misterearl wrote:martin - this is a tricky draft for our beloved New York Knicks. Let us not be distracted by measurements, video clips or second hand workout quotes from reporters who were not in the gym. It is tricky because our President is packing his bags, his protege is headed to the DLeague. The idea of buying one of the ost coveted commodities, a draft pick, in this economy is more than a notion. EVERYONE wants a cheaper, quality player. Our dilemma is that Carmelo and Amare could use a running buddy who can RUN a team... and Chauncey is 73 years old.
There is chaos in the front office and the remaining suits are jockeying for position. Decisions by committee are rarely effective. Somebody gotta make an expert call. The Knicks may only get one shot at a player who can step in and play immediately. There is no time for players with limited skills sets who need to develop other aspects of their game.
Give me the triple double or give e death!
Here is the long term thinking that I hope Donnie is still in charge of.
First the questions:
- What to do long term with Chauncy? Were his injuries a fluke or is he done? Can he be like Jason Kidd and play til 38? Can Chauncy blend his game with Melo/Amare? Is he going to move on from Knicks after season so team can target Deron/CP3 (maybe it's a done deal already like LeBron, Bosh)? Will the Knicks use his expiring midseason to shore up team in other areas?
- What to do long term at the C position? Can you really draft a C after this year considering Knicks will prob have no better than #17? Is DHoward in the picture?
- Draft for need versus upside?
For me, C and PG are the positions of (most important) need for the Knicks. You can always get a SG at low cost on the FA market; it's probably the easiest position to fill (heck, all the Knicks need there IMHO is a spot up shooter who plays defense).
Looking at the horizon, it seems to me that that PG spot is either covered or can be covered more easily than the C spot. I would have to say that I have gut feeling about guys watching the Heat get to finals and coming to their own conclusion about their teammates and chances of beating Miami.
And this is why I would lean towards Vucevic. Knicks are OK at the PG spot for at least a year. Can Vucevic play defense? Does he have the attributes to be sufficient? No one would ask him to be Ben Wallace, but he does need to hold his own. I have no idea on this, but from what I have read he is not deficient (which is of course not to say that he is good either). Can he be the Charles Oakly of Cs? Just brutish and positional?
Dude is strong and long enough. And then the Knicks would have a 3 starters who could all pull their respective defenders out to the 3 point line, and for the life of me, I don't think there is a team in the NBA that could do that. Almost unstoppable, as any guard with half a clue should be able to waltz to the paint and get to the rim or dish to a jump shooter.
Forget MDA offense, I don't care about that. But Vucevic, Amare and Melo frontline would be a nightmare IF - big if - Vucevic is a capable starter (now or eventually). Dude can catch and shoot. He is a post player, which fits Amare and Melo nicely.
This certainly would be the start of an anti-Chicago and anti-Miami team, but it would be a good one IMHO.
And if you tack on Deron or CP3 in the summer offseason, almost unstoppable on one end of the court. Team would have to grow defensively based on rebounding and positional defense.
As a second step, I would absolutely target as many late first rounders or second rounders and draft one of those other scoring PGs and hope and pray they work out.
And then I would sign Aaron Gray with MLE.