. Melo can pass, but is more comfortable calling his own number. Walker and Fields don't pass. Goodness knows TD can't pass. Shump is a rook and I can guarantee he never ran anything as complicated as this offense in college. I think Shump can and will get better, but it's asking a lot of a kid like him to be a pure Point, which is what this team needs. Lin may just have enough skill to do it, but my guess is that he hadn't shown he had it down yet either.

sealy
Posts: 20683
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 11/1/2010
Member: #3291
USA
1/26/2012  2:39 PM
Where's the Novak thread?

That's who needs to be playing if we continue to bomb 3s because driving the ball to the bucket has apparently gone out of style.

RonRon
Posts: 25531
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 5/22/2002
Member: #246
1/26/2012  2:43 PM
not only do I think Lin should start because he would allow Iman and Melo to not have to worry about the PG spot if someone else was in.
But Iman and Melo could be used both penetrate.

Melo is our best post player but he post up if the other players cannot spread the floor and have to worry about helping to the PG.
This is where he is the most effective, but the Center and PF, must be able to spread the floor so JJ and Chandler cannot play unless, especially together.
If Chandler is playing, our PF has to Melo or Novak

Not having Jorts hurts us, because he is realistically a stretch 5
But Jordan has shown the ability to hit the 15footer so I don't understand why he doesn't play when he is out 2nd biggest guy after TC

Our shooters, cannot create their own shot, but Lin can create so play the damn guy. Regardless if Baron Davis is back or not, we constantly need players that can penetrate. Field's is not that player, especially at SG, unless someone earns a step for him.

Ic Lin, being a realistic long term PG if we can get Nash to mentor him. Lin is quicker than Nash but he can learn plenty and if would just give him a shot
then he might think about coming back for the cheap too, therefore we would get his bird rights. Whether he will be a starting PG in the future, he deserves a shot to START NOW, but he can be a 2nd PG with legit size, speed, and quickness, with the IQ...

nixluva
Posts: 56258
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 10/5/2004
Member: #758
USA
1/26/2012  2:51 PM
RonRon wrote:not only do I think Lin should start because he would allow Iman and Melo to not have to worry about the PG spot if someone else was in.
But Iman and Melo could be used both penetrate.

Melo is our best post player but he post up if the other players cannot spread the floor and have to worry about helping to the PG.
This is where he is the most effective, but the Center and PF, must be able to spread the floor so JJ and Chandler cannot play unless, especially together.
If Chandler is playing, our PF has to Melo or Novak

Not having Jorts hurts us, because he is realistically a stretch 5
But Jordan has shown the ability to hit the 15footer so I don't understand why he doesn't play when he is out 2nd biggest guy after TC

Our shooters, cannot create their own shot, but Lin can create so play the damn guy. Regardless if Baron Davis is back or not, we constantly need players that can penetrate. Field's is not that player, especially at SG, unless someone earns a step for him.

Ic Lin, being a realistic long term PG if we can get Nash to mentor him. Lin is quicker than Nash but he can learn plenty and if would just give him a shot
then he might think about coming back for the cheap too, therefore we would get his bird rights. Whether he will be a starting PG in the future, he deserves a shot to START NOW, but he can be a 2nd PG with legit size, speed, and quickness, with the IQ...

If Lin is whipping passes and driving by his man in practice I guarantee you that MDA would put him in. You think TD is looking any better in practice? So if Lin is outplaying him he'd get a shot soon.

RonRon
Posts: 25531
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 5/22/2002
Member: #246
1/26/2012  2:56 PM
nixluva wrote:RonRon, perhaps MDA is soon going to try and insert some of the bench guys to shake things up, but really We've seen this movie before. You want to see the backup QB, cuz he always looks good when the starter is floundering. That is until you get to see him as a starter and can pick apart his flaws. We have no way of knowing what if any improvement the bench guys would make.

I think Novak can help, but he needs to be setup just like everyone else and so far we don't have anyone who can do that consistently. Is Lin that guy? I do know that Lin is not a pure passer. He may be a better version of scoring PG than TD, but he's no Nash type. I do believe he'll get a shot soon tho. I think MDA is doing the right thing by sticking with a set rotation and giving it as much time as possible to gel. Changes don't guarantee better chemistry.

The biggest problem is we're asking players to do something they've never done well. PASS the ball. STAT and Tyson aren't passers. Melo can pass, but is more comfortable calling his own number. Walker and Fields don't pass. Goodness knows TD can't pass. Shump is a rook and I can guarantee he never ran anything as complicated as this offense in college. I think Shump can and will get better, but it's asking a lot of a kid like him to be a pure Point, which is what this team needs. Lin may just have enough skill to do it, but my guess is that he hadn't shown he had it down yet either.

we have given everyone a shot besides him with getting the same results, inability to penetrate, set up the offense, get good looks, and we are are quarter in to the season. So there is absolutely no reason why Lin doesn't get a shot.

Iman doesn't even have the speed/quickness Lin has. He is much more athletic, but Iman is playing with players that cannot spread the floor or handle the ball.
While TC and Amare also are constantly in the paint, with no room to operate, while neither can post up.
But Iman could be the 2nd guy that could penetrate, even TD and Fields could be more efficient with penetration, if our PG can break the defense down.
Whether Baron Davis is back or not, we have seen enough of the PG/SG's are not doing it, and Dantoni has stuck with a losing recipe with the same result.

It was garbage time, Lin had some jitters, but some starters were in the game, with 2nd unit players with the Bobcats. That squad showed us and identity, while Novak was able to get a good look with Lin's penetration. Jordan was playing his role with rebounding, boxing out, defense, and shot blocking.
He has shown the ability to hit the 15 footer, that TC is not a threat at.

Walker, TD are all making stupid fouls and are being broken down with the penetration of PG/SG, even Fields has shown the lack of quickness/speed needed at the SG.

PG is currently our biggest hole but it isn't the only problem of our lineups, without the ability to spread the floor, and lack of post options.

Playing TD and Bibby together is a clear mismatch, as even playing 1 of them at PG gives us problems but playing both makes it that much harder, especially when
JJ is playing with them...

RonRon
Posts: 25531
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 5/22/2002
Member: #246
1/26/2012  3:00 PM
nixluva wrote:
RonRon wrote:not only do I think Lin should start because he would allow Iman and Melo to not have to worry about the PG spot if someone else was in.
But Iman and Melo could be used both penetrate.

Melo is our best post player but he post up if the other players cannot spread the floor and have to worry about helping to the PG.
This is where he is the most effective, but the Center and PF, must be able to spread the floor so JJ and Chandler cannot play unless, especially together.
If Chandler is playing, our PF has to Melo or Novak

Not having Jorts hurts us, because he is realistically a stretch 5
But Jordan has shown the ability to hit the 15footer so I don't understand why he doesn't play when he is out 2nd biggest guy after TC

Our shooters, cannot create their own shot, but Lin can create so play the damn guy. Regardless if Baron Davis is back or not, we constantly need players that can penetrate. Field's is not that player, especially at SG, unless someone earns a step for him.

Ic Lin, being a realistic long term PG if we can get Nash to mentor him. Lin is quicker than Nash but he can learn plenty and if would just give him a shot
then he might think about coming back for the cheap too, therefore we would get his bird rights. Whether he will be a starting PG in the future, he deserves a shot to START NOW, but he can be a 2nd PG with legit size, speed, and quickness, with the IQ...

If Lin is whipping passes and driving by his man in practice I guarantee you that MDA would put him in. You think TD is looking any better in practice? So if Lin is outplaying him he'd get a shot soon.

What are you talking about, Lin was the only one that has shown the ability to penetrate with speed and quickness. He was at first playing with JJ and Bibby but once
they went out and the line up was

Jordan
Balkman
Novak
Fields
Lin

EVERYTHING looked smooth and we were getting good shots/ball movement...
Lin was penetrating in the lane while dishing out to JJ who had no offensive awareness, but Lin made the correct pass...

Bippity10
Posts: 13999
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 1/26/2004
Member: #574
1/26/2012  3:06 PM
RonRon wrote:
nixluva wrote:
RonRon wrote:not only do I think Lin should start because he would allow Iman and Melo to not have to worry about the PG spot if someone else was in.
But Iman and Melo could be used both penetrate.

Melo is our best post player but he post up if the other players cannot spread the floor and have to worry about helping to the PG.
This is where he is the most effective, but the Center and PF, must be able to spread the floor so JJ and Chandler cannot play unless, especially together.
If Chandler is playing, our PF has to Melo or Novak

Not having Jorts hurts us, because he is realistically a stretch 5
But Jordan has shown the ability to hit the 15footer so I don't understand why he doesn't play when he is out 2nd biggest guy after TC

Our shooters, cannot create their own shot, but Lin can create so play the damn guy. Regardless if Baron Davis is back or not, we constantly need players that can penetrate. Field's is not that player, especially at SG, unless someone earns a step for him.

Ic Lin, being a realistic long term PG if we can get Nash to mentor him. Lin is quicker than Nash but he can learn plenty and if would just give him a shot
then he might think about coming back for the cheap too, therefore we would get his bird rights. Whether he will be a starting PG in the future, he deserves a shot to START NOW, but he can be a 2nd PG with legit size, speed, and quickness, with the IQ...

If Lin is whipping passes and driving by his man in practice I guarantee you that MDA would put him in. You think TD is looking any better in practice? So if Lin is outplaying him he'd get a shot soon.

What are you talking about, Lin was the only one that has shown the ability to penetrate with speed and quickness. He was at first playing with JJ and Bibby but once
they went out and the line up was

Jordan
Balkman
Novak
Fields
Lin

EVERYTHING looked smooth and we were getting good shots/ball movement...
Lin was penetrating in the lane while dishing out to JJ who had no offensive awareness, but Lin made the correct pass...

What was the score of the game at the time?

I just hope that people will like me
joec32033
Posts: 30611
Alba Posts: 37
Joined: 2/3/2004
Member: #583
USA
1/26/2012  3:10 PM
If there is one thing we have noticed it is once Mike gets a rotation he sticks with it for a while. Now I agree Shumpert is not a PG. At least not a traditional Steve Nash type PG. He is a scoring D-Wade type PG (just comparing types, breathe guys). In Mike's world, a DWade style PG is a SG.

Part of this is probably who to bench. It is either Fields or Iman. They have kind of played each other to a standstill in a race for one spot.

~You can't run from who you are.~
sealy
Posts: 20683
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 11/1/2010
Member: #3291
USA
1/26/2012  3:20 PM
joec32033 wrote:If there is one thing we have noticed it is once Mike gets a rotation he sticks with it for a while. Now I agree Shumpert is not a PG. At least not a traditional Steve Nash type PG. He is a scoring D-Wade type PG (just comparing types, breathe guys). In Mike's world, a DWade style PG is a SG.

Part of this is probably who to bench. It is either Fields or Iman. They have kind of played each other to a standstill in a race for one spot.


I actually think they've (Fields & Shump) played alright together at times. I think the problem is when TD, Bibby, and Walker get heavy minutes. They are all horrendous and when on the floor, even with Iman or Fields playing the 1 or 2, the offense seems to spiral outta control. We looked fine in the 1st Qtr.

I said this in the game thread: Did anyone else TD shoot more than Melo in the 4th last night? He should've been yanked outta the game immediately for that BS.

Melo and Amar'e were taking to the hole with ease and then they went away from it, IM ASSUMING, either because of the guard play or plays that were being called.

RonRon
Posts: 25531
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 5/22/2002
Member: #246
1/26/2012  3:25 PM
sealy wrote:
joec32033 wrote:If there is one thing we have noticed it is once Mike gets a rotation he sticks with it for a while. Now I agree Shumpert is not a PG. At least not a traditional Steve Nash type PG. He is a scoring D-Wade type PG (just comparing types, breathe guys). In Mike's world, a DWade style PG is a SG.

Part of this is probably who to bench. It is either Fields or Iman. They have kind of played each other to a standstill in a race for one spot.


I actually think they've (Fields & Shump) played alright together at times. I think the problem is when TD, Bibby, and Walker get heavy minutes. They are all horrendous and when on the floor, even with Iman or Fields playing the 1 or 2, the offense seems to spiral outta control. We looked fine in the 1st Qtr.

I said this in the game thread: Did anyone else TD shoot more than Melo in the 4th last night? He should've been yanked outta the game immediately for that BS.

Melo and Amar'e were taking to the hole with ease and then they went away from it, IM ASSUMING, either because of the guard play or plays that were being called.

believe it or not, his shot's were better looks than anything he could generate while facilitating.

Bippity10
Posts: 13999
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 1/26/2004
Member: #574
1/26/2012  3:32 PM    LAST EDITED: 1/26/2012  3:33 PM
joec32033 wrote:If there is one thing we have noticed it is once Mike gets a rotation he sticks with it for a while. Now I agree Shumpert is not a PG. At least not a traditional Steve Nash type PG. He is a scoring D-Wade type PG (just comparing types, breathe guys). In Mike's world, a DWade style PG is a SG.

Part of this is probably who to bench. It is either Fields or Iman. They have kind of played each other to a standstill in a race for one spot.

TD was benched after how many games?

Bibby has been in and out of the line-up

Walker got significant minutes, then sat for months last year

nate was a starter, then a bench player then a starter.

Mozgov, started, sat, came off the bench, started

I can throw a few more examples at you.

Most coaches stick with their rotations and make small changes for guys that are being outplayed by guys behind them. We have no indication that anyone has been able to outplay Shump or Landy or TD and since we are all playing so bad there is no reason to single out one guy at this point. This team needs to learn to play together, not randomly shuffle guys in and out of the line-up

I just hope that people will like me
sealy
Posts: 20683
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 11/1/2010
Member: #3291
USA
1/26/2012  3:33 PM
RonRon wrote:
sealy wrote:
joec32033 wrote:If there is one thing we have noticed it is once Mike gets a rotation he sticks with it for a while. Now I agree Shumpert is not a PG. At least not a traditional Steve Nash type PG. He is a scoring D-Wade type PG (just comparing types, breathe guys). In Mike's world, a DWade style PG is a SG.

Part of this is probably who to bench. It is either Fields or Iman. They have kind of played each other to a standstill in a race for one spot.


I actually think they've (Fields & Shump) played alright together at times. I think the problem is when TD, Bibby, and Walker get heavy minutes. They are all horrendous and when on the floor, even with Iman or Fields playing the 1 or 2, the offense seems to spiral outta control. We looked fine in the 1st Qtr.

I said this in the game thread: Did anyone else TD shoot more than Melo in the 4th last night? He should've been yanked outta the game immediately for that BS.

Melo and Amar'e were taking to the hole with ease and then they went away from it, IM ASSUMING, either because of the guard play or plays that were being called.

believe it or not, his shot's were better looks than anything he could generate while facilitating.


I completely agree that many were good looks, but the fact remains that Amar'e and Melo were getting high percentage shots/ getting to the line, while TD couldn't hit anything.

And these looks were only better than anything he could get for others (I assume that's what you mean) while facilitating for the simple fact that he cannot facilitate anything while on the court and is the reason he should take a seat next to Mike.

Childs2Dudley
Posts: 23906
Alba Posts: 5
Joined: 1/25/2010
Member: #3051
USA
1/26/2012  3:44 PM
Lin is nothing special and this wont happen anyway so there is no point in discussing it.
"Our attitude toward life determines life's attitude towards us." - Earl Nightingale
Nalod
Posts: 71160
Alba Posts: 155
Joined: 12/24/2003
Member: #508
USA
1/26/2012  3:49 PM
Walker is not doing his job well off the bench.

Its a problem.

RonRon
Posts: 25531
Alba Posts: 0
Joined: 5/22/2002
Member: #246
1/26/2012  3:51 PM
Childs2Dudley wrote:Lin is nothing special and this wont happen anyway so there is no point in discussing it.

If you believe this, you should not complain about the poor play that TD and Mini Me produces at the PG/SG together.
They are unable to facilitate, create good shots, penetrate, and are unable to hit the 3 at a good %.

Start Lin @ PG

©2001-2025 ultimateknicks.comm All rights reserved. About Us.
This site is not affiliated with the NY Knicks or the National Basketball Association in any way.
You may visit the official NY Knicks web site by clicking here.

All times (GMT-05:00) Eastern Time.

Terms of Use and Privacy Policy